The Positive And Negative Effects Of Cameras In Courtrooms

1802 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essay for cameras in courtrooms

Discuss the history of cameras in court rooms and outline the positive and negative of their presence. Cameras in the court room have been a recent phenomenon starting in the US at the end of the last century and has only recently been used in UK courts, although not as much as in the US (Lambert 2013). This essay will discuss the history of camera in courtrooms, outline the positives and negatives of their presence, how it has an impact within the court rooms and the impact cameras in courtrooms have on people on trial. The cameras in court rooms have both negative and positive impacts in courtrooms which will be explained throughout this essay.
The first part of this essay will explain the reasons why cameras in courtrooms have a negative …show more content…

This could affect a person’s Human Rights. Cameras in courtrooms could violate a person’s right to security and privacy. This is linked to Article 5 and 6 of the Human Rights Act 1998 (Hickman, 2010). Even though at court you are able to stand in a dock and not be witnessed by the suspect or anyone else, a person will still feel unsafe that they are being videoed on camera. A person will also have a privacy concern if their personal information is revealed through cameras or video broadcasting. Cameras will not only invade a person’s privacy but will also affect the person’s emotions. This normally happens in sexual assault cases or cases involving children. Cases which are to do with assault or children could lead to danger as the camera acts as a form of victimisation (Federalevidence.com, 2015). This is because people who are a victim of crime or are giving evidence in court will feel nervous or …show more content…

Cameras in the court room have been a recent phenomenon starting in the US at the end of the last century and has only recently been used in UK courts, although not as much as in the US (Lambert.) Looking back at all the research and understanding that having cameras in courtrooms could not only effect someone as a victim, but as a suspect as well. It can cause a person whether a victim or a suspect to an unfair trial. The Human Right Act applies to everyone and a person’s right should be respected at all times, but mainly cameras in courtrooms will effect a person’s security, privacy and a right to a fair trial. This relates to Article 5 and Article 6 of the Human Rights Act (Gov.uk 2014). Having cameras in courtrooms could also make the victims and suspects feel unsafe as they are being recorded, and also could make not only the victims and suspects feel nervous but also the people inside the courtrooms. The positives of having cameras in the courtroom will mean that, everything is recorded and used as evidence and can as well be used for media coverage. The media can also influence the coverage in courtrooms. Another positive factor for cameras in courtrooms is the judges and lawyers have proof if any unfair decision is made within the trial. The history of

Show More
Related

  • Kyllo Danny vs. The United States

    1163 Words  | 3 Pages

    The main subject in the Kyllo case deals with the advance in modern technology and how it relates to constitutional law. The overall question in this case is whether or not the use of thermal imaging technology should be used as a tool for searching the home of a person. The argument by the appellant, Mr. Kyllo, uses the unreasonable search and seizure clause of the Fourth Amendment as a defense against the use of thermal imaging systems without a warrant to search for illegal drug production inside his home. Kyllo v. U.S. is currently pending before the United States Supreme Court so the objective of this essay is to explain the procedural history of this case and to predict a final result and the implications of that prediction.

    Read More

  • Psychological research shows that eyewitness testimony is not always accurate, therefore it should not be used in the criminal justice system. Dis...

    1751 Words  | 4 Pages

    In summation, is can be identified in this paper that eye witnesses do not play a constructive role within the criminal justice system. This can be seen through a thorough discussion of the many issues portrayed through this paper. To conclude Schmechel et al. (2006) reiterates that statements this paper has presented and discussed;

    Read More

  • Jurors on a Death Penalty Case

    956 Words  | 2 Pages

    As one of the seven jury deliberations documented and recorded in the ABC News television series In the Jury Room the discussions of the jurors were able to be seen throughout the United States. A transcript was also created by ABC News for the public as well. The emotions and interactions of the jurors were now capable of being portrayed to anyone interested in the interworkings of jury deliberations. The first task,...

    Read More

  • A Courtroom Comparison

    1239 Words  | 3 Pages

    “I think there’s just one kind of folks. Folks” (Lee 304). Harper Lee is the renowned author of To Kill a Mockingbird which was inspired by the real events of the Scottsboro Trials. Throughout her novel, Lee indirectly references the case by creating characters, events, and symbols that resemble and contrast the case. These elements allow the novel to emerge with a more realistic and historic plot. In particular, the similarities and differences between Judge Horton and Judge Taylor, Victoria and Mayella, and the atmosphere of the courtroom are most prevalent. By examining these components one will be able to respect the historical features present in Harper Lee’s fictional literary phenomenon, To Kill a Mockingbird.

    Read More

  • Police Body Cameras Essay

    1118 Words  | 3 Pages

    I feel body cameras will bring more awareness to police departments when it comes to the honesty in their staff’s action when they are unsupervised. They can be used as hard evidence in court rooms, to help make the correct judgment on the situations in question. A case of which Officer Michael Slager fell victim to when the courts later changed their verdict after being presented with a video of what really happened.

    Read More

  • Police Body Cameras Research Paper

    749 Words  | 2 Pages

    While both dash cams and body mounted cams record interactions between police and citizens, “dash cam- eras are confined to places where cars can go, which are usually public places, such as roads and parking lots. A dash camera cannot easily record inside people’s homes and other places where there is a heightened expectation of privacy”(Freund 97). Thus, allowing body mounted cameras to record the more private aspects of a law enforcement related situations. Also “unlike body-mounted cameras, CCTV cameras do not record conversations”(Freund 98).This could deter people from going to the police when they witness a crime, because they are afraid of being exposed to the person who committed the crime, giving them the information needed if they choose to retaliate. Ebi, Kevin states that “sensitive information can 't get out if it 's never recorded in the first place,” so, if there is a distress call made to the police for help, there won’t be concern that the person in distresses voice, face or the inside of their home could end up on YouTube ("Body Of

    Read More

  • Examples Of Court Observation

    784 Words  | 2 Pages

    For the court observation assignment, I visited the Tolland County Courthouse. I went to court on Tuesday April 4th, 2017 from 11am to 12:30pm. The matters I observed in the courtroom regarded a restraining order from an ex-girlfriend to her ex-boyfriend. The details involved in the case included the welfare of their three-month-old baby and the custody battle.

