Over seventy years many have accused Margaret Sanger of being a racist. Margaret Higgins Sanger was an American birth control activist, sex educator, writer, nurse, and founder of the established organization Planned Parenthood Foundation of America. Was Margaret Sanger a racist? People have said she was into eugenics and that her aim of Planned Parenthood was to rid of the black population through contraception, birth control. Margaret Sanger’s belief in eugenics does not guarantee her that she was racist towards the black population.
Eugenics is the science that tries to improve the human race by controlling which people become parents. During the 1920s and 1930s there was a big eugenics movement. This movement was that a better human race, breed, would come about if the healthy, physically and mentally, had more children then the unwell population. This is similar to Darwin’s theory of survival of the fittest. Sanger’s role in Eugenics was to try to give all of the sick, diseased, and those in poverty birth control. Giving them a contraceptive would greatly decrease the growth of their kind. Sanger once used plants to compare human race cleansing in her, “Children’s Era,” speech given in 1926:
“Before you can cultivate a garden, you must know something about gardening. You have got
…show more content…
to give your seeds a proper soil in which to grow. You have got to give them sunlight and fresh air. You have got to give them space and the opportunity (if they are to lift their flowers to the sun), to strike their roots deep into that soil. And always--do not forget this--you have got to fight weeds. You cannot have a garden, if you let weeds overrun it. So, if we want to make this world a garden for children, we must first of all learn the lesson of the gardener.” In this statement Sanger suggest that the feeble minded, criminals, the impoverished, those afflicted with inheritable diseases, and the unfit are the “weeds” and they should be sterilized or given birth control. So was Sanger a eugenicist for all races or was she a racist-eugenicist? Many critics will say she was a racial-eugenicist, but there is not enough evidence. On August 12 of last year Dr. Ben Carson basically accused Sanger of being a racial-eugenicist. Carson stated: "I know who Margaret Sanger is, and I know that she believed in eugenics, and that she was not particularly enamored with black people. And one of the reasons that you find most of [Planned Parenthood's] clinics in black neighborhoods is so that you can find a way to control that population.” This is not the first time Sanger has been accused of being racist.
Although she may have had a certain attitude toward the african Americans, her aim was to help all races with a contraceptive. Her first birth control clinics were mainly for the poor immigrant women, such as the Italians and the Jews in 1916. It was not until the 1930s that Sanger opened a clinic in a mostly black neighborhood. Even then, it was James H. Hubert, a black social worker, that asked Sanger to open that clinic in Harlem. This collaboration and making of the Harlem clinic was approved by W. E. B. Du Bois. The workers there were interracial and she did not tolerate any bigotry with her
staff. Although there is no real evidence that Sanger was racist towards the black community the amount of black women today receiving abortions today far exceeds the amount of abortions white women receive today. Today studies show that the percentage of African American abortions is about four times elevated than the white women. This still does not give proof of Sanger’s accused racism, because only one-hundred and ten out of eight-hundred of all the abortion clinics are located in a mostly black community. This high rate of abortions in the African American population can be linked to issues in the economy and other unknown reasons, but not to the location of the clinics, nor the false claims of Sanger being a racist-eugenicist. In conclusion, Margaret Sanger was not racist, nor was her aim to eliminate the black population. She did believe in eugenics and how the unfit should not be able to reproduce, because in her eyes they were not able to care or raise a child. Sanger’s main aim was to care for the poor, uneducated, diseased, and immigrant women of all races. Works Cited Sanger, Margaret. ""Children's Era" Speech." Primary Source Documents: 1920 to 1929. Facts On File, 2014. American History Online. Web. 1 May 2016. Sanger, Margaret. ""Children's Era" Speech." Primary Source Documents: 1920 to 1929. N.p.: Facts On File, 2014. American History Online. Web. 1 May 2016. Kessler, Glenn. "Ben Carson's false claims about black abortions." Washington Post 22 Aug. 2015. World History in Context. Web. 30 Mar. 2016. Sanger, Alexander. "Eugenics, Race, and Margaret Sanger Revisited: Reproductive Freedom for All?." Hypatia 2007: 210+. Academic Search Complete. Web. 30 Mar. 2016. Kengor, Paul. "Was Margaret Sanger a Racist?" CNS News. N.p., 17 Sept. 2015. Web. 1 May 2016.
Dorothy Wardell’s article titled “Margaret Sanger: Birth Control’s Successful Revolutionary” explains what inspired Sanger ideas on contraception and what problems she faced while working to change the notions and laws on Birth Control. The central argument presented by Wardell is that Sanger’s efforts led to privileges for women’s bodies and health centers providing methods for women to act on these privileges (Wardell, 736). Although Wardell is effective in supporting her argument, it would be stronger if she included some historical context and evidence of Sanger’s opinion in her own words found in a speech of hers and in Family Limitation. Wardell begins by addressing that “…a definitive biography and assessment has yet to be written.”,
Margaret Sanger was, at large, a birth control activist, but this speech was more about the questioning of birth control corrupting morality in women. People must remember, in the day and age where Sanger presented this speech, November 1921, women were considered very far from equal and much closer to servants or maids. In her speech, I saw that ethos was present in the sense that she gave herself credibility. Through Sanger’s detailed words and actions, and her statements including the presence of scientists and, or, professionals, the masses of listening people could infer that she was very well informed and solid in her statements. Though she presented herself as agreeable, Sanger was firm in her beliefs. In addition, Sanger says, “We desire to stop at its source the disease, poverty and feeble-mindedness and insanity which exist today, for these lower the standards of civilization and make for race deterioration. We know that the masses of people are growing wiser and are using their own minds to decide their individual conduct” (Sanger, par.15). To me, Sanger made herself appeal to the audience by using the word ‘we.’ In the practice of ethos, this focused on the author more than...
