How Free Should Be Given To Students In Elementary School

1176 Words3 Pages

Choice is something that I feel we take for granted in our everyday life. We have the choice of what we eat, wear, and the daily activities that we do. I know that personally I do not realize how important that luxury is, especially for students in school. Being able to decide what to write about and what to do projects on increases a student’s motivation to want to do well on the assignment. However, the challenging part of choice comes down to how much freedom should be given to children in elementary school. In my opinion, the lower elementary grades should be allowed to have more freedom than the upper elementary years. Not everyone may agree with me on this, but here is why I feel this way. First of all, when introducing writing, it is …show more content…

Boys in elementary school, especially the upper level grades, have a tendency to be influenced by the games that they play or through various exposures. Why is it that boys tend to me more heavily influenced by outside factors as compared to girls? Or does it only seem that way because of the assumption that girls are better at reading and writing? Ganske writes, “it is important to reconsider the nature of the ‘literacy gap’ between boys and girls as a symptom of the kinds of things that are implicitly valued in school, and not necessarily as predetermined differences in their interests and abilities” (2014, p. 120). Boys and girls can be interested in the same types of things, but as a teacher it is important to reach each child in the room and not just focus on one group. Choice is the main way to foster that type of environment, “we can see how choice is integral to the creativity, excitement, and ingenuity it can nurture” (Ganske, 2014, p. 121). This all may seem obvious, but in third and fourth grade this is important to think about. Interest are more solidified when it comes to their writing so being presented with issues of boys not producing the best work when a topic does not interest them becomes more …show more content…

After reading the article about helping struggling writers, I found that part about self-regulation. I had never thought about the fact that if a writer is struggling, it may be difficult for them to correct there own writing: “struggling writers do little revision without teacher or peer support, and the majority of revisions made by struggling writers involve only minor changes to surface-level features of the text” (Helsel, Greenberg, 2007, p. 2). In the classroom, it could be beneficial to have a mini-lesson, or even a full lesson because it is so important, dedicated to teaching what goes into self-regulation of writing pieces. At the third and fourth grade level this could look more like a rubric than in the lower levels. I do not fully support the idea of rubrics, but if it could help teach about self-regulating then it has a beneficial

Open Document