Don't Ask, Don't Tell

1437 Words3 Pages

Imagine being in the heat of war, a place where trust is needed most. Imagine, however, that in the heat of war you cannot trust your fellow soldier because of personal tensions within the unit. It was this problem that the policy known as “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” was designed to avoid, the tension caused between soldiers when homosexuals are serving openly. Without this policy, homosexuals serving openly could create tension that interferes with the military’s effectiveness. While it may not be obvious at first, the policy of “Don’t Ask Don’t Tell” actually supports the both values of the military and the rights of homosexuals. As a result, “Don’t Ask Don’t Tell” is needed to protect homosexual service members and is crucial in securing military effectiveness.

Throughout history openly practicing homosexuals have not been accepted in the United States Armed Forces. During the American Revolution and the Civil War, while no military code actually addressed homosexuals, anyone found committing homosexual acts was dishonorably discharged (Walke). With the turn of the century, the U.S. military actively began prohibiting and prosecuting homosexual acts (Walke). Throughout the 20th century, individuals seeking to serve in the military were prohibited from serving if they had a history of homosexual activity. With his election in 1994, President Bill Clinton sought to change this prohibition. However, once in office he met opposition from military leadership. As a result, a compromise between the Clinton administration, military officials and conservatives brought about the “Don’t Ask Don’t Tell” policy.

“Don’t Ask Don’t Tell” is the official policy of the U.S. Department of Defense towards homosexuals in the military. Members of t...

... middle of paper ...

....

Works Cited

Beattie, LCDR Scott J., JAGC, USN. Personal Interview. 5 Apr. 2011.

Bowman, Jeffery, and Laura Finley. “Homosexuals in the Military: An Overview.” Points of View: Homosexuals in the Military. 2009: 1. Points of View Reference Center. Web. 31 Mar 2011.

Issitt, Micah, and Geraldine Wagner. “Counter Point: The ‘Don’t Ask Don’t Tell’ Policy of the U.S. Military is a Form of Discrimination.” Points of View: Homosexuals in the Military. 2009: 3. Points of View Reference Center. Web. 31 Mar 2011.

Owens, Mackubin Thomas. “The Case Against Gays in the Military.” Wall Street Journal. 03 Feb 2010: A. 17. SIRS Researcher. Web. 29 Mar 2011.

Walke, Jacob, and Chuck Goodwin. “Point: America Cannot Afford to be Weakened by Homosexuality.” Points of View: Homosexuals in the Military. 2009: 2. Points of View Reference Center. Web. 31 Mar 2011.

