Rhetorical Analysis Of Why Establish This Cary

Through the tonal shifts impacted by the lofty diction in “Why Establish This Paper” in correlation with the strategic use of syntax, Cary stresses the necessity of establishing her newspaper as it provides the vital link between the fugitives to promote the antislavery cause.
The philosophical tone created through the lofty diction demonstrates that the principles of the Constitution are in actuality unconstitutional in regards to society’s attitudes toward the forced labor system. Cary emphasizes that the inhumane treatment of slaves goes against the moral values of the nation as it takes away the necessities that all are inclined to. Consequently, this led to the mass movement of abolitionists, demanding that they “… [make] our voice heard at home” (Cary 1-2) in a place where

oppression is present. The freedom that should have been unanimously given to the people, regardless of gender or race, was not as “Such freeman we never were before…” (Cary 19). Through this statement, Cary highlights the values that many have taken for granted as this dehumanizing act built the foundation of the American people’s sense of superiority over others.
The shift to a more reflective tone as created by the lofty diction forces the audience to reflect on their values concerning the promotion of the antislavery cause.

Through words such as “plain” (Cary 15) and “concealed” (Cary 29), Cary draws on the audience’s beliefs of holding themselves on a higher platform and stresses that by doing so, the nation should feel ashamed that they are neglecting the existence of others. Essentially, the audience feels obligated in questioning whether the issue of slavery goes against the virtues of human nature because despite the Constitution stating that everyone is of equal standing, there are exceptions. The writer emphasizes how society views the abolitionists and fugitives in “cold contempt” (Cary 43) and draws a connection between their sense of arrogance and the effects it has on those who do not share the same beliefs. Furthermore, not a single newspaper was printed that “… represented the intelligence of colored Canadians…” (Cary 30-31) and taking advantage of this statement, Cary demonstrates that the antislavery cause should be promoted in order to destroy the preconceived ideas that those who are not white are deemed as lowly

beings.
The author’s use of elongated and telegraphic sentences emphasizes her point of establishing the newspaper as a platform to link the fugitives and promote the abolition of slavery. She creates a sense of urgency by stressing that for their voice to be heard throughout the nation, the abolitionists and fugitives must “… need an organ, too…” (Cary 1-2). Despite the distinct differences between the two groups, they share a common goal: extending the principles of the abolition movement in order for every individual in the nation to have their entitled rights and privileges. Cary emphasizes her concerns for the fugitives due to their constant oppression and argues that “… we have a paper because we think we need one…” (Cary 55-56) to highlight the importance of promoting the antislavery cause. By doing so, the writer simultaneously unravels the harsh living conditions the slaves were subjected to and draws on the audience’s values to push for the publication of the newspaper.
The principles of human nature are overshadowed by the people’s arrogance in demonstrating their sense of superiority over others. Through the shifts in tone along with the strategic use of syntax, Cary emphasizes the negative effects of slavery on the people as a whole and that by establishing the newspaper, the process of promoting the antislavery cause will gradually become a global concern.