More handpicked essays just for you.
Two different versions of cinderella
Compare contrast two versions of cinderella
Two different versions of cinderella
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
There are thousands of versions of cinderella told all around the world in different cultures and languages. They are all similar and different in their own way and all of the similarities and differences can reveal something about the culture they originate from. Katie Woodencloak and The Irish Cinderlad have both have their own fairy godmother but they are not the same. Both fairy godmothers reveal something about the economy of the country.
The fairy godmother in Katie Woodencloak is a bull and back then people had nothing we do, they had cows. Cows were practically walking money. They gave you milk and from milk you had butter and cheese. Also if their was a famine, you could kill and eat it. The bull is chosen as the fairy godmother because at times a cow can be a saviour. In the story. The Bull saves and provides for Katie. After the bull dies it still provides for Katie just like the meat of a bull can provide for a hungry family.
…show more content…
In The Irish Cinderlad the bull dies at the first hardship but in Katie Woodencloak it goes through many hardships before dying.
In the irish Cinderlad the bull comes against a different bull, says he will die, tells the kid to cut off its tail was the bull has died, and does. It seems like in in Norway the cows can indore more than in Ireland.
As it is clear these two versions of Cinderella are very similar but are still different versions. As Stephanie Gilmore said ¨Experiencing different cultures is one of the best things a human can do. It puts your whole world into
perspective.¨
To start off with, “Ashenputtel” is German, “Yeh-Shen” is Chinese, and “The Algonquin Cinderella” is Native American. Furthermore, Ashenputtel and Oochigeaskw both marry a prince, while Yeh-Shen marries a king. Another thing, is in “The Algonquin Cinderella”, the prince had a sister, and Oochigeaskw didn’t have a stepmother. In addition to that, the other two stories both had a stepmother and the prince didn’t have a sister. Even though the prince didn’t have a sister in “The Algonquin Cinderella”, Oochigeaskw had two sisters. Meanwhile, “Ashenputtel” has two stepsisters, and “Yeh-Shen” only had one stepsister. The ending to all the stories is different as well, because the stepsisters get punished in different ways. On One hand, the stepsisters in “Ashenputtel” get their eyes pecked out by doves. On the other hand, the stepsisters and the stepmother in “Yeh-Shen” are crushed to death in a shower of flying stones. In “The Algonquin Cinderella”, neither of the sisters are punished in any way. Finally, the “Interview” is very different from all the stories. First off, it is a poem and not a story. Secondly, it is in the stepmother’s viewpoint, and she is the only character in the poem. Moreover, the stepmother has a different view on how Cinderella was treated, and she also believes that the stepsisters are
The first clear difference is seen in the format the versions are written in. While the Grimm’s is written in prose, Sexton’s is a poem, with many stanzas and a few rhyme schemes as well. Despite the stories being similar, this format helps Sexton, who was a poet, separate her version from that of the Grimm’s, and helps her story create its own original identity. The Grimm’s prose form allows a more straightforward approach to its audiences, while Sexton’s poem helps it give the story a deeper meaning. Another major difference was Sexton’s addition of a new introduction and conclusion to her story. The poem starts off by mentioning other stories and fictional tales, but ends with truthful statements that show just how fictional the relationship between Cinderella and the prince is, like “Regular Bobbsey twins” (Sexton 79). Sexton also breaks the fourth wall in some instances, mostly to show her cynical and sarcastic attitude towards her story’s own character, Cinderella. In comparison, the Grimm’s Cinderella is shown to be the typical goody-two shoes damsel in distress, which every girl should try to be like. Sexton’s commentary in her poem changes this attitude towards Cinderella, and instead makes Cinderella look like the fragile, naïve, and helpless woman that she is. These divergences are what grab new and old readers of either the fairy tale genre, or Cinderella’s story alike. Old readers get to experience new elements and a fresh take on an old story, while newer readers can find it easier to understand and follow through Sexton’s story and the ideas it’s trying to convey. All these contrasting elements help change Sexton’s versions tone and connotations, despite the stories being very
Growing up as a little black girl, I rarely found dolls or princesses that looked like me. It was until I ran across the Rodgers and Hammerstein’s version of Cinderella movie starring the African American pop star Brandy as Cinderella. The made-for-television film was a remake of the Julie Andrews R&H Cinderella. But even the Julie Andrews version was based off the ancient folk tale. Although the movies are very similar, both films have a very unique touch to them.
