Male homoeroticism in Plato's Symposium and the Greek lyric poets: Complimentary or contradictory?

1721 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Plato aristophanes theory of love

Male homoeroticism in Plato's Symposium and the Greek lyric poets: Complimentary or contradictory?

Works Cited Missing

Images of male homosocial and homoerotic relations pervade Athenian culture. From plays to poetry and jugs to the justice system one can find these relations represented pictorially and in words. But do all these images align with each other or are there irreconcilable differences between them? To look at this question we will take two small pieces of culture, a philosophical treatise, Plato's Symposium and the lyric poetry of Theognis and Anacreon.

Homoerotics are mentioned in several speeches in Plato's Symposium but I will focus on those statements made by Phaedras and Pausanias. The reason for the use of these two sources is to elucidate the numerous representations of homoerotics in Athenian Greece.

Phaedras begins by stating that everyone can agree that, the greatest benefit, to my mind, that a young man can come by in his youth is a virtuous lover, and a virtuous boyfriend is just as good for a lover too. (Plato, 178c) This is a value that the modern world can easily grasp, a young man (the object of love) is well served by a virtuous older man (erastes) who will honor his superior position and treat the young man well and teach him what he can. In turn, the the erastes is better off with a virtuous boyfriend (eromenos) who will stay loyal to him. After all, the older man is the lover to which Phaedras refers and so a young boyfriend who was not faithful could be quite injurious to the older man?s heart and reputation. So does this image fit with that of the lyric poets?

Indeed, Phaedras? representation of male homoerotics aligns quite easily with that of the lyric poets. Theognis speaks often...

... middle of paper ...

...ric poets. Love for boys is a wonderful thing, especially if both parties are virtuous and loyal. Also, Theognis and Anacreon, likely along with Pausanias, attribute more loyalty to men than to women, resulting in a deeper commitment to ?relationships.? Phaedras disagrees saying that women can, in fact feel equal loyalty. There is general agreement that a love for boys based purely on beauty is a common thing, and not a good one. It leads to having stupid eromenai, which is not desirable. The lyric poets do seem to maintain that while intelligence is important, young boys are still better material for love than older men. Pausanias disagrees, arguing for lifelong homosocial relationships. So while there are a few differences between the lyric poets and these speakers of the Syposium they seem to be based more on choice of lifestyle than true differences of paradigm.

Show More
Related

  • The Oresteia - The War-of the-Sexes in Eumenides

    2114 Words  | 5 Pages

    In this essay I will examine the war-of the-sexes taking place in The Eumenides, the final play of The Oresteia. The plot of The Eumenides pits Orestes and Apollo (representing the male gods and, to a certain extent, male values in general) against the ghost of Clytemnestra and the Furies (equally representative of female values.) Of more vital importance, however, is whether Athene sides with the males or females throughout the play.

    Read More

  • The Cotton Gin’s Impact on American Industry and Slavery

    745 Words  | 2 Pages

    Prior to the cotton gin, a laborer could only pick the seeds out of approximately one pound of cotton a day. The cotton gin made it possible to clean up to 50 pounds per day. The farmers could now plant as much cotton as they wanted and not have the worry about the difficulties of seed removal. Eli’s invention spurred the growth of the cotton industry, and the South took up the slogan “Cotton is King.”

    Read More

  • Important Role of Women in Homer's Odyssey

    1720 Words  | 4 Pages

    Yet, despite the fact that no two women in this epic are alike, each—through her vices or virtues—helps to delineate the role of the ideal woman. Below, we will show the importance of Circe, Calypso, Nausicaa, Clytaemestra, and Penelope in terms of the movement of the narrative and in defining social roles for the Ancient Greeks. Before we delve into the traits of individual characters, it is important to understand certain assumptions about women that prevailed in the Homeric Age. By modern standards, the Ancient Greeks would be considered a rabidly misogynistic culture. Indeed, the notoriously sour Boetian playwright Hesiod-- who wrote about fifty years before Homer-- proclaimed "Zeus who thunders on high made women to be evil to mortal men, with a nature to do evil (Theogony 600).

