Macbeth: Truth vs Fiction

1537 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: + macbeth real history compared to shakespear

William Shakespeare altered history for his play, Macbeth, to flatter King James. There are several big differences between Shakespeare’s version of Macbeth and the true history of Macbeth and Banquo. In the true history of Macbeth, Banquo was a traitor to King Duncan. In Shakespeare’s version of Macbeth he made Banquo loyal to King Duncan. Shakespeare altered history to flatter King James. Shakespeare also changed history to not only flatter King James but to avoid the consequences of offending the king. William Shakespeare altered Banquo’s history to compliment King James.

In the true history of Macbeth, Banquo was a traitor to King Duncan. There are many differences between this history of Macbeth and Banquo and Shakespeare’s version of these two figures. One major difference is how King Duncan dies. In history King Duncan died in a different way than William Shakespeare proposed. As written in “Macbeth (c.1005 – 1057)”, “In August 1040, [Macbeth] killed the ruling king, Duncan I, in battle near Elgin, Morayshire” (1). Shakespeare changed history in his play by saying Macbeth killed Duncan in his own room, not in battle. Another way Shakespeare also portrayed Macbeth differently from his true character was his right to the throne. As written in “English Background”, “Macbeth was a real eleventh century Scottish king, but the historical Macbeth, who had a valid right to the throne, reigned capably in Scotland from 1040 till 1057” (1). William Shakespeare showed in his play that Malcolm succeeded Duncan, but in history Macbeth truly succeeded Duncan. Duncan and Macbeth were cousins, grandsons of King Malcolm II. Shakespeare portrayed Duncan as a respected elderly character. However, it is written in “English ...

... middle of paper ...

...William Shakespeare altered history for his play, Macbeth, to flatter King James. There are several big differences between Shakespeare’s version of Macbeth and the true history of Macbeth and Banquo. In the true history of Macbeth, Banquo was a traitor to King Duncan. In Shakespeare’s version of Macbeth he made Banquo loyal to King Duncan. Shakespeare altered history to flatter King James. Shakespeare also changed history to not only flatter King James but to avoid the consequences of offending the king. William Shakespeare altered Banquo’s history to compliment King James.

Works Cited

"English Background." BBC News. BBC, 2013. Web. 03 Dec. 2013.

Kirszner, Laurie G., and Stephen R. Mandell. Macbeth. The Blair Reader: Exploring Issues and

Ideas. Boston: Prentice Hall, 2011. N. pag. Print.

"Macbeth (c.1005 - 1057)." BBC News. BBC, 2013. Web. 03 Dec. 2013.

Show More
Related

  • Macbeth Loyalty Quotes Analysis

    559 Words  | 2 Pages

    Macbeth had been keen yet conflicted on what to do. To become king, his cousin Duncan, the current king of Scotland, must die.

    Read More

  • Banquo And The Juxtaposition In Macbeth

    1378 Words  | 3 Pages

    Both Banquo and Macbeth are introduced as loyal captains in the king`s army, but as the play progresses, Macbeth is overcome with the desire of power due to his reception of the prophecies. Upon hearing, Banquo does not become greedy for power, but, alternatively, he is suspect and cautious begins wondering if “we [Macbeth and Banquo] eaten on the insane root that takes the reason prisoner?” (1.3). Realizing the witches were simply trying to make him ambitious, Banquo remains loyal to his king and his country, despite knowing that he will have a dynasty to rule Scotland. Despite having the motivation, Banquo does not commit treason against his king but rather wants to “keep my [his] bosom franchis'd and allegiance clear” (2.1), meaning that he has no desire to betray the king for personal gain. Conversely, upon hearing the witches’ prophecies, Macbeth becomes ambitious for power and follows them blindly. He is curious about the witches’ prophecies and demands they “stay… [and] tell me [him] more” (1.3). When he hears that the prophecy that his heirs will rule Scotland he will be king, Macbeth`s ambition is born and his thoughts instantly turn to murder, even though the witches had not mentioned murdering King Duncan which shows that Macbeth has previously thought about murdering his king. As a result, Macbeth has no loyalty to neither his king nor his country and commits treason. While both Banquo and Macbeth hear the witches` prophecies that promised power, only Macbeth conceded to their prophecy and became overcame with ambition. Macbeth is a direct antithesis to the honorable, dependent Banquo. He transforms into a greedy man who is obsessed with his

