Dissent, Depression, and War The 1880s and 1890s was an era of hard times, in which farmers and industrial laborers each fought for their own battles. While farmers united to fight for change, industrial laborers decided to take a stand. The laborers felt threatened as businesses combined into huge corporations. They wanted to fight for the workers’ rights to have better working conditions, higher wages, shorter working hours, and greater worker control in the increase of mechanization. Three major strikes took place in this time period. Two of which were the lockout of steelworkers in Homestead, Pennsylvania, and the Pullman strike in Illinois. In 1892, steelworkers in Pennsylvania squared off against Andre Carnegie in a decisive struggle …show more content…
over the right to organize in the Homestead steel mills. This bloody strike started as a result of Carnegie’s resolve to crush the Amalgamated Association of Iron and Steel Workers. This union consisted of skilled workers who bargained for workers rights such as good pay and exceptional work rules. The early 1890s were a time of severe economic recession and demand for most products had fallen making it difficult to maintain a profitable business. So, the management was determined to cut the cost of production, which they would be able to accomplish by breaking the union. First, the company demanded a wage cut for 325 employees on top of the large wage cut three years ago. Second, when the union decided to renew their contract at the Homestead mill, Carnegie refused. The Amalgamated were never denied a contract before. Carnegie and his chairman, Henry Frick, were determined to provoke a strike. They even prepared by having a fifteen-foot fence build around the plant and topped it with barbed wires. Frick hired 316 mercenaries from Pinkerton National Detective Agency to defend his fort and protect the strikebreakers. While Frick was getting ready, the workers were also prepared by organizing the town on military basis. They were "establishing pickets on eight-hour shifts, river patrols and a signaling system," according to McCollester. On the June 28, the Homestead lockout started, when Frick locked the workers out of the mills and prepared to bring the strikebreakers.
Strikebreakers were non-union workers, who were brought in to keep the plant operating during strikes. The union vowed to not let the strikebreakers into the plant. On June 6, a lookout spotted an attempted smuggling of Pinkertons into Homestead by Frick’s instructions. As the word spread thousands of workers and their families crowed the river barges to keep them out. Fighting erupted and gunfire shots broke out, killing more than a dozen Pinkertons, and some thirty strikers. In the end, the Pinkerton surrendered and came ashore where they were beaten and cursed by the angry workers. Though the workers became victorious in the “battle of Fort Frick,” they didn’t win completely. Four days later, Frick pressured Pennsylvania’s governor to order eight thousand National Guard troops into Homestead to protect Carnegie’s property and take back the control of the town. In an attempt to reignite the uprising, Alexander Berkman attempted to assassinate Frick. But Frick survived, and the union lost any support and sympathy from the public. In the end, the Homestead strike failed. In November, the Homestead mill reopened and men returned to work with lower wages and longer work hours. The Homestead strike had inspired many workers, but it also became clear that without the power of government any labor unions would have a difficulty …show more content…
winning. The second major strike was a disturbing event in the history of Illinois. The main cause of the Pullman Strike was because of the way George M. Pullman, founder and president of the Pullman Palace Car Company, treated his workers. Pullman had moved his plant and workers to a town he created. He required his workers to live there. The Pullman City had parks, libraries, playgrounds, hotels, churches, shops, markets, and 1,800 housing units. Nothing was free at Pullman City. The workers would be pay high price to live in the model town. The Pullman town was clearly superior to the neighboring towns, but so were the rents which ran 10 to 20 percent higher than nearby communities.1 In 1893, the economic depression caused factories to cut the workers wage by 25-28 percent, but Pullman refused to lower the rent in his model town. The problem was more than just economic inequality. The company also attempted to control work process by undermining skilled craftsmen. Fed up with the problems, Pullman’s workers asked the American Railway Union for help. The American Railway Union was led by Eugene V.
