General Haig's Role in the Battle of the Somme

1400 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Reasons for the failure of schlievens plan in world war 1

The Battle of the Somme was one of the most famous battles that took place during World War One. Germany had believed that a war with Russia was likely to occur and if that happened then they would also come into attack from France. In order to avoid attack from both sides Germany planned to attack France first and then Russia, believing that Russia would need 6 weeks to attack them and they could defeat France in that time. This was the basis of the Schlieffen Plan. Germany attacked France through neutral Belgium as they thought that Belgium would not fight them. Germany launched a massive attack in the French city of Verdun in early 1916.This gave a real shock to France as they did not see it coming but, to lessen the pressure on France, the British planned an attack at Somme. The British wanted to break the German lines so that all the allies could continue the war into Germany.

The Anglo-French alliance intended to wear down the German army at Verdun before engaging in the Battle of Somme however, due to the large French losses at Verdun, the date for the Battle of Somme was brought forward to the 1st of July. The battle of the Somme lasted for just 4 months from July 1916 to November 1916 but was easily known as one of the worst battles ever fought.

The Somme offensive was planned late in 1915 with the aim of draining the German forces of their reserves. The plan was agreed upon by the new British Commander in Chief, Sir Douglas Haig, although Haig would have preferred an offensive among the open ground of Flanders where they could execute their strategies more tactically. Haig intention was to carry out the attack using the ideas of both himself and General Rawlinson.

People have interpreted General Haig’s role in ...

... middle of paper ...

...

In conclusion I think that Haig should not be seen as the Butcher of Somme despite the large number of people that died because according to the sources the battle was well planned and his perfect plan to break the German lines was a success. Although people disagree with him being a good general others supported him when he returned. Other says that not only was he a butcher of the Somme he also lost the trust that people had in him during the frightful war.

Due to Haig's lack of having a more original or effective strategy, he was constantly bombarded with accusations of being incompetent to be a general, but in all fairness if another officer had concocted a more successful strategy, then they would have taken over command. The Germans also used the same strategy, nevertheless, when the troops were dying in thousands, it's easy to blame the man in charge.

Show More
Related

  • Film The Battle of the Somme Compared With the Real Event

    600 Words  | 2 Pages

    were poor and men loathed them. The soldiers slept on a bed of mud and

    Read More

  • Haig's Decisions in Attacking the Germans at the Somme

    1542 Words  | 4 Pages

    Source A tells us that Haig did not care about his men and is willing

    Read More

  • Battle Of Stalingrad Dbq Analysis

    627 Words  | 2 Pages

    “In Stalingrad, in addition to its heavy losses, the German army also lost its formidable image of being invincible,” Document 8 reveals.” In fact, with the loss of Stalingrad, the German army began to lose battles all across the Eastern Front and in North Africa”(Document 8: Graphics). The men did not lose their lives in the Battle of Stalingrad did lose the image that had been built for themselves. The following loses after that battle prove that the German army was weakened and could no longer keep all of their word and the image Hitler had built up for them. Without pushing the soldiers to stay at Stalingrad, Hitler and the Germans could have salvaged the war and their reputations. Although the end of World War II was 2 ½ years after the Battle of Stalingrad, the result of the battle influence who won the war. Because the Germans lost at Stalingrad, they began to lose other battles and suffered questioning and disbelief of their previous reputation of being invisible. The biggest mistake Adolf Hitler made was how he conducted the Battle of

    Read More

  • The First Battle of Ypres, 1914

    2681 Words  | 6 Pages

    middle of paper ... ... Haig came under intense criticism both in 1917, and since, for persisting with the offensive after it became clear that a breakthrough was unlikely to happen. Critics have argued that the main launch pad for the attack should have been sited at Messines Ridge, captured. by Plumer in June; but Haig’s original plans precluded this, viewing.

    Read More

  • Blaming Haig for the Slaughter of the Somme

    2151 Words  | 5 Pages

    of that what Haig did was infact what he was supposed to do at the

    Read More

  • Life and Suffering in The Trenches

    1694 Words  | 4 Pages

    World War I, also known as the Great War, lasted from the summer of 1914 until the late fall of 1918. The war was fought between the Allies, which consisted mainly of the United Kingdom, France, and the Russian Empire, and the Central Powers, which consisted mainly of the German Empire, the Ottoman Empire, the Austro-Hungarian Empire, and the Kingdom of Bulgaria (Alliances - Entente and Central Powers). In total, it is estimated that twelve million civilians and nine million combatants died during this horrific and devastating war (DeGroot 1). When the war first began in 1914, many people thought that it would be a war of movement that would quickly be over. However, that changed when the Germans, who were trying to reach and capture the city of Paris in France, were forced to retreat during the Battle of the Marne in September 1914 (Ellis 10). German General von Falkenhayn, who felt that his troops must at all cost hold onto the parts of France and Belgium that they had overtaken, ordered his men to dig in and form defensive trench lines (Ellis 10). The Allies could not break through the enemies lines and were forced to create trenches of their own (Ellis 10). This was only the beginning of trench warfare. A war of movement had quickly come to a standstill on the Western Front. A massive trench line, 475 miles long, quickly spread and extended from the North Sea to the Swiss Frontier (Ellis 10). With neither side budging, soldiers were forced to live in the most miserable of conditions. Simply put, life in the trenches was a living hell. A lieutenant of the 2nd Scottish rifles wrote, “No one who was not there can fully appreciate the excruciating agonies and misery through which the men had to go [through] in those da...

