Judith Butler Gender Essay

I agree with this for many reasons I understand the other side of it and agree that biologically there is only two genders. That is not the point Judith is trying to get across, she is trying to say that gender doesn’t define us and that we ourselves are our own person and we should be proud of that and not try to fit the overused mold society has created for us. Socially we are told from a young age how to act based off of our gender we told what to do and mentally that sticks with us. Watching TV you can see very easily how gender is seen in our society the men are supposed to be strong rugged and always ready to protect the frail weak women. That’s just not realistic. Women can be strong and men can be frail it’s not based off gender it's

based off of who you are.
I chose this position because it makes sense. Gender Shouldn’t describe you it’s something that honestly shouldn’t matter when doing anything. There is some occasions where gender may matter but not in the place of modern day society. This is similar to what Judith Butler believes, she states her beliefs in the 1990 book gender troubles. In this book she talks about how feminism is taking the wrong step by stating women as a group of people with similar characteristics and interests. She believes there is not two clear cut groups but that you yourself decide your own identity and shape this identity to describe you. She says feminism is hypocritical by rejecting the idea of biology being destiny, she says feminism develops an account of male dominated culture whith says that masculine and feminine genders would always end up being built, by culture, upon 'male' and 'female' bodies, making that destiny just as inescapable theory.org. This argument doesn’t allow any room for choice, difference or resistance from the norm.
Judith Butler states gender isn’t something binary but is more or less an identity that we as people form based off interests and characteristics physical attributes have nothing to do with gender.

Judith Butler believes that gender should be seen as a fluid variable which shifts and changes in different contexts and at different times theory.org. Gender is something that should describe you as a person it shouldn’t be something that we aim to fit into. If you don't like manly things like “football”, “fighting”, and “hunting” you’re not any less of a man you just have different opinions towards things. If you don’t like wearing dresses and cleaning the house you’re no less womanly it’s just how you feel about it and that is something that we shouldn’t use in society to define people stereotyping people into enjoying and being better in certain tasks can lead to many harmful things for society. For over hundreds of years we lived with the idea that women shouldn’t be allowed to vote or even have regular jobs and now today women are still only making 73 cents to every dollar a man makes aauw.org. That can be attributed to the many years of believing women shouldn’t even go to school and have a proper education that’s something that set our whole nation back hundreds of years think about how much progress could be obtained if the smart women of our time were allowed to work with great men and share their ideas there’s no way to tell but we could be far ahead in the research we have

now.
There are many people who disagree with Judith Butler for what she says. Martha Nussbaum attacked her saying “it is obvious that Butler’s work is directed at a non-academic audience eager to grapple with actual injustices”judithbutler.wordpress.com saying the majority of her readers were college students who didn’t know anything about politics and were just trying to fight against any injustice they could find. This statement isn’t wrong the majority of her buyers being women aged 18-25. Martha Nussbaum says this because she’s trying to make it seem as if all her readers are uneducated by doing this she makes it seem like all followers don’t know what’s actually going on the real world.
Opposers of judith butler also speak about how scientifically there are only two gender male and female. This is true the biology of it is that there are two genders. Critics say that gender is not fluid and therefore can’t be something that describes you. They also believe gender is something you’re born with and you don't get to decide whether or not you want to be male or female it's just how you were born. These opposers tend to be conservatives, Judith Butler's book gender problems is a far left idea on what gender is and how it affects us socially. Critics state that Judith is misinformed in saying gender is fluid and that it’s something that is concrete and shouldn’t be changed or thought of as an identity.
The chief criticism stemming from popular feminist activists seems to surround Butler’s theoretical, language-based approach that appears impractical for solving real-world inequalities judithbutler.wordpress.com. She’s saying that Butler is focused too much on the idea of gender and not on the biological side which doesn’t account for the vast majority of transgendered and just takes the side of spoken genders. Spoken genders are genders that can’t be figured out by looking at someone or running a test on them it’s more of their own idea on who they are, Bordo explains that this does not do enough to support actual transgendered and that in turn isn’t realistic that it’s a feel good movement focused on making everyone feel better about who the are. This completely ignores the biological struggles faced by the transgendered each day. Bordo writes that for Butler, “there is one correct, unimpeachable position: it is that any conception of the ‘natural’ is a dangerous ‘illusion’ of which we must be ‘cured'” (290). This is saying that if you are a Cisgendered person that nothing matters for you. She is saying that they face no problems and that if you are on their side you are on the wrong side.