    Read More

  • Two Types of Love in Plato's Symposium

    1223 Words  | 3 Pages

    I have always thought that there was only one type of love, which was that feeling of overwhelming liking to someone else. I am aware that Lust does exist and that it is separate from Love, being that the desire for someone's body rather their mind. In Plato's Symposium, Plato speaks of many different types of love, loves that can be taken as lust as well. He writes about seven different points of view on love coming from the speakers that attend the symposium in honor of Agathon. Although all these men bring up excellent points on their definitions on love, it is a woman that makes the best definition be known. I will concentrate on the difference between the theory of Common and Heavenly love brought up by Pausanias and the important role that Diotima plays in the symposium.

    Read More

  • Health Care IT and Quality Health Care

    1126 Words  | 3 Pages

    Unfortunately, the quality of health care in America is flawed. Information technology (IT) offers the potential to address the industry’s most pressing dilemmas: care fragmentation, medical errors, and rising costs. The leading example of this is the electronic health record (EHR). An EHR, as explained by HealthIT.gov (n.d.), is a digital version of a patient’s paper chart. It includes, but is not limited to, medical history, diagnoses, medications, and treatment plans. The EHR, then, serves as a resource that aids clinicians in decision-making by providing comprehensive patient information.

    Read More

  • Aristophanes Views On Love

    1132 Words  | 3 Pages

    Aristophanes has mildly insulted the previous speakers in two ways. By claiming that one of the original forms was androgynous, he has suggested that heterosexuality is at least as natural as male homosexuality – as is being a lesbian. In contrast, Empedokles in fact did hold to a theory of sorts based on fitness to the environment, the description at 191c strongly suggests that only heterosexual relationships yielding only a temporary satisfaction and relief, allowing the participants to go about their business.

    Read More

  • Cotton Gin During The Industrial Revolution

    251 Words  | 1 Pages

    During the Industrial Revolution many important inventions made an impact in the economy of America. One of the greatest inventions in this time was made by Eli Whitney on March 14, 1974, he invented the cotton gin. The invention of the cotton gin made an impact in the Agriculture and manufacturing industry in the south of America. The south region used slaves in the production and collection of cotton. The cotton gin was a machine that was able to remove the cotton fibers from the seeds. This machine was more efficient and faster than a slave. The raised of cotton production made the slavery system even more important in the south. The idea of Whitney was to sell his machine to the farmers and get a percentage of the profits over the time.

    Read More

  • Forms of Love in Plato's Symposium

    2571 Words  | 6 Pages

    Love, in classical Greek literature, is commonly considered a prominent theme. Love, in present days, always appears in the categories of books, movies, music, etc. Interpreted differently by different people, Love turns into a multi-faceted being. In Plato’s work Symposium, Phaedrus, Pausania, Eryximachus, Aristophane and Agathon, each of them presents a speech to either praise or definite Love. Phaedrus first points out that Love is the primordial god; Pausanias brings the theme of “virtue” into the discussion and categorizes Love into “good” one or “bad” one; Eryximachus introduces the thought of “moderation’ and thinks that Love governs such fields as medicine and music; Aristophanes draws attention to the origin and purposes of Love; Agathon enunciates that the correct way to present an eulogy is first to praise its nature and gifts.

    Read More

  • Female Gender Roles In Lysistrata By Aristophanes

    985 Words  | 2 Pages

    In modern day society, female gender roles are defined in several of forms; ranging from the stereotypical concept of women being the primary caretakers to women being the dominant sex. After analyzing two sources of past literature, two iconic women represent personas of both social standings. In the literary works “Genesis” of The Hebrew Bible; along with, “Lysistrata” by Aristophanes, impactful phenomena take place in the era of these women.

    Read More

  • What Is The Persuasive Speech In Plato's Phaedrus?

