American’s and people in general are an audience targeted for various commodities, advertising being a major contributor. The world of advertising has become a multiplex science, as mentioned in “What We Are to advertisers,” Twitchell divides consumers into 8 categories and Craig, in “Men’s Men and Women’s Women,” concludes there are specific times of day for advertisements to be displayed to reach specific audiences. “Mass production means mass marketing, and mass marketing means the creation of mass stereotypes,” claims Twitchell. These stereotypes of men, women, and humans in general are how advertiser’s reach their targeted audiences.
In James Twitchell’s article, “What We Are to Consumers,” he states that “the object of much consumer
…show more content…
research is not to try to twist their feathers so that they will flock to your product, but to position your product in such a place that they will have to fly by it and perhaps stop to roost.” This quote perfectly defines the science behind advertisements and the advertiser’s diabolical mindsets in getting consumers to buy a certain product. Of course, every product available is not catered to every person. As mentioned in Twitchell’s article, there is a system called the VALS2+, Values and Lifestyle System, that contains 8 different kinds of consumers, actualizers, fulfilled, believers, achievers, strivers, experiencers, makers, and strugglers. The VALS2+ is a schematic based on the fact that consumers “are motivated to acquire products, services, and experiences that provide satisfaction and give shape, substance, and character to their identities.” The more resources one has, the more likely they will be to use those resources to acquire the bigger and better. Beginning the VALS2+ system is the actualizers. The actualizers are where every person strives to be. Financially, they are more than stable and character wise, they are independent and smart, these are the people advertisers despise as they are extremely difficult to persuade them to buy into things. Next is the fulfilled who are mature, comfortable, and satisfied and value functionality and quality. Then the believers, usually those of religious families, they are predictable and old-fashioned Americans. Then the achievers, the ideal of consumerism. “They not only favor establishment, but are establishment.” Next are strivers, those who are unsure of themselves and not quite where they want to be in life. Then comes the experiencers, they try new things and live on the edge. Lastly, the makers and strugglers. Makers are the experiencers practical side, they do things for themselves. As for the struggler’s, they are outside the spectrum of materialistic but not because they have it all, because they are chronically poor. In Steve Craig’s article, “Men’s Men and Women’s Women,” he separates his target consumer audience by gender, unlike the compared Twitchell who separates economically. Craig also narrows his argument down more from gender advertisements, to gender television advertisements. He goes on to state, “the gendering of programming allows the industry to provide the proper audience for advertisers by constructing shows pleasurable for the target audience to watch.” In a nutshell, displaying the desired traits of both one’s own gender and traits generally desired in the opposing gender, in advertisements is what grab the consumer’s attention and sells it. Advertisements will portray a “man’s man,” by displaying a good looking, fit male and incorporating him in a situation that conveys the idea to the consumer that if they use that certain product they too could look like him. A “man’s woman,” generally in beer commercials or men’s cologne commercials, portray a beautiful woman, usually fit, thin, and most times blonde, being drawn to the man using the product. A “woman’s woman,” is generalized as a fit, thin, and beautiful woman and a “woman’s man” is a rugged, strong, fit, and handsome man. Incorporating these individual’s, one’s who portray to be the gender’s idealistic man or woman, grabs the attention of the consumer. The advertisements then insinuate that by using the product, they will attain or achieve the ideals for themselves. Commercials relate to every individual adversely.
Twitchell takes the economical standings approach that is laid out and defined in the VALS2+ System. Craig, categorizes by gender. But each author incorporated the ideals of individual consumers. As laid out by Twitchell, there are 8 different types of consumers economically and they each put higher value on different things, using that system advertisers can correctly and efficiently target and sell their product. As stated by Craig, aside from economics, gender plays a large roll in advertisements. Playing into the gender’s fantasy and idealistic means, by portraying they can achieve their ideals by buying the …show more content…
product. In my overall opinion, Twitchell’s view to take advertisements to the more economical approach is more realistic in today’s society.
Mainly because in today’s society, people are more conscious of being politically correct, are more sensitive, and are quick to call out things that offend them. Craig’s approach on playing out the gender specific ideals could be seen as objectifiable and deter a number of the initial targeted consumers away. Unless of course, the advertisements play more into the gender equality scenario, popular in today’s pop culture. Twitchell’s ideas economically and the use of SRI’s VALS2 system, is still applicable in today’s society, and will have a longer lasting applicability sense social classes and economical classes are virtually unavoidable. Advertisers will be able to ultimately rely more on the VALS2 system however, that is not to say that Craig’s “man’s man and woman’s woman” is not pertinent. For example, a beautiful woman all over a man who had recently used a certain cologne. This advertisement would entice men to buy into it, assuming they want beautiful women all over them. However, women could cause uproar and feel objectified by this commercial, though not the
intent. In conclusion, there is a greater deal of science behind advertising than meets the eye. The time of day, the colors displayed, the actor’s (if any) used, and so on, it all is specific to reach a targeted consumer. Twitchell’s approach will be useful to most all advertisers, since it is based on economic value of consumer’s, generalizing and categorizing them economically and socially. While Craig’s, still applicable and very affective, plays on gender ideal’s and individual fantasy to reach their consumers. In the end, both approaches are based on stereotypes of consumers.