    Read More

  • Major-General James Wolfe

    2504 Words  | 6 Pages

    ... military allowed him to take calculated risks that won him the Battle of Quebec. By distracting the larger portion of the French forces, Wolfe was able to get a fair fight upon numbers, but not at all in the sense of military ability. He was not mad, he was a student of war and he was able to excel when it counted the most. When it was told to King George II that Wolfe was mad the king replied with, “Mad is he? Then I hope he will bite some of my other generals!” (May, 25). Not only did Wolfe have the respect of his soldiers, but even that of the king of his country. Patton was considered a madman as well, but at the end of the day results are what count. He died heroically on the battle field, victorious, and will forever be one of the most infamous characters of modern American history.

    Read More

  • The Battle of the Bulge

    608 Words  | 2 Pages

    The prelude to the Battle of the Bulge began on a winter day in mid-December of 1944. Three powerful German divisions, were the last German offensives in the west at that time during World War II. They began after the Normandy invasion in June 1944. Allied had forces swept rapidly through France but became stalled along the German border earlier that year in September. On December 16, 1944 taking advantage of the weather, which kept the Allied aircraft on the ground, the Germans launched a counteroffensive through the semi-mountainous and heavily-forested Ardennes region in Germany, and advanced 31 miles into Belgium and northern Luxembourg near the Meuse River. Their goal was to trap four allied armies, divide the Americans and the British to force negotiated peace along the western front, and retake the vital seaport of Antwerp in Belgium. Thinking the Ardennes was the least likely spot for a German offensive, American staff commander chose to keep the thin line, so that manpower might concentrate on offensives north and south of the Ardennes known as the "bulge" in the Allied lines. These American lines were thinly held by three divisions in the Allied Army and part of a forth division, while fifth division was making a local attack and the sixth division was in reserve. Division sectors were more than double the width of normal defensive fronts, therefore there were more men scattered along a larger area. The German advance was halted near the Meuse River in late December. Even though the German Offensive achieved total surprise, nowhere did the American troops give ground without a fight. Within three days, the determined American stand and the arrival of powerful reinforcements insured that the ambitious German goal was far beyond reach. In snow and sub-freezing temperatures the Germans fell short of their interim objective- to reach the rambling Meuse River on the edge of the Ardennes. But they managed to avoid being cut off by an Allied Pincer movement.

    Read More

  • World War I Changed Combat Tactics

    1649 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Generals and politicians thought the war was going to end very quickly where every I gets to go home on Christmas. Generals and Politicians said “A few quick campaigns and a few decisive victories would “bring the boys home by Christmas, “perhaps even by the fall” (Overfield, James H. Sources of Twentieth-century Global History. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2002. Print.) , p74. They were definitely wrong on that note. The war lasted 4 years in the hell the soldiers called the battlefield. One of the first major battles on the western front was called the Battle of Marne. The battle that halted the Germans from entering France into a long standing stalemate. The trench warfare started here, where soldiers dug deep into the ground and settled down to fight off the enemy soldiers. It was a stalemate for man...

    Read More

  • General Gouglas Haig

    1867 Words  | 4 Pages

    A judgement of Haig cannot be reached without an understanding of his context. Haig, in society today, is most commonly viewed as a foolish “butcher” who failed to grasp the basics of the battlefield and proceeded to sacrifice Britain’s ‘flower of youth’. But to blindly accept this perspective is to misunderstand the complexities surrounding interpretations of Haig. We must realise that the First World War was one of inherent contradictions: a war with unexpected 20th Century technology, a war of attrition rather than the traditional 19th Century one of movement. Commanders, including Haig, struggled with the advent of modern warfare. This inflexibility is one of the traditionalists’ main lines of argument – move this into a paragraph on the mini-debate of inflexibility, but then I’m unsure where the following paragraph fits, because it i...

    Read More

  • Retired General Colin Powell

    946 Words  | 2 Pages

    The General did not excel or apply himself in school. As a teen, he was sent home from summer camp for leaving the camp are and having a beer. He was sent home for the stunt, but was later found out from one of the Priest, that he had owned up to the mistake. He had taken responsibility; this is a leadership trait that he took through his long years of Military life, along with his tenure in the diplomatic world.

    Read More

  • The Development of Stalemate on the Western Front

    742 Words  | 2 Pages

    unready offensive drew German troops away. They were now fighting a war on two fronts. Another reason why Stalemate developed on the western front was because the British and Russian troops arrived at the Battle of Marne. Germany invaded Belgium in August 1914. The battle of the Marne was between August and September the Germans advanced across Belgium but were held up briefly by the British Expeditionary Force at Mons on 23.

    Read More

  • The Battle of France

    2520 Words  | 6 Pages

    World War I had been fought primarily on French soil, and the military as well as the government never wanted that to happen again, therefore they wanted to reinforce their main border against any future German. Little did they know that only twenty-two years later they would be bested by German forces in a way that would shock the world.... ... middle of paper ... ... Situational awareness was almost non-existent, with many French commanders not even knowing where their own subordinate units were located.11

    Read More

  • The Influence Of The Allied Soldier On The Western Front

    233 Words  | 1 Pages

    Between 1915 and 1917 there were several offensives along this Front. Among the most costly of these offensives were the Battle of Verdun,in 1916, with a combined 700,000 casualties (estimated), the Battle of the somme, also in 1916, with more than a million casualties, and the Battle of Passchendaele, in

    Read More

  • Battle Of Argonne Forest Analysis

    793 Words  | 2 Pages

    Germany formed a plan to March on Paris in 1918, which would almost guarantee full control of the country by the end of the year (Smith). To accomplish this, Germany massed 35 Divisions and began its march toward Paris. Tenacious fighting forced besieged

    Read More

More about General Haig's Role in the Battle of the Somme

Open Document