Comparing The Sick Rose, My Pretty Rose Tree, and The Lily

905 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Similarities and dissimilarities between song of innocence and experience

Comparing The Sick Rose, My Pretty Rose Tree, and The Lily

William Blake was born in London on November 28, 1757, to James, a

hosier, and Catherine Blake. Two of his six siblings died in infancy.

From early childhood, Blake spoke of having visions—at four he saw God

"put his head to the window”. Since then Blake’s vision was based on

the idea of cosmology and that’s where he got his framework of images

and ideas. Blake takes traditional images and presents them in a fresh

form unlike other poets (for example, Robert Burns’ “My Love is Like a

Red Red Rose’). As he was a contemporary writer, he has his own

conventional ways.

He published his most popular collection, Songs of Innocence, in 1789

and followed it, in 1794, with Songs of Experience. Some readers

interpret Songs of Innocence in a straightforward fashion, considering

it primarily a children's book, but others have found hints at parody

or critique in its seemingly naive and simple lyrics. ‘Songs of

Innocence and Experience’ are two contrary states of a human soul.

Innocence may be identified with the earthly paradise and experience

with the wilderness. These two states are not jus sacred and profane

but they are interactive. All three poems are from the ‘Songs of

Experience’.

In ‘The Sick Rose’, the speaker is addressing the rose saying that it

is sick. An "invisible" worm has stolen into its bed in a "howling

storm" and under the cover of night. The "dark secret love" of this

worm is destroying the rose's life. The traditional view of the rose

could be a symbol of love and beauty on the surface. While the rose

exists as a beautiful natural object that has become infec...

... middle of paper ...

...g his life and times (emblem of the lily having a closed

side). A feminine explanation for this poem could be that the rose and

lily are expressive symbols while the lily is the suppressed one in

society.

In conclusion, all three poems are related to relationships and love

in some way. For example, ‘The Sick Rose’ is about a worm jealous of

the rose tree and how it corrupts the rose; ‘My Pretty Rose Tree’ is

also to do with relationships (critics have said that this poem is

autobiographical); and the general interpretation of ‘The Lily’ could

be about how love has two sides and love can be both pleasurable as

well as painful. Another similarity is that the poems are relatively

short although they have a deeper meaning to them; two poems in

particular which are short are “My Pretty Rose Tree’ and ‘The Sick

Rose’.

Show More
Related

  • Comparing Sea Rose By H. D And Vague Poem By Elizabeth Bishop

    1322 Words  | 3 Pages

    “I think I dreamed that trip” (2) is a hyperbole because the trip she went on was so good that the narrator doesn’t even think it’s real. Within the first two lines, the reader can interpret that this poem is not an actual event that did not happen. Another hyperbole is “I almost saw it: turning into a rose without any of the intervening roots, stems, buds and so on; just earth to rose and back again” (28-31). The narrator did not see anything turning into a rose without stems and buds, she is exaggerating. “Vague Poem” is a piece of narrative poetry, because it tells a story. There are characters and a plot and a climax. While “Sea Rose” is a free verse poem, because there is no pattern in the stanzas of the poem. I believe the image of the rose is in this poem represents a person that the speaker of the poem was in love with, who did them wrong. I believe the speaker of the poem still loves this person and is puzzled with their feelings for the person that hurt them. “More precious than a wet rose, single on a stem--you are caught in the drift” (4-8) is interpreting the love that the speaker had for the person that hurt them and that they thought there was no one else like

    Read More

  • Roses in Fairy tales: Traditional Belief vs. The Language of the Flowers.

    1742 Words  | 4 Pages

    These definitions of this age old symbol, the rose, evolved over time as cultures came into contact with what has now called the Language of the Flowers. This “language” first appeared in the East and was used as a form of silent communication between illiterate women in harems. During the Victorian era this form of communication began to move towards Western Europe. The first compilation of this language was written in French and then was later translated into English. (Seaton, ).The Victorians used this new method of communication to express love, sorrow and much more through the flowers that they cultivated and bought. This language of flowers or rather the use of flowers to symbolize different messages can certainly influence a story if one has knowledge of this method and chooses to interpret it in this manner.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of One Perfect Rose

    1235 Words  | 3 Pages

    Is love a cliche or simply great, is it something to dread or a once in a lifetime find? “One Perfect Rose” by Dorothy Parker and “How Do I Love Thee? Let Me Count the Ways” by Elizabeth Barrett Browning state different viewpoints on the topic of love. From the rhyming schemes to the meter as well as the meaning behind the poems they are similar as well as different.

    Read More

  • The Mental Traveller by William Blake

    1708 Words  | 4 Pages

    William Blake is a literature genius. Most of his work speaks volume to the readers. Blake’s poem “The Mental Traveller” features a conflict between a male and female that all readers can relate to because of the lessons learned as you read. The poet William Blake isn’t just known for just writing. He was also a well-known painter and a printmaker. Blake is considered a seminal figure in the history of poetry. His poems are from the Romantic age (The end of the 18th Century). He was born in Soho, London, Great Britain. He was the third of seven children. Even though Blake was such an inspiration as a writer he only went to school just enough to read and write. According to Bloom’s critical views on William Blake; one of Blake’s inspirations was the Bible because he believed and belonged to the Moravian Church.