    Read More

  • Macbeth's Corruption

    1293 Words  | 3 Pages

    After murdering Duncan, Macbeth feels that he needs to kill Banquo. He is afraid that Banquo is going to be a problem for him. He is suspicious that Banquo believes Macbeth had something to do with Duncan's murder, "Our fears in Banquo/ Stick deep; and in his royalty of nature/ Reigns that which would be feared" (3.1.47-49). He plans to kill him, though Banquo has made no direct threat against Macbeth. He speaks of feeling inferior to Banquo, even though he is king. "There is none but he/ Whose being I do fear; and under him/ My genius is rebuked" (3.1.53-55). Banquo is Macbeth's closest friend, he is starting to lose trust in everyone around him.

    Read More

  • Macbeth Despise Analysis

    864 Words  | 2 Pages

    Banquo and Macbeth have been brothers-in-arms for a very long time. Macbeth is hosting Banquo in his castle and the have a long talk one night as friends do. It is here that we admire Macbeth because Macbeth shows concern for his long-time friend. We can admire this because showing concern for is a good thing to do and we as viewers can stand by that. What happens later is when Macbeth becomes king by regicide and wants to secure his position. What makes us despise him is how he goes about securing his position. The only way he deems fit to do so is by killing his long-time friend, Banquo, Also there’s a bit of jealousy involved with this because Banquo’s future was also revealed by the Three Weird Sisters, that he would be the head to a long line of kings but won’t be one himself. Macbeth has decided off the top of his head to kill Banquo and his son, Fleance. We despise Macbeth at this point because Macbeth has almost like a two-faced personality, showing kindness and concern one moment then later having people hunt them down and kill them. Shakespeare presented us Macbeth b having us admire him and despise him by helping, then killing his best

    Read More

  • More Then a Noble Perception

    602 Words  | 2 Pages

    Banquo is Macbeth's best friend in the tragedy. Banquo is with Macbeth when Macbeth meets the witches and they tell him of his upcoming fortune. Banquo notices how Macbeth is too ambitious after he sees Macbeth's reaction to the witches predictions. He feels even though Macbeth is his best friend he feels Macbeth is capable of wrong doing in the future to get what he wants. This is shown in one aside after they leave the witches. "…And oftentimes, to win us to our harm, The instruments of darkness tell us truths, Win us with honest trifles, to betray 's in deepest consequence. Cousins, a word, I pray you. (Act1, SceneIII,line123)" This quote is stating that Banquo thinks Macbeth may do anything to get what he wants no matter what the consequences are. Duncan is the King of Scotland and Macbeth's leader. Duncan's view of Macbeth is narrow-minded. He perceives him as a loyal, noble, trustworthy, soldier whom he is very fond of. Duncan also feels Macbeth is the reason for them winning the war. There is many times in the play where this is pointed out by the things Duncan says. For example, "Give me your hand. Conduct me to mine host: we love him highly, And shall continue our graces towards him...(Act1, SceneVI,line29)" This quote shows that Duncan seems to feel like he owes Macbeth something for his loyalties and bravery in the war. Duncan's perception of Macbeth will prove to be his downfall.

