Should kids get trophies just for participation? That's the big question. People have different ideas on this subject. Today's society has changed its ideas in how we should treat competition in young people. It used to be that only kids who have done good in the sport receive trophies, but now, everyone who participates gets one. Many people like think that only kids that have achieved excellence in their sport should receive trophies, while others believe all participating kids should get one. I, for one, believe that kids should only get trophies if they have achieved excellence in their sport.
Kids need to learn that everything in life should be earned. Effort alone is not a cause for recognition. Trophies that are just handed out for participation do not have long lasting value. If participation trophies were not handed out, the life lessons received instead would have a much longer lasting value, that can last a child his or her whole life. Such lessons include the fact that life isn't fair, and that the world is tough. You need to earn what you want. Kids that are raised with participation trophies are a weaker generation than the kids who had to earn their trophies. When kids that get trophies just for participating grow up, they get rushed when they get to the real world, completely unprepared, causing them a lot more stress at one time.
…show more content…
Kids that get trophies by participating don't strive to do better, or for greatness.
They know that they get a trophy no matter what, and begin to think they are entitled to a trophy, as well as equal treatment. The truth is, no one is entitled to anything at all. Kids have to earn what they want, not expect it, otherwise they'll expect everything to be handed to them. Kids that get trophies for winning work at getting better, so that they can earn a trophy. They will train and practice, to achieve greatness, in order to get a trophy. This is exactly what is needed in youth, because they will learn early on about how life
is. Kids can cope with life better when they are older if they aren't raised with participation trophies. People for participation trophies say that the memories made are better, and those trophies bring back those memories. Life lessons are way more than memories of an easy childhood. Stanford researcher, Carol Dweck, studied children's coping and resilience mechanisms for over 40 years, and said that too much praise may lead to less resilient children. If children were given trophies for actual achievements, they would learn lessons that would fit their needs as adults. If they lose and don't get a trophy, they can be taught to congratulate those who win. that would help them build the motivation and endurance needed to face real life challenges. Many people today who were raised with participation trophies (most millennials), do not know how to handle defeat. In the previous election, a lot of them supported Hillary Clinton. She ended up losing the election to Donald Trump. Instead of congratulating those who won, they ended up rioting and protesting. They did not know how to handle things. Everyone has their disagreements. Younger generations don't see the problems with participation trophies while the older generations do. Some people think that participation trophies are important. Others agree that trophies should be earned. The points written above will hopefully be enough to point out that trophies should only be earned.
Children shouldn't be given participation trophies, this can cause false sense of confidence and it can make them expect to always be a winner in life. This can affect them every day not everyone will nail that job interview or win the game and it will be hard on them not being able to except that they lost or couldn't do it. You don't get paid to just show up at a job, you have to work. You don't win by showing up to the hockey
However, some people may argue that leagues should give out participation trophies. In an article by Lisa Hefferman on Today.com, it states “ the idea of giving trophies to only the winners doesn’t emphasize enough of the other values that are important.” (Today.com Aug. 2015) While this may seem true their are many other lessons children can learn from earning a trophy. These lessons may seem important there are many other important lessons children could learn from getting a trophy. In conclusion, young athletes should not get participation trophies.
Our society has shifted its beliefs in how we should treat competition in young people. The question is asked, should all kids get a participation trophy? As it may seem to be an unanswerable question, it honestly isn’t. Thought that the participation trophies may send the message that “coaches” value the kids’ efforts despite their abilities, trophies do not need to be given out. Your words mean just as much when you remind an athlete that you value them in more ways than one. Some may think trophies are a great idea because it shows that everyone’s a “winner.” However, I disagree with that idea. I believe that kids should know that they need to work their hardest in order to be rewarded and understand that not
To illustrate, Ashley Merryman, the author of the article “Losing is Good for You” states, “ However, when it comes to rewards, people argue that kids must be treated identically: everyone must always win. That is misguided. And there are negative outcomes. Not for just specific children, but for society as a whole.” This explains that when kids get trophies, they think that they are always going to win, no matter how poorly they did their job. This can cause major problems in the society, such as companies not improving. In addition, Ashley Merryman also states, “ Having studied recent increases in narcissism [having an excessive interest in oneself; an over inflated ego often due to parents’ overvaluation] and entitlement among college students, she [Jean Twenge, author of Generation Me] warns that when living rooms are filled with participation trophies, it’s part of a larger cultural message: to succeed, you just have to show up.” This shows that even young kids are starting to be egoistic, and that can stick with them their entire life. When kids will go into the real world, it would be too late to realize that winning is not important. As a result, narcissism increases in the kids and makes them
All Kids Should Not Get Trophy's Do you think all kids should get trophy's? They should not get trophy's because, not all kids practice hard at getting better. Second it will teach the kids a life lesson that will show them nothing comes free in life and u must work for what u want. Third, people think that kids should get trophy's for just participating.
