Alain de Botton, the author of Religion for atheists : a non-believer's guide to the uses of religion believes that agents should be able to stay as committed atheists and still find religions practical, compelling and encouraging. It is possible for atheists to be uninterested by the doctrines of the Christian Trinity and the Buddhist Eightfold Path and nonetheless at the same time be provided with the ways in which religions save sermons, advocate morality, provoke a spirit of community, inspire travels, motivate gratitude. In the first section of the book 'Wisdom without Doctrine', de Botton holds that it is possible for atheists to balance a disbelief in religion with a selective admiration for religious ceremonies and notions.
According
…show more content…
to de Botton, a sense of community could be one of the most lacking elements in the modern 21st century. The privatization and individualization of religious belief were due to the fact that agents ceased to honor God jointly. Church, however, realizes about alienation of human beings, creating communities for humanity. A ritualized meal at church which we know as the 'Eucharist' brings Christians together to have a feeling of being home and let Christians to become family or friends from total strangers. The author even compare Mass with an Agape restaurant, where agents can become friends and feel closeness while dining together. Religions are not only good at forming community through their rituals, but also they are good at maintaining community even if it faces difficulties. For example, Judaism is specifically known for its own way to alleviate anger. On the day of Atonement, it is recommended annually to seek forgiveness from all agents could have hurt over the previous year. Section seven of this book, 'Perspective' was the most intriguing part of de Botton's arguments. 'Religion is above all a symbol of what exceeds us and an education in the advantages of recognizing our paltriness... Being put in our place by something larger, older, greater than ourselves is not a humiliation; it should be accepted as a relief from our insanely hopeful ambitions for our lives" (pg.200). De Botton's disbelief on religious faith and considering Christian's faith as obsolete superstition are well-shown in this section. De Botton considers religious concepts and religious practices as mechanical. He reveals his argument strongly that in any God-given sense, no religions are true. According to De Botton, the highest God in each religion is just a symbolism to maintain a productive human life. One of the main defects of this book is the fact that de Botton undervalues the power of faith, and considers religious rituals as behavioral mechanisms that generate effects instinctively. De Botton also finds paths to relate the mechanisms of religion to the area of atheism, rather than admitting the power of belief which should not be neglected. For instance, the author makes a point that most parents apply star charts not only to motivate their children, but also to develop the moral ability of their children effectively. As children age, on the other hand, they are not in need of the counterpart of adult star charts. Even in the fields of Education, de Botton has points to argue about what true religion is.
To Christians, the purpose and meaning of education is different from the concept of human nature. Christianity believes that human beings are vulnerable, sinful and far from being knowledgeable. These facts lead Christians to the need of God. De Botton holds that Christianity is more focused on souls rather than intelligence and emotion. Christian's part of job is to "nurture, reassure, comfort and guide our souls" (pg.113). Atheists, on the other hand, hold a new perspective on education, insisting that religions teach wisdom while secular societies offer information. For instance, "Secular education will never succeed in reaching its potential until humanities lecturers are sent to be trained by African-American Pentecostal preachers" (pg.131). Secular society gives agents a pile of new information, and make agents unable to remember the whole information which are taught. Then how should secular education should be changed? According to de Botton, the way could be found from how Christians are being taught. Just as pastors teaching sermons, ideas need to be presented and repeated. If secular education had redeemed with the way how Christians are taught, most philosophical and informative ideas and figures would have been able to be taught more …show more content…
effectively. De Botton further insists that some atheists eager to find alternatives for the beauty and emotion of ecclesiastical art.
They believe that even though gospels could be replaced by the secular books, ecclesiastical art could not be replaced. Even if they visit museums or galleries, it is difficult to find piece of art which brings agents to come up with any questions related to religion. To christians, art reveals that "other people are just altered versions of ourselves: fellow fragile, uncertain, flawed being likewise craving love and in urgent need of forgiveness" (pg.227). Christian art has a mission to spread God's words, virtues and vices. It also keep reminds modern society not to forget some important factors of life that could be easily forgotten such as love, hope and faith. De Botton holds that art galleries and museum could be transformed as a new form of church rather than just a place for showing impressive art pieces. Most arguments from this section were agreeable except for the part that the theme of Christian's ecclesiastical art is quite limited. This point of argument is not agreeable since the main goal of ecclesiastical art is to reveal how God saved us and how he created world. It is supposed to have curative powers for people who believe in God rather than painting a variety of different subjects. It should be reminded for most atheists that one of the ecclesiastical art's purposes is a therapeutic
purpose. As a perspective of Christian, temple, church, and chapel events, gather agents together not because of their closeness, but because of the common reciprocal belief that God in the highest heaven loves human beings, expecting humans to love family universally in the name of Jesus Christ. Even though de Botton's lacking viewpoints are provocative and need evidence, this book is quite recommendable. Each section of this book is thought provoking even to Christians. De Botton expects his readers to rethink about religion by making his points on the values of self-awareness, openness, universal love etc. De Botton strives to alleviate darkness in modern society in the perspective of atheists leaving readers with the question of 'what true religion is'.