    Read More

  • One Perfect Rose Analysis

    889 Words  | 2 Pages

    Tradition is losing its value; people want to experience new things rather than the same routine. In One Perfect Rose, Dorthy Parker changes the emotional feel the readers get from the beginning, then how it is towards the end of the poem. Emphasizing how she is tired of the traditional rose and hints her admirer in breaking away from the perfect rose. Her love story impacts how she wrote and definitely resembles in the poem. She also uses imagery and repetition to get her message clear on leaving the typical rose behind.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast A Rose For Emily And A Cask Of Amontillado

    387 Words  | 1 Pages

    Samuel Johnson once said, “Actions are visible, though motives are secret.” In the two passages, “A Cask of Amontillado” by Edgar Allen Poe and “A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner, Montresor and Emily did similar things however, their motives are completely different. These two characters have committed a crime towards the antagonist, however one was for love and the other was from hate. The differences in the characters show how looks can be deceiving.

    Read More

  • Analysis of Little Girl Lost by Blake

    987 Words  | 2 Pages

    In first poem, a young seven-year-old girl named Lyca falls asleep in the wilderness under a tree. While her parents worry about her, she sleeps innocently in the woods with a lion prancing around her while she slumbers. The poetic vision seems to be a portrayal of young love--of innocence unprotected in the passion-haunted forest. In the second poem, found in "Experience," the feeling shifts from innocence to suggest a subversive course of love exploration. The young girl, Ona, discovers passion only to find that her father has a negative view on the very love she has just been introduced to.

    Read More

  • What Does Rose Mean To You Essay

    637 Words  | 2 Pages

    I have a cousin that study at a vocational school and got his degree in engineering in less than one-year, and he is now working on fixing computers. Rose is saying that any vocational or non- traditional school is good to study and get a degree. I agree with Rose because to obtain a degree it can happen in any type of school. As has been mentioned “Elias it is not only central to what he wants to do for a living, it has also become part of his attempt to redefine who he is”. “Cynthia is finding her way into institutional life and the public sphere, and in so doing, she is acquiring an on-the-ground civic education.” and “Bobby he’s found solidity at the college, a grounding that frees him in a way that he never knew on the streets.”

    Read More

  • Comparison Of A Rose For Emily And Boys And Girls, By Alice Munro

    1120 Words  | 3 Pages

    The stories selected for comparison are “A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner and “Boys and Girls” by Alice Munro. After reading both stories, one gets a notion that in the past men and women did not have equal rights even in this part of the world which is considered to be one of the most developed countries in terms of practicing human rights. The first story tells us the condition of a lonely woman who from her very young age has been obsessed for a true relationship especially after her father dies. Being an isolated woman in that era was considered to be unusual therefore, her neighbours and all other people observing her day-to-day life thought her to be crazy at times. The second story tells us the feelings of a

    Read More

  • rose is a rose

    1138 Words  | 3 Pages

    Because it is in fact a set of reproductive organs, a flower is known to commonly represent a woman’s vagina, and with this, life and fertility. The size of a blossom can relate to how fertile the flower is. According to Freud, the rose specifically represents the female genitalia. On the other hand, according to C.G. Jung the rose is always a symbol of entirety, or the higher spiritual world order.

    Read More

  • William Blake Research Paper

    249 Words  | 1 Pages

    In “Songs of Innocence”, and “Songs of Experience” Blake sets a dismal and gloomy tone. This is accomplished by using words such as “Dark”, “Black”, and “Coffins”; these words provoke a dark and ominous feeling when reading. Also, both poems have a depressed to exuberant tone shift, for example, from line one; the words “crying” and “weep” set a dark tone. Then in line nine the words “happy” and “heaven” shift the tone to a much lighter one.

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis Of A Rose For Emily

    804 Words  | 2 Pages

    In William Faulkner 's short story "A Rose for Emily", Faulkner brings attention to an elderly woman, Miss Emily in small-town Jefferson. Miss Emily was left with nothing but the house she had always lived in when her father passed away. With the death of her father, Emily 's life changes. The story is divided into five sections and begins with Miss Emily 's funeral, then switches over to talk about the new modern ideas and the requirements for Miss Emily. Miss Emily came from a wealthy family whom the colonel pardoned from paying their taxes. When new government officials came into office, they insisted Miss Emily pay her taxes, and she refused. This was not the only complaint townspeople had about Emily. The townspeople had multiple complaints about Miss

    Read More

  • A Rose For Emily Home Analysis

    410 Words  | 1 Pages

    William Faulkner’s "A Rose for Emily" is an written as an example of a post-Civil War era Southern lifestyle. Faulkner illustration the lifestyle through the element of characteristic. Miss. Emily’s life, house and relationship represent as examples of the North vs. South.

    Read More

  • A Rose For Emily And Girl Analysis

    370 Words  | 1 Pages

    When I read two stories dedicated to "A Rose for Emily" and "Girl," I found that both authors have a different point of views in their stories, but they both are all profoundly reflecting the society. William Faulkner's story focuses on Emily's life and her inner world. Jamaica Kincaid mainly focuses on first-person. In the story, Jamaica uses "I" as a mother to give daughter advice about the importance of life. In the "A Rose for Emily," Emily has influenced with the South which the economy is outdated. William Faulkner used Emily as the lady of the Southern aristocrats, proudly stubbornly embodying the unspeakable belief of the South. Emily fell in love with Homer from the north, but it didn't help Emily to escape the influence of her father.

    Read More

  • A Rose For Emily Symbolism Analysis

    1215 Words  | 3 Pages

    Symbolism can represent an object if it is stated clearly to the to the reader like in the book the rose can be represented as purity as long as the rose is white because white is the cleanest color like Emily from the book she was pure she was un touched also color can be a factor of symbolism because depending on the color of the rose as red can easily be represented as love and black is repressed as death.

    Read More

More about Comparing The Sick Rose, My Pretty Rose Tree, and The Lily

Open Document