Debating Animal Rights: A Middle Ground Perspective

624 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The arguments of animal rights

Letter to Editor Even if animals are like us, human rights for them sound a bit too unrealistic. I guess we should just let all animals roam free and make the whole universe go vegan (nothing against vegans though). In 3 articles, either written by Yong, Braithwaite, or Rifkin, there are solid topics that slowly reel their way into the ongoing and serious debate: Should animals have the same rights as humans? Where I stand is a difficult position. Animals should definitely have rights, but only to a certain extent. Animals feel pain, which is why they should not be abused. Animals are like humans, which is why they should be treated with respect. There is such a thing called “The Circle of Life,” which is why animals are where they stay. …show more content…

Fish are animals, and it was proven that they feel pain. Humans have two nociceptors that actually alert us when we are hurt or damaged. Braithwaite says, “fish have the same two types of nociceptors that we do- A-delta and C fibers.(3)” If these 2 same nociceptors make us feel pain and damage, fish should feel the same. Fish feel pain, then maybe other animals do too. Bottom line is that animals should not be abused. There is a difference between abuse and discipline. Reversing roles, if we were animals, we would never want to be abused. It is still not a proven fact that all animals feel pain, but animals do have a sense of …show more content…

In the article, “Of Primates and Personhood” written by Ed Yong, primates are claimed to have personality. Primates are claimed to be much like humans. There is a program called the Great Ape Project that seeks to provide primates with legal rights. They should not be mistreated. Yong writes, “Those laws would ban the use of apes in experiments or entertainment or commercial ventures...captivity.(3)” This law should be granted. They have personhood and should be able to stay clear from being experimented on. If primates, then for all animals. An article written by Rifkin (“A Change of Heart”) gives an example of how pigs need social interaction or else they feel lonely and upset. This gives a sense of emotion. They should be treated with respect and have some rights of their own. They are just like

Show More
Related

  • Victoria Braithwaite's Hooked On A Myth

    497 Words  | 1 Pages

    To most people, animals are merely things for us humans to use as we see fit, for food, fashion and etc. This opinion of animals is not only insensitive and apathetic but also false. In addition, scientists and philosophers are saying that we humans are avoiding the thought of animals feeling the same pain that we do. In "Hooked on a Myth" by Victoria Braithwaite claims that fish are just as much liable to pain as humans are and raise an much doubt about whether or not fish should be treated with more mercy. As human beings who're capable of intentionally ending a life in order to relieve pain such as suffering, it may be time to treat marine life with more compassion as we do with other animals. It's unacceptable to just unashamedly ignore that fish "more than simple automata" (14). I think it's important to take into account Braithwaite's argument to find more humane ways to lock up the approach with captured fish if we were to continue to apply them as most people do now.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Dogfighting

    1072 Words  | 3 Pages

    Animal rights can defined as the idea that some, or all non-human animals are entitled to the possession of their own lives and that their most basic interests should be afforded the same consideration as similar interests of human beings. Animal rights can help protect the animals who experience research and testing that could be fatal towards them. The idea of animal rights protects too the use of dogs for fighting and baiting. Finally, animal rights affects the farms across america, limiting what animals can be slaughtered. The bottom line is, there is too much being done to these animals that most do not know about.

    Read More

  • Primates Essay For Kids

    527 Words  | 2 Pages

    From chimpanzees to capuchins to lemurs to marmosets, primates of all sizes are kept as pets worldwide. But even they are cute as babys they still grow up , and some are more powerfull than human!So the But the question looms: do they actually make good pets? Primates require professional, well-managed care. They are susceptible to both transmitting diseases to humans and contracting diseases from humans. People considering private ownership of primates should seek professional advice before making their decision. As monkeys mature, so do their motivations. Primates have been known to suffer intense psychological maladies, quite similar to ours. Prisoners become terminally depressed because they are kept in dark, sun-deprived quarters with minimal human interaction. Primates like her are highly social animals that require group

    Read More

  • The Cove: an Analysis of Argumentation for Animal Rights

    930 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Cove is a film of activism, a film meant to move the hearts of individuals who love and support the rights of mammalian sea-dwellers like that of whales, porpoises, and most importantly dolphins. Produced in 2009 by the Oceanic Preservation Society it offers a unique perspective, when compared with other activist documentaries. In The Cove the producer and co-founder of the Oceanic Preservation Society was actually personally involved in the filming efforts and worked directly with dolphin trainer Richard O’Barry in drawing light on the events occurring in a private cove in the city of Taiji, Japan. The documentary is, of course, very biased towards the topic, with obvious pro-animal rights leanings supported indirectly with a strong utilitarian basis. When analyzing documentaries such as this it is vitally important to take as objective a perspective as possible, though humanity tends to be innately prone to bias, and scrutinize through perspectives that have established ethical guidelines.

    Read More

  • Rights and Ethics: What We Need

    1140 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many countries around the world agree on two basic rights, the right to liberty and the right to ones own life. Outside of these most basic human and civil rights, what do we deserve, and do these rights apply to animals as well? Human rights worldwide need to be increased and an effort made to improve lives. We must also acknowledge that “just as one wants happiness and fears pain, just as one wants to live and not die, so do other creatures” (Dalai Lama). Animals are just as capable of suffering as we are, and an effort should be made to increase their rights. Governments around the world should establish special rights that ensure the advancement and end of suffering of all sentient creatures, both human and non-human. Everyone and everything should be given the same chance to flourish and live.

    Read More

  • Primates Persuasive Speech

    921 Words  | 2 Pages

    In each and every year there are more than 105,000 primates that are taken from the only home they will ever truly belong and could possibley never go back. They are thrown in to laboratories where they are abused in the worst ways possible. So many are killed each year due to the extreamely invasive experiments. They have indored more pain than any animal or any living creature should ever have to go through in a life time. It has been said that nonhuman primates are a very sensitive species.