    Read More

  • Macbeth - Manipulation

    945 Words  | 2 Pages

    When we first hear about Macbeth from the sergeant’s report, we are led to believe that he is very much a person who does only what he believes is right. Furthermore, when he first appears in the play, his fellow nobleman, Banquo, accompanies him. Given this, we would think that he does what is right, and makes all his own decisions. However, this belief is proven wrong. Although Macbeth starts off as a loyal subject of Duncan, he is ambitious and this is a weakness, which allows him to be manipulated by a few factors in the play.

    Read More

  • Free Essays - The Manipulative Lady Macbeth

    399 Words  | 1 Pages

    But he wont, so she insults him more, and goes to do it herself. Lady Macbeth was the initial force to make this entire play roll along. Macbeth was comfortable where he was, he was curious about the fact the witches stated, but he didn't want to force it to work. After Lady Macbeth's help in the killing of Duncan, the only influence she has upon him is to keep everything to themselves. At the party after Banquo's murder, Lady Macbeth tries to calm Macbeth, and tell him that what he sees is only an illusion, and not to worry about Banquo, and to shut up because his fit may show everyone that they are the murders of Duncan and Banquo.

    Read More

  • How Does Lady Macbeth Obsession With Power

    902 Words  | 2 Pages

    After the death of Duncan, Macbeth begins to distance himself from Lady Macbeth, and he becomes ambitious. Despite being a king, Macbeth is worried about Banquo:

    Read More

  • unit 2

    994 Words  | 2 Pages

    Macbeth is portrayed as a good man in the opening of the play. The wounded Captain described him by saying, “Brave Macbeth, well he deserves that name” (1.2.17). Macbeth is depicted by the Captain this way because he witnessed Macbeth brutally take the life of Macdonwald. Although he is brave and brutal, he is also honored because of his loyalty to King Duncan. Macbeth expresses his loyalty to Duncan when he says, “The service and loyalty I owe in doing it pays itself” (1.4.25). However, Macbeth’s appearance will change suddenly after him and Banquo meet the witches. The witches prophesized their fates to them and it all seemed great for Macbeth, who they said will be king hereafter (1.3.53). What the witches also state in their prophecies is that Banquo is lesser than Macbeth, but he will have sons as kings even though he won’t be one himself (1.3.70). One of the predictions actually comes true; the witches told Macbeth he would become Thane of Cawdor (1.3.52). Once this prediction comes true, Macbeth is already in a struggle with his ambition.

    Read More

  • How Shakespeare Altered the History of Macbeth

    857 Words  | 2 Pages

    In what is said to be one of Shakespeare's most famous tragedies, Macbeth, there are many historical inaccuracies. Many experts in literature believe Shakespeare did this for a couple reasons. One reason is that the changes in history give the play a more dramatic purpose and more exciting story than what actually happened. Another reason could be to give Macbeth and more complicated characterization. The most believed reason that Shakespeare altered history was because he wanted to cater to the desires of the current monarch, King James the First, who was a descendant of Banquo, one of the main characters of the story.

    Read More

  • Free Essays - Character Changes in Macbeth

    565 Words  | 2 Pages

    Later in the play Banquo starts to have a bad feeling about Macbeth. "Thou hast it now: King, Cowdor, Glamis, all,/ as the weird women promised, and I fear/ thou play'dst most foully for `t." III i 1-3, this is a quote from Banquo explaining how he feels about Macbeth's predictions coming true. Macbeth realizes this about Banquo and he starts to have feelings about killing Banquo. This isn't the only reason he feels this way, the witches had also made predictions for Banquo. "Thou shall get kings, though thou be none." I iii 67, Macbeth doesn't want any of Banquo's family to rule Scotland; he wants his own family to continue to rule. Macbeth hires two murderers to kill Banquo and his on Fleance. The murderers end up killing Banquo, but Fleance gets away.