Art educates. This education can be both positive and negative but art can function as an educational tool that has lasting effects. A 2009 article in the New York Times titled: “Schools Adopt Art as Building Block of Education” indicates the growing acceptance of art functioning in education. In this article, the unique architecture of the building was used practically by students “measuring whimsical figures of hot-air balloons, paper airplanes and pinwheels built right into the walls of their school” (par. 1). The architecture also functioned as inspiration for further learning. In addition, the article documented the perspective of a four-year old child who proclaimed that “When you look at it, it helps you learn.” (par. 20) When Jeremiah looked at the image of heaven and hell he learned significant life lessons. This picture that was presented in residential school ...
Art has always been considered the effervescent universal tool of communication. Art does not require a concrete directive . One sculpture,drawing or written creative piece, can evoke a myriad of emotions and meaning . Artistic pieces can sometimes be considered the regurgitation of the artist's internal sanctum. In Richard Hooks graphic painting,Adoption of the Human Race, the effect of the imagery,symbols ,color and emotional content projects a profound unification of a spiritual edict.
According to Marx, religion comes from the imagination of the mind, “Man makes religion.” (H/R,p.11) Marx believes in Atheism and that religion is simply justification to our actions and behaviors as “followers.”
H.J McCloskey’s article, “On Being an Atheist,” is an attempt to show atheism as a more practical alternative to the Christian belief. McCloskey reasons against the theistic beliefs of the cosmological argument, the teleological argument and design. He references the presence of evil in a world created by God and the absurdity of living by faith. This article is an attempt to reason that God does not exist because He is perfect and the world is not perfect; evil exists therefore God cannot exist. McCloskey’s article labels these arguments as “proofs” and concludes none of these arguments would be evidence of God’s existence. I find McCloskey’s article to lack logic and coherence which only serves to invalidate his arguments. I find this little more than an attempt to justify his own atheistic worldview.
Imagine pondering into a reconstruction of reality through only the visual sense. Without tasting, smelling, touching, or hearing, it may be hard to find oneself in an alternate universe through a piece of art work, which was the artist’s intended purpose. The eyes serve a much higher purpose than to view an object, the absorptions of electromagnetic waves allows for one to endeavor on a journey and enter a world of no limitation. During the 15th century, specifically the Early Renaissance, Flemish altarpieces swept Europe with their strong attention to details. Works of altarpieces were able to encompass significant details that the audience may typically only pay a cursory glance. The size of altarpieces was its most obvious feat but also its most important. Artists, such as Jan van Eyck, Melchior Broederlam, and Robert Campin, contributed to the vast growth of the Early Renaissance by enhancing visual effects with the use of pious symbols. Jan van Eyck embodied the “rebirth” later labeled as the Renaissance by employing his method of oils at such a level that he was once credited for being the inventor of oil painting. Although van Eyck, Broederlam, and Campin each contributed to the rise of the Early Renaissance, van Eyck’s altarpiece Adoration of the Mystic Lamb epitomized the artworks produced during this time period by vividly incorporating symbols to reconstruct the teachings of Christianity.
...n atheist might find the existence of a Creator incompatible with his life-long belief, and feel the clash between the truth and his philosophy in life unbearable. A devote priest would find the correctness of the evolution theory equally disrupting in his lifestyle and unacceptable. Another problem, though not extensively discussed in this report, is as relevant. Plato believed that less gifted people should not waste the society's and their own resources on learning and advancing to the 'Good'. Only the wisest would learn to become philosopher kings and receive education of the highest quality. This preposition rebels against everything discussed above and yields those less of a genius would inevitably lead less enjoyable lives. The happiest lifestyle would only be reserved to intelligent individuals. This introduces enormous contradiction and simply cannot stand.
Art, by definition, is “something that is created with imagination and skill and that is beautiful or that expresses important ideas or feelings”. Throughout history, one way that art has been used is to reflect a multitude of ideas and beliefs. Christian beliefs and ideas have been portrayed in artwork since the beginning of Christianity, although, it was not always acceptable to do so. The idea of the final judgement is a Christian idea that has been displayed in art repeatedly in a variety of ways. Michelangelo’s fresco the Last Judgment (1536-1541) is a piece that visualizes this idea. Since the time it was finished, this significant piece found in the Sistine Chapel has been continuously critiqued and analyzed. Many Christians struggle to interpret the event of a final judgment after reading it through Scripture. In analyzing Michelangelo’s piece, it is similar difficult to determine what he exactly meant to portray and what the various part of his masterpiece represent exactly. Many have examined this piece and made different regarding what exactly the various figures and objects are supposed to represent. The diverse interpretations of this work further shows the idea that when Christian ideas are reflected through artwork, it is hard to ascertain exactly what an artist intended to demonstrate. In addition, the controversies surrounding this piece represent the idea that when Christian ideas are revealed through art, there is potential for disagreement regarding what should and should not be included in Christian art. Michelangelo’s Last Judgment is just an example of what results when Christianity is brought into art.
