More handpicked essays just for you.
Differences between the 1951 movie a christmas carol and the book
Christmas carol book main differences from the movie
Differences between the 1951 movie a christmas carol and the book
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Have you ever watched a movie and realized it is much different from the book? It might make you wonder why the movies are so different from their source material. According to Quora, one of the biggest issues is time. Movies and TV shows have a limited time period in which to get the point across to the audience.While watching “The Muppets Christmas Carol”, I’ve noticed many differences between the movie, and Charles Dickens, The Christmas Carol. This might be because the movie is only one hour and fifteen minutes long, while the book being one hundred sixteen pages. But the movie wasn’t completely different, there was many similarities too.
You could notice similarities since the movie first began. Here are the ones I noticed before the first ghost even arrived. Firstly, both story and movie were narrated, allowing the piece to be more detailed through explaining thoughts and feelings the characters were having. I’ve also noticed that the book and the movie share similar or exact dialog in some scenes. This proves that the directors studied their source material. It also allows viewers to understand some of the characters mood as they are saying their lines by hearing them get played out in the movie. Lastly Scrooge’s house was described the same way in both.
…show more content…
This is helpful so the viewers can picture and see the house and how it affected the plot. The film and story also had differences between them.
Here are three I’ve noticed before the first ghost appeared. The movie didn’t begin in the same setting as it did in the book. In the story it began at Marley's funeral, this brought out more atmosphere, because you get to see Scrooge’s reaction to Marley's dead body. Also, in the movie there is a comedic outlook while the book is more serious. This difference can definitely set the mood for the story.The story is taken more seriously, while the movie is more suited for children. Finally, a coraler came to his door in both. This gave the viewers a chance to see how rude Scrooge can really be, by showing him denying and yelling at the charity
collector. More similarities can be seen throughout the story during and after the first ghost arrived. To begin with, the first ghost comes at exactly 1:00 a.m. The timing is important so that viewers don’t get confused by the time the ghost came, and the movies timing is correct. In addition, the ghost takes Scrooge to see Belle. It introduces Scrooge’s love interest, and is one of the reasons Scrooge is so sour in the present. Last but not least, one of the biggest similarities, is that Scrooge changed for the better in both. This is very important because it shows that all the spirits efforts weren’t for nothing and it also shows Scrooge’s character development. Differences can be noticed through the beginning till end, on hand are some since the first ghost came, till the resolution. First of all, there was more time spent explaining the surroundings of the past in the book. This was a mistake the movie made because setting is a large part of the plot, but it can be different since you can physically see the setting in the movie. To continue, there’s a lot more characters in the movie than in the book. This can cause the story to get confusing and jumbled, making you focus on multiple characters at once. At last, in the movie it shows Scrooge's change and gives more details and examples of his behavior at the end than the book does. Many books get re-imagined into movies. The Christmas Carol being one of those books. It’s remakes shared many similarities and differences between them, but in the end, it’s all just one story.
Whether or not you consider Ron Howard's version of Dr Seuss's classic How The Grinch Stole Christmas comical, yet disgraceful, there's no ignoring the little green monster's reign over the box office. The movie, How the Grinch Stole Christmas starring Jim Carrey, was released in November of 2000, reaching a gross high of over $200 million in the U.S alone (The Numbers). However, I feel that this version has over exaggerated the original story, and I will back this up by showing many examples of how Dr. Seuss’s classic turned into a marketing, franchise frenzy.
The morality play Everyman and the drama A Christmas Carol both show how to live a life that isn’t focused around one’s self. For one, they both teach a similar moral lesson. The lesson of both is essentially that if you live a life full of sin then, you won’t have the more fulfilling pleasures in life. They both bring into account that the day of reckoning will come and everyone must be ready for that day. The characters presented in Everyman are the Messenger, the Doctor, Kindred, Angel, Death, Fellowship, Everyman, God, and so many more. The characters in A Christmas Carol are Tiny Tim, the Ghost of Christmas Past, the Ghost of Christmas Present, the Ghost of Christmas Future, Ebenezer Scrooge, as well as a few others. The main characters in both stories, Everyman and Scrooge, are spoken to by some sort of out of world thing.
When you get to the beginning, middle, or end u realize they are both very different. The movie and book have a lot in common like they both have the same characters .
being seduced to. It has been said by many at the time that sex was
How do we know when or how to change ourselves as people? Sometimes, we all need a shove from something or someone to help us better ourselves. The most dominant factors are kindness, fear, and regret. These three things can make us willing to go through the hassle and hard work of breaking out of a habit, whether it be putting your feet on the couch, or your attitude.
