How does Cormac McCarthy present the narrator or character in your chosen extract from The Road? Is it consistent with the rest of the novel?

932 Words2 Pages

The pages 276-278 begin with a confrontation between the man and the thief. This extract presents a harsh and unforgiving side to the man's character which differs to his portrayal in earlier parts of the novel. He is previously presented as kind and morally upright which contrasts to the cruel and almost immoral way his character behaves in this moment of the novel. At the beginning of this extract, the thief pleads with the man to return his clothes and shoes which the man has taken from him, saying "[c]ome on man I'll die". The man flatly refuses and replies "I'm going to leave you the way you left us". The man’s tone here is blunt and measured as he is exacting what he believes is justice. The statement shows that the man feels no sympathy towards the thief even though his actions could lead to the thief's death. The persistent way he forces the thief to remove his clothing is so shocking because it is totally unnecessary. The man’s treatment of the thief is similar to the cruel and sometimes horrific ways other survivors treat each other, which is ironic because the man always refers to himself and the boy as “the good guys”. His harshness raises questions as to whether or not he really is a "good guy" and if it is possible to remain morally good in a world where true “goodness” is scarce. McCarthy uses literal and figurative language to describe the thief which creates a sympathetic image of him and positions the reader to pity him. The use of visual imagery in phrases such as "nude and slatlike creature" adds to the thief’s already pitiful image. By comparing the thief to a "creature", McCarthy stirs within the reader the natural compassion and desire to protect animals that humans have. The word “nude” also suggests a v... ... middle of paper ... ...in other parts of the novel, for example when he shot the man who threatened the boy’s life, those actions were always for the purpose of survival and to protect himself and his son. The pressure of living in a post-apocalyptic setting causes the man to always be in a highly strained emotional state and this is one of the main reasons why he reacted to the thief in such an outrageous manner. This suggests that the man is a product of his environment and so his behaviour is determined by external conditions, implying that the man lacks agency and autonomy to some extent. McCarthy’s representation of the man’s character in this extract encourages the reader to think about whether moral rules, which were established in a normal civilisation, can still exist in a world where all civilisation is destroyed and if they can how will people ensure that they are carried out.

Open Document