Problems with the Gender Binary System

2310 Words5 Pages

Across the globe, gender systems vary in ways that often exclude individuals who don’t identify within their realms. From the binary structure of the West, to the ternary system of India, there are many ways in which societies conceptualize gender. Gender systems are generally considered inherent to humanity, and are seldom questioned or altered. This has led to the marginalization and discrimination of individuals who diverge from the implemented structure. The gender binary of Western culture dichotomizes disgendered females and males, categorizing women and men as opposing beings and excluding all other people. Former professor of Gender Studies Walter Lee Williams argues that gender binarism “ignores the great diversity of human existence,” (191) and is “an artifact of our society’s rigid sex-roles” (197). This social structure has proved detrimental to a plethora of people who fall outside the Western gender dichotomy. And while this gender-exclusive system is an unyielding element of present day North American culture, it only came to be upon European arrival to the Americas. As explained by Judith Lorber in her essay “Night to His Day: The Social Construction of Gender”, “gender is so pervasive in our society we assume it is bred into our genes” (356). Lorber goes on to explain that gender, like culture, is a human production that requires constant participation (358). Prior to 15th century colonization, indigenous peoples of North America enjoyed a gender system that included not only women and men, but also a third gender known as Two-Spirit. In Native American culture, individuals who identified as Two-Spirit were revered by society and held important roles among tribes. In their article “The Way of the Two-Spirited Pe... ... middle of paper ... ... Michael Anhorn. "The Way of the Two Spirited People: Native American Concepts of Gender and Sexual Orientation” Dancing to Eagle Spirit Society. N.p., 2008. Web. 03 May 2014. Lorber, J. "Judith Lorber (1987-1990)." Gender & Society 25.3 (2011): 355-59. Print. Mohanty, Chandra Talpade, “Feminism Without Borders” Feminist Frontiers 8th Edition (2009) 97-103 Nibley, Lydia, “Two-Spirits Documentary” PBS Channel 2011 Singer, Phoenix “Two-Spirit Identity and the Logics of White Supremacy” Academia Journal 2011 Stryker, Susan, “Transgender Feminism: Queering the Woman Question” Feminist Frontiers 8th Edition (2009) 83-89 Williams, Walter L. "Persistence and Change in the Berdache Tradition Among Contemporary Lakota Indians." Journal of Homosexuality 11.3-4 (1986): 191-200. Print. Wheeler, Mark, “The Damaging Effects of Discrimination,” Medical News Today, 2010

Show More
Related

  • Sexuality In California's Franciscan Missions By Albert L. Hudarto Summary

    712 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Albert L. Hudarto’s essay, “Sexuality in California 's Franciscan Missions: Cultural Perceptions and Sad Realities,” I initially thought the author would discuss sexuality in the San Francisco Mission district as I probably was not paying too much attention to the title. I also questioned how this article would relate to the first lecture discussed in class about Native American tribes in California. Hudarto clearly states his thesis as “This essay will examine an aspect of the mission experience that has not received much attention -- Indian sexuality and Franciscans ' attempts to control it.” His purpose is to inform reader of California Indians’ sexuality prior to and post integration of Franciscan beliefs, and the effects the Franciscans had on the Indians.

    Read More

  • Indian From The Inside Native American Culture Summary

    529 Words  | 2 Pages

    Pages one to sixty- nine in Indian From The Inside: Native American Philosophy and Cultural Renewal by Dennis McPherson and J. Douglas Rabb, provides the beginning of an in-depth analysis of Native American cultural philosophy. It also states the ways in which western perspective has played a role in our understanding of Native American culture and similarities between Western culture and Native American culture. The section of reading can be divided into three lenses. The first section focus is on the theoretical understanding of self in respect to the space around us. The second section provides a historical background into the relationship between Native Americans and British colonial power. The last section focus is on the affiliation of otherworldliness that exist between

    Read More

  • Seeing Red By Ines Talamantez Summary

    1022 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the text “Seeing Red: American Indian Women Speaking about their Religious and Cultural Perspectives” by Inés Talamantez, the author discusses the role of ceremonies and ancestral spirituality in various Native American cultures, and elaborates on the injustices native women face because of their oppressors.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Gail Bederman's, Manliness And Civilization

    963 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Gail Bederman’s, Manliness & Civilization: A Cultural History of Gender and Race in the United States 1880-1917, Bederman asserts, manhood, race, and gender are three cultural issues that are inseparable and have shaped our American and human history (4-5). Bederman supports her theory using the journalistic works of those effected, political giants using these social constructions for personal gain, and through pop culture during the period being analyzed.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Gender Frontier By Kathleen Brown

    1312 Words  | 3 Pages

    Jamestown, Virginia, is a crucial source of legends about the United States. Pocahontas, a daughter of an Indian werowance married an Englishman named John Rolfe and changed her name to Rebecca. In her article, “Gender Frontier”, Kathleen Brown underscores gender role and responsibility in both Native American and English settlers. Gender frontier is the meeting of two or more culturally specific system of knowledge about gender and nature. She also stresses the duties that they played in their societies prior to the arrival of the English people in the early colony in Virginia. Brown describes the difference values between Europeans and Native Americans in regards to what women and men should and should not do and the complex progression of

    Read More

  • Comparing Leslie Marmon Silko's Yellow Woman And A Beauty Of The Spirit

    713 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Yellow Woman and a Beauty of the Spirit” contains a great deal of beliefs connected with the sexuality of human beings. In a village near the Laguna Pueblo reservation occupied a man “Who wore

