Many books and movies have strived to capture the teachings of the Bible, and one book by WM. Paul Young titled The Shack, tries to confront the dramatic scenario of finding and understanding God’s reasons for not stopping horrifying incandesces from happening. The book as a whole is heartwarming and does highlight some things that people may forget about God. However, some parts of the book can be debated as to whether or not that is God’s true intentions over the Ten Commandments, the dialog between the protagonist Mackenzie Allen and the Holy Trinity, along with the denial of God’s wrath, and reasons why other movies and books change the words in the Bible.
Some of the arguably better parts of the shack include God’s love for everyone and
…show more content…
the encounter with Lady Wisdom Chapter 153-171, that helps to explain why God has a hard time condemning any person to hell by drawing the similarities of having to choose between which of your own two children will go to Heaven or Hell. Just as most parents love their children so does God love mankind, not only the innocent but also the sinners. Jesus is a second chance for people if they truly accept Him in their lives. Yet what makes someone a sinner? The Ten Commandments help to show us what not to do and the original sin by Adam and Eve help to show us that by not following God’s command we sin. In Romans 3:23 Apostal Paul says “For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” showing that everyone has sinned. Without the Ten Commandments people will suffer as everyone would be a sinner and for the large part not know why. Stealing would not be wrong, adultery and murder would be ok. Despite what Young may write about the Ten Commandments they are still important to this day. In 1st Corinthians 11:1 Apostle Paul says, “Imitate me, just as I also imitate Christ.” While on page 205 in the Shack Mack and the Trinity talk about how people do not have to follow the rules of not only the Government but also the Ten Commandments. The Trinity then goes on to explain that because mankind does not have to follow the rules man can do no wrong, instead God will be disappointed when people make horrible decisions and that sin alone will punish people who do bad things without repentence. This goes against the teachings in the Bible because Hell is a real place and no one can escape the jugement of God. God is all loving, and his fatherly love is not meant to be kind all the time. He is the Father and fathers reward those who are good and punish the children that are bad. By saying that the Ten Commandments do not matter only undermine God’s words in the Bible. The dialog between Mackenzie and the Trinity is difficult to follow as Young tries to write down his interpretation of what God would say that explained the reasoning behind allowing bad things to happen.
Paul Young is human and even when people try to write about God they forget that Gods Reasoning is higher than mans reasoning. (Isaiah chapter 55:8-9) thus problems with the dialog between Mack and God can become confusing as Young tries to adapt to the higher thinking of God. Even with the best intentions in mind Young cannot add to the word of God (Proverbs Chapter 30 verse 5-6) Every word of God is pure; He is a shield to those who put their trust in Him. However, Young has pointed out something that is stated in the bible as he writes about the Trinity loving all men and women whether they sin or repent. All loving is one of the key characteristics that mankind can truly say God has because God was willing to sacrifice his only begotten son in order to save the human race. The Trinity in the Shack then say on page 209, “Rather than the top of a pyramid I want to be the center of a mobile”. The Shack argues against a hierarchy and tries to argue that God should not be put first in people’s lives but instead in the center. The bible says in Matthew 6:33, “But seek first the kingdom of God and all these things shall be added to you.“ and this means that no matter what people do they should always put god first. The difference between putting God first or in the center of …show more content…
peoples lives is only an argument over the same position and Young is only trying to further strengthen the fictional version of God in the Shack. The God that is shown in the Shack is more closely resembled to the teachings of the New Testament, and when God’s wrath is brought up on page 121 as Mack questions why God does not unleash His wrath on murderers, God states He never did that, and that sin is a punishment in itself. The problem with this statement is that while God is all loving He is also the Father and His wrath is just. Paul Young is not a bad author, but he is misinterpreting the bible and this is wrong. God is good and he does not give us what we want but what we need in order to live good honest lives in heaven and on earth. However, the Shack does highlight a truth that people must understand, and that is that no matter what happens to the people we love, or the innocent in the world we all must forgive or we will all be lost in anger, and despair. It is not our place to Judge others no matter what horrendous sin they have committed because in the eyes of the Lord we are all sinners and children of God. All sins are equal and though some people may not murder they may worship a false idol, or lie to their neighbors. In the end we will all be judged by God and He will know