My Year Of No Shopping Summary

1429 Words3 Pages

The No-Shopping Pledge In the article “My Year of No Shopping,” critically-acclaimed American author and bookstore co-owner, Ann Patchett (2017), analyzes how a ‘no-shopping-year’ makes one observant about poverty and grateful of the things he/she has. She wants people to take some time off showing and differentiate between their wants and needs. Patchett began by casually following the rule of no-shopping until New Year’s Eve when she decided to stop buying anything personal; clothes, shoes, bags and jewelry. However, she continued to shop for things related to her career like books and bookstore supplies and grocery items. During the first months of this oath she realized she had more than enough self-care and personal products. Overtime, …show more content…

For example, Patchett writes in her article “the things we buy and buy and buy are like a thick coat of Vaseline smeared on glass: We can see some shapes out there, light and dark, but in our constant craving for what we may still want, we miss life’s details” (2017). She is comparing life with a glass, and shopping with Vaseline. She is relating things which are not in fact related. Yes, by applying Vaseline on glass, the glass becomes blur and translucent, however this does not mean shopping may blur our (spiritual) vision. On the same token, she mentions how browsing online shopping websites made her feel worse “the way a late night in a bar smoking Winstons and drinking gin leaves you feeling worse” (Patchett, 2017). Here, she is exaggerating her emotions by comparing it with a hangover. The actual reason why drinking and smoking causes painful hangovers is, as Browne explains, because "Alcohol is a diuretic, which means that it helps the body get rid of fluids. When you have a severe hangover, you're often severely dehydrated, and the body can't get rid of the byproducts of metabolizing alcohol … [which] are irritating" (Browne, 2011). On the other hand, she actually felt guilty while browsing e-commerce websites and trying to buy things which she already had in abundance; this has nothing to do with a hangover. Hence, the comparison of her feeling with the after-effects of drinking is absolutely faulty. In conclusion, using false analogies make her arguments

Open Document