Snow White and Cinderella are the heroines of the said tales and they have similar family situations, and also, Cinderella beats Snow White in terms of intelligence and mental sufferings. First of all, they’re so gorgeous that even their names remind the readers of beauty, they’re daughters
Even though the time periods are very different (by 200 years) the formulas for their fairy tales seems to remain constant. Character development, which is very important in fairy tales is both well done and accurately portrays the living situation for a character in the time period of when it was written. Perrault's version seems to put Cinderella's family in a higher, well-off situation of the Grimm's because she is still abided to obey the rules that her dying mother had set for her. Something that you would see a women do in the late 1600's. Her higher class and the rules of her generation has set her to not have revenge on her step-sisters and helps them marry in the end, making a happy ending to the story for everyone. This also gives off the rules of the time to the young girls who would be listening or reading this story back then. They knew their place in society and tales like Perrault's reinforced it. The Grimm's version, titled Ashenputtle, has key elements in the story line that make it very different from Perrault's Cinderella. The theme becomes very different as the end of the tale results in revenge on the step-sisters from Ashenputtle. This variation in the story line represents the setting in which the Grimm's either lived in themselves, or the living situation of the people who related this tale to the Grimm's.
For as long as most people can remember, they have been told fairy tales and stories. At a young age, children are read “Cinderella”. By looking back at the story, one can recall that Cinderella was a beautiful, yet ordinary to poorly dressed young woman who found her husband only after magic gave her the most beautiful gown and led her to a ball to meet her prince. In the text of a rewrite of “Cinderella” states, “This godmother of hers [Cinderella], who was a fairy, said to her ‘Thou wishest thou couldst go to the ball; is it not so?’ ‘Yes,’ cried Cinderella, with a great sigh” (Charles Perrault). This quote shows one how upset Cinderella was at this instant. She wept because she was not as beautiful as her step sisters and could not attend the King’s son’s ball. But recall how Cinderella’s attitude changes shortly after. The godmother flicks her wand and Cinderella appears wearing the most beautiful gown and awaiting to board a wonderful carriage that will carry her to the ball. Later, Cinderella attends the ball and has the best ...
The settings displayed in all three versions of Cinderella play an important role in the development of each story. Even though the overall setting of each story remains the same or very similar, there are smaller settings that have both similarities and differences. Each version of Cinderella takes place in a time long ago where women had no rights and basically had to make a living through marriage. But, the seasons each story takes place is different between each version. For example, the Grimm brothers’ version of “Cinderella” starts in the Autumn.
Though there are many fairy tales that have been created through the years, Cinderella is into our subconscious by stimulating the part of us that sympathizes with the mistreatment of Cinderella. Others say that the theme of a down-and-out poor girl rising up to become rich and happy appeals to any normal person. This theme is the common bond between all the stories. Recently, however, modern versions of the tale have surfaced in an attempt to relate to modern audiences. In the textbook Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum the editors decide to take out a chapter entitled Fairy Tales: A Closer Look at Cinderella. This chapter includes the stories, The politically Correct Cinderella, A feminist View, and America's Cinderella.
Kenney, Kayla and Wagner Melanie. "Why are Fairytales important for Young Children? By Kayla and Melanie." NY Teachers. N.p., 4 Dec 2012. Web. 11 Apr. 2014.
