Objection Analysis: Do Black Lives Matter?

481 Words1 Page
bulb-icon

Recommended: Community police reform in united states

On the Matter of Black Lives Question: Do Black Lives Matter? Objection 1: No, All Lives Matter. Just saying that Black Lives Matter overlooks the importance of other kinds of people. We should be working collaboratively to confront social issues. Objection 2: No, Black Lives Matter is terrorist organization that calls for the murder of police officers throughout the United States.. Objection 3: No, Blue Lives Matter. We need to support law enforcement and protect against false narratives about law enforcement officials. On the contrary: None of these objections answer the basic question of whether the lives of black citizens matter, but instead diverts attention from the original issue. I answer that: Black lives do matter. Period. Reply to objection 1: Saying that Black Lives Matter does not inherently take away from the value of any other person’s life. And frankly, Black people shouldn’t have to reference every other group before acknowledging themselves. For example, no one crashes a Breast Cancer Awareness rally to say “but what about all of the other diseases?” No one would say that having a Breast Cancer Awareness rally overshadows the other diseases. Everyone knows that the other diseases exist and need to be addressed, but during the Breast Cancer Awareness rally is not the time to highlight this. Likewise bringing attention to issues that affect the black community is not the time to shout “but what about the other communities.” Herein …show more content…

Those who ascribe to this objection attribute the extreme actions of a couple of people loosely associated with Black Lives Matter to the intent of the entire Black Lives Matter movement. One cannot infer something that is true of a part of the whole as true of the whole. This is logically fallacious. Black Lives Matter cannot be considered a terroristic organization only because some supporters have carried out extremist

Show More
Related

  • Rhetorical Analysis: The All Lives Matter

    321 Words  | 1 Pages

    The All Lives Matter supporters believe that black people who were killed recently showed violence against the policemen and they were not innocents. The president of Amherst College Republicans Robert Lucido responses, “First, the Black Lives Matter group was originally titled ‘F--- the Police.’ The organizers of the Awareness week claimed that every 28 hours a black man is killed by a law enforcement officer, but they never mentioned that a law enforcement officer is killed every 48 hours in the line of duty. The organizers may have thought it clever, but such a title is utterly shameful” (Lucido). The author uses ethos by showing facts in his response that illustrates the opposite of what Black Lives Matter group claimed; however, these

    Read More

  • Letter From Birmingham Jail Analysis

    1120 Words  | 3 Pages

    Racial inequality is once again on the forefront of Americans ' minds, and the rise of the Black Lives Matter movement has become a topic of contentious debate. However, this tension is by no means a new phenomenon, this is the same anger that inspired civil rights leaders like Martin Luther King Jr to rally against the status quo and fight for racial equality. The essay "Letter from a Birmingham Jail" by King addresses the same issues of racial inequality, prejudice, and police violence that has given rise to the Black Lives Matter movement. In the 1960 's, the Jim Crow laws that mandated segregation and prevented black Americans from voting were brutally, and blatantly racist policies. Additionally, the penalties for breaking these laws

    Read More

  • Understanding the 'Black Lives Matter' Movement

    1362 Words  | 3 Pages

    Today there are many controversial subjects discussed throughout the media. One of the most discussed is race and the Black Lives Matter movement. Recently, I came across an article titled “The Truth of ‘Black Lives Matter’”, written by The Editorial Board. The article was published on September 3, 2015, to the New York Times. In the article, The Editorial Board writes about what they believe African Americans are facing as challenges in society today, including the all-too-common police killings of unarmed African-Americans across the country. The Editorial Board is right that some African Americans have been treated unfairly, but all ethnicities have been. Life is a precious thing that comprises all ethnicities. This brings us to ask; why

    Read More

  • Black Lives Matter: Is Black Lives Matter?

    824 Words  | 2 Pages

    We have to state "Black Lives Matter," since we 're not living it. Nobody is addressing whether white lives matter or whether police lives matter. Be that as it may, the topic of whether Black lives truly matter is an open question in this nation. Our organizations demonstration like Black lives don 't make a difference. The police demonstration like Black lives don 't make a difference when they shoot unarmed Black individuals with their arms in the air and when Blacks are shot at more than two times the rate of whites, even when whites are outfitted. The

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On Racial Profiling

    1881 Words  | 4 Pages

    Racism is a common and ancient social problem in the U.S.. African Americans spend many years on solving the problem. From the Emancipation Proclamation to the Civil Rights Movements, they consistently fought against racism and gradually gained the justice and rights. During that time, many famous people were born, such as Martin Luther King. Because of their efforts, nowadays, even the president of the US, Barack Obama, has African American blood. However, racism becomes a headline in the news again recently. In the past few months, protests have happened in many big cities like New York and Washington. African Americans went on the street protesting against the discipline of the police department. They claimed that they

    Read More

  • Plessy Vs. Ferguson And W. E. B. Du Bois

    725 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Supreme Court ruling of the court case Plessy vs. Ferguson and W.E.B. Du Bois’ The Black Codes determined the meaning of equality in similar ways. The Black Codes had full intentions to deprive any African American from gaining freedom. In addition, the verdict in the Plessy case interpreted the meaning of the 14th Amendment to justify that “separate is equal” (U.S. Const. amend. XIV.). By examining the dehumanizing language in both the court case and the article, it becomes clear that certain language is used to justify segregation, which negatively impacted African Americans because it categorized them and made an “inferior” race. This is significant because it creates division among people by socially making race a classification thus, leading to social tensions.

