Scrooge Vs. The Grinch
It’s already Christmas time, and Christmas is due in less than a week, and everyone is excited. Hallmark started playing all of those Christmas movies that usually include a “hero”, sometimes being a range of things; A fireman, cop, and etc. But not everyone enjoys this time of year, although a lot of people do. There are two popular individual who come to mind, both of which are from famous stories. The main protagonists in Charles Dicken’s A Christmas Carol and Dr. Seuss’s How the Grinch Stole Christmas, Ebenezer Scrooge and The Grinch are those two people. These characters hate Christmas with a passion, and are both horrible people, but there is a catch, which one of this Christmas Meanies are the worst of their bunch? Everyone has taken their sides by now, but The Grinch is one of the meanest of them all.
…show more content…
Throughout the the animation, How the Grinch Stole Christmas by Dr.
Seuss, The Grinch is the main protagonist in this tale, but not much background is given on this green fellow. In the story, The Grinch is accompanied by his dog, Max, throughout most of the movie. Max acts as a sidekick that helps the Grinch, but is somewhat of an underdog. But puns aside, Max wasn’t treated the best by the Grinch in most of the movie. The Grinch made him pull an entire sleigh which held the Grinch and all of the Whos’ Christmas food, gifts, and decorations. While Max is pulling the sleigh, The Grinch is continuously yelling at him to make him move faster despite the extremely heavy weight on his shoulders, and expects him to carry all of it on his lonesome. To add onto that, The Grinch makes Max help, treating Max almost like a slave, which is extremely unethical and should never be done. But The Grinch doesn’t really even treat Max like a worker, Max just does what he’s told, and doesn’t get much out of the things he’s done for the
Grinch. In the play and movie, A Christmas Carol written by Charles Dickens, the main character is Ebenezer Scrooge, an old man that usually stays locked up in his mansion and likes to count his money. He’s a very stingy man, but still had a sidekick. I say had, because his sidekick, Jacob Marley, died 7 years before the time the play took place. Scrooge surprisingly mourned his death, despite how the man seemed like he could care for no one, because he thought of Marley as a genuine friend, and was the only person to attend his funeral. But unlike Max in The Grinch’s story, Jacob did get something out of this partnership, he got money. Jacob also wasn’t a slave persay to Scrooge, they both worked together in unison and both benefitted from the outcome of their work. In the play, it even shows how Marley comes back to try and help Scrooge become a good man, despite not having too, Scrooge treated him well enough to the point where Marley started to care for Scrooge and in the end saved him from a horrible death. Although they were both stingy with their money, Scrooge treated Jacob fairly well compared to how the Grinch treated Max. Scrooge and The Grinch, two formidable contestants in this Christmas Meanie throwdown, but like most competitions, only one meanie can come out on top. In this category of sidekicks, The Grinch wins this throwdown due to the way he treats Max throughout the story compared to how nicely Scrooge treated Marley in his story.
Scrooge was and owner of a factory and made a whole bunch of money, but he did not care about anyone else. “Merry Christmas said his nephew, what right do have to be merry you are poor enough”. This shows that scrooge is mean to family and does not care about Christmas.
In Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol, Scrooge's selfish, cold, melancholy nature is contrasted with Fred, Scrooge's light-hearted nephew. At the beginning of the novel, Fred and Scrooge are complete opposites, but, as the novel progresses, they become more and more alike. Throughout the novel, Dickens uses Fred to show Scrooge's transformation from a cold, unfeeling man to a man of warmth and compassion.
Ebenezer Scrooge is the major character in the story, A Christmas Carol written by Charles Dickens. A Christmas Carol is about how a “cold-hearted, tight fisted, selfish” money grabbing man is offered an opportunity of a life time, to change his behaviour, attitude... to have a second chance in life.
The difference from Fezziwig and Scrooge are very obvious. We can all tell the Scrooge isn’t the kindest in contrast to the oh-so jovial Fezziwig. This paragraph will be on the differences including quotes as evidence.my first piece of evidence is that he wasn’t at all jolly about giving he employees christmas off. The quote “Be here all the earlier next morning” shows his unwillingness and before this he had a small dispute about how useless it was to let him off on christmas. “Yo ho, my boys’ said Fezziwig. ‘No more work to-night. Christmas eve, Dick. Christmas, Ebenezer.” shows nothing but Fezziwig’s willingness to let them both have time to let them be with their friends and family. Also “When the clock struck eleven this domestic ball
How do we know when or how to change ourselves as people? Sometimes, we all need a shove from something or someone to help us better ourselves. The most dominant factors are kindness, fear, and regret. These three things can make us willing to go through the hassle and hard work of breaking out of a habit, whether it be putting your feet on the couch, or your attitude.
