Comparing King Lear And A Thousand Acres By Jane Smiley

1491 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Tragedy in king lear essay

King Lear by William Shakespeare, and A Thousand Acres by Jane Smiley are both fantastic tragedies that follow a similar story arc. Although King Lear was written in 1606, and A Thousand Acres was written in 1999, they contain the same essential elements of a tragedy. Jane Smiley modeled her novel after King Lear, focusing less on Lear’s story, and more on the daughters’ stories. The story-line of both is extremely similar: a father chooses to divide his land amongst his daughters, and everything following that is a disaster. King Lear and A Thousand Acres utilize the elements of unexpected suffering, suffering that extends beyond the protagonist, and society/status to mold their stories into classic tragedies.
A Thousand Acres and King Lear share the …show more content…

A massive storm is a significant event in both stories that marks the beginning of the tragic end. Events that precede the storm are comparatively cheery to the events that follow shortly after. The storm in both stories leads to the fleeing of the father, both driven away by their daughter’s actions. During the storm in A Thousand Acres, Ginny loses her helpful and submissive personality in order to stand up to her father, ¨You don 't deserve even the care we give you. As far as I 'm concerned, from now on you 're on your own” (Smiley 183). This change in her attitude is a stark contrast to the previous Ginny, who took care of three families without complaints. The storm in King Lear is the last time the reader experiences Lear with part of his mind still in-tact. The scenes after the storm depict Lear frolicking around with a crown made of weeds on his head. The transformation of his language and attitude from the beginning of the play, “Hear me, recreant; on thine allegiance, hear me...the moment is thy death. Away” (Shakespeare

Show More
Related

  • Exile In King Lear

    443 Words  | 1 Pages

    Once his daughter’s exiled him from the kingdom, Lear and the Fool find themselves outside in a fierce storm. The turning point for Lear is when he is outside in the storm. It is through his anger over his last confrontation with his "family" and the power of the storm that begin the process of change within Lear.

    Read More

  • Jane Eyre vs House of Mirth Lily

    2029 Words  | 5 Pages

    her is inferior to Rochester and others of high class. She is forced into this social

    Read More

  • King Lear and Death of a Salesman

    2158 Words  | 5 Pages

    Social pressures change as time passes, therefore it is interesting to see how these three texts whom differ by almost four hundred years perceive society and the effect this has on the protagonists; Shakespeare’s King Lear which was first performed in 1606 during the Jacobean era, presents a patriarchal society. Whilst, Arthur Miller uses the characters in ‘Death of a salesman’ to show the failure of the ‘American dream’ during the “golden era” of America in the late 40’s. The ‘American Dream’ was a set of ideals which suggested that anyone in the US could be successful through hard work, and had the potential to live a happy life. The sense of the deterioration in the equality of opportunities links to the fall in power and hierarchy in King Lear. Arudanthi Roy, however, uses her contemporary Indian novel to illustrate, using a proleptic and coalesce structure, the lives of the protagonists living in a post – colonial society. In each of these three texts there are characters who fit the stereotypes that society has instilled in them, but then there are those characters who noticeably differ from the norm; According to 19th century novelist Alfred de Musset “how glorious it is – and how painful – to be an exception.” Hence this statement can be seen as applicable to these characters, because in all three texts these characters do end up losing a lot.

    Read More

  • Comparing and contrasting Jane Eyre to Lord of the Flies

    1520 Words  | 4 Pages

    Jane doesn't even want to go near the red room and is quite happy to

    Read More

  • Catcher In The Rye, Macbeth And Death Of A Salesman Comparison Essay

    1858 Words  | 4 Pages

    In literature, characters often confront challenges and due to their misconceptions of reality these challenges become complicated by external factors, which ultimately lead to tragic results. Willy, from the play Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, Holden, from the novel The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger, and Macbeth, from the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, live with false perceptions of life and struggle through life's challenges. Willy struggles with the challenges of his life by lying, causing him to suffer because of how he defines success. Holden is upset with the world and tries to become a savior to future generations. While Macbeth's ambitions dominates his life resulting in an inflated ego transforming him from an honorable soldier into a crazed tyrant. When faced with challenges, these characters fight to be who they imagine they are, yet due to conflicts they ultimately fail.

