Comparing Simon And Piggy In Lord Of The Flies By William Golding

456 Words1 Page

Lord of the Flies, a novel by William Golding, follows a group of boys stranded on an island and dives deep into the nature of humankind and the evil within everyone. Two of the main characters, Simon and Piggy, are brutally killed by Jack’s tribe without hesitation or any second thoughts. Simon and Piggy are two extremely different characters who advance the plot in their own various ways. Simon is a visionary who knows the truth about the beast and symbolizes innocence. Piggy is a symbol of intelligence and is the rational character who is ostracized by everyone except Ralph, whom he grows close to over time. Contrary to the ending of the novel, Ralph should weep for Simon as Simon is the only boy who knows the truth about the beast, the …show more content…

However, he should weep for Simon seeing Simon is the only boy who has a genuine concern for others on the island. For example, Simon gives his share of the pig’s meat to Piggy after Jack’s first kill and is ridiculed and shunned by Jack for his display of selflessness. The boys will never be able to apologize for all the times they jeered at Simon. They never trust or listen to what Simon has to say, and they ignore him when he tells them, “‘Maybe there is a beast….maybe it’s only us.’” Simon embodies the innocence inside all the boys. When they rip him apart, they destroy their own innocence in the process. Before they even mature into adults, they lose the child-like spirit that resides in them. If Simon brings the truth to the boys, Jack will lose his power and the island will be unified once again. The truth will set all the boys free of Jack’s tyranny. Simon’s murder is the final straw that cuts the boys off from civilization, their old lives back in England, and the remainder of their

Show More
Related

  • Lord Of The Flies: Rejecting Savagery

    1346 Words  | 3 Pages

    The boys’ fear of the beast causes them to pay no attention to their morals and act savagely to defeat it. However, Simon is ultimately able to understand the beast and avoid savagery because his embrace of nature allows him to avoid any fears of the island. Simon demonstrates this lack of fear when he climbs the mountain by himself in order to find the beast, despite the dangers that might await him. The hunters and even Piggy and Ralph want to avoid the mountain because that is the last place where the beast was seen, but Simon seems to Once he reaches the top, he finds a physical beast, but not the kind the boys were expecting: a dead parachutist. The parachutist serves as an ironic symbol of Simon’s understanding; the monster the boys were afraid was a human. In contrast, Piggy displays immense fear throughout the novel, especially about Jack. For most of the story, his appreciation of logic and order help him remain civilized, but eventually his fears overcome him and he acts savagely the night of Simon’s murder. As Golding states, “[Piggy and Ralph] found themselves eager to take place in this demented but partly secure society….[the crowd] leapt on the beast, screamed, struck, bit, tore” (136). After this occurrence and the theft of his glasses, Piggy decides to

    Read More

  • The Importance of Piggy in Lord of the Flies by William Golding

    461 Words  | 1 Pages

    the island who wears glasses; this is ironic as he is one of the only

    Read More

  • Who Is Responsible For Jack's Downfall In Lord Of The Flies

    641 Words  | 2 Pages

    As Jack hunts his “frustration seemed bolting and nearly mad” which shines in his slowly deranging eyes (Golding 67). In Lord Of The Flies by William Golding, stranded boys struggle to find order and civilization on an island with no other humans. After their plane crash lands, a few boys, such as Ralph and Piggy, are quick to set up standard rules. But, not everyone agrees that rules and rescue are what is most important. Jack, a boy who cares more about hunting, disrupts the goodness and order that remains in the boys. When a simulated hunting influenced and led by Jack goes awry, the boys kill Simon. The now deceased Simon is the purest and kindest of the boys. Jack leads the elimination of the only good left on their island. Whether it is his intention to kill him or not, Jack should be held responsible for Simon’s demise because he leads the group to kill him, regardless of his age.