all of our sins. It is important to realize that no matter what mankind goes through Gods words will not change and if people truly follow the teachings of Jesus and the Apostles then there will be a place for them in heaven. People should notice the change that some movies make to the bible text in order to catch the audience’s attention. Movies like Noah may look nice with its art and graphics, but it does not accurately describe the events that take place with Noah’s family. These mistakes are more noticeable in Noah than the Shack but they are still mistakes made in order to sell money. Why should people care if a movie is inaccurate, especially when it comes to movies based off of religious text and documents? It is because while people who read the bible may catch the mistakes, the younger generations will feel that the movie is the true account of the bible and that every problem and consequence can be avoided with God. Free will is Humanities curse and gift because people can truly love God of your own choice and or they could unwittingly drift further away from him. In the process hurting others and themselves by not knowing the Ten Commandments or the punishment that await for not abiding by them. God is not mean and cruel and if people only look at how nice and forgiving god is then they will suffer a consequence over their hope that god will forgive their sins. Then they can go on living and making the same mistakes over and over without any consequence. God may forgive you but you must still pay for the people that you hurt and wrongs that you committed. The Ten commandments may be difficult to follow but because we have Jesus who is the path to God we have a chance to do the right things and pray to Jesus to help guide us along the course of our lives. In Psalms 139:7-8 it states ,”where can I go from Your Spirit Or where can I flee from your presence?
(8) If I ascend into heaven, You are there; if I make my bed in hell, behold \,You are there.” As the holy spirit explains in the Shack page 197, “Have you been with me the entire time?...Of course I am always with you” When people are alone they have a choice about whether they will abide by the rules even when no one is watching. The surprise is that even when you think God is ignoring you and that everyone is gone He is watching and seeing all that you do and he waits for you. If you feel like you are safe, that you pulled the wool over Gods eyes then be prepared for when God reveals that the person trying to deceive Him was the delusional one after. The Shack may not be accurate for the whole book but people should know that God is all loving and despite the differences between us God still tries to help us with both the wrathful and just God from the Old Testament, and the caring and compassionate God from the New
Testement. God is all loving and sometimes people forget that God is not always going to stop tragedies before they no matter how much people think he will. We are all free to make our own decisions and God has given people a chance to make the good decisions in life. People can choose the wrong path to follow and because of Adam and Eve’s banishment from the Garden of Eden people know the difference between right and wrong. The knowledge of the difference between good and evil and the Ten Commandments help to outline the actions and deeds that people must avoid in order to have a better chance of going to heaven. When people try to explain God in fiction they should be sure to follow the teachings in the Bible even if they are not always things that you agree with. Young’s depiction of the Trinity as three separate people was unique and if he had followed both of the Old and the New Testament teachings then the Shack could be a reminder of God’s infinite love for everyone. People are not perfect and are prone to mistakes, yet with the Bible and faith people can make good decisions and be free of a guilty soul. If people do want to write a story with God then they should be wary of their efforts. God is above us in every way and people should not try to mimic God unless we truly uphold the teachings in the Bible. God Jesus and the Holy Spirit help to better man and people should not try to change their teachings in the Bible. In life God should be put first in everything people do so that they can reap the benefits of following God.
The Kingdom of Matthias by Paul E. Johnson and Sean Wilentz is a story of the rise and fall of a religious cult established by Robert Matthews (Matthias). Within his kingdom, Matthias and his followers, abided by Matthias, believes of the subjugation of women by men. Even though at the time the cult was in existence the United States was experiencing two great movements that urged the forward progression of women, the Market Revolution and the Second Great Awakening. Two women in particular are mentioned in Johnson and Wilentz’ book that were really suppressed by Matthias and his subjects. One was Isabella van Wagenen, the slave that worked in Mount Zion and even Matthias’ own daughter Isabella Matthews Laisdell. The Kingdom of Matthias reveals the 19th century experienced the presence of an oppressive “prophet” known as Matthias who tyrannically degraded women through cruel treatment, sexual advances, and belittling them in a society that was starting to notice the inclination of women’s rights, all of these violent and atrocious acts eventually lead to the downfall of Matthias’ kingdom.