There are many things one has learned from the experience, although the twelve versions of Cinderella are similar to each other but yet in some way they are different, which make it unique. Similar plot and similar circumstances however, different author with different minds. They are portraying with similar knowledge but the way the story may be told is different such as the characters names, locations, and the time it was created. No matter what it is I’ve learn that Cinderella will be Cinderella regardless of the different author, different time or different title. These creations of different versions is precisely similar to when one tells another person a story and is passed on to another person than the story will be shorten with less details and added with a few other exaggerations, in which will cause the stories to be different from each other.
In the story Cinderella there are many versions. Over the years writers think of different ways to write the classic Cinderella. Some of the different versions of Cinderella are from China, Germany, Grimm, and Disney, to name a few. There are so many different views also, but one thing remains the same in the Grimm’s Cinderella and Disney’s Cinderella. She is characterized by being with her new step-sisters and stepmother. Cinderella is also viewed as a maid. Despite bearing some minor similarities, the differences between Disney’s Cinderella and Grimm’s Cinderella are striking.
The main message behind the Cinderella fairytale is that you should always stand up for what you believe in and never stop fulfilling your dream because the main title role Cinderella never gave up even after being enslaved by her stepmother for many years. These same characteristics are also shown in Strictly Ballroom because Scott continues to follow his dream which is to dance his own steps at the all-important Pan-Pacific Grand Prix Dancing Championship. Even though he was told numbers of times by his family and friends that he has to stick to strictly ballroom dance steps. However, both films have a character that guide them in the right path to accomplish there fantasy. For Cinderella, her fairy godmother comes into the film when Cinderella
My first diference is how they traveled. In the cinderella story cinderella went only to the palace but in the katie wodencloak story the bull and Katie wodencloak traveled very much to get away. So the most time in the Katie wodencloak story they were not at home like in the Cinderela story, but they almost always traveled. It was because the bull was helping katie wodencloak to eat, but her stepmother did not want that bull will help and wanted to kill him, so the bull and katie wodencloak went to a big journey. To the
This over exaggeration of the human imagination is what makes fairytales stand alone in their own category of fictional stories. Valerie Gokturk describes a fairytale as, “having magical things happen…talking animals… inanimate objects talking.” This can be seen through the Cinderella story as Cinderella is treated poorly by her new step-family, so in response she turns to frequently visiting her passed mother. Upon request, the father of Cinderella brings her a hazel twig to place on the mother’s grave. With the twig placed on the ground, a magical element comes into play as a hazel tree grows and produces birds that grant Cinderella wishes. This sense of magic is further seen as the tree produces a series of exquisite dresses that Cinderella wears to the prince’s ball. No tree of non-magic origin would be able to fully grow in such a short period of time, not to mention being able to spawn flawless dresses. The birds are seen as having a magical essence as Cinderella talks to them, instructing them to pick out the lentils out of the ash in the fireplace. This event can be seen as slightly more plausible; however, the fact that the birds can communicate with Cinderella places the series of events that unfold in a magical category. With the utilization of talking birds as well as a magical tree, it is clearly shown that the story of Cinderella has the essential element of magic that allows it to
As much as these two stories differ,separated by years and miles, they are very much alike one another and contain the same basic principle in both stories. There are many different variants to the Cinderella story that follow a story where the main character is being mistreated and then one day has a major change in their life and everything becomes better. However both stories revolve around the transformation of the main characters beauty, they both focus on the main character 's feet, for example in the chinese variant, “The more he marveled at its beauty, the more determined he become to find the woman to whom the shoe belonged” (Ai-Ling, 4). Also seen in the disney’s version ,”The Prince sent the Grand Duke to find the girl who fit the glass slipper.”(Disney, 14). The chinese culture found beauty in the woman 's foot size and that the smaller foot was always meant to mean a more beautiful woman. This form of beauty was taken from the chinese culture and used in the current day cinderella story as well to show that cinderella was beautiful. The Cinderella story isn 't just one story it has many different variations all along the world that even include a male version of