    709 Words  | 2 Pages

    Phaedrus informs Socrates that he had just heard a speech by Lysias, the greatest rhetorician of the age and a sophist. Socrates, eager to hear Lysias’ speech entices Phaedrus to reenact it. Phaedrus obliges and recounts Lysias’ speech depicting the advantages and disadvantages of the love and non-lover. Lysias’ speech intends to persuade the audience to view the non-lover as the more accommodating choice. “But if you are persuaded by me, first, in my association with you I shall attend not to present pleasure, but also to the benefit that lies in store for the future; I’ll not be worsted by love, but in mastery of myself…” (Phaedrus p. 33). The lover is described, as someone who gets jealous, is obsessive or controlling, and desires physical appearance before the mind. Furthermore the lover, brings turmoil back, is overly sensitive, and overly encouraging or fearful of the beloved. Whereas, the non-lover is presented as the friend, who prefers the mind to physical appearance, is less needy, and won’t diminish your reputation. A non-lover, will not expect gifts back, exercises more self-control, more rational thought, is not jealous of friends or the time, and is less likely to be

    Read More

  • Sexuality In Greek Society

    776 Words  | 2 Pages

    Women served two separate and distinct purposes, neither condoned in the same woman. One purpose was matrimony and procreation, the other was sexual pleasure for pleasure’s sake (Freeman, 228-229). The Greeks had several beliefs

    Read More

  • Overview of the Atkins Diet

    1162 Words  | 3 Pages

    Atkins diet formed in 1963 was mainly the solution for the increasing obesity problem in the United States. It is based on the concept of eating the right kind of food high in proteins while cutting down the intake of carbohydrate which would transform the body from a carb-burning to a fat-burning machine. Dr. Atkin claims his Atkins diet program as "the amazing no-hunger weight-loss plan that has helped millions lose weight and keep it off" (Atkins).To begin it is important to know what Atkins diet actually includes. It mainly works on the principle of Ketosis. The diet program is divided into four phases. First phase is known as the induction phase that is considered to initiate the weight loss, it includes no more than 20 grams of carbohydrates per day are to be consumed and encourage the intake of proteins and good fats, while cutting down fruits from your diet. The second phase is of ongoing weight loss where the foods that were cut down are included again in the diet. The third phase is where you take more control of your diet and add good carbohydrates to maintain the healthy lifestyle and the final fourth phase is where you reach the target weight and still stick to the carbohydrate restrictions that keeps weight under control. This seems to be a quicker way to reduce weight but as every program this has its advantages as well as disadvantages. The advantage is that it is very filling due to intake of more proteins and keeps weight under controls it also has the disadvantage that cuts down the essential nutrient of our body that is the carbohydrates. There have been many problems reported with this diet that includes heart disease, kidney failure and high cholesterol. Atkins diet includes all the attractive food and still...

    Read More

  • Treatment of Women in Ancient Literature

    2408 Words  | 5 Pages

    Walcot, P. “Greek Attitudes towards Women: The Mythological Evidence.” Greece & Rome 2nd ser. 31.1 (Apr., 1984): 37-47. Cambridge University Press on Behalf of The Classical Association Article Stable. Web.

    Read More

  • William Shakespeare and Edmund Spenser

    759 Words  | 2 Pages

    Therefore, because William Shakespeare’s “Sonnet 18” and Edmund Spenser’s “Sonnet 75” share the idea that love is sincere and eternal, they can be looked upon as similar in theme. However, although similar in theme, Shakespeare’s intent is portraying the true everlasting beauty of his love, which is already achieved, whereas Spenser concentrates more on trying to entice his desired love, remaining optimistic throughout the entire poem.

    Read More

  • Gender Ethics And Media Influence Paper

    1600 Words  | 4 Pages

    The use of sexual appeal in advertising has become commonplace. Marketers are always looking to attract consumers. Being continually inundated with certain messages, the media has been an undeniably formidable influence over our concepts of self as well as a universal society. They employ many different tactics that sometimes has little to nothing to do with the product being advertised. For example, a recent commercial for Xyience Xenergy energy drink. It depicts a scantily clad model, wearing knee high spiked boots, dancing like a stripper in an attempt to entice the viewer to buy

    Read More

More about Male homoeroticism in Plato's Symposium and the Greek lyric poets: Complimentary or contradictory?

Open Document