Douglass continues to describe the severity of the manipulation of Christianity. Slave owners use generations of slavery and mental control to convert slaves to the belief God sanctions and supports slavery. They teach that, “ man may properly be a slave; that the relation of master and slave is ordained by God” (Douglass 13). In order to justify their own wrongdoings, slaveowners convert the slaves themselves to Christianity, either by force or gentle coercion over generations. The slaves are therefore under the impression that slavery is a necessary evil. With no other source of information other than their slave owners, and no other supernatural explanation for the horrors they face other than the ones provided by Christianity, generations of slaves cannot escape from under the canopy of Christianity. Christianity molded so deeply to the ideals of slavery that it becomes a postmark of America and a shield of steel for American slave owners. Douglass exposes the blatant misuse of the religion. By using Christianity as a vessel of exploitation, they forever modify the connotations of Christianity to that of tyrannical rule and
In his book, An Imperfect God, Henry Wiencek argues in favor of Washington being the first true president to set the precedent for the emancipation of African-American slaves. Wiencek delves into the evil paradox of how a nation conceived on the principles of liberty and dedicated to the statement that all men are created equal was in a state that still preserved slavery for over seven decades following the construction of the nation. Washington’s grandeur estate at Mount Vernon at its peak had the upkeep of over 300 slaves 126 of which were owned by Washington. First, it must be understood that Washington was raised on slavery receiving ownership of 10 slaves at the age of 11 years old and that Washington was a man of his time. However, it must also be understood that Washington’s business with slavery was in the context of a constrained social and political environment. Weincek maintains that this does not exonerate the fact that Washington maintained slavery however; it does help to quantify the moral shortcoming by which Washington carried until his last year of life.
In the book, Apostles of Disunion, author Charles B. Dew opens the first chapter with a question the Immigration and Naturalization service has on an exam they administer to prospective new American citizens: “The Civil War was fought over what important issue”(4). Dew respond by noting that “according to the INS, you are correct if you offer either of the following answers: ‘slavery or states’ rights’” (4). Although this book provides more evidence and documentation that slavery was the cause of the Civil War, there are a few places where states’ rights are specifically noted. In presenting the findings of his extensive research, Dew provides compelling documentation that would allow the reader to conclude that slavery was indeed the cause for both secession and the Civil War.
And while describing the fiery wrath of the “Angry God,” Edwards states, “The use of this awful subject may be for awakening unconverted persons in this congregation.” By focusing on this group of people, Edwards instills a sense of fear within the audience of “sinners.” 3) Edwards purpose in delivering this sermon was to inform “sinners” of the inevitable doom that He thus creates a sense of helplessness in his audience, and encourages them to submit to God and renew their faith in Christianity. His use of parallelism allows Edwards to exponentially build a sense of fear, and it is maintained throughout this sermon.
On July 8th 1741, Jonathan Edwards preached the sermon “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” in Enfield, Connecticut. Edwards states to his listeners that God does not lack in power, and that people have yet not fallen to destruction because his mercy. God is so forgiving that he gives his people an opportunity to repent and change their ways before it was too late. Edwards urges that the possibility of damnation is immanent. Also that it urgently requires the considerations of the sinner before time runs out. He does not only preach about the ways that make God so omnipotent, but the ways that he is more superior to us. In his sermon, Edwards uses strong, powerful, and influential words to clearly point out his message that we must amend our ways or else destruction invincible. Edwards appeals to the spectators though the various usages of rhetorical devices. This includes diction, imagery, language/tone and syntax. Through the use of these rhetoric devices, Edwards‘s purpose is to remind the speculators that life is given by God and so they must live according to him. This include...
Dennis Covington writes about a unique method of worship—snake handling, in his memoir, Salvation on Sand Mountain. He begins as a journalist, looking in on this foreign way of life; however, as time progresses he increasing starts to feel a part of this lifestyle. As a result loses his journalistic approach, resulting in his memoir, detailing his own spiritual journey. Upon the conclusion of his stay in this world, Covington realizes the significance of this journey, and argues in his memoir that we cannot entirely know ourselves until we step outside of our comfort zone and separate ourselves from our norm.
