Who Has Seen the Wind by W.O. Mitchell, best exhibits the questions humans have on the complexity of life. Throughout Brian’s childhood he had to cope and deal with the loss of many loved ones. The death of a pigeon and Brian’s dog Jappy makes it difficult to discover the value of life on the prairie. After the sudden death of Brian’s father, he has trouble finding the value of life on the prairie. Brian find it hard to discover the value of life on the prairie after the loss of his grandmother. Brian struggles to find the value of life on the prairie because of the complexity of death.
Brian finds it difficult to understand the value of life on the prairie after the death of a pigeon and Brian’s dog Jappy. Brian was first introduced to death
…show more content…
when he held a dead pigeon in his hands. Brian questioned his father about the bird’s death, his father gave him a simple answer “it stopped” (Mitchell 67). Brian felt content with that answer and it was enough for him to understand. However, Brian questioned the death of his dog Jappy immensely. “Now there was an emptiness that wasn’t to be believed” Brian was in shock and did not want to believe that his dog was died (Mitchell 196). Brian hoped that as he was burying Jappy in the prairie dirt he would jump out from under the dirt. Then he was reminded of the cold stiff body that was similar to the pigeons and he knew that Jappy was died. Brian was able to accept the death of the pigeon, with the death of his dog Jappy the answers were no longer sufficient because he had not seen death to something he loved. Brian felt as if life was unfair, he did not understand why god would give him a dog to love if only to take it away from him soon after. The value of life on the prairie was hard to grasp after the death of a pigeon and his dog Jappy. Brian struggles to find the value of life on the prairie after the sudden death of his father.
Although he did not know his father was dying, Brian was drawn to the prairie. Brian ran away from his Uncle Sean’s searching for a sense of home, to only feel a naked sense of vulnerability and loneliness. Brian was informed of his father’s death while standing in the prairie. “His father was dead, but Brian did not feel like crying. He did not feel happy, but he did not feel like crying” he knew he was supposed to but he could not (Mitchell 257). Brian did not cry because he did not believe his father was actually gone, he still hoped that one day his father would come walking through the door. This was because Brian was not present for the death of his father, he did not get to bury the body or feel the stiffness of it like he had with the pigeon and dog which left him with further questions. Brian’s father was no longer there to answer his questions like he had been for the death of the pigeon. Brian was forced to try and answer his questions himself. As Brian stands in the stillness of the prairie he realizes that the prairie was forever “but for man, the prairie whispered – never – never. For Brian’s father - never” (Mitchell 263). Brian feels like life is unfair considering the prairie was forever but humans were not. Brian has trouble discovering what the value of life on the prairie is after the sudden death of his …show more content…
father. After the death of Brian’s grandmother, he has trouble seeking the value of life on the prairie.
Brian’s grandmother knew “her time had come” as a result did not want the clock on (Mitchell 314). She did not want to be reminded that her clock would soon come to an end, instead she wanted her window open to feel the wind once more which represented symbol of life. However, “the feeling that his grandmother was not dead, persisted in him” (Mitchell 317). Brian struggled to come to terms with the death of his grandmother because of the vast question, “Why did people die? Why did they finish up? What was the good in being a human? It was awful to be a human. It wasn’t any good” (Mitchell 318). As he stood looking out upon the stillness of the prairie he became content with the fact that he does not understand the meaning of death. As he stood, he saw tracks of jack rabbits, coyote trails and the tracks from a chicken, Brian knew “No living things move” which was the only things he seen (Mitchell 318). After the death of his grandmother Brian was drawn to the prairie because that was where he had dealt with the death of loved ones before. Brian struggles to find the value of life on the prairie after the loss of his
grandmother. The complexity of death is the reason Brian struggles to discover the value of life on the prairie. The death of a pigeon and Brian’s dog Jappy makes it difficult to find the value of life on the prairie. Brian struggles to find the value of life on the prairie after his father’s sudden death. The grandmother’s death makes it tough for Brian to discover the value of life on the prairie. After Brian experiences three major losses in his life he was able to come to terms with the fact that he may never understand the complexity of death. Brian realizes the prairie was full of death but still went on and that life goes on even with death. Brian still does not understand the value of life on the prairie but he chooses to see the good instead of the bad as he looks out onto the prairie to see, “dogs barking, coyotes howling and a train riding into the night” rather then the lives lost (Mitchell 318).
Brian's Search for the Meaning of Life in W.O. Mitchell's Who Has Seen the Wind
My initial response to the poem was a deep sense of empathy. This indicated to me the way the man’s body was treated after he had passed. I felt sorry for him as the poet created the strong feeling that he had a lonely life. It told us how his body became a part of the land and how he added something to the land around him after he died.
One of the only truly inevitable things in life is death. While there are ways to prolong the time before death, there is no escaping it, as the main characters of “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall” and “A Good Man is Hard to Find” knew all too well. Both of these elderly women expected their deaths in some way, and while they may have been initially resistant, they eventually came to accept their fate. When comparing the characters of Granny Weatherall and the grandmother from “A Good Man is Hard to Find”, similar elements such as religion, death, and a less than ideal relationship with their family can be found.
