Shame Punishment Essay

924 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Community-based corrections as an alternative to incarceration

The Reason for Shame Punishments in the American Jail System
Shame punishments should be implemented in the Justice system. Because we waste so many tax dollars for incarcerating small-time offenders, we should use shame to save money and make the system more helpful for those who are in it. Punishing by shame can be effective through many forms such as community service or participating in an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting to overcome drinking problems. Shame makes the punishment more personal to the offender and creates a solution that is the greatest for society. If a graffiti painter had to clean up all of the graffiti in the city, he would become sick of graffiti paintings. Shame is a resolution to the current problem in the justice system.
Jail Time vs. Shame In her essay, June Tangney explains her position on shame in the criminal justice system. She does not believe in shaming the person, but she wants to shame the act. When the person is ashamed of their self, they feel like they are a bad person and it diminishes their self-worth. They will not be less likely to commit the crime either because it causes them to continue their destructive …show more content…

People, who are humiliated through shame punishment, will act out because they do not want to be made out as a bad person. Humiliation should not be the goal of shame punishments. Guilt should be the goal to work towards. If a person is humiliated amongst their peers, they will act out with aggression by attacking people that make fun of them. What happens with humiliation is people use it to punish the person, not the action. Guilt punishes the actions and causes the individual realize that they are not bad people they did a bad action. Once the person realizes the consequences of their bad actions, they will grow as individuals and repair their

Show More
Related

  • June Tangney's Essay Condemn The Crime, Not The Person

    756 Words  | 2 Pages

    When an individual commits a crime, it is often discussed as to whether or not a jail or prison sentence or a punishment such as community service would be a good consequence. Others deem that public humiliation would be the perfect punishment for these crimes. In the essay “Condemn the Crime, Not the Person” by June Tangney, she argues against the use of public humiliation as a way of punishing against crimes committed. Of all of the different options for punishment available today, I believe that public humiliation is not an appropriate form of punishment and less severe punishments are the appropriate consequences for individuals who have committed crimes.

    Read More

  • James Gilligan Preventing Violence Summary

    694 Words  | 2 Pages

    James Gilligan is an American psychiatrist who presents the causation and prevention of violence from his point of view of working in US prisons for decades in his book “Preventing Violence”. Gilligan provides readers with a multitude of data and theories, but his book (or at least the first four chapters) boils down to the fact that violence towards other is caused by shame. He calls upon his many years of interaction with prison inmates and explains how inmates who committed violent crimes often said it was because they were disrespected, and therefore shamed. However, it’s very important to highlight that it takes not only shame but also an inability to “regain respect” after a shameful event, to cause violence as Gilligan proposes. This

    Read More

  • Shame The Emotions And Morality Of Violence By James Gilligan Summary

    1082 Words  | 3 Pages

    Once upon a time, the theory that the majority of violent crimes was caused by biological reasons, was a trendy opinion. However James Gilligan a notable psychiatrist, who has been working with prisoners and prison systems for years to study and develop the general method to prevent crimes, sees this psychological perspective, and comes out with a different conclusion. In the article “Shame: The Emotions and Morality of Violence,” Gilligan emphasizes that shame is the reason why most people commit crimes, and they tend to “diminish the intensity of shame” by violence.(44) He explains the concept of preconditions, which are key elements for violence to happen, to discuss the origins of violent crimes. Gilligan suggests that violent men are “shameful to feel ashamed about themselves.”(43) They also believe that they have no

    Read More

  • Capital Punishment: A Perspective from Death Row

    1036 Words  | 3 Pages

    punishment is an asset to society: it is the only punishment that fits the crime, it deters potential criminals

    Read More

  • Crime And Media Analysis

    1098 Words  | 3 Pages

    When the victim does not fit the ideal victim attributes which society has familiarised themselves with, it can cause complications and confusion. Experts have noticed there is already a significant presence of victim blaming, especially for cases involving both genders. The fear of being blamed and rejected by the public is prominent in all victims. Victim blaming proclaims the victim also played a role in the crime by allowing the crime to occur through their actions (Kilmartin and Allison, 2017, p.21). Agarin (2014, p.173) underlines the problem of victim blaming is due to the mass of social problems and misconceptions within society. The offender can have “an edge in court of public opinion” if victim blaming exists, resulting in the prevention of the case accomplishing an effective deduction in court (Humphries, 2009, p.27). Thus, victims will become more reluctant to report offences because of their decrease in trust in the police and criminal justice system, leading to the dark figure of

    Read More

  • June Tangney's Condemn The Crime, Not The Person

    957 Words  | 2 Pages

    Some crimes do not have to resort to being put in jail. This is where he the alternative come in at . Like for drunk drives, A.A, or if a person has a bad anger problem, have them go to anger management before he harms someone. Some are low enough offences that can be solved without shaming. Tapping into the feelings of individuals to behave in a more responsible manner in the future by fostering constructive behavior. Researchers have stated that “public shaming and humiliation is not the path of choice”. (June Tangney “Condemn the Crime Not the Person,” pg. 578) but it is a more affordable

    Read More

  • The Benefits Of Shame Punishment

    417 Words  | 1 Pages

    Shame punishments can build an immeasurable amount of good character. Typical judicial punishments today involve years jail time, and they simply hinder upon interactions with friends and family. A shame punishment serves as an effective method to build the hard working traits of a model citizen. For example, after enduring the punishment, the person will be reminded of it every time they think about doing something wrong. The painful experience