Throughout a lifetime, many things are gained; experience, wisdom, knowledge, as well as a sure sense of self. But along with all these great things come regret, guilt, and shame of past events. Everyone deals with these in different ways, sometimes turning to religion and denial as coping mechanisms. In the novel The Poisonwood Bible, By Barbara Kingsolver, each member of the Price family deals with a personal guilt either gained while on their mission in the Congo or long before. This novel exemplifies the different types of guilt the Price family experienced throughout their stay in the Congo, and shows various means of reconciliation and forgiveness as the guilt is absolved.
Plans are revealed to, “hold a separate service on Sundays for [the slaves’] benefit,” in which pointed sermons were to be delivered to the slaves (Jacobs 57-58). One such sermon is inherently accusatory and meant to instill fear in its slave audience. Statements such as “God is angry with you,” “You tell lies”. God hears you,” and “God sees you and will punish you” serve to foster a sense of guilt and fear within the slaves, casting disobedience in any form as an affront against God, one that merits divine punishment (Jacobs 58). The sermon creates an emotional tie to profitable slave behavior – obedience stemming from fear – which it goes on to enforce as the will of God: “If you disobey your earthly Master,” the preacher claims, “you offend your heavenly Master” (Jacobs 58).
The theme of spirituality takes place in many novels that we have read this semester. Natives has used spiritual guidance as a means of connecting with their past and honoring their ancestors. To Natives, spirits have always played an important role in their culture and everyday lives. When Natives were forced to convert to Christianity and over time have their beliefs sucked out of them, the spiritual connection was broken as generations passed. One novel that particularly spoke to me on this subject was Monkey Beach, by Eden Robinson. The main character, Lisa, is struggling to fins herself after being blessed with the gift of being a shaman. In this novel, the author exploits how the European or western “white” culture has destroyed the native culture so immensely, that the younger generation cannot identify a spiritual connection without society calling them mentally unstable. Lisa suffers to accept the gift she has been given, and instead fights it by numbing herself with drugs and alcohol, which also being in another major theme of alcoholism in native culture, due to the suppression of the Native American race.
Slave-owners forced a perverse form of Christianity, one that condoned slavery, upon slaves. According to this false Christianity the enslavement of “black Africans is justified because they are the descendants of Ham, one of Noah's sons; in one Biblical story, Noah cursed Ham's descendants to be slaves” (Tolson 272). Slavery was further validated by the numerous examples of it within the bible. It was reasoned that these examples were confirmation that God condoned slavery. Douglass’s master...
“For The Bible Tells Me So” by Daniel Karslake is a documentary style film that focuses on issues about sexuality. The film focuses on the conflict between homosexuality and Christianity and the analysing of several Bible verses about homosexuality. The film attempts to alter the minds of homophobes by using facts, science and several interviews with Christians who also have gay children. The interviews are done with five American, very Christian families and “how they handle the realization of having a gay child” (Karslake, 2007.)
The Story of Christianity is a book written by Justo Gonzalez; a native of Cuba. Gonzalez serves on the faculty of the Interdenominational Theological Center which is located in Atlanta Georgia. He attended Yale University, where he received his M.A. and Ph.D. in historical theology; in fact Dr. Gonzalez is the youngest person at Yale to be awarded a Ph.D. He is also one of the first generation Latino theologians and instead of growing up Catholic, comes from a protestant background. In addition to writing many other books, Gonzalez is also Cokesbury’s publishing chief narrator of the Christian Believer study video lessons course and the recipient of the Ecumenism Award from the Theological Consortium in Washington, which he received as a result of his ecumenical work of bringing together churches of different denominations
... Print. The. 2003 Hartman, Louis F. & Lella, Alexander A. The Anchor Bible, The Book Of Daniel. New Haven & London: Yale University Press. Print, 1978 Cook, Stephen L. Apocalyptic Literature.
New Revised Standard Version. New York: American Bible Society, 1989. Print. The. Russell, Eddie.