    Read More

  • An Analysis Of Daniel David Moses's 'Sovereign Erotics'

    1079 Words  | 3 Pages

    “Josh couldn’t find the right words for his rage. He felt all the words flaming up before his eyes and burning away like stubble before he could use them. In church he had heard Jesus’ words to the centurion: Speak the Word and you shall be healed. He no longer believed" (45). Both of their attitude and responses result from those societal pressures that internally police their actions and impulses. "For Native people, terms like 'lesbian ' and 'queer ' are seen as a part of dominant Euro-American constructions of sexuality that have little to do with the more complicated gender systems in many Native traditions" (5-6). Queer indigenous people face the challenges of breaking through the confining social constructions of settler religious values, as well as overcoming settler control over history and even indivdiuality. Yet, settler and colonizer narratives are an integral part of Native American stories. Thus, there is an intrinsic struggle with how to face those challenges in a manner that is authentic, reflecting the facticity of their individual life but not allowing that facticity to determine

    Read More

  • Women In the Fur Trade

    2974 Words  | 6 Pages

    Kugel, Rebecca, and Lucy Eldersveld Murphy. Native women's history in eastern North America before 1900: a guide to research and writing. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2007.

    Read More

  • Racial Inequality in America

    872 Words  | 2 Pages

    Black Elk, F (2000). Observations on Marxism and Lakota Tradition. In Brunk, T., Diamond, S.,

    Read More

  • Women in World War One

    918 Words  | 2 Pages

    French, Katherine L., and Allyson M. Poska. Women and Gender in the Western past. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin, 2007. Print.

    Read More

  • Gender Roles In Contemporary American Culture

    2622 Words  | 6 Pages

    In today’s contemporary American culture, gender roles are despised by the younger generation because of the distinctions placed on them. This is the era of open-mindedness and self-expression and because of this individuals feel they should not be told what they can and cannot do based on their sex. There are now material things such as, clothes, shoes and perfumes that are considered unisex, males and females can now fight in wars and men are no longer fully needed to be the providers of their families. Though the American culture has attempted to make a leap forward when it comes to breaking down the barriers of gender roles, it is still being held back. Being a culture that was first influenced by the Christian religion, there are still traces of these gender roles present. From areas of

    Read More

  • Commentary on Lorber´s Night to His Day”: The Social Construction of Gender

    787 Words  | 2 Pages

    As Lorber explores in her essay “Night to His Day”: The Social Construction of Gender, “most people find it hard to believe that gender is constantly created and re-created out of human interaction, out of social life, and is the texture and order of that social life” (Lorber 1). This article was very intriguing because I thought of my gender as my sex but they are not the same. Lorber has tried to prove that gender has a different meaning that what is usually perceived of through ordinary connotation. Gender is the “role” we are given, or the role we give to ourselves. Throughout the article it is obvious that we are to act appropriately according to the norms and society has power over us to make us conform. As a member of a gender an individual is pushed to conform to social expectations of his/her group.

    Read More

  • The Role of Women in American Society

    1488 Words  | 3 Pages

    American society needs to break from the mold of the myth of gender, which suggests that society and culture dictate our roles as men and women, as can only restrict us into unnecessary conformity. The opinion of society should no longer decide who we are, what we do, and what we’re capable of doing. We, as Americans, need to deeply analyze and question this fallacy of gender and the way it restricts us at home, in the media, and in the classroom. If we continue to follow the invisible guidelines of in invisible rulebook, we’re destined to hurt ourselves and our future generations by remaining nestled into our cultural cocoons and never shedding them.

    Read More

  • The Social Construction Of Gender

    3360 Words  | 7 Pages

    Gender is such a ubiquitous notion that humans assume gender is biological. However, gender is a notion that is made up in order to organize human life. It is created and recreated giving power to the dominant gender, creating an inferior gender and producing gender roles. There are many questionable perspectives such as how two genders are learned, how humans learn their own gender and others genders, how they learn to appropriately perform their gender and how gender roles are produced. In order to understand these perspectives, we must view gender as a social institution. Society bases gender on sex and applies a sex category to people in daily life by recognizing gender markers. Sex is the foundation to which gender is created. We must understand the difference between anatomical sex and gender in order to grasp the development of gender. First, I will be assessing existing perspectives on the social construction of gender. Next, I will analyze three case studies and explain how gender construction is applied in order to provide a clearer understanding of gender construction. Lastly, I will develop my own case study by analyzing the movie Mrs. Doubtfire and apply gender construction.

    Read More

  • Cross Dressing Essay

    2050 Words  | 5 Pages

    Although there weren’t always terms for the acts, cross-dressing and homosexuality have existed since man has. Although they have both taken place for thousands of years, there is very rare documentation of the participants—particularly after the rise of Christianity and the condemnation of any of these marginalized groups of people. The American western frontier was no different—men and women continued to participate in cross-dressing and had relations with those of the same sex. However what is particularly interesting about this time and place is how men and women utilized their resources to deceive their communities and benefit from these largely taboo—particularly at the time—performances. The environment in the west was vastly diverse in the late 1800’s/early 1900’s and to the few documented cases that exist today better depict the reactions of different mining towns, reservations or frontiers.

    Read More

More about Problems with the Gender Binary System

Open Document