The Left Hand Of Darkness Alliance Pros And Cons

574 Words2 Pages

"The Left Hand of Darkness" by Ursula Le Guin explores an alien's attempt to get a separate planet's king to agree to join an alliance of the system's planets called the Ekumen. Although Genly Ai makes logical and well-supported arguments for the alliance of Karhide and the Ekumen, the king of Karhide refuses to accept Genly's proposal of alliance. Had I been place in the king's situation, I would have cautiously agreed to join the Ekumen. However, I would have refused to join without some sort of promise and proof of legitimacy. If a logical argument were all it took for King Argaven to agree to the alliance, Genly would have easily gotten the approval of the king. He gives multiple reasons for the alliance including material profit, trade, and increase of knowledge. Although all of these benefits would affect Karhide, Argaven does not see a need for …show more content…

Argaven is worried about how the alliance will affect Karhide’s honor, or “shifgrethor”, and Genly attempts to comfort Argaven by saying that their shifgrethor would be "enhanced, not threatened by the presence of the Ekumen."(37) The king's denial makes it much harder for Genly to prove his points but it doesn't stop him from trying. In an attempt to prove that his mission is legitimate, he opens a file with "films, photos, paintings, activities, and some cubes"(37) that represented the rest of the planets and the beings that lived on them. His last attempt to get Argaven to believe him is to show the communication between Genly and the Ekumen. Argaven reveals that although he is not sure whether or not he should believe Genly, he is sure of his fear towards Genly and the Ekumen. His realization of the scale of his fear causes him to dismiss Genly from Karhide and refuse to become a part of the

Open Document