Why Men Should Not Compete In Women's Sports?

1114 Words3 Pages

Can a level playing field exist when athletes transition genders? What are the real costs of winning when the rules are changed in the game? As a female who plays sports, men should not compete in women’s sports, especially transgender men. Men are biologically stronger than women so when a man is competing against women they have a way higher chance of winning so it would not be a fair competition. Men outperform women when it comes down to ability and physical activity. Not only should men not compete in women sports but women should not compete in men sports also, it should go both ways. Men should not compete in women's sports due to their physical differences. The deliberation over transgender participation in women’s sports is sparked …show more content…

“If you go through puberty, you have all of the benefits of having a male body. Even if you transition and reduce your testosterone, you’re still going to have those benefits” (Mackenzie 17). This quote provides insight into how Peyton Mackenzie feels about this topic. She is conversing about the physical advantages that a biological male, assigned at birth, may maintain even after transitioning, due to going through male puberty. It is often alluded to in debates about transgender athletes in sports. As the consultation on gender identity and sports intensifies, a striking source quote brings to light a contentious issue. This quote challenges society to examine the intersection of diversity and fairness within competitive sports. “Among the casualties of the woke transgender ideologies are the biological women whose athletic records are being shattered and whose accomplishments are being overshadowed by biological males pumped with female hormones” (Duncan …show more content…

The involvement of transgender athletes in competitive sports raises many individuals questioning the fairness and criteria for diversity. Muller is expressing how he does not grind words when weighing in on the argument in which he displays a specific detail. “Thomas, yet another biological male pretending to be a female, dominated the race, even setting a season record within the NCAA for that year” (Muller 10). This quote demonstrates trans athlete, Thomas, who biologically is a male but transitioned into a female and then competed in women’s sports and set records. Muller’s view seems crucial to Thomas’s participation, implying an unfair advantage due to Thomas’s biological genes. However, Shields brings a certain outcome more personal by sharing a more passionate moment. “She witnessed a fellow competitor finish 17th in a race that Thomas dominated, narrowly missing the chance to be an All-American and to compete in the consolation race” (Shields 10). This is echoing in the specific athlete who came close to a huge achievement that got taken away due to the competitiveness in

Open Document