    Read More

  • How Is Piggy Brave In Lord Of The Flies

    726 Words  | 2 Pages

    Lord of the Flies, a book written by William Golding, published by Faber and Faber and winner of the Nobel Prize for Literature is a story that talks about a group of school age boys who have landed on an unknown / uninhabited island during the second world war. Throughout their stay on the island they find ways to survive, such as finding and hunting for food as well as building basic needs like shelters and a fire. At a certain moment in the book two of the main characters, Ralph and Jack declare a war between each other because Jack refuses to have Ralph as the group’s leader for another second. This then leads to the division of the group as well as many scenes in which one sabotages the other. An example of this is when Jack’s tribe steals

    Read More

  • Civilization and Social Order in Lord of the Flies by William Golding

    596 Words  | 2 Pages

    The novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding is about a group of boys that were on a plane crash in the 1940’s in a nuclear War. The plane is shot down and lands on a tropical island. Some boys try to function as a whole group but see obstacles as time goes on. The novel is about civilization and social order. There are three older boys, Ralph, Jack, and Piggy, that have an effect on the group of younger boys. The Main character Ralph, changes throughout the novel because of his role of leadership and responsibility, which shapes him into a more strict but caring character as the group becomes more uncivilized and savage

    Read More

  • Jack Lord Of The Flies Power Analysis

    1284 Words  | 3 Pages

    The impact of Jack’s savagery on the island leads to the boys forgetting the real truth about about themselves. The boys on the island are able to explain that human are evil from the beginning and that they aren’t impacted by society. The boys see the island as a place where they are free from the adult world and without any rules. The boys don’t realize that a world without rules causes the chaos on the island and the savagery within the boys. Jack’s authoritative power forces him to push the rest of the boys out of their comfort zone by making them evil being that was not there true identity before. Upon realizing that the savagery they had obtained was only destroying themselves they “wept for the end of innocence, the darkness of man's heart”(202). The power that was developed by Jack impacts everyone and destroys all of the lives that rejected him. Piggy who was the most knowledgeable character and also the weakest character was often disrespected by Jack because he opposed Jack’s power and recognizes that his power not voted for. As as result, Piggy is killed by Jack’s own boys because they too have been impacted by brute force. They killed piggy just like how they hunted pigs. Next, Simon's death reflects the rejections of religion and the idea that the

    Read More

  • The Deaths of Simon and Piggy in The Lord of the Flies by Golding

    852 Words  | 2 Pages

    all used clubs and sticks to kill Simon and no one can do that without

    Read More

  • The Presentation of the Deaths of Simon and Piggy in William Golding's Lord of the Flies

    704 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Presentation of the Deaths of Simon and Piggy in William Golding's Lord of the Flies

    Read More

  • Lord Of The Flies

    1578 Words  | 4 Pages

    The lord of the flies is a book about a group of boys stranded on a tropical island to illustrate the evil characters of mankind. Lord of the Flies dealt with changes that the boys go through as they gradually got use to the stranded freedom from the outside world. Three main characters pictured different effects on the other boys. Jack Merridew began as the bossy and arrogant leader of a choir. The freedom of the island allowed him to further develop the darker side of his personality as the Chief of a savage tribe. Ralph started as a self-assured boy whose confidence in him came from the approval of the others. He was kind as he was willing to listen to Piggy. He became increasingly dependent on Piggy's wisdom and became lost in the confusion around him. Towards the end of the story when he was kicked out of the savage boys he was forced to live without Piggy and live by himself. Piggy was an educated boy that was more mature than the others, that was used to being picked on. His experiences on the island were a reality check of how extreme people can be with their words.

    Read More

  • Lord Of The Flies Literary Analysis Essay

    1004 Words  | 3 Pages

    Lord of the Flies is a novel written by William Golding in 1954 about a group of young British boys who have been stranded alone together on an island with no adults. During the novel the diverse group of boys struggle to create structure within a society that they constructed by themselves. Golding uses many unique literary devices including characterization, imagery, symbolism and many more. The three main characters, Ralph, Piggy, and Jack are each representative of the three main literary devices, ethos, logos, and pathos. Beyond the characterization the novel stands out because of Golding’s dramatic use of objective symbolism, throughout the novel he uses symbols like the conch, fire, and Piggy’s glasses to represent how power has evolved and to show how civilized or uncivilized the boys are acting. It is almost inarguable that the entire novel is one big allegory in itself, the way that Golding portrays the development of savagery among the boys is a clear representation of how society was changing during the time the novel was published. Golding is writing during