    Read More

  • Essay On Macbeth Is A Victim Of Fate In Macbeth

    736 Words  | 2 Pages

    Macbeth knows from even before he kills Duncan that Banquo’s loyalty lies with Duncan (2.1.26-28). Banquo suspects that Macbeth killed Duncan. (3. 1.1-4). Banquo suspicions of Macbeth seem to show later in the scene in lines 15-18. He says he is bound to serve the king, but this line in much colder than the interactions between Macbeth and Banquo in Acts One and Two. This possibly tipped Macbeth off to the fact that Banquo was doubting his loyalties. Also, Macbeth knows of the witches’ prophecy to Banquo that his descendants will be kings. (1.3.65-68). Macbeth fears that everything he has done will go to Banquo’s heirs even due to the fact Macbeth does not have children and the possibility of what the witches said coming true (3.1.63-64). Macbeth fears for his throne due to this prophecy and Banquo’s questionable loyalties. He decides he needs kill Banquo to ensure that he has absolute security in his throne and not allow Banquo’s heirs to inherit the throne without any

    Read More

  • Macbeth: History of Scotland from an English Perspective

    1250 Words  | 3 Pages

    At the time Shakespeare wrote Macbeth, it was the beginning of the seventeenth century. The reign of Macbeth was actually during the mid-eleventh century. He became king in 1040 after killing King Duncan who according to Fisher “was an ineffectual king” (Fisher, 43). Macbeth would then rule for the next 17 years, having appeared “to have been a good king, active and conscientious, if not always able to hold on to the whole of the territory he had gained through the murder of Duncan” (Fisher, 44). Quite the opposite in the play, Shakespeare portrays Macbeth as an evil and cruel king during the whole time of his reign. Glover points out this untruth, “Macbeth’s character has suffered unjustly at the hands of Shakespeare, as he ruled Scotland well for some seventeen years, and there is evidence that the country enjoyed some prosperity during his reign” (Glover, 39). Yet Macbeth’s reign did end in 1057 when he was killed by Malcolm, Duncan’s son, in the battle of Lumphanan. However, it wasn’t until after Macbeth’s step-son Lulach ruled for about a year, that Malcolm became king after killing him in 1058. This is where Shakespeare ends the play wit...

    Read More

  • Macbeth: The Evolution of Corruption

    1423 Words  | 3 Pages

    These ambiguities are iteratively explained, corresponding with the changes in characterization; for example, when the second vision granted to Macbeth by the Weïrd sisters advises him to, “Be bloody, bold, and resolute. Laugh to scorn / The power of man, for none of woman born / Shall harm Macbeth” (4.1.90-92). Upon hearing this, Macbeth appears to simply disregard the earlier prophecy that it will be Banquo’s children, not his own, that will take the throne after him and believes himself to be effectively invincible, which coincides with another shift in Macbeth’s nature, more specifically his growing arrogance that eventually leads to his defeat at the hands of

    Read More

  • Banquo And Free Will Analysis

    1044 Words  | 3 Pages

    Even Banquo’s “revenge” isn’t very subversive. Macbeth’s paranoia makes him believe that he must kill Banquo in order to stay king. He even convinces the murderers that Banquo is at fault for evil things. Before Macbeth has the murderers kill Banquo, Macbeth says, “We have scorched the snake, not killed it,/ She’ll close and be herself whilst our poor malice/ Remains in danger of her former tooth” (III. II. 93). Macbeth compares Banquo to a snake that must be killed so that Macbeth can stay safe. Comparing Banquo to a snake is another way of comparing him with nature. Macbeth must keep killing people because he has used free will to mess with fate, and he must continue killing to avoid facing the consequence of taking fate into his own hands. After Banquo is killed, Banquo’s ghost comes back to Macbeth. This makes Macbeth seem crazy in front of the Scottish lords. Perhaps, it was Banquo’s way to get a small revenge. As Macbeth betrays loyalty throughout these events, Banquo’s calm and rational actions are juxtaposed to Macbeth’s rash and aggressive ones. This helps to emphasize how free will can have consequences that fate and nature don’t

    Read More

More about Macbeth: Truth vs Fiction

Open Document