After this altercation Cindy Lou that deep down he was a good person for even if he denied it he saved her life. As she begging her journey to find more about the Grinch the audience and Cindy Lou find out the real story of the Grinch and begin to feel sympathy for the character and his miserable past. The Grinch, in sociology terms, had a stigma or blemish, in school he was teased of his furry green body that did not correspond with the others in Whoville. When the Grinch decides to leave Whoville he curses the day and the gift-giving because his classmates called it garbage and judged the way he looked after he shaved. In a future scene, we again feel sympathy for the Grinch in his response to hitting himself or using noise distractions to forget his past and to forget his loneliness. As Cindy Lou speaks out against the norms of the town she wants to invite the Grinch over to the celebration and to accept the award of the cheer minster. When Cindy Lou arrives at the lair and lets the Grinch see the invitation and what he would be awarded as she leaves the Grinch describes his “plans that involve him which is quoted, “Four o'clock, wallow in self-pity; 4:30, stare into the abyss; 5:00, solve world hunger, tell no one. 5:30, jazzercise. 6:30, dinner with me.
The following paper compares a popular short films character, The Grinch, of How The Grinch Stole Christmas, with Abraham Maslow's hierarchy of needs. The reason such a comparison seems apt is that the Grinch seems to have all a “man” could want, but is nonetheless unhappy and miserable. Although his material needs have been met, he lacks a sense of belonging, does not have true self-esteem, and has never come close to Maslow’s descriptions of self-actualization. “How the Grinch Stole Christmas” shows the evolution of the Grinch from a miser and robber to a being of generosity and empathy. Using Maslow’s theory allows us to see the Grinch’s structure and development of personality, the psychopathology, therapeutic techniques, and the limitations
Charles dickens classic novella “A Christmas Carol” endorses the notion that “Generosity involves more than the giving of money, it’s also about the giving of one's goodwill, compassion, sympathy, empathy and kindness. By taking his seemingly irredeemable protagonist Ebenezer Scrooge on a supernatural journey, Dickens’ intends to convey to all of society the importance of generosity. He proclaims that generosity of the spirit defines Christmas, and goes a large way towards defining true humanity for him as well.
However a little girl named Cindy Lou Who is feeling depressed and lacking the holiday spirit. When her brother and his friends return from climbing Mount Crumpit, claiming they saw the Grinch, Cindy Lou grows curious of the Grinch. The Grinch is a mean spirited villain sporting yellow teeth and covered in green hair. His small heart has no room for feeling while his only friend is his dog, Max. The holiday season is especially despised by the Grinch. He has an extreme hate for Christmas and holiday cheer. The Grinch tri...
When you read How The Grinch Stole Christmas, it takes about 10 minutes. Chuck Jones’ challenge was making those same rhyming couplets and drawings come alive for television. Jones worked hard to create the Grinch model based on Dr. Suess’ book.
The Grinch is an individual, who is bitter and lives in a cave on the snowy Mount Crumpits, which is 10,000 feet tall and north of Whoville town. The Grinch age is unknown, however looks to be about in his mid-40s and is unemployed. Thus, results in him spending a lot of time alone in his cave with his dog, Max, as his social companion. At any rate, the Grinch faced many issues when he was younger, causing his current behavior, where he was abandoned as a child, and made fun of because of his look and horrendous appearance at school and as a way to cope he decided to run away. The Grinch behavior shows signs of depression, aggression, and irritation though out a large sum of the movie. In that case, the kid that use to make fun of
First, let’s talk about the psychoanalytic therapy which Corey (2009) says is “a model of personality development and an approach to psychotherapy. He gave psychotherapy a new look and new horizons, calling attention to psychodynamic factors that motivate behavior, focusing on the role of the unconscious, and developing the first therapeutic procedures for understanding and modifying the structure of one’s basic character” (pg. 60). How can I relate this therapy model to the Grinch? Well looking at the Grinch he appears to want nothing more than to ruin Christmas for the whos. Which to me this shows a sign of aggression and I guess of being destructive if you look at it this way. The Grinch didn’t have any insight into the happiness of Christmas for the whos’. He wa...
During stage seven, the Grinch is battling problems of generativity vs. stagnation. Generativity is giving optimism about humanity to the next generation(where all of Whoville is terrified and this is great if he gives it to them). Stagnation refers to the failure to find a way to contribute. The Grinch has always felt uninvolved with their community because he isn’t a Who. Throughout his life, the Grinch was curious with the concept of Christmas. He would watch all of Whoville celebrate. When there was a 99% Christmas sale going on, the Grinch wore a cloak and a mask so people wouldn’t try to distinguish him. He told his dog Max “The city is a dangerous place” as they explored. As an adult, he is feeling worthless and bored living in a cave with his dog. He talks to the walls and listens to their echos. He scares teenagers away when they arrive to the door because social interaction is all new to him. He yells who he hates from the phonebook one by one. Yet, deep down he has a heart. The goal is to value others and ensure future generations. Whoville is scared that a genocide is going to happen. He ensures them peace when he carves the roast-beast. Therefore, he has success by becoming involved with their
Whos, with his negative emotions towards the Christmas holiday. The Grinch is stated in the
From beginning, the Grinch's greed and self-interest causes to plot for the demise of Christmas. As evident in the quotes below, the Grinch is heavily ingrained in his capitalistic goals.