    Read More

  • Comparing Great Expectations And Jane Eyre

    1686 Words  | 4 Pages

    Abraham Maslow, a well-known American psychologist, theorized that human beings have innate needs that must be met in order to have a happy, healthy existence. The most necessary is, of course, the fulfillment of basic physiological requirements, followed by a feeling of safety. If these are fulfilled, every mentally healthy individual begins craving love and a need to belong. Love and being loved in return is, in fact, vital to an individual’s mental state. This, in addition to the feeling of euphoria, pleasure and joy it provides, and the sensual experience of romantic love, makes it a great obsession in nearly every culture. This craving humans to have their unrequited love returned makes great fodder for movies, songs, and novels. Many

    Read More

  • Comparing Jane Eyre And Catching Fire

    736 Words  | 2 Pages

    In my opinion Jane Eyre connects to a couple of other books and movies such as Harry Potter and The Hunger Games. This book reminds me of Harry Potter because at the beginning of Jane Eyre her parents died as did Harry Potter's, they are both orphans and are both treated very poorly. At times they were both put into isolation, Jane into the red room and Harry under the staircase, in his “room”. They both had the main issue of dealing with their family, and both tried to forget about what was going on around them by reading books. Jane Eyre connects to The hunger games, Catching Fire, main character Katniss Everdeen especially, both main characters were torn between two men, they are very independent women, they question the society that surrounds them, they are abused, and they struggle to find food. Jane Eyre and Wuthering Heights have many connections, mainly because the authors were sister, so they grew up in the same household, they were raised the same way,

    Read More

  • Literary Elements of The Storm by Kate Chopin

    885 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...way that the story is being interpreted and how the storm influences the story as a whole. Sometimes people need a wakeup call or a 'storm' to make them aware of how good they have things. In this short story Alcee and Calixta both come to realization of how good they have things with their spouses and how that they already found the ones that they love, which weren't each other. This made me aware of how we as people can take things for granted or believing we know what’s best for us. In reality we don't always know what’s best until something occurs and shows us that what we already have is the best.

    Read More

  • Comparing A Thousand Acres and King Lear

    538 Words  | 2 Pages

    When Jane Smiley wrote A Thousand Acres, she consciously made the story parallel to Shakespeare's King Lear for several reasons. The novel's characters and basic storyline are almost direct parallels to King Lear, but Smiley's dissatisfaction with the traditional interpretation of King Lear is showcased in her modern day version (Berne 236).

    Read More

  • Comparing Catcher In The Rye And Lord Of The Flies

    102 Words  | 1 Pages

    “Make them laugh, make them cry, make them wait.” These are three demands for the writing of fiction. By following these demands, an author sparks interest in his/her work. “Make them wait” is a signifigant in creating the interest in the novels The Catcher in the Rye and Lord of the Flies. This essay will explain how making the reader wait creates interest in the two novels stated earlier.

    Read More

  • Representations of Nature in King Lear

    856 Words  | 2 Pages

    It is important to distinguish the concept of nature present in King Lear from the imagery it invokes in modern culture of picturesque forests teeming with every sort of adorable squirrel and chipmunk imaginable. As Sarah Doncaster puts it in her essay “Representations of Nature in Shakespeare’s King Lear,” nature in Shakespeare’s hands, “is a social construct, which is utilized in order to legitimise the existing social order.” The notion that a...

    Read More

  • Catcher In The Rye And Othello Comparison

    124 Words  | 1 Pages

    Othello, Catcher in the Rye, and How to Read Like a College Professor, were titles I read this past school year. While How to Read Like a College Professor was interesting; Othello and Catcher in the Rye were the most enjoyable to me because of their plots, characters, and themes. Layered with tribulations and epiphanies for each character, the plots of each book wove intricate stories which significantly added depth to the characters and to the themes of each book. Moreover, the characters of each story were relatable to me, as I could see some of my own faults within the characters.Furthermore, I also appreciated the themes of each story as they re-taught lessons which are both relevant and applicable to my own life.

    Read More

  • Analysis of Jane Eyre

    558 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 1847, Charlotte Bronte, although a woman, published her semi autobiographical Jane Eyre. She wrