Counter Offer Case Study

1707 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Negotiation conflict cases

Counter offer is an offer made in response of a past offer by the other party during negotiation for a last contract. The offer can be terminate if the counter offer is made by changing the terms of the original offer. Making a counter offer consequently rejects the earlier offer, and requires an acceptance under the terms of the counter offer or there is no agreement. For an example of the case is Hyde V Wrench, the defendant offer to sell a farm to claimant for 1000 pound on 6 of June 1840. After that on 29 of June 1840, claimant reply to defendant to offer 950 pound which the defendant had rejected the counter-offer from claimant. Claimant brought an action for this specific performance. So in the end, there was no contract as this contract …show more content…

This offer is opened for a week only and it is closed after a week which is on 8 of January. But on January 2nd, Tina sent a letter saying that RM60, 000 is too much for her and she offer RM50, 000 to David. After Tine had made her consideration, she sent her second letter to David saying that RM60, 000 is reasonable and she accept the offer. In the same time, David had sold the car to 3rd party which is Ling Ling. If Tina no makes counter-offer to David, the acceptance is still valid. Therefore, Tina has failed to accept the offer in the first time and she made a counter-offer to David. When the time that Tina made the counter offer which means she had destroyed the original offer and the first offer is no longer to be accepted. Lastly, David has his own right to sell the car to other parties after Tina had made the counter-offer. So in this case, David is allowed for not sell the car to …show more content…

Along these lines, goods which have been displayed in a self-administration shop and shop window are not being offered for sale however are just being displayed for potential customer to pick them up and to make an offer. Henceforth, when the customer gets goods from self-serviced shops and markets, and conveys them to the cashier for installment, he is the one making an offer to the cashier and once the cashier acknowledges the cash, a contract of sale is closed. On the off chance that the cashier decays to offer the goods, the customer does not have a substantial reason for activity to sue the shop for break of contract as the contract had not been finish.
So for the case Fisher v Bell (1960), the defendant displaying a flick knife in his shop window with price tag on it. Under the Restriction of Offensive Weapons Act 1959, section 1(1), it is illegal to sell flick knife as it is a dangerous weapon, dependent had been caught and sent to the court. But at last, magistrate decided dependent was not guilty for offering offensive weapons for sale by having flick knives on display in his window. Displaying of the flick-knife was merely an invitation to treat and is not

Show More
Related

  • Adeels Palace V. Moubarak (2009) 239 CLR 420

    651 Words  | 2 Pages

    Case, Adeels Palace v Moubarak (2009) 239 CLR 420 entails a defendant, Adeels Palace Pty Ltd and two plaintiffs, Anthony Moubarak and Antoin Fayez Bou Najem. On New Year’s Eve 2002, a function, hosted by Adeels was open to members of the public, with a charged admission fee. A dispute broke out in the restaurant. One man left the premises and later returned with a firearm. He seriously injured both respondents. One was shot in the leg and other in the stomach. The plaintiffs separately brought proceedings against the defendant in the District Court of New South Wales (NSW), claiming damages for negligence. The trial judge issued Bou Najem $170,000 and Moubarak $1,026,682.98. It was held that the duty of care was breached by the defendant as they ‘negligently’ failed to employ security for their function. The breach of duty and resulted in the plaintiff’s serious injuries.

    Read More

  • Exchange Vs Alderson

    1167 Words  | 3 Pages

    First, when a creditor (ICE) extends credit to a debtor (Top Quality) and takes a security interest in some property of the debtor, Top Qualities inventory in this case, it is called a secured transaction. The inventory is then considered collateral for the financing that ICE provided for Top Quality, which was made clear in the financing statement that ICE filed. Any secured transactions where personal property is used as collateral is governed by Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code. The UCC was revised in 2001 to better adhere to modern times, and since this case took place from 2007 to 2009, we will be applying the revised edition. There are many sections of Article 9 that should be considered when examining this case. First, the filing of a financing statement, form UCC-1 in Article 9, should be confirmed as filed with the appropriate state office. Once this has been done, confirming the attachment of Top Quality’s inventory to ICE, we can then look to confirm that the initial sale to Chrisman was paid in full to Top Quality, which it was. If this were not the case, ICE would be entitled to the remaining sale proceeds. Now we move on to the requirements of a buyer in the ordinary course of business, per Article 9 of the UCC. According the textbook, “A buyer in the ordinary course of business who purchases goods from a merchant takes the goods free of any perfected or unperfected security interest in the merchant’s inventory, even if the buyer knows of the existence of the security interest” (Cheeseman). The textbook then continues to explain that this rule is necessary because buyers would be reluctant to purchase goods if the merchant creditors could recover the goods if the merchant defaulted on the loans owed to secured creditors. These statements come from the Revised Article 9, section 320(a). This is based on the idea that the buyer purchases in good faith, meaning that they are

    Read More

  • Case Study Of The Real Estate Purchase Contract

    1649 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Mailbox Rule is an area of Utah state law that declares the contract to be effective once the person accepting terms of said contract delivers it to a mailbox. The buyers stated in Addendum No. 2 that if they had not heard back from the seller by 12 a.m. that day, they would consider their counteroffer accepted. The seller was aware of the Mailbox Rule and delivered the accepted contract to a mailbox at 10:15 p.m.. The seller then experienced a phenomenon known as seller’s remorse, and left a voice message for Jon and Marsha at 12:30 a.m., thirty minutes past the proposed

    Read More

  • Takem's Case

    2560 Words  | 6 Pages

    Walker, Takem’s has the statutory law of contracts in his favor. In a contract, the seller and the purchaser have certain rights and obligations. Four basics must be met for a contract to be created (Chrisman, 2014). First, the offer has to be made. In the case at hand, the door-to-door salesperson made an offer of a computer to Ms. Walker. Second, the consideration has to be accepted. Ms. Walker accepted the offer to purchase a computer. The third step is capacity. The purchaser must be legally capable of entering into a contract; minors and the mentally incompetent are excluded in this case. Takem’s has given Ms. Walker the computer in exchange for her payments on her store account. Finally, the intention to enter into a contract has to be present. Ms. Walker signed a bill of sale, a security agreement, and a negotiable promissory note- which is an unconditional promise to pay a certain sum of money at a certain time in the future. Though Takem’s has the advantage to combat her claims, Tommy needs to ensure that his salespeople have not made any false statements or misrepresentations to Ms. Walker as this could have legal implications for the store and against the contract (Vaccaro, 1987). Ms. Walker is legally bound by the contract she agreed to in exchange for the computer; however if there has been any misrepresentations or false statements Ms. Walker may be able, with legal assistance, to call the contract into question

    Read More

  • The Case Of DPP V Carr

    1850 Words  | 4 Pages

    R N Howie and P A Johnson, Annotated Criminal Legislation NSW, 2011-2102, (Lexis Nexis Butterworths 2012) 17769-1774

    Read More

  • The Statute of Frauds and the Uniform Commercial Code

    820 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...useless car to a junk yard to recover some loss, but the difference of the re-sale of the junk-car would be a significant loss. Though there were no adequate assurances to the contract, anticipatory repudiation is the only probable remedy for Jack. However, the outcome would weigh on the predominant factor test, which is met because Tom is covered as a merchant because he is operating in his usual daily business, and Jack is the buyer. The sole purpose of the contract was for Tom to sell Jack a car, and for Jack to buy a car from Tom. The UCC, though less stringent than the statute of frauds, does effectively regulate commercial transfers allowing the free market to operate without diminishing the integrity of trade.

