Jonas Community In The Giver

Imagine a world without problems, one where everyone is equal and treated the same way. In the book, The Giver by Lois Lowry, Jonas lives in a society that is very much like this world. Clearly, Jonas’ utopian community is a better place to live than Elsewhere for many beneficial reasons. Although some people could argue that living in Elsewhere is better because of freedom of choice, speech, and overall independence for many things. In reality, though, Jonas’ community is the better one to be a part of because of the lack of racism, a good way to deal with population control, the lack of love and attraction, and the way of dealing with job choosing. Overall, Jonas’ Community is the better place to live in.

Jonas’ community is beneficial because

One way that they have done this is by removing color. On page 97, it states that, “ The giver told him that it would be a very long time before he had the colors to keep.” This quote shows that Jonas has never, and would have never known that color exists if he had not gotten memories of them. Although this seems horrifying, just like release, it actually has benefits. Not having color gets rid of racism, and discrimination of color. This way everyone treats everyone equally, and doesn’t neglect anyone. Color also makes something more superior compared to others, which could create conflict. This could make one person’s tunic look better than another’s. But when color is eliminated, equality is maintained. In Elsewhere, though, these problems persist. This could act as a distraction in school, work, or anywhere where interaction is needed. This easy method of getting rid of colors has a slight set-back, but it is for the greater good. So in the end, eliminating color helps everyone put all their effort into helping the community thrive. Another way that Jonas’ community reduces distraction is by getting rid of love and attraction. On page 37, it states that, “ A reminder that stirrings must be reported for treatment to take place.” This quote refers to stirrings, or the wanting. This is a basic form of attraction toward other people. This is a distraction, to the learning environment and tasks in life. And instead of choosing a spouse, just like jobs, they are chosen. The elders take a long time to pair you up with a spouse, so there is no disagreement. This also helps stop attraction, and makes people focus on their lives. In addition, if someone applies for a spouse, they will get one no matter what. On the contrary, in Elsewhere, people might not get the one that they want, nevertheless anyone. Attraction and love is actually very common and is a part of its