    Read More

  • Black Lives Matter: Police Brutality In Eric Garner's Case

    1041 Words  | 3 Pages

    Black Lives Matter is a movement amongst black communities, demanding changes within our criminal justice system, police brutality, racial profiling and a number of other instances. This movement was created to shine a light on racism in America, to recognize the importance of black lives, to expose systematic racism and to protest for a long needed change within our country. The creation of Black Lives Matter was to give black people confidence and strength to fight against injustice and for once and for all stand our ground. Black Lives Matter wants to improve the black community, to tell our black brothers and sisters that they could be so much more than what systematic racism tries to limit us to do. We want to improve not only our lives but influence the criminal justice system to push for better-trained police officers and ensure protection for all people of color.

    Read More

  • Police Brutality: The Black Lives Matter Movement

    484 Words  | 1 Pages

    Police brutality is a prevalent issue in today’s society due to racial bias authorities use in determining the extent in which force should used, and the reality that cops are not held accountable for shooting unarmed black individuals. The Black Lives Matter Movement has worldwide attention, and one of the most significant acts of public controversy that resulted from the kneeling protests of the U.S. National Anthem initiated by former San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick. Kaepernick’s decision to protest the National Anthem inspired a diverse multitude of professional athletes to follow his example.

    Read More

  • Racial Equality in the United States

    2565 Words  | 6 Pages

    ...slators and citizens alike must keep in mind our nation?s goal of racial equality, and not lose sight of that goal by making and following foolish laws. Certainly African-Americans have suffered greatly in the past, however, we must not continue to make things easier for blacks at the expense of whites today.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Black Lives Matter

    1211 Words  | 3 Pages

    The statement “Black Lives Matter” has greatly evolved within the last year. If you support this side, you believe these words correlate with the unneeded and over excessive use of police brutality against African Americans compared to police brutality against whites, bringing racism soaring back into the US. As you may know, the statement became more predominant after the murder of African Americans

    Read More

  • Argument Against Policing

    1750 Words  | 4 Pages

    Martin Luther King Jr. said all that needed to be said in 1966: "[The] law can't make a man love me, however it can control him from lynching me, and I believe that is really imperative moreover." After two years, he was shot and murdered in Memphis. In any case, his fantasies that the United States lawful framework may in the end defeat its racial inclinations and serve its non-white subjects similarly lives on. Throughout recent months, government officials have conjured King's legacy to beseech African American residents to remain tranquil even with routine brutality. The incongruity of this request appears to be lost on its askers, yet it does fall in accordance with a question that is spooky Black Lives Matter dissenters for as far back as 10 months, to be specific, "what will occur next?” At the end of the day: How, other than challenging, would we be able to really ensure that not any more African or Latino individuals are

    Read More

  • Essay On The Black Lives Matter Movement

    777 Words  | 2 Pages

    Overall, many believe that the undeviating war on racism in today’s society is fueled by police brutality and anti-police violence. Specifically, the Black Lives Matter movement, which is the source of controversy regarding these topics. To summarize, this campaign is “both a hashtag and a political project that formed after the acquittal of George Zimmerman in the 2012 killing of Trayvon Martin.” (Miller). Later in the article Chelsea Fuller, senior communications associate at The Advancement Project, a multi-racial civil rights organization, states “The Black Lives Matter movement is to deal with anti-black racism, to “push for black people’s right to live with dignity and respect” and be included in the American democracy that they helped create” (Miller).

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Black Lives Matter

    1020 Words  | 3 Pages

    Black Lives Matter is not a movement that believes all lives do not matter; nevertheless, it highlights the fact that black lives are taken for granted by the judicial system. Protests around the world have taken place to fight for justice in the black community. The immense number of deaths of unarmed black men and women is a clear sign that they are more likely to be killed by police than white people. Physical violence and excessive use of force by the U.S. police towards African Americans are seen in the news regularly.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On Black Lives Matter

    1587 Words  | 4 Pages

    I truly feel that the outraged party are missing the concept of the whole movement. Black Lives Matter is necessary movement that is not saying the other lives do not, and it should continue until that unspoken social tension is resolved. With movements such as all live matters there has been a lot of tension.There have been riots and with that, outrage is completely understandable and outrage should be felt unanimously across America for these barbaric acts of vandalism and violence. I feel that when you say Black Lives Matter people feel as if they 're being

    Read More

  • Causes Of Miscommunication

    703 Words  | 2 Pages

    Miscommunication was the mastermind in a plethora of wars. Miscommunication has led to divorces, fights, failed relationships, and other misfortunes, rather intentionally or unintentionally. One great issue going on today that brings on a civil debate within itself is the war between “Black Lives Matter” and “All Lives Matter” rally for peace. On one end, people take the terms “Black Lives Matter” as in saying that black lives are equally important. While on the other hand, some take the term “Black Lives Matter” as making one race more superior than the other. The debate of BLM is not a debate on rather people consider if black people’s lives matter or not. The debate is all over the use or words used to protest the rally. Majority who are against the BLM movement are at unease because the terms indicates that black lives, and only black lives matter. This issue of proper wording is causing a separation between both groups. In an article by Ian Olasov, he mentions

    Read More

More about Objection Analysis: Do Black Lives Matter?

Open Document