    Read More

  • Simon And Simon In William Golding's Lord Of The Flies

    738 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Golding’s book Lord of the Flies Simon is a very significant character, who strangely isn’t made very familiar with the reader until the end of chapter three. At this point in the book the group of school boys who have crash-landed on this uninhabited island, have found a course of action. Unfortunately, not all the boys are working hard to accomplish what needs to get done. Jack is set on catching a pig, Ralph on getting rescued, and the rest of the boys are enjoying their time without adult supervision. While Ralph and Jack are busy arguing over what needs to get done Simon sneaks away for some peace and quiet. At this point in the novel Golding then follows Simon’s walk alone into the forest. Through this Golding effectively establishes

    Read More

  • Fear In Lord Of The Flies Persuasive Essay

    836 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Lord of the Flies, by William Golding, is a great book to read. During the book, these young school boys are trying to escape Europe from a new war, and end up crashing on a remote island. Over time, the boys start becoming the savages they don’t want to be, and start fighting their selves to what is realty and actuality of the “Beast”. When Jack becomes the hunter, he paints his face and starts hunting pigs, showing that he is losing control with himself. Then he promises that he can kill the “Beast”, but it’s too late for the boys to find it, except Simon who finds out who is the “Beast”, but it has already consumed them all. Death and evil starts destroying friendship, to the point where Jack kills Simon, so he doesn’t believe that the “Beast” is in us. In the end, they live long enough to become the monster. The boys end up seeing that the weak powerless Piggy was the one who could save them all. In the novel, William Golding, advises that the reason individuals incline into violence is the impact of others on their natural instincts.

    Read More

  • Jalousy In Lord Of The Flies

    488 Words  | 1 Pages

    People act differently in society, but act how they normally would when there are no longer any rules or supervision. In Lord of the Flies by William Golding, the story revolves around a group of children who are “without warning” find themselves alone in an isolated island without any adult with them after their plane delinquency. Ralph was the first arrival to the nearby forest area, and met with another boy wearing glasses named Piggy. Ralph is a strong and confident boy waving in his eyes and starting activity while Piggy is a shy, not good looking boy that sounds very intelligent. Ralph and Piggy use the conch to call the other boys on the island. When everyone arrives, the boys choose Ralph as their chief and this cause the

    Read More

  • Peer Pressure In Lord Of The Flies Essay

    697 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Piggy and Ralph, under the threat of the sky, found themselves eager to take a place in this demented but partly secure society,” showing how belonging and society, even if it is unbalanced, is important to both of the boys when faced with disaster (Golding 152). In William Golding’s Lord of the Flies, a group of British boys survive a plane crash, landing on a deserted island. There are no adults, and one of the boys, Ralph, is chosen to lead the boys and create order within the group, hopefully finding a way for them to return home. However, savagery takes over most of the boys and horrible events occur. The way of the island becomes dangerous, such as the rituals that the boys perform. The dance that they have come to enjoy causes one of the boys, Simon, to be killed. While Ralph takes apart of this dance, he is innocent due to the fact that he is influenced by

    Read More

  • Lord Of The Flies Book Report

    842 Words  | 2 Pages

    Jack and Ralph have a huge falling out and Jack decides to form his own tribe. ”I’m going off by myself.” (Golding 127). After Jack goes off by himself, his tribe hunts down a pig and removes its head. The head was then mounted on a stick as an offering to the beast in exchange for peace. Although Simon isn’t part of Jack’s tribe, he wanders off into the woods and stares at the pig head. Simon, being the outcast that he is, hallucinates and hears the pig talk. The pig is known as “The Lord of the Flies”. “We are going to have fun on this island!” “Or else” “We shall do you?” (Golding 144). Simon is clearly threatened by his own imagination. When Simon wakes up after passing out, he walks away from the head for a while. He later tramples upon the dead parachuter. He then realizes that there is no real beast. While dragging the parachuter back to the Campsite to prove the lack of a beast on the island, he interrupts a chant initiated by Jack’s tribe and is killed. It is a moment in which the boys are truly indulged by their dance and are vulnerable to violence. “Simon’s dead body moved out toward open sea." (Golding 154). After this event

    Read More

More about Comparing Simon And Piggy In Lord Of The Flies By William Golding

Open Document