The Invisible War Rhetorical Analysis
1280 Words | 3 Pages
From the mothers and fathers of the daughters and sons in the military to the friends that are left back home when someone enlists and prepares on their journey, this film provides a starting point to influence conversation’s about the sexual violence and injustice prevalent across the DOD. The film speaks out to the audience’s emotions by delivering jaw-dropping statistics all while providing a strong ethical basis of trustworthy resources, interviews, and statistics. This documentary is a great example of how using pathos, ethos and logos to implore an audience to question how the DOD reacts to MST. By combining all these rhetoric appeals, Kirby is able to convince the audience that there is sexual misconduct in the military and there is no evidence to prove that they are doing anything about
Read More
Why Gays Shouldn’t Serve by David Horowitz
1050 Words | 3 Pages
In the essay “Why gays shouldn’t serve” by David Horowitz he states that “Don’t ask, Don’t Tell policy is a way of containing the destructive force of sex on a combat capability called Unit Cohesion. (354)” This controversial topic has surfaced more and more recently because Barack Obama wanted to let all people serve in the military, regardless of their sexual orientation. “More than 1,000 retired flag and general officers have joined us in signing an open letter to President Obama and Congress, repeal of this law would prompt many dedicated people to leave the military (James J. Lindsay).” There are multiple points you could focus on when trying to explain your point on why gays or lesbians should not serve in the military. The first point we will be focusing on is: how would military life change if straight men or women knew that there were gays or lesbians sleeping next to them? The second point is: would straight men and women communicate with the gays or lesbians the same way as they would toward other straight men or women? The third and final point is: how would other countries view our military if they knew we had gays or lesbians in the military?
Read More
Comparison of The Crucible And Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell
1260 Words | 3 Pages
Frank, Nathaniel. Unfriendly Fire: How the Gay Ban Undermines the Military and Weakens America. New York: Thomas Dunne, 2009. Print.
Read More
Proposed Revisions To the Army Tattoo Policy
1027 Words | 3 Pages
For the last few months there has been an ongoing debate about whether troops with tattoos should have to get them removed or exit the military. Sgt. Maj. Raymond Chandler states that the new policy will not allow troops to have tattoos that are racist, extremist, and or sexist .Also under the new policy recruits cannot have tattoos below the knee and elbow and above the neckline (Stars and Stripes). Why is this just limited to the new recruits? As Chandler also stated the older troops that have tattoos will have to go through a grandfathering process for their, but they still cannot have a one that falls in the category of being vulgar(Stars and Stripes). No matter what their classification is they will have to meet with an army counselor to self-identify the meaning and discuss what will happen if they have to get it removed. While it is true that a person’s tattoos can tell a story about them, it does not necessarily dictate how well a person can perform their assigned job. It is now a heated discussion amongst the soldiers about whether it is fair or not for them to have to go through this. I firmly support troops not having to get their tattoo removed.
Read More
Military Rape Victims Re-victimized
693 Words | 2 Pages
Kitfield, James. “The Enemy Within”. The National Journal. 13 September 2012. Web. 4 November 2013 http://www.nationaljournal.com/magazine/the-military-s-rape-problem-20120913
Read More
Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell Policy
1747 Words | 4 Pages
(Wagner) In the early 1990s, large numbers of military personnel were opposed to letting openly gay men and lesbians serve. President Bill Clinton, who promised to lift the ban during his campaign, was overwhelmed by the strength of the opposition, which threatened to overturn any executive action he might take. The compromise that came to be known as "don't ask, don't tell" was thus a useful speed bump that allowed temperatures to cool for a period of time while the culture continued to evolve.
Read More
African Americans and the Military
603 Words | 2 Pages
Since even before the United States has been classified as a nation, African Americans have served in armed forces. From a little village militias to the army or sailors, African Americans have stepped up to help defend and eventually earn their own freedom. The battle for unification and for recognition of black soldiers has been a slow undertaking. It wasn't until after World War II that the U.S. armed forces became fully and lawfully unified, under a 1948 executive order by President Harry S. Truman. They were “unified”; meaning that the African American troops could be in the same regiments and squads as the white men. Previously they underwent completely separate training and were assorted to their own regiments. Throughout time many groups of enlisted black men have made up the hammer which broke down the racial barriers which were all too common up until about 45 years ago. All of this had to start somewhere, which leads me to the Revolutionary War.
Read More
Women and the Draft
984 Words | 2 Pages
"Update: Women in the Military." Issues and Controversies. Facts On File News Services, 29 May 2007. Web.
Read More
Rape In The Military Essay
1425 Words | 3 Pages
Despoil in the military occurs more often than many civilians believe. It is very important
Read More
Sexual Orientation Discrimination in the Military
1873 Words | 4 Pages
Prior to the “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy the United States and its citizens were not very tolerant to openly gay, lesbian and bisexual individuals. Prior to World War II gays were not specifically targeted for exclusion from the military, although sodomy was considered a criminal offense as early as the Revolutionary War. However by the beginning of World War II, the military had shifted focus from excluding acts that were considered homosexual to focusing on members that were considered homosexual. In 1942, the military issued its first regulation that contained a paragraph defining the difference between a homosexual and a normal person. In fact, this regulation also described procedures for rejecting gay draftees. (Martinez, Hebl, & Law, 2012). The military based these procedures on medical rationale and psychiatric screening to...
Read More
Rape and Sexual Assault in the Military
1105 Words | 3 Pages
The purpose of this essay is to discuss the issue of rape and sexual assault in the military. The number of attacks for rape and sexual assault in the military are at an all-time high. Women have recently been allowed to fight on the front line. While this may be a huge achievement for women-kind, for this woman, it is a very scary thought. I am a junior at Texas Academy of Biomedical Sciences; a school geared towards students wishing to enter the medical field. I may be forced to join the military one day if a war breaks out and women are needed to protect the country. I would be happy to serve my country if I did not have to be scared of my fellow soldiers. Rape and sexual assault are major issues in the military and have been for many years without much effort to decrease the attacks. I am suggesting that unless the rape and sexual assault issue is fixed, the amount of people joining the military, specifically the women, will decrease greatly.
Read More
Don T Ask Dont Tell Research Paper
517 Words | 2 Pages
In 2010, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Admiral Michael Mullen said, “I cannot escape being troubled in the fact that we have in place a policy that forces young men and women to lie about who they are in order to defend their fellow citizens. For me, personally, it comes down to integrity. Theirs as individuals and ours as an institution.” Admiral Mullen was speaking about our nations past policy on LGBT military service, “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell”. President Bill Clinton coined this term when he signed the policy into law in 1993, telling service members “don’t ask, don’t tell, don’t pursue, and don’t harass.” This went into effect on October 1st, 1993. The “don’t ask” aspect of the policy was aimed to prevent harassment. The “don’t tell” aspect was designed so that if an individual were openly gay, they would be discharged from the military.
Read More
Interview with a Social Worker
2018 Words | 5 Pages
Daley, J. G. (1999). Understanding the Military As an Ethnic Identity. In J. G. Daley, Social Work Practice in the Military (pp. 291-303). Binghamton: Haworth Press Inc.
Read More
Lgbt Military Service Equality Research Paper
231 Words | 1 Pages
LGBT military service equality was only equal as of three years ago. Members were at risk of discharge if one was to marry one of the same sex and no benefits were obtained. Homosexuals and bisexuals in the American armed forces were not able to receive same-sex benefits due to the, "Don't Ask Don't Tell" policy. The secret had to be kept due to the risk of being discharged. In 2010, Congress repealed the, "Don't Ask Don't Tell". This allows LGBT to serve openly. The Department of Defense recognizes same-sex marriages and allows federal benefits. The Supreme Court struck down the Defense of Marriage Act. This caused over a thousand legally same-sex married couples to be denied benefits. Same-sex marriages were still available as it stands now,
Read More
And Tango Makes Three: Bring it Into the Elementary Classrooms
1430 Words | 3 Pages
Marinoble, Rita M. "Homosexuality: A Blind Spot In The School Mirror." Professional School Counseling 1.3 (1998): 4-7. ERIC. Web. 23 Mar. 2014.
Read More

Open Document

Wait a second!

Don't Ask, Don't Tell

The Invisible War Rhetorical Analysis

Why Gays Shouldn’t Serve by David Horowitz

Comparison of The Crucible And Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell

Proposed Revisions To the Army Tattoo Policy

Military Rape Victims Re-victimized