Debs, who pledged to organize all railway workers. Without union’s authorization, the three thousand workers went on a strike. Pullman countered by shutting down the plant. The strikers appealed to the ARU for aid. After slight hesitation, the ARU members voted to boycott all Pullman cars. By June 29, switchmen across United States refused any train that carried Pullman cars. The uprising quickly increased and the General Managers Association acted to overturn the Pullman boycott. Their strategy was to fire the switchmen and recruit strikebreakers. The reaction was that entire train crews walked off the job in show of support the Pullman workers. The strike soon spread to more then fifteen railroads. The boycott/strike stayed peaceful with no violent riots or property damage occurred. Debs made sure to let the union know that no violence should take place. However, the newspapers flooded stories that portrayed the protest as violent. In order to break the strike the railroads knew they needed the federal troops, however governor of Illinois refused observing that the boycott remained peaceful. Attorney General Richard B. Olney was determined to put down the strike, so he convinced President Grover Cleveland that federal troops are needed to protect the mails. Olney’s strategy worked and the president called out the army. Upon seeing the troops, violence erupted and in one day 25 workers were killed, 60 more were wounded.
Though it wasn’t the bullets the broke the strike it was Debs arrest. With the leader in jail and its member disheartened the ARU was defeated along with boycott. Pullman reopened his factory and hired new workers to replace many of the strikers. Overall the aftermath left 1,600 workers without jobs.1 The outcome of both major strikes concludes that without the government interference, the laborers would have won. However, though the workers did not win the strikes, they did plant a seed of doubt for the way workers and laborers were being treated. I believe it’s these major conflicts, the Homestead lockout and the Pullman strike, which made it clear that an alternative vision of American economic democracy was needed.
The Pullman Strike was a disturbing event in Chicago, Illinois history. It occurred because of the way George Pullman, founder of the Pullman Palace Car Company treated his workers. George Pullman was born in 1831, in upstate New York, he was the son of a carpenter. He learned carpentry himself and moved to Chicago, Illinois in the 1850s. From there, he opened up his own railroad company called the Pullman Palace Car Company and it took off from there. During the Civil war he began creating a new kind of passenger car that would allow passengers to enjoy themselves. It was a new line of luxury railroad cars featuring comfortable seating, restaurants, and improved sleeping accommodations. Because low paid railroad workers, led by Eugene Debs, took a stand against George Pullman by boycotting and
During the Railroad Strike of 1877, when large crowds in Baltimore attempted to attack militia breaking up the strike, President Hayes got word of the uprising and personally sent his troops to quell it (DOC B). Many witnesses of the strike used Yellow Journalism to make it seem as if Communists were causing the strike through the use of political cartoons in newspapers, such as “Always killing the goose that lays the golden egg” (DOC C), where the strike was purposefully invalidated to break up the labor movement. Nevertheless, the largeness of the uprising made strikes become more widely-known, causing employers to be slower to slash wages in fear of a bigger
James B. Weaver illustrates the true damage of monopolies on the public in “A Call to Action” (Document 4). Weaver, a two-time candidate for president of the United States, addresses the meticulous tactics which trusts and monopolies use to increase their profit at the expense of the public and asserts that their main weapons are, ”threats, intimidation, bribery, fraud, wreck, and pillage.” Arguments such as Weaver’s, suggest and end to the end of the laissez-faire capitalism that monopolies are sustained upon. Laissez-faire capitalism is essentially a system where the government takes no position in the affairs of businesses and does not interfere, no matter what harm is being done. This ideology dominated the business world of the century and allowed for vast unemployment, low wages, and impoverishment. Soon, laborers also begin to express their dismay with the way that such businesses are run and the treatment of workers in the railroad industry. An instance of this being the Pullman Strike of 1894. In 1894, laborers went on a nationwide strike against the Pullman Company; they issued a statement regarding their strike in June (Document 6). Workers are repulsed by Pullman’s exertion of power over several institutions and how his greed affects his competitors, who must reduce their wages to keep up with his businesses. This incident inspires many to take
The 1919 steel strike was an attempt to organize the United States steel industry after World War One. The strike lasted about five months, and was unsuccessful. It began on September 21, 1919, and collapsed on January 8, 1920. It was started by the Amalgamated Association of Iron, Steel and Tin Workers, or the AA. The AA had formed in 1876. It was a union of iron and steel workers which was very committed to creating unionism, but advancements in technology had decreased the amount of skilled workers in the industries.
