Disgrace: David Lurie as Hero

811 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Disgrace jm coetzee summary

Who could ever confuse David Lurie, from the book Disgrace, to be a hero? Heroes never selfishly think of their own personal desires before others. David Lurie's character flaws of selfishness and lust would fit him into the mold of a tragic hero. David continually lusts women causing him to be no typical hero. A tragic hero can be a hero yet have some type of character flaw that brings him down. Therefore David is considered a tragic hero. In Shakespearean literature the use of a tragic hero has set standards. "The Tragic story leads up, and includes the death of the hero. The suffering and calamity are exceptional. They are themselves of a striking kind. They are as a rule, unexpected. They are contrasted with previous happiness and/or glory." (http://global.cscc.edu/engl/264/TragedyLex.htm#GENERAL) J.M. Coetzee uses these standards and deviates slightly from them to create his own modern tragic hero in Disgrace. The book Disgrace begins by displaying David's lust for women. The first chapter portrays David being with a prostitute named Soraya. After his encounters with Soraya have come to a close David becomes entangled with one of his students. This is what leads to his fall from high standings. David is a professor and is eventually asked to leave his position at the university due to his encounters with Melanie. When David is being asked to apologize for his actions with his student, David does not even consider apologizing. He is prideful and feels that he has done no wrong. Actually he blames his actions of the god of love. David feels he is above the laws of the land and the university he works for through this display of no apologies. Da... ... middle of paper ... ...to Lucy. This is the most frustrating for our tragic hero David who wishes to punish him for his bad deeds. David is our tragic hero and though he does not die in the end of the book, he does seem to give up on life. He is a beaten man in the end. Not only does he forgive Melanie's parents but he decides to let the dog that likes him die. After sleeping with Bev Shaw he realizes this is type of woman he must not be comfortable with. This shows that David has given up pursuing the women he wants to and basically just surrendered or died in essence. David is a hard character for the reader to understand. His decisions are very rash and selfish causing the reader to hope he will change in the end. Yet in the end of Disgrace David Lurie has given up on life and this symbolizes his death to society. The death to society completes Lurie's journey as a tragic hero.

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of Quarantine In The Novel 'The Loners'

    752 Words  | 2 Pages

    David, the main character in the book, realizes that his girlfriend Hilary has cheated on him. To make things even worse she is cheating with one of his friends from the football team, Sam. David tries to talk to Hilary but she thinks he hasn’t been the same since his mother died about a year ago. Later, David beats up Sam at a party.

    Read More

  • Literary Analysis Essay On The Memory Keeper's Daughter

    479 Words  | 1 Pages

    The greatest conflict in the book was Man vs. Man for David, because he had to face his childhood of when his sister June had died due to down syndrome. This internal conflict led to the guilt he experienced when dealing with the secret of giving his daughter Phoebe away and lying to Norah(his wife) that Phoebe had died at birth. Norah and the family later realised Phoebe was alive but in that time frame before that the family was falling apart.

    Read More

  • Montana 1948

    726 Words  | 2 Pages

    David Hayden, the son of Wesley and Gail, was the most loyal character in the book. One day David noticed Uncle frank walking out of the house in the middle of the day. David was an intelligent young boy who knew that something was off. Later that day David heard the news that Marie Little Soldier had died and it was not of natural causes. Guilt comes with loyalty. When a person witnesses a scene that was unlawful they are put into the middle of a paradigm. In this case, David, who knew Uncle Frank killed Marie, felt he was the only witness. For a twelve year old boy, David knew himself very well. He was able to find that his loyalty was to Marie and the rest of the family. Although David knew where his loyalty was he was sure that not everyone did know. "I wasn't protecting her-I no longer had any illusions that I could play that role-but I stayed out of loyalty.”(149). In spite of the fact that David had already designated his Loyalty to his family, he felt his loyalty was tested during the investigation. Davids instincts told him that the right thing to do was superset his father, but with his mother encouraging him to abandon his father, David felt he should neglect his instincts. For example, when the four men were sent by his grandfather to retrieve Unc...

    Read More

  • David's Changing View in The Chrysalids

    814 Words  | 2 Pages

    Uncle Axel , and The Sealand lady are the three important people in David's life whose

    Read More

  • A Child Called It By Dave Pelzer

    831 Words  | 2 Pages

    At first, David cares that his mother treats him badly. After awhile, he doesn’t care and becomes apathetic.

    Read More

  • A Child Called It By Dave Pelzer

    673 Words  | 2 Pages

    1. In the book, the father tries to help the son in the beginning but then throughout the book he stops trying to help and listens to the mother. If I had been in this same situation, I would have helped get the child away from his mother because nobody should have to live like that. The father was tired of having to watch his son get abused so eventually he just left and didn’t do anything. David thought that his father would help him but he did not.

    Read More

  • John Wyndam's The Chrysalids

    727 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...s life into what it is at the end of the novel. Some of these help him change for the better, but many of them change him for the worst. So yes, David became more of his own person, escaped the society of Waknuk, and started a new life in Zealand. However, he also was betrayed by his own father, kicked out of his home, and was persecuted by people he knew and cared about simply due to telepathy. All of these factors, in the end, result in David being a more mature and resilient character, but also make him rather resentful towards the society of Waknuk or the world in general. Growing up is always an uphill struggle, but for someone such as David Strorm, the path is even harder. Yet, in the end, he finally made it to the top, despite all of the adversity he faced. This truly is the mark of a person who is willing to give up everything in order to succeed in the end.