Lisa is part of the 'for' group when it comes to this debate, Vivian is part of the 'against' group. In Lisa's article one can clearly see that she is a firm believer that children now can benefit from receiving participation trophies. She states that trophies will motivate "kids to participate in sports, to learn to improve their skills, to help others, to work hard and make a contribution to the team. " She is not really concerned or mentions these kids and how they may be in the future. Vivian on the other is worried that if we keep handing out participation trophies to children, we are going to raise a bunch of young adults who cannot handle losing in the real world.
Do you think children should get trophies just for trying and showing up? The debate on participation trophies, and if they should be given out is a rising debate in our country. Participation trophies are doing a lot of harm to kids, and shouldn’t be given out.
This proves that experts believe that participation trophies are awards for kids that don’t win and make it so that they don’t strive to win and improve their abilities. According to The Sun's Washington correspondent and sports reporter, Jeff Barker stated that kids need to learn to “take the good with the bad. ”(Baltimore Sun). This quote shows that kids need to be able to learn lessons and improve instead of being rewarded for making mistakes. Overall, if people want their kids to be the best or improve their skills participation trophies should not be given out.
Kids should not get participation trophies because that means that kids are getting praise without doing much to earn it and that won’t help them in life, this will prepare them for what society has to throw at them, and even though people might think they are sentimental, but people will soon just forget about them. Participation trophies are harming our kids because they are teaching our children that in the future, they don’t have to work hard for what they want. According to an article by Vivian Diller, “After studying children's coping and resilience mechanisms for over 40 years, Stanford researcher Carol Dweck states that too much praise may lead to less
There are many pros and cons to participation trophies. Ultimately, all athletes are trying to win the game. Kids should not earn a trophy merely for participation. The first reason kids should not receive trophies for participation is because it does not reward the right goal. There is clearly a difference between winning and losing and the only way for children to learn the difference is to experience it.
What is the purpose of giving our kids participation trophies in sports at all? It can give them a skewed point of view of their athletic abilities. Also what about the kids that won? How would you feel if the team you just beat got the same trophy as you! Why would you put those who lost on the same level as the winners? Going to practice is expected and something not worth a trophy. This is especially true if a team or a kid goes above expected and ends up in the same spot. We should stop giving kids participation trophies because, kid can get a false sense of their accomplishments and their athletic abilities.
Trophies should not be awarded to everyone for participation, but only to the select individuals who have had the determination to reach their goal of coming out on top of everyone else. Participation trophies will not teach children and teens the real realities of life, that not everything is going to go your way. Children need to know at an early age, that just showing up to a sport, isn't going to help you or your team win, if you don't put effort. Trophies are setting kids up for failure, rather than trying to teach them to succeed in life.
Think back to your childhood and imagine all of the activities you have done. I have done soccer, karate, swimming and dance and I have tons of trophies from my many years of. When I think back did I really derive those trophies or did I get them just for showing up. This is a good example of all the trophies that get handed to kids for just participating or showing up. Trophies can get kids desires up way to high when they realize that they aren't the most valued player.
One reason that children with lower playing skills don’t play as much in a game, but still give their best effort that allows more playing time. This shows coaches want to build up all of their players with the skill they need to learn. In addition to kids getting play time, receiving trophies can encourage young athletes to continue playing if they’re not
Attendance, good attitude and sportsmanship, and the desire to improve are all great attributes for athletes to have. Since these attributes are not showcased in all people who participate in sports, they still manage to get trophies. To some parents, trophies for participation are very important but to others, they disagree. In my opinion, participation trophies are not necessary because kids can learn from their mistakes, strive to improve, and work hard to actually deserve trophies.