“Industrial unions dominated the landscape of the late nineteen century U.S. labor movement.” They gathered all level workers together without discrimination of gender, race, or nationality. They declared the eight-hour workday for the first time when normal work time should be 12. Low wage of workers caused the “Great Strike of 1877”, which began with railroad workers in Pennsylvania and West Virginia. After the “Great Strike”, industrial union started to
George Pullman was not always believed to be a cruel boss. George Pullman started off believing that anyone could be successful if they worked hard enough. But as his business grew, he took this belief too far, furthering his own company by working his employees hard, treating his employees like slaves. There were many factors included in how the Pullman strike started. George Pullman and the company’s treatment of employees, how the town of Pullman, Illinois reacted to their treatment, other strikes that led up to the Pullman employee unhappiness and their reaction, the Pullman Strike.
In the late nineteenth century, many European immigrants traveled to the United States in search of a better life and good fortune. The unskilled industries of the Eastern United States eagerly employed these men who were willing to work long hours for low wages just to earn their food and board. Among the most heavily recruiting industries were the railroads and the steel mills of Western Pennsylvania. Particularly in the steel mills, the working conditions for these immigrants were very dangerous. Many men lost their lives to these giant steel-making machines. The immigrants suffered the most and also worked the most hours for the least amount of money. Living conditions were also poor, and often these immigrants would barely have enough money and time to do anything but work, eat, and sleep. There was also a continuous struggle between the workers and the owners of the mills, the capitalists. The capitalists were a very small, elite group of rich men who held most of the wealth in their industries. Strikes broke out often, some ending in violence and death. Many workers had no political freedom or even a voice in the company that employed them. However, through all of these hardships, the immigrants continued their struggle for a better life.
The Transportation Revolution in the 1800s, sparked up industrialization and the building of railroads that stimulated every other industry causing an economic boom known as the Gilded Age. From the outside, America seemed like the place to go to make all your dreams come true. But in reality, in was an era of serious social problems mainly caused by an economy with a free market policy, low tariffs, low taxes, less spending, and a hands-off government. This type of economy would eventually lead to the development of monopolies. These monopolies would then, in turn, lead to worker uprisings ‒caused by the suppression of unions created mostly by unskilled workers‒ that would contribute to the rapid rise and downfall of America. An example of this suppression is the Homestead Strike of 1892; due to hostility created by the unions, the employer fired all the workers, and rehired them on the basis that there would not be any more unions. After the workers started working again, the conditions were still unbearable, so the workers shut down the facility. The police got involved, the workers were pushed back, and the facility was reopened union free.
The Pullman Strike of 1894 was the first national strike in American history and it came about during a period of unrest with labor unions and controversy regarding the role of government in business.5 The strike officially started when employees organized and went to their supervisors to ask for a lowered rent and were refused.5 The strike had many different causes. For example, workers wanted higher wages and fewer working hours, but the companies would not give it to them; and the workers wanted better, more affordable living quarters, but the companies would not offer that to them either. These different causes created an interesting and controversial end to the Pullman strike. Because of this, questions were raised about the strike that are still important today. Was striking a proper means of getting what the workers wanted? Were there better means of petitioning their grievances? Was government intervention constitutional? All these questions were raised by the Pullman Strike.
...s became even more desperate at the time of the great depression that ultimately led to the great railway strike, in which many workers lost their lives at the hand of the Pennsylvania militia. This act proved to be a major turning point in the evolution of the labor movement in the United States.
The unions resorted to many forms of tactics such as boycotts, picketing, and the less prominent “closed shop”. The most prevalent of these methods, however, was the formation of riots. During the late 19th century riots included: the Haymarket Square Riots (1886), the Homestead Lockout, and the Pullman Car Company strike. The Haymarket Square Riots of 1886 took place at the McCormick plant in Chicago, Illinois in response to the worker’s need for an eight hour workday. The first two days were innate, but the third day was where the the situation actually instigated the cause. The owner of the plant, McCormick, attempted to bring strikebreakers (scabs), and a battle had begun between the scabs and the strikers. The riot, wistfully, ended the lives of four men when the police began to attempt to impede and halter the situation. These four deaths initiated a chain reaction resulting in the calling for the revenge of the four men by German radical Johann Most. Despite Johann’s reaction, 200 more Chicago policemen ordered the remaining strikers to leave the area. In the crowd, in the moment, a homemade bomb was hurled leading in the death of one policeman; acting as a predecessor of events, this event lead to a shooting between the policemen and the strikers concluding with the death of four workers and seven more policemen; entirely approximately one hundred people were injured. The Haymarket Riots caused public opinion to turn against labor. The Homestead Lockout took place in Homestead, Pennsylvania at Andrew Carnegie’s steel plant and was instigated by Henry Clay Frick’s wage cut. In this riot workers walked out of the company and then Frick ordered company doors to be locked and trapped the workers inside. Employees rebelled and caused about 200 Pinkerton detectives to come up the river to protect company property and created a battle.