Religion cannot be lived in textbooks, it is about the personal consciousness of those that believe and “their own account of their religion and its relevance in contemporary life” (Fisher, 1996). It is performed, experienced by the individuals living within society and communities. For some it is a sense of hope, to connect with a supreme power, to end the cycle of birth and death, find inner peace and/or a way of life. Traditional understanding of religion through textbooks, television, and internet does provide one with understanding about the religion doctrine and what they believe in. The majority of people will know what religion is when seeing it, for example, a Buddhist Monk sitting cross-legged in meditation. However, it is important to study religion off campus in order to grasp an explanation and a clear understanding of how beliefs change personal lives, how individuals tackle certain situations due to belief for example, Buddhist Monk sitting cross-legged in meditation, but w...
Theology is an intentionally reflective endeavor. Every day we reflect upon the real, vital, and true experience of the benevolent God that exists. We as humans tend to be social beings, and being so we communicate our beliefs with one another in order to validate ourselves. Furthermore atheism has many forms, three of the most popular atheistic beliefs include: scientific atheism, humanistic atheism and the most popular one being protest atheism. Scientific atheism is the idea that science is the answer for everything and god is not existent. The humanistic approach states that society is self-sufficient; therefore God is not needed for survival. Therefore how could he exist? The position that I will argue in this paper is the pessimistic idea of protest atheism.
The crux of Emile Durkheim’s The Elementary Forms of Religious Life lies in the concept of collective effervescence, or the feelings of mutually shared emotions. Through a hermeneutical approach, Durkheim investigates the reflexiveness of social organization, the balance between form and content, and the immense cooperation in collective representations. In his work, society is the framework of humanity and gives it meaning, whereas religion acts as the tool to explain it. Since society existed prior to the individual, the collective mind must be understood before the concept of the individual can be grasped. However, one component seems missing from his social theory – what underlies society in terms of rituals and rites? Only when this element is fleshed out can the individual be comprehended with respect to the collective conscience. One, out of many, possibilities is the often-overlooked influence of emotions. What is the connection between social functions and emotions? Perhaps emotions reify social solidarity by means of a collective conscience. Durkheim posits the notion that society shares a bilateral relationship with emotional experiences, for the emotions of collective effervescence derive from society but also produce and maintain the social construct.
Religion is the belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, especially a personal God or gods, a particular system of faith and worship or a pursuit or interest followed with great devotion (Oxford Dictionary, 2014). From religion, many new groups, communities and further derived religions have formed. Closely related to religion and with endless controversies surrounding it’s classification as a religion is the concept of Atheism- which is defined as the disbelief or rejection of a deity. Descending from this is a social and political movement in favour of secularism known as New Atheism. Understanding the historical content concerning the emergence of atheism, this essay will then address how various aspects within the field inclusive the goals, structures and approaches have emerged and developed over time in comparison to the original atheist ideals.
Steve Turner’s “Imagine” is a compelling book that urges Christians to view the arts in an unprecedented way. He challenges commonplace belief that “Christian artists” should only create for “Christian audiences.” Turner confronts the idea that most “churched” people uphold an ideology that our talents are to be confined to church walls. Meanwhile, it is more often the case that an artist would have better reach if their audience were secular. Turner forms his argument that “Christians should be writing poetry infused with godly perception rather than poetry about religion.” (28) Turner invites his reader to look past religion and deep into the heart of why the arts exist in the first place.
In today’s modern western society, it has become increasingly popular to not identify with any religion, namely Christianity. The outlook that people have today on the existence of God and the role that He plays in our world has changed drastically since the Enlightenment Period. Many look solely to the concept of reason, or the phenomenon that allows human beings to use their senses to draw conclusions about the world around them, to try and understand the environment that they live in. However, there are some that look to faith, or the concept of believing in a higher power as the reason for our existence. Being that this is a fundamental issue for humanity, there have been many attempts to explain what role each concept plays. It is my belief that faith and reason are both needed to gain knowledge for three reasons: first, both concepts coexist with one another; second, each deals with separate realms of reality, and third, one without the other can lead to cases of extremism.
The theory of evolution is often taught in the public school textbooks. It is widely felt that evolution is an attempt to completely remove God from all aspects of creation. Evolution destroys all meaning, purpose, direction, justice and hope in life. “You came from nothing, you are going nowhere, life is meaningless!” The Bible says in Psalm 14:1: “The fool has said in his heart, there is no God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that does good.” Secular schools attempts to erase God from the classroom and from the minds of the next generation by eliminating the Bible as the basis for all knowledge. They pontificate to students and do not allow them the freedom to use their faith-based foundations to express their understanding without being stifled for not being politically correct.
Art through the ages has been a powerful voice for both secular and religious ideas, and the treasury of Christian art should not be relegated to museum viewing. The art should be displayed in the church were it is meant to be. Its richness can be brought to people in schools and adult study groups. This, in turn, can help to bring art up to the level, that the faith deserves. Churches should fill the walls with art to show what happened throughout the bible. Art creates connections and associations between what we see and what we sense happened. Both ritual and art challenge us to take us beyond the immediate, if they are to bring about true insight and transformation in our lives.