    Read More

  • Theme Of Self Awareness In The Chrysalids

    1281 Words  | 3 Pages

    The characters that help David come to terms with who he is and prove that being himself is beneficial to himself are Uncle Axel, the Sealand Lady and Sophie. Uncle Axel helps David achieve self-awareness through genuineness and impartiality. When Uncle Axel was explaining how David and Rosalind may easily be closer to the “true image”, this displays his integrity: “Perhaps the Old People were the image: very well then, one of the things they say about them is that they could talk to one another over long distances. Now, we can’t do that - but you and Rosalind can. Just think about that Davie.

    Read More

  • Julius Caesar versus Brutus

    553 Words  | 2 Pages

    The classical definition of a tragic hero is a person who is neither completely virtuous nor utterly villainous and falls from great status caused by a tragic flaw or error in judgment (bisd303.org). As all heroes do, tragic heroes often fall in line with archetypes. Tragic heroes repeatedly enjoy free choice, endure a punishment that exceeds their crime, undergo a course of enlightenment, and harvest a catharsis or a purging of human emotions in readers (Crowther). Tragic heroes are never perfect and are either killed by the end of the story or have fallen so far from their previous high status that they have nothing left from their old life.

    Read More

  • James Baldwin's Giovanni's Room

    840 Words  | 2 Pages

    his father and dead mother. David's father has an idealized vision of his son as

    Read More

  • Tragic Heroes: A Comparative Analysis Across Literature

    1397 Words  | 3 Pages

    Macbeth, Brutus from Julius Ceasar, John Proctor from The Crucible, Hercules, Sirius Black from Harry Potter, and Spiderman all have a common fate, they are all tragic heroes. A tragic hero is a great or virtuous character in a dramatic tragedy who is destined for downfall, suffering, or defeat. Every hero has a downfall and a purpose; typically it is for the greater good for everyone else. In The Oedipus Plays of Sophocles, there are two characters that could be defined as tragic heroes, they are Antigone and Creon. Bounteous people do not envisage Antigone as a tragic hero, these people believe she was crazy, had no purpose, and did not help the kingdom. Although, countless people do not comprehend that she actually did save the citizens of Thebas, and tried to help Creon.

    Read More

  • The Life of David Brainerd

    1077 Words  | 3 Pages

    David was always a type of person inclined to be melancholy. He was always a religious person. He made sure that he did everything right, because he was afraid of death. He performed all the duties of religion without a true conversion.2

    Read More

  • John Proctor As A Tragic Hero Essay

    748 Words  | 2 Pages

    A tragic heros is someone who faces adversity and has courage and they have similar characteristics throughout different literature. A hero often times experience a downfall, but confronts the situation in a way that causes them to be given the title of a tragic hero. Aristotle once stated about tragic heroes and recited “A man doesn’t become a hero until he can see the root of his own downfall.” Aristotle also came up with six characteristics that all tragic heroes have. Romeo is a prime example of a tragic hero by the quick judgements he makes due to his love for Juliet. He decides to attempt suicide when he sees Juliet faking her death, this shows his character falls in love too fast and too hard. The way he loves Juliet is Romeo’s downfall

    Read More

  • David Lurie's Change In Disgrace By J. M Coetzee

    1237 Words  | 3 Pages

    I also believe this occurring played a huge role in David's change. It is obvious that going through something so traumatizing, such as knowing your daughter's been raped, can greatly effect a person's mental state. We know that Lurie was shaken up by the whole situation and could be psychologically damaged, meaning he could have PTSD (post traumatic stress disorder) or something similar. Since this could be a possibility, could this also play a role in his personal character becoming changed? I believe it can. A quote from chapter 13 is what makes me think this. The quote says, “His pleasure in living has been snuffed out. Like a leaf on a stream, like a puffball on a breeze, he has begun to float toward his end. He sees it quite clearly, and it fills him with despair. (pg. 46)” You can paint a vivid image in your head when you read these words about Lurie's change after the incident. The life that was once inside of him has been drained out. It’s almost like he has fallen into a deep depression. Other than this internal change Lurie has gone through, he seems to have changed in another way as well when it comes to women. After finding out Lucy has been raped, his demeanor towards women changes. He treats them with more respect, at least more than he did in the beginning of the novel. For example, him going back to see Melanie, even after everything they’ve been through, shows a true change of his character. I believe he would not have agreed to that if Lucy never got raped. This shows that he is no longer a coward hiding away and is finally taking responsibility for his actions. There is a quote from chapter 14 that also helps me demonstrate my point. The quote says, “A flurry of anger runs through him, strong enough to take him by surprise. You are whipping yourself into a rage, he admonishes himself: Stop it! Yet at this moment he would like to take Petrus by the throat. (pg.

    Read More

  • King Saul's Development

    1146 Words  | 3 Pages

    In chapters twenty-four and twenty-six David has two opportunities to kill Saul. Each time he spares Saul’s life, but he leaves a mark to let Saul know that he could have killed Saul. The first time David cuts part of Saul’s robe. The second time David takes Saul’s spear and his ______________________. David was playing with Saul’s mind. Saul was powerless in comparison to David. Saul had been determined to kill David, but each time he would fail. David gets two chances to kill Saul, and he spares Saul both times. Saul was no match for David and he knew it. Saul realizes he is unable to get rid of David, because God is with him.

    Read More

More about Disgrace: David Lurie as Hero

Open Document