It's about sunlight. It's about the special way that dawn spreads out on a river when you know you must cross the river and march into the mountains and do things you are afraid to do. It's about love and memory. It's about sorrow. It's about sisters who never write back and people who never listen.” -pg. 85
The death of a parent changes people in a profound way. In the movie Fly Away Home, Amy Alden, a thirteen years old girl loses her mother in a tragic accident that changes her and her whole life greatly. After her mother’s death, she moved from her home to her father’s home in Ontario, Canada. She is very depressed, she sleeps a lot and she doesn’t want to go to school. She also did not connect to her father because she thinks her father is strange. She felt alone and isolated from the world and she does a lot of things for herself that a mother should do to her child. She is now very independent and she lost her innocence now that her mother died. Her life begins to brighten up again when she finds the geese eggs in the wilderness near to
The funeral was supposed to be a family affair. She had not wanted to invite so many people, most of them strangers to her, to be there at the moment she said goodbye. Yet, she was not the only person who had a right to his last moments above the earth, it seemed. Everyone, from the family who knew nothing of the anguish he had suffered in his last years, to the colleagues who saw him every day but hadn’t actually seen him, to the long-lost friends and passing acquaintances who were surprised to find that he was married, let alone dead, wanted to have a last chance to gaze upon him in his open coffin and say goodbye.
Death and Reality in "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?" by Joyce Carol Oates
James Baldwin had a talent of being able to tell a personal story and relate it to world events. His analysis is a rare capability that one can only acquire over an extensive lifetime. James Baldwin not only has that ability, but also the ability to write as if he is conversing with the reader. One of his most famous essays, “Notes of a Native Son,” is about his father’s death. It includes the events that happened prior to and following his father’s death. Throughout this essay, he brings his audience into the time in which he wrote and explains what is going on by portraying the senses and emotions of not only himself, but as well as the people involved. This essay has a very personal feeling mixed with public views. Baldwin is able to take one small event or idea and shows its place within the “bigger picture.” Not only does he illustrate public experiences, but he will also give his own personal opinion about those events. Throughout “Notes of a Native Son” Baldwin uses the binary of life versus death to expand on the private versus public binary that he also creates. These two binaries show up several times together showing how much they relate to each other.
Through an intimate maternal bond, Michaels mother experiences the consequences of Michaels decisions, weakening her to a debilitating state of grief. “Once he belonged to me”; “He was ours,” the repetition of these inclusive statements indicates her fulfilment from protecting her son and inability to find value in life without him. Through the cyclical narrative structure, it is evident that the loss and grief felt by the mother is continual and indeterminable. Dawson reveals death can bring out weakness and anger in self and with others. The use of words with negative connotations towards the end of the story, “Lonely,” “cold,” “dead,” enforce the mother’s grief and regressing nature. Thus, people who find contentment through others, cannot find fulfilment without the presence of that individual.
For a parent it must be a horrible experience to see their children die, and for Ayah it was worst because “it wasn’t like Jimmie died. He just never came back”. She might still being waiting for her sun to return. Ayah hoped that her son would take charge of the family and continue the traditions, “She mourned Jimmie because he would have worked for his father then;” But he was dead now, he could no longer learn and teach the ways of his culture. Somethi...
In this excerpt from We Were the Mulvaneys, Joyce Carol Oates explores the theme of death and the passing of time. The author characterizes Judd through the use of symbolism of a rushing brook to show Judd’s helplessness, stream-of-consciousness writing that reveals Judd’s tortured and confused thoughts, and repetition of a key thought to further emphasize Judd’s deep-thinking and tortured character.The except begins with Judd falling into a trance over a rushing brook. This brook begins his thoughtful journey, and symbolizes the years rushing past. This symbol shows us how, like the brook, the journey of life can absorb us; “it began to happen as it always does the water gets slower and slower and you’re the one who begins to move —oh boy! We-ird!” Just like life, the brook is glimmering and hard to hold on
The sunset is the death of the day and the birth of the, reveled for their initial beauty, and soon feared for the darkness that ensues. These ostensibly opposite situations appear when the Gladney family find themselves unsure of how to react to the beautifully terminal sunset: “Certainly there is awe, it is all awe, it transcends previous categories of awe, but we don't know whether we are watching in wonder or dread, we don't know what we are watching or what it means, we don't know whether it is permanent, a level of experience to which we will gradually adjust, into which our uncertainty will eventually be absorbed, or just some atmospheric weirdness, soon to pass” (DeLillo, 308). Death exists as this a foreign yet familiar concept you go throughout your entire life knowing the inevitability of. It inspires you to live your life to the fullest while concurrently indicating that eventually none of it will matter. There is no correct way to endure or confront it. The only way to truly come to respect death is by forming a crowd, a shield, to ward off irrelevant extrapolation. The sunset scene demonstrates the validation of death through crowds. Jack and his family realize that only by being together, the mysterious concept no longer has control over them. By validating the existence, you
...ple. The way that Frost uses body language, shows how distant that the couple is becoming. There are many ways that people can handle grief, this poem is just one way that two people handle their lost. “Home Burial” also gives the “morbidness of death in these remote place; a women unable to take up her life again when her only child has died. The charming idyll” (Robyn V. Young, Editor, 195).
In William Faulkner’s As I Lay Dying, characterization, specifically through the multitude of narrators, transforms an otherwise pedestrian plot into a complex pilgrimage to the truth. As I Lay Dying is told from the perspective of fifteen different characters in 59 chapters (Tuck 35). Nearly half (7) of the characters from whose perspective the story is narrated are members of the same family, the Bundrens. The other characters are onlookers of the Bundrens’ journey to bury their mother, Addie. Each character responds to the events that are unfolding in a unique way and his or her reactions help to characterize themselves and others.
Katherine Mansfield explores profoundly the world of death and its impact on a person in her short story, "The Garden Party."