There are many similarities presented to the audience between the movie and the novel. One
In the play, A Christmas Carol, it started out with Marley speaking out to the audience, unlike the movie, where it just started out with Mr. Scrooge trudging through the snow. (Dickens 1) Another minor difference was in the play, the spirit of Christmas Past was a man, yet in the movie being a woman. (Dickens 11) During the visit of Christmas Past, Mr. Scrooge traveled through the past as another’s perspective, instead of his own. (Video
We see that he is immediately very touched when he sees this scene before him, which is exactly the reaction the ghost hoped for. After this scene, Mr. Scrooge sees his sister telling him that their father has given his consent to let Scrooge come home. We learn that she is now dead and that she left a child:
Some traditional stories are so influential, they are born again in modern-day books. Such as, A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. Ebenezer Scrooge lives in London in the 1800’s. He is selfish and greedy. His ex-partner comes to visit him as a ghost. He warns him that he will be visited by three spirits: The Ghost of Christmas Past, The Ghost of Christmas Present, and The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come. Just like A Christmas Carol, How The Grinch Stole Christmas by Dr. Seuss, The Grinch is mean. He tries to steal the Who’s, from the imaginary town of Whoville, Christmas spirit and happiness. Cindy Lou Who helps The Grinch become a better person. And of course, The Grinch’s dog, Max, tags along.
The drama of A Christmas Carol is a very popular selection as it brings out the Christmas spirit of even the stone-hearted. It starts with a grumpy old man named Ebenezer Scrooge. He dislikes Christmas and wants nothing to do with it. In order for him to gain his Christmas spirit back he is taken to his past, present, and future by three different ghosts. Doing this helps him to realize what Christmas is about. The turning point of the play is when Scrooge sees his own grave. This made him fully understand what he has done and what needs to be fixed. Ebenezer makes many
Halloween is the time of the year when people dress up and have fun scaring people. Christmas is the time of the year full of joy and happiness. All though these two holidays are quite the opposite, some people find it hard to determine what type of movie The Nightmare Before Christmas is. There are two different sides, the people who think it’s a Halloween movie and the people who think it's a Christmas movie. I personally feel and believe that The Nightmare Before Christmas is a Christmas movie. I feel this way because after watching the movie multiple times, I’ve come up with many valid reasons that can make your mind change to stand with me on the side of people who also believe it’s a Christmas movie.Those reasons include the movie’s
The two genres are similar in the areas of character development, setting and plot. Scrooge's, Mr.Cratchit's and the Ghost of Christmas future's character development were almost exactly the same. In the book and movie Scrooge goes from a cold hearted grumpy old man to a beloved kinf and generous old man. In both genres the story starts on Christmas Eve. In both the book and movie all the ghost visit Scrooge in his bedroom. The conflict in both genres is man vs self.
One minor difference in the movie was that the Ghost of Christmas yet to come has a hand of skin. Not a hand without skin that was wrote in the book. I think that this makes a difference though because it doesn't show a big impact on the story. I think Charles Dickens put the skinless hand in his story to give his story a "chill-factor". I don't think that the director of the TNT version of A Christmas Carol thought that it was a big deal or a big impact to the rest of the story. Another difference between book and movie is that Scrooge doesn't go to church at the end of the story. I think it makes a big difference though, because it shows how much Scrooge has changed since the three spirits came to visit him. It shows a "before-and-after" effect which I think made a big impact on the story. The last significant change between the book and the movie is that when Scrooge follows the Ghost of Christmas yet to come, he ends up falling into his grave. This is significant because Scrooge gets to meet the old Scrooge and gives him a slap in the face of reality of what's going to happen if things don't change. Its ironic too because it's the new Scrooge that wakes up on the bed in the morning.
In the timeless tale, A Christmas Carol, Charles Dickens focuses upon the extreme transformation of a character named Ebenezer Scrooge. The fact that several moralistic themes can be applied throughout the novel confirms why it is a classic.
Have your ever wondered how similar a book and a movie are? The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, -written by L. Frank Baum and the movie The Wizard of Oz, directed by Victor Fleming, is a great example. There are a lot of major differences in the movie and the film. In the book, the Land of Oz is real, Dorothy actually goes to the Land of Oz unlike the movie, where it is all a dream. One of the most interesting change in the movie is the color of the shoes. In the book the shoes are silver while in the movie, they are red. Another difference is the introduction of the characters. The differences are extremely important, because they make the story more interesting and unique.