The Land Of No Love In A Class-Riven America Analysis

1344 Words3 Pages

Clash of the Classes In America, many people are divided by what we comprehend as a class system. Within our society, a multitude of people finds themselves not interacting often with those outside of their class and can rarely find similarities with people with a different financial status. In Andre Dubus’ writing “The Land of No: Love in A Class-Riven America”, he speaks about his experience with his girlfriend who comes from an affluent background opposed to his less advantaged upbringing. Dubus shows that the experiences people face from different classes can differ entirely and therefore it makes it difficult to identify with someone outside of your class. In Andre Dubus’ writing, “The Land of No: A Class-Riven America” he is showing …show more content…

Dubus also shows that he is resentful because while Emily lives lavishly he constantly compares her circumstances with the many struggles he was forced to overcome growing up. Dubus is also resentful because if the classes in America were not so far apart, it would be less difficult for him to identify with Emily. While Dubus’ mother struggled, and worked two jobs to pay rent, Emily’s parents own five homes with countless rooms and a vacation ranch. Also, while Emily’s home was garnished with fine art and was brimming with designer carpets and furniture, Dubus’ home was filled with various infestations that seemed impossible to be taken care of. Both Emily and Dubus would not be able to identify with each-others upbringing. Emily most likely could not fathom living in the conditions Dubus grew up in while Dubus was amazed by the beautiful home Emily’s family owned. Emily shows her want to identify with life outside of what she is used to. Dubus declares, “Emily didn’t have to work, but, while she was looking for an internship at a TV studio, she found a job in a bookstore. She said she was grateful for her inherited wealth but did not earn it so would not use it” (113). Although Emily directly states that she is grateful for her money, she shows us that she also resents it. Emily is …show more content…

Dubus also displays his resentful feelings during this incident toward Emily because she appears to be nonchalant about the woman’s struggles that represent the same struggles he himself identifies with. This exhibits the invisible line between the classes which makes it challenging for people on either side to identify with one another. Dubus points out how he is from the “Land of No” while she is from “The Land of Yes”. This reinforces Dubus’ resentful tone because he constantly points out that he and everyone within the same class as him, have no choice but to fight for what their necessities. By Emily being from “The Land of Yes”, she can receive what she needs whenever she wants. With more wealth, people in society have higher access to things than those with less money which can cause people in lower classes to harbor ill feelings. On another occasion, Dubus states, “maybe because of our fights over her privileged life, Emily told me she would not even consider dipping into her trust fund, though she did not make enough at the bookstore to support us both” (115). Dubus was so resentful of Emily’s wealth, he made her feel as if she should bring herself down to his level to make him feel better about their financial differences. In many cases Dubus attacks Emily for her accumulated wealth and financial status.

Open Document