It’s clear that those advertisements try to make an impact on our buying decisions. We can even say they manipulate viewers by targeting specific group of people or categorizing them so they could have a feeling this product is intended for them or what he or she represents. For instance, they use gender stereotypes. Advertises make use of men and woman appearance or behavior for the sake of making the message memorable. Therefore, most effective and common method is to represent a woman as a sexual object. They are linked with home environment where being a housewife or a mother is a perfect job for the. In other hand men are used more as work done representations. They are associated with power, leadership and efficiency. Those stereotypes make the consumer categorize themselves and reveals the mainstream idea of social status each gender needs to be to fit in and what products they are necessary to have to be part of that
Men and women both drive cars, it’s a simple necessity to be able go to work for most people, however, from the commercials on television, one would assume that men are the primary purchasers of cars. In Steve Craig’s essay, Men’s Men and Women’s Women, he analyzes four commercials to illustrate how advertisers strategically targets the viewers. Craig argues that advertisers will grasp the attention of the viewer by the gender ideals that both men and women have of each other. Not only do advertisers pick a target audience demographic, but they also will target the audience at specific time to air their commercials. By analyzing an Audi and Bud Light commercial, one can see that Craig arguments are true to an extent but it appears that commercials have gone from an idealized world to a more realistic and relatable stance. for are still [true, however it seems that commercials may have altered to appear more realistic.] [relevant to an extent. This is to say, it appears that advertisers may have altered their commercial tactics. ]
Twitchell’s claim is the article is that materialism is highly judge by the consumer especially by the Academy. One of his questions is “The real interesting question may not be why we are so materialistic buy why are we unwilling to acknowledge and explore what seems the central characteristic of modern life?”(365 Twichell) It states his claim and the thesis of his argument in this brief question. He wants the reader to think about this statement so he can further explain his answer. He stated that “Consumption have become production,” (367 Twitchell) that the consumer demands for product gives the sense of what they want or need leading to the producer to satisfy this urge. He also claims that commercialism is to the consumers “the water they swim in, the air the...
“What We are to Advertisers” by James B. Twitchell is a short article that emphasize how advertisement attracts audience magically. From the quote, “ Mass production means mass marketing, and mass marketing means the creation of mass stereotypes” James points out of how the world appear to be. The advertisers seems to be psychologically abuse to the public for them to be successful in their industry. Base on the way the society act, dress and thinks, we fantasize something ridiculous and only our imagination can only make it close to a reality. With that in mind, the industry of advertisements will immediately think of a way to try and sell their product to us.
Common sense seems to dictate that commercials just advertise products. But in reality, advertising is a multi-headed beast that targets specific genders, races, ages, etc. In “Men’s Men & Women’s Women”, author Steve Craig focuses on one head of the beast: gender. Craig suggests that, “Advertisers . . . portray different images to men and women in order to exploit the different deep seated motivations and anxieties connected to gender identity.” In other words, advertisers manipulate consumers’ fantasies to sell their product. In this essay, I will be analyzing four different commercials that focuses on appealing to specific genders.
The gendered patterns in advertising that Craig outlines in his essay still exist today, in commercials of how men and women are portrayed. In Steve Craig’s, “Men’s Men and Women’s Women,” it is stated that large advertisers and their agencies have evolved the pseudo-scientific method of time purchasing based on demographics, with the age and gender of the consumer generally considered to be the most important predictors of purchasing behavior. Therefore, Craig argues that computers make it easy to match market research on product buying patterns with audience research on television viewing habits, eventually building a demographic profile of the “target audience.” According to an article titled Web Advertising: Gender Differences in Beliefs, Attitudes and Behavior, previous research suggests males and females exhibit different beliefs about and attitudes toward traditional media advertising along with different advertising-suppressed consumer behaviors. Craig talks about how in John Fiske’s book, Television Culture (1987, Chs.