    Read More

  • Hooked On A Myth Analysis

    286 Words  | 1 Pages

    In “Hooked on a Myth”, Victoria Braiyhwaite states that fish feel pain. Even though many think otherwise. I totally agree. In spite of the fact that fish might be seen as dumb , that does not imply that they can't feel pain. I've never been fishing but i can only imagine how much pain they go through and we don't realize because they show empty expressions. In any case, if no one shows their emotions you won't realize what they're going through.

    Read More

  • The Case for Animal Rights

    850 Words  | 2 Pages

    "The Case For Animal Rights" written by Tom Regan, promotes the equal treatment of humans and non-humans. I agree with Regan's view, as he suggests that humans and animals alike, share the experience of life, and thus share equal, inherent value.

    Read More

  • Animals and Humans Are Not Equal

    1101 Words  | 3 Pages

    Animals will have rights when they have the means to enforce them. They don't have the ability to reason as humans do. The human race has such a vast understanding of the necessities for all of the different species of animals to exist. Humans are far superior to any other animal because they are so advanced in technology. One advantage of advanced technology is, humans can store information as reference material. With all of this reference material humans can look back at previous mistakes so they don't do the same thing again. With this knowledge, humans can see and predict outcomes before a choice is made. Humans have the knowledge to enforce their rights, something no other animal has.

    Read More

  • Animal Rights Vs Animal Welfare

    750 Words  | 2 Pages

    Animal Rights and Animal Welfare? Two totally different things; one implies that animals should have the equality of humans, and the other implies that animals must be treated with respect, and cared for properly. Animal Welfare is the act of respecting, and caring for animals properly, and Animal Rights is wanting animals treated the same as humans. Now, the issue with this is, animals are used on a daily basis; varying from clothing to shoes, to ingestion, and scientific research. My opinion on it is that animals cannot be treated equally as humans, for they need us just as much as we need them. Over time, animals have been domesticated to depend on humans and that is exactly what has happened. For example, they now depend on us for

    Read More

  • Animal Testing Essay

    1303 Words  | 3 Pages

    Most would not put animals in the same category as humans so giving them the same rights seems quite ridiculous; since humans are supposed to be seen as the alpha species. What is a more realistic term is to consider them our property, because we continue to use animal testing and think it is okay to harm these animals. In the end, animal testing and research is cruel and should be done away with. It is a proven fact that animals feel pain just like humans do. No animal deserves to have his or her life purpose be to give his or her life unknowingly for science. We must to put an end to this cruelty and torture because just like humans, animals are living beings. No matter how it is perceived, it is cruel and unusual punishment.

    Read More

  • Literature Circle And Walk Two Moons By Sharon Creech

    586 Words  | 2 Pages

    A literature circle involves a small group of students gathered together to discuss a piece of literature. The discussion is guided by students' response, to what was read. You may hear them talk about events, characters in the book, the author's craft, or personal experiences related to the story. When doing a literature circle, it is important for each student in the group to know their role. As the circle progresses each week specific roles given are often rotated.

    Read More

  • Animal Cruelty Essay

    1257 Words  | 3 Pages

    Animals DO have feelings. They may not be able to talk and tell us where it hurts, but they do feel pain, just like humans. There are laws to protect animals, just like humans. I do not feel as though the laws are strong enough, nor are they enforced the way they should.

    Read More

  • ANIMAL RIGHTS

    794 Words  | 2 Pages

    Animals have their own rights as do to humans and we should respect that and give them the same respect we give each other. Animals deserve to be given those same basic rights as humans. All humans are considered equal and ethical principles and legal statutes should protect the rights of animals to live according to their own nature and remain free from exploitation. This paper is going to argue that animals deserve to have the same rights as humans and therefore, we don’t have the right to kill or harm them in any way. The premises are the following: animals are living things thus they are valuable sentient beings, animals have feeling just like humans, and animals feel pain therefore animal suffering is wrong. 2 sources I will be using for my research are “The Fight for Animal Rights” by Jamie Aronson, an article that presents an argument in favour of animal rights. It also discusses the counter argument – opponents of animal rights argue that animals have less value than humans, and as a result, are undeserving of rights. Also I will be using “Animal Liberation” by Peter Singer. This book shows many aspects; that all animals are equal is the first argument or why the ethical principle on which human equality rests requires us to extend equal consideration to animals too.

    Read More

  • Human Rights Vs Animal Rights Essay

    1878 Words  | 4 Pages

    Many people don’t even think twice about what rights they have, they assume since they are a human being there are just things they are automatically entitled to. At one point in my research I came across and article that showed 30 different rights we as human should have. For example: we are all free and equal, right to life, no torture, freedom to move, right to a good life, even a free and fair world. After reading the list several times I thought to myself why are these only human rights why can’t these right be applied to animals as well. The definition of animal rights states that animals should be free from human use and exploitation. Would these be the same rights as humans? No not by any means. I think what people fail to realize is that humans are animals, we are all mammals, primates, etc. Over time though it has come to be a separate topic and anything that is not a human being and is living is referred to as an animal. One of the best examples I found of animal rights is that “the prophet taught that the animals’ rights are to be respected, to be spared from suffering and given the food it needed, to be treated well, was not negotiable.” (Waldau 2010, 3) This shows what I believe to be the best interpretation of what animal rights exactly are. I choose to explain animal welfare only because upon researching I found a lot of

    Read More

More about Debating Animal Rights: A Middle Ground Perspective

Open Document