    Read More

  • Cameras in the Courtroom

    2274 Words  | 5 Pages

    Throughout history there have always been issues concerning judicial courts and proceedings: issues that include everything from the new democracy of Athens, Greece, to the controversial verdict in the Casey Anthony trial as well as the Trayvon Martin trial. One of the more recent and ever changing issues revolves around cameras being allowed and used inside courtrooms. It was stated in the Handbook of Court Administration and Management by Stephen W. Hays and Cole Blease Graham, Jr. that “the question of whether or not to allow cameras in American courtrooms has been debated for nearly fifty years by scholars, media representatives, concerned citizens, and others involved in the criminal justice system.” The negatives that can be attached to the presence of cameras inside a courtroom are just as present, if not more present, than the positives that go hand-in-hand with the presence of cameras.

    Read More

  • Courts and Power Relations

    1420 Words  | 3 Pages

    The architecture of the courtroom establishes clear power disparities within the courtroom setting. The physical dimensions of Courtroom 5.1 were organised in such a way that the hierarchal nature of the court is visually clear from the moment you step into the room. The stratification of power amongst the courtroom actors is displayed through the ‘structural elevation’ of the seating (Carlen, 1976, pp. 50). The magistrate is seated at the uppermost level at the bench facing the defendant, solicitors and public gallery. This particular positioning demonstrates pre-eminence which allows com...

    Read More

  • The Accuracy of Eyewitness Testimony in the Criminal Justice System

    1837 Words  | 4 Pages

    Eyewitnesses are primarily used by the criminal justice system for investigating and prosecuting crimes, particularly in circumstances where it is the only evidence available (Wells & Olson, 2003). Their testimony is highly regarded as it allows for police, prosecutors, judges and juries to establi...

    Read More

  • It’s Time to Remove Cameras from the Courtroom

    1602 Words  | 4 Pages

    The human race has taken the solemnness of these meetings, and has changed it to a form of entertainment only clowns would be involved with. The public is so involved with this newfound form of fun, that they don't realize the actual damage that it is causing to the judicial system as well as human life. I feel that even though cameras are a very innovative way to educate people about unknown situations, they need not be in courtrooms involved with high-profile cases. The biggest trial of the century has been said to have been the O.J. Simpson trial. People flocked to their favorite public places to be with friends so they could watch the trial together.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Surveillance Technology

    195 Words  | 1 Pages

    Surveillance technology has improved abundantly overtime. It is so advanced in today’s society, to where you could be sitting in the comfort of your own home, and not know that you are being watched through your webcam. Being as though it is developed to capture ones every move it can be a bit invading. Although surveillance technology is a great resource for many things such as keeping society safe, it could lead to negative outcomes including: invasion of privacy and identity theft. Surveillance technology has grown vigorously since the attack on 9/11. For example, there has said to have been a proliferation of surveillance cameras that have been installed in public places such as Times Square and the nation’s capital. Also Britain being

    Read More

  • The Issues With Public Surveillance

    817 Words  | 2 Pages

    There are some major upsides in having cameras in public places. In early 2013 two people set off bombs at the Boston marathon, which killed several people and injured hundreds. The city of Boston had cameras monitoring the streets, and was able to identify the bombers within two days. (La Vigne, Nancy) The FBI was able to catch them before they were able to carry out another planned attack in Times Square, which could have been much, more devastating. In addition to being able to solve crimes that have already happened by using cameras, we are also able to use them and the other technologies that go with it to prevent crime. The National Security Agency has reported that it has prevented several terrorist attacks since 2001 using new technology put in place to prevent the attacks. However, much of the NSA’s tactics have been criticized lately, though the majority of people still agree that it is worth it. Using cameras is also a cheap way to monitor an area. Having to employ several police officers to patrol an area can be expensive and those officers could be out doing more important jobs. When you have cam...

    Read More

  • Law Enforcement Cameras an Invasion of Privacy

    1067 Words  | 3 Pages

    A. The "'Camera on Every Corner': Protection or Invasion?" ABC News. The. ABC News Network, 29 July 2007.

    Read More

  • Disadvantages Of Technology In Crime

    998 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Each light has a different preset wavelength designed to detect hair, fibers, and body fluids at crime scenes, these lights allow a crime scene to be processed faster and more thoroughly than ever before.” This technology is speedy and can help locate the whereabouts of criminals. The use of in-car camera systems has become very popular, especially by law enforcement. These cameras are used to record traffic stops and road violations of civilians. “From the time the first in-car cameras were installed to document roadside impaired-driving sobriety tests, the cameras have captured both intended and unintended video footage that has established their value. Most video recordings have resulted in convictions; many provide an expedited means to resolve citizen complaints, exonerate officers from accusations, and serve as police training videos.” Photo enforcement systems helps to maintain road safety by “automatically generating red light violations and/or speeding summons and as a result to greatly improve safety for the motoring public.” (Schultz,

    Read More

More about The Positive And Negative Effects Of Cameras In Courtrooms

Open Document