    Read More

  • Australian Consumer Law Objective

    1575 Words  | 4 Pages

    However prior to the modern understanding of Consumer Rights there was a understanding of Caveat Emptor – Buyer Beware –this has been a fundamental premise of consumer wellbeing prior to World War ‖ , relation to transactions, principle that the buyer purchases at his own risk in the absence of an express warranty in the contract . This common law rule assumes that buyers and sellers are in an equal bargaining position. However there has been evident change in consumer rights which have contributed to the precedence of using Caveat Emptor is no longer acceptable, apparent in the case ACCC v Hewlett Packard Australia (HP), illustrated that no longer can a company ...

    Read More

  • Louisiana Needs Gun Control Laws!

    1263 Words  | 3 Pages

    Of the few restrictions that exist, laws such as “RS 14:95” defines the kind of weapons illegal to carry in the general public. Weapons such as the “switchblade knife and spring knife” are among the few considered illegal (“RS 14:95”). Not only is it confusing, but also disturbing because the law seemingly holds no restriction on lethal weapons.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Contract Law

    717 Words  | 2 Pages

    Since the elements were met to satisfy an actual contract being made, with promises albeit moral and legal, the behavior in which Johnny executed warrants a breach of contract on his part. Also to note is Johnny is not a merchant under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), which defines a merchant as “a person who deals in goods of the kind or otherwise by his occupation holds himself out as having knowledge or skill peculiar to the practices or goods involved in the transaction” (American Business Law Journal, 1970). Had Mark been identified as a merchant, he would have been held to a different set of rules and Johnny would have been protected, but Mark is a casual seller and not held to a higher standard of

    Read More

  • Donoghue V. Stevensonson Case Study

    974 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Donoghue V. Stevenson Case 1932 was about the violation of a consumer’s right to safe consumption of a product. Mrs. Donoghue the plaintiff was bought for a drink (Ginger Beer) by a friend in a cafe store. In the process of consuming the drink, a decomposing snail was discovered after it floated from the opaque bottle. The plaintiff had already consumed the drink and was in shock to discover the snail. Mrs. Donoghue was later diagnosed with shock and gastroenteritis. She later sued the manufacturer, Mr. Stevenson, seeking fiscal compensation for the damages (Donoghue v. Stevenson, [1932]).

    Read More

  • International Trade Law Case Study

    3692 Words  | 8 Pages

    The goods must also be paid for by various methods of payment to facilitate international trade. This essay aims to analyse the possible claims from our advising buyer G arising from other parties to the contracts involved in this transaction. The essay will also analyse the legal relationships of all parties created that their respective rights and duties may have in the transaction. In doing so, it will discuss sale of contracts on c.i.f.

    Read More

  • The English contract Offer and Acceptance

    1227 Words  | 3 Pages

    An offer continues in existence, capable of acceptance until it is brought to an end.

    Read More

  • Case Study Of Offer And Acceptance In Modern Contract Law

    894 Words  | 2 Pages

    One of the last remaining strongholds of classical contract law is the notion that contracts require offer and acceptance therefore, in order for a contract to become binding, offer, acceptance, consideration and intention to create legal relations must exist. However contracts are formed in different ways for each different circumstance. (Shawn Bayern, Offer and Acceptance in Modern Contract Law: A Needles Concept, 103 Cal. L. Rev. 67, 102 (2015)

    Read More

  • Carill V Carbolic Smokeball Case Study

    1388 Words  | 3 Pages

    This judgment given set criterion which is still been used in the modern court system and due to this case it was developed that an offer of contract can be unilateral and doesn’t have to be made to a specific party only. Also it was developed to that the acceptance of an offer does not require a notification and that once the concerned party purchases the product the contract is active then and there itself. And it was also established that purchase of an item is a fine example of consideration and therefore makes it a valid contract. (Smith, 2000).

    Read More

  • The Transfer of a Title by a Non-Owner

    2073 Words  | 5 Pages

    'subject to this Act, when goods are sold by a person who is not their

    Read More

More about Counter Offer Case Study

Open Document