Ethical Dilemmas

787 Words2 Pages

Title: Ethical Dilemmas in Reporting Suspected Child Abuse: A Case Study Analysis. Abstract: This research essay explores the ethical issues surrounding the case of a young girl suspected of abuse by her father, as described by her concerned sibling. Using Rae's methodology for ethical decision-making, the essay examines the various considerations involved in reporting such abuse, including the potential consequences for the family, the credibility of the accuser, and the duty to protect the vulnerable. The essay also considers the role of institutions, such as the church and Child Line, in addressing cases of suspected abuse. Ultimately, the essay argues that while reporting abuse can have significant consequences, the ethical imperative …show more content…

An adolescent suspects their father of assaulting their younger sister. The father is the sole breadwinner, and the entire family relies on him financially. The mother appears aware, yet helpless to act. The teenager is divided between familial loyalty and the desire to protect their sister. Ethical Issue: The ethical question in this scenario is whether to disclose suspected child abuse despite probable negative implications for the family, such as financial difficulty or social humiliation. Furthermore, the accuser's veracity is called into question, given the father's recognized standing in the community and church. Furthermore, there is the issue of protecting the vulnerable, in this case, a fourteen-year-old girl who is reportedly being molested. Other concerns include the teenager's reluctance to approach their father, the mother's seeming passivity, and the potential repercussions of reporting the abuse, such as the father's incarceration and the family's financial security. Gathering Relevant Information: To make an educated …show more content…

Consideration of Alternative Courses of Action: This type of situation has several options for action. The protagonist might face their father personally and attempt to resolve the situation inside the family. They may also seek assistance from other family members or friends to intercede on their behalf. Alternatively, they might report the abuse to ChildLine or the police, regardless of the possible implications for the family. Each solution carries both benefits and hazards. Making Decisions Based on Ethical Principles: It is crucial to keep the ethical standards that are guiding our behaviour in mind when making decisions. These consist of the autonomy, justice, beneficence, and non-maleficence principles. In this instance, the beneficence principle implies that the victim's welfare should come first, even if doing so means taking steps that could be detrimental to the victim's family. This viewpoint is also supported by the principle of non-maleficence, which calls on us to stop harming other people. Regardless of their social standing or place in the community, everyone should be treated fairly and

Open Document