    Read More

  • Importance Of Emotional Intelligence In Restorative Justice

    748 Words  | 2 Pages

    Emotional intelligence in restorative justice not only falls into a method for helping mend wounds and resolve anger and fear issues after a crime has taken place, but also to prevent it. By holding emotional power over potential offenders, the community can use these emotions to seek to restore and prevent reoffending individuals. Besides positively engaging offenders, communities that practice restorative justice can also seek to shame offenders for their acts, without blaming the offender directly for their actions. One such method of restorative justice that communities utilize is the reintegrative shaming theory. Developed by Braithwaite in 1989, the theory states that societies that aim to create shame on the act of crime will reduce crime rates (Braithwaite, 2001). The theory

    Read More

  • Shame Essay

    1016 Words  | 3 Pages

    Shame can be an excellent tool to motivate a person to readjust their unacceptable behavior. It can also be painful as well as humiliating when others are unsympathetic. One can be shamed by their appearance, the way a person conducts their self in a public setting, or even stating their opinion. It seems that today there is an increase in being shamed by others due to a boost in social media usage. Within minutes of sharing a post online, that post can travel to thousands of different people. Shame can be both beneficial as well as harmful. When used correctly, many people can learn valuable lessons from being shamed for their ill behavior. Use shame the wrong way or maliciously, people can suffer emotionally and mentally.

    Read More

  • Public Shame Essay

    1046 Words  | 3 Pages

    Public shame is a painful emotion caused by a strong sense of guilt, embarrassment, and unworthiness that affects the community around the person according to the dictionary definition. However, most people refer to public shaming more commonly as a negative or positive result. For ages, public shame has influenced and affected people of all shapes and sizes worldwide. Each one of these people can refer back to that one moment where they were exposed to public humiliation whether it was tripping over a stair or completely blanking on a presentation speech. The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, “The Price of Shame” by Monica Lewinsky, and “Is the Internet a Mob without Consequence?” by Nick Bilton all discuss public shame in their

    Read More

  • Essay On Public Shaming

    1310 Words  | 3 Pages

    Public shaming is a form of punishment that dates back hundreds of years ago. Although, as of recently, public shaming is being used by judges as an alternative method of punishment, rather than the typical jail time. Multiple police captains and judges from all around the country are using social media as one form of shaming, and actual public embarrassment as another. Public shaming forces the offender to think about their crime while everyone else looks upon them, rather than sitting in a cell alone. Along with that, it can be used as a deterrent to the general public as well. By placing the offender in a public situation, it allows others to see what could happen to them if they were to commit a similar offense. Public shaming teaches offenders

    Read More

  • Victim Blaming Essay

    768 Words  | 2 Pages

    Assigning blame has become an increasingly difficult and complex concept to understand, especially in our legal court system. I associate blame with being held responsible for the consequences of one’s intentional actions. In regards to sexual assault cases, I think the blame should not be placed on the victims, but rather on the perpetrators. Victim blaming justifies the perpetrator’s actions, discourages sexual assault reportings, and can have psychological effects on the victim.

    Read More

  • Moral Ethics Essay

    903 Words  | 2 Pages

    Moral ethics is the belief that all human beings are born to know right from wrong. We come into this world as good people, but the temptations and challenges in life influence our mind set to as it will. Every person on Earth chooses if they’re to follow through with their life of good or go down the path of bad. “A person’s moral ethics” (unknown.)

    Read More

  • Humiliation Essay

    1162 Words  | 3 Pages

    Teenagers who bully, shame, or humiliate along with their victims often deal with negative psychological effects that could lead to suicide. According to merriam-webster.com the definition of humiliation is “to cause someone to feel very ashamed or foolish.” (Humiliation) According to merriam-webster.com the definition of bullying is “a blustering browbeating person; especially: one habitually cruel to others who are weaker.”(Bullying) According to merriam-webster.com the definition of shaming as “dishonor or disgrace.” (Shaming) As one can see from the definitions these words are closely related. They define the process of one person or group of people trying to make an individual or group feel like there is something wrong with them. The strong link between these negative behaviors and suicide is alarming.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Stricter Punishment

    1106 Words  | 3 Pages

    There must be a reason why there is no longer a use of pillories and branding. “The chief evil in public humiliation sanctions is that they involve an ugly, and politically dangerous, complicity between the state and the crowd” (Whitman 1059). These sanctions builds a wall between the government and the people. To Society, it is morally unjust to publicly humiliate someone for his crime. To the state, it is an effective penalty. It is a dangerous position to be in. This division between people and state can cause turmoil beyond control. However, they are effective in justifiable ways. Massaro, a strong critic of shame sanctions, admits that there are clear justifications to said sanctions including retribution, rehabilitation, deterrence, and incapacitation (1890-1900). Shaming offenders for their crimes does rehabilitate them by embarrassing them beyond any imaginable length. It deters them by giving them just enough of a punishment while instilling the fear of being sent to prison if there is any resistance. Incapacitating the offenders allows the public to feel safe while excluding the offenders from any area that may persuade them from repeating their offense. As for retribution, a conducted survey entails that sixty seven percent of Fountain Central High School alone is associated with someone who has been affected by drunk driving. On one hand, there were multiple

    Read More

More about Shame Punishment Essay

Open Document