The American Eugenics Movement was led by Charles Davenport and was a social agenda to breed out undesirable traits with an aim of racial purification. Eugenics was a used to breed out the worst and weakest to improve the genetic composition of the human race, and advocated for selective breeding to achieve this. The science of eugenics rested on simple mendelian genetics, which was a mistake because they were assuming complex behaviors could be reduced to simple mendelian genes. After Nazi Germany adopted the ideas behind the American eugenics movement to promote the Aryan race, the eugenics movement was completely discredited.
...still a vital part of world today. Planned Parenthood is not segregated to color or affluence and has definitely changed the world as we know it today. Margaret Sanger though a determined selfish women did not get everything the way she wanted it to be. She hung up fliers in immigrant neighborhoods just so the poor or colored would go to the clinic. She wanted these people to go to the birth control clinics so they couldn’t reproduce. Margaret believed that if you couldn’t support the family you already have you shouldn’t have more children and she was a strong believer that the inferior race should not be able to reproduce. All of Mrs. Sanger’s actions said more then what her voice said. Margaret Sanger was a powerful strong woman who was celebrated as an advocate of women’s rights; however her motives were for all the wrong reasons.
"A free race cannot be born" and no woman can call herself free who does not own and control her body. No woman can call herself free until she can choose consciously whether she will or will not be a mother"(Sanger A 35). Margaret Sanger (1870-1966)said this in one of her many controversial papers. The name of Margaret Sanger and the issue of birth control have virtually become synonymous. Birth control and the work of Sanger have done a great deal to change the role of woman in society, relationships between men and woman, and the family. The development and spread of knowledge of birth control gave women sexual freedom for the first time, gave them an individual identity in society and a chance to work without fearing they were contributing to the moral decline of society by leaving children at home. If birth control and Sanger did so much good to change the role of women in society why was birth control so controversial?
Margaret Sanger was the founder of The American League of Birth Control which later became Planned Parenthood and her argument in those times was that it was not fair for women who were from a lower class could not have access to Birth Control.
One of the most important roles that a nurse fulfills as a responsibility of the profession is the advocate. Nurses are responsible to provide the information needed for a patient to make a decision and consequently support that decision. Margaret Sanger was one of the most influential advocates for women’s health and sexual health in general. Margaret Sanger was a public health nurse in New York who noticed that there was a significant problem in the way that women were treated within the healthcare system. Through her efforts she started what is today known as Planned Parenthood, defeated laws preventing the distribution of contraceptives and information regarding contraceptives,
The concept of eugenics was not initially intended to prevent overcrowding, however, it would later be used as a form of population control. Eugenics is the idea of improving society by breeding fitter people. Francis Galton was the first person to originate this term and was a major proponent of the concept during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The practice of eugenics was originally performed through the use of selective breeding. Eugenics was a progressive idea, driven by social perceptions. In fact, "many of its most strident advocates were socialist, who saw eugenics as enlightened state planning of reproduction."2 Fearing the degradation of society, the elite desired to prevent further social decay of the world by eliminating individuals who were considered unfit physically, mentally, or socially.
Margaret Sanger, a feminist and birth control pioneer, was born in Corning New York, the sixth of eleven children and the third of four daughters of Anne Higgins and Michael Higgins, both of Irish descent. Michael Higgins, an atheist and socialist, owned a monument shop and carved statuary for tombstones. Anne Higgins, a devout Catholic, was a strong-willed woman who died at the age of forty-nine of tuberculosis, worn out, in her daughter’s vi...
Bibliography: Nwhm.org. (2014). Education & Resources - National Women's History Museum - NWHM. [Online] Retrieved from: https://www.nwhm.org/education-resources/biography/biographies/margaret-sanger/ [Accessed: 31 Mar 2014].
Suffragists fought very hard for nearly a century to get the Nineteenth Amendment passed. Most people are aware of the great efforts by such suffragists as Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton, originating in the Seneca Falls Convention of 1848. However, what many people do not realize is the eugenic and racist ideas that the suffragists espoused. Why did the suffragists have these ideals, and where did they get them from? The sources discuss the suffragists’ motives in having these ideals, describe how these ideals advanced suffrage, and explain what larger implications this had in America both historically and politically.
The eugenics movement was a period of time when it was believe that the genes of your father and mother gave rise to any and all traits, whether it be physical, mental, emotional, behavioral, and moral. Essentially, eugenics established that all of a persons appearance, skill, and potential was rooted in your genes.
Soon she abandoned all caution in making public her radical views about marital relations. "A multitude of timid, undeveloped men and women, afraid of priests and politicians, ... are a hindrance rather than a help in any reform." ... forced national recognition of the morality of antislavery with a "thoroughly sifted small group of picked men and women." (64)
During the early 1900s, American nurse Margaret Sanger led the birth-control movement in the United States. She and others opened clinics to provide women with information and devices. Although frequently jailed, she and her followers were instrumental in getting laws changed. In subsequent years, laws against birth control gradually weakened, and more effective methods were developed.
Margaret Sanger develop this theory because her mom died from having too many kids and because of her belief with Eugenics. She believe that the unfit should not have kids and wanted to stop African Americans from having generation. Margaret Sanger was arrested for sending diaphragms in the mail. Diaphragms is a method of birth control used by women. She was later arrest again for opening birth control clinics. Birth Control has a huge impact on today’s society because there are plenty American Americans who use this method and do not know the damage they are causing their