The Coal Strike of 1902 occurred as a result of many problems that were faced by miners. At the time of the coal strike there were 150,000 miners working in the mines (Grossman) Due to the depression of 1893, miners had their wages cut and were living in poverty (Grossman). Many miners were dissatisfied and looked to the United Mine Workers for support in raising their standard of living. This proved difficult since employers refused to recognize labor unions for fear of giving them significant control over the industry. In most instances of employee demands before 1902, employers would use government troops or hire immigrants to take the jobs of the strikers (David Kennedy).
The early 1900s was a time of many movements, from the cities to the rural farms; people were uniting for various causes. One of the most widespread was the labor movement, which affected people far and wide. Conditions in the nation’s workplaces were notoriously poor, but New York City fostered the worst. Factories had started out in the city’s tenements, which were extremely cramped, poorly ventilated, and thoroughly unsanitary. With the advent of skyscrapers, factories were moved out of the tenements and into slightly larger buildings, which still had terrible conditions. Workers were forced to work long hours (around 12 hours long) six hours a day, often for extremely low pay. The pay was also extremely lower for women, who made up a large portion of the shirtwaist industry. If a worker were to openly contest an employer’s rule, they would be promptly fired and replaced immediately. Also, strength in numbers did not always work. Managers often hired brutal strikebreakers to shut movements down. The local police and justice were often of no help to the workers, even when women were being beaten. At the time, the workers needs were not taken seriously and profit was placed ahead of human life. This was not just a struggle for workers’ rights; it was also a movement for the working class’ freedom.
Beginning in the late 1700’s and growing rapidly even today, labor unions form the backbone for the American workforce and continue to fight for the common interests of workers around the country. As we look at the history of these unions, we see powerful individuals such as Terrence Powderly, Samuel Gompers, and Eugene Debs rise up as leaders in a newfound movement that protected the rights of the common worker and ensured better wages, more reasonable hours, and safer working conditions for those people (History). The rise of these labor unions also warranted new legislation that would protect against child labor in factories and give health benefits to workers who were either retired or injured, but everyone was not on board with the idea of foundations working to protect the interests of the common worker. Conflict with their industries lead to many strikes across the country in the coal, steel, and railroad industries, and several of these would ultimately end up leading to bloodshed. However, the existence of labor unions in the United States and their influence on their respective industries still resonates today, and many of our modern ideals that we have today carry over from what these labor unions fought for during through the Industrial Revolution.
Opposing the WFM were associations of mine owners and businessmen at each location, supported by the Colorado state government. The strikes were notable and controversial for the accompanying violence, and the imposition of martial law by the Colorado National Guard in order to put down the strikes. A nearly simultaneous strike in Colorado's northern and southern coal fields was also met with a military response by the Colorado National Guard. Colorado's most significant battles between labor and capital occurred between miners and mine operators. In these battles the state government, with one exception, sided with the mine operators. Additional participants have included the National Guard, often informally called the militia; private contractors such as the Pinkertons, Baldwin–Felts, and Thiel detective agencies; and various labor entities, Mine Owners' Associations, and vigilante groups and business-dominated groups such as the Citizens' Alliance. The WFM strikes considered part of the Colorado labor wars include: Colorado City, March to April 1903, and July 1903 to June 1904, Cripple Creek mining district, March to April 1903, and August 1903 to June 1904, Idaho Springs, May to September 1903, Telluride, September to December 1903, Denver, July to