Three Key Limitations Of SIA In Resource Development And Design?

1009 Words3 Pages

Although that SIA is considered to contribute effectively to social sustainability, there are three key limitations of current SIA practices leading challenges to achieve it (Vanclay et.al 2011). Firstly, the limitation of SIA in resource development and design. Secondly, people have traditional understandings about SIA, which limits the effective contribution of SIA to sustainability. Thirdly, the SIA lack of a regulatory agency definition and peer review studies. However, in order to fully achieve potential contribution of SIA to sustainability, three ways are promoted to achieve better sustainable development.

At first, from a resource developer’s perspective, the limitation of SIA practices (drawbacks in resource development and design) …show more content…

According to the definition of SIA, SIA is used to analyze, monitor and manage the social consequences. However, the current SIA practices has tended to be limited to being the assessed and estimated process (Vanclay et.al 2011). Especially, the current SIA is often used to predicate impacts other than to manage and monitor the impacts (Auchamp et.al 2011). In addition, the SIA was initially used for the public to discuss the likely impacts of decisions relating to government actions (Harvey 2011). While the current SIA practices do not meet the requirements. For example, the SIA community cannot convince all stakeholders to achieve the full potential of SIA. To address this limitation, a way is promoted to improve the SIA: Increasing the understanding and awareness of the benefits of SIA are essential for the public. To be specific, Esteves and Vanclay (2009) argued that the only method is establishing the value for SIA to all of its stakeholders (Vanclay et.al 2011). Through strongly emphasizing the value of SIA, achieving the fully potential contribution for sustainability becomes more directly. Moreover, here is a business case example for SIA to evident the effectiveness of this way. To get the better development results for both people and communities, the value of SIA is needed to be followed. On one hand, understanding the benefits of SIA is helpful to reduce risk for companies. On the other hand, SIA value always means the right thing (Vanclay et.al 2011). It is also beneficial for leading decision making and reduce unnecessary costs for companies. Furthermore, some other current good practice SIA are based on a good understanding of SIA and determining the value of SIA. Even in different levels of stakeholders, the value creation of SIA shows obvious and effective outcomes for them, such as the business, governments, local communities and civil

More about Three Key Limitations Of SIA In Resource Development And Design?

Open Document