The documentary Killing Us Softly 4 discusses and examines the role of women in advertisements and the effects of the ads throughout history. The film begins by inspecting a variety of old ads. The speaker, Jean Kilbourne, then discusses and dissects each ad describing the messages of the advertisements and the subliminal meanings they evoke. The commercials from the past and now differ in some respects but they still suggest the same messages. These messages include but are not limited to the following: women are sexual objects, physical appearance is everything, and women are naturally inferior then men. Kilbourne discusses that because individuals are surrounded by media and advertisements everywhere they go, that these messages become real attitudes and mindsets in men and women. Women believe they must achieve a level of beauty similar to models they see in magazines and television commercials. On the other hand, men expect real women to have the same characteristics and look as beautiful as the women pictured in ads. However, even though women may diet and exercise, the reality...
Professors Carrie Packwood and Debra Merskin, authors of the essay “Having It His Way: The Construction of Masculinity in Fast-Food Advertising”, repudiate the stereotypical macho behaviors that are used in several commercials to build a reputation for men while women are used as objects. Media use this stereotype to sell nearly every product; being fast food, beer, and cars on top of the list. Furthermore, Packwood and Merskin claim that advertisement present men, compared to women, as superior individuals with total freedom who see women as prizes. The perfect macho type is a strong resource to sell beer; the Tui beer commercial “Temptations can be dangerous, stay focused” applied this stereotype, where men are on the spotlight and women
Advertising in American culture has taken on the very interesting character of representing our culture as a whole. Take this Calvin Klein ad for example. It shows the sexualization of not only the Calvin Klein clothing, but the female gender overall. It displays the socially constructed body, or the ideal body for women and girls in America. Using celebrities in the upper class to sell clothing, this advertisement makes owning a product an indication of your class in the American class system. In addition to this, feminism, and how that impacts potential consumer’s perception of the product, is also implicated. Advertisements are powerful things that can convey specific messages without using words or printed text, and can be conveyed in the split-second that it takes to see the image. In this way, the public underestimates how much they are influenced by what they see on television, in magazines, or online.
Curry and Clarke’s article believe in a strategy called “visual literacy” which develops women and men’s roles in advertisements (1983: 365). Advertisements are considered a part of mass media and communications, which influence an audience and impact society as a whole. Audiences quickly begin to rely on messages sent through advertisements and can create ideologies of women and men. These messages not only are extremely persuasive, but they additionally are effective in product consumption in the media (Curry and Clarke 1983:
Advertising surrounds the world every second of the day. This form of influence has had the power to influence how society views gender roles ever since men and women began to appear in advertisements. Through the exposure to many different gender portrayals in advertising, gender roles become developed by society. This stems from how men and women are depicted, which forms stereotypes regarding the individual roles of men and women. People often shift their definition of an ideal image towards what they see in advertisements. From this, they tend to make comparisons between themselves and the advertisement models. Advertisements tend to be brief, but impactful. The different portrayals of men and women in advertising show that advertisements
Originally the consumer was perceived as a blank canvas nowadays however, the figure of the modern customer is a very recent invention that originated in the big capitalist enterprise: an active, ever-evolving consumer. Businesses had the idea of ‘segmenting’ the market by sociographic characteristics
Nevertheless, one of the most important constants among all of us, regardless of our differences, is that, above all, we are buyers. We use or consume on a regular basis food, clothing, shelter, transportation, education, equipment, vacations, necessities, luxuries, services, and even ideas. As consumers, we play an essential role in the health of the economy; local, national and international. The purchase decision we make affect the requirement for basic raw materials, for transportation, for production, for banking; they affect the employment of employees and the growth of resources, the successfulness of some industries and the failure of others. In order to be successful in any business and specifically in today’s dynamic and rapidly evolving marketplace, marketers need to know everything they can about consumers; what they are want, what they are think, how they are work, how they are spend their leisure time. They have to find out the personal and group influences that affect consumer decisions and how these decisions are made. In these days of ever-widening media choices, they need to not only identify their target audiences, but they have to know where and how to reach
The allure of a marketplace is down to a science. Marketers want a customer to be as engaged and willing to spend their money as possible. Some tactics are downright dirty and a perfect reflection upon the company who employs them. While customers should be outraged at such ploys, perhaps they also need to realize the effect such campaigns have had upon themselves. Customer’s materialism is a direct reflection of today’s market and America’s consumerism.
Sometimes, when relatives and friends say “go big or go home” it’s not always in sports-related situation.. Graham Hill and Jessi Arrington both address the theme of minimalist in their videos during a Ted Talk. They both are very relevant to this theme as is the article “The Realities of Hedonistic Consumerism” in Rereading America. Although they all have their distinct characteristics and reasons for being relevant, Graham Hills video Less Stuff, More Happiness does a better job of explaining and giving examples. The two videos and the one article explain how as the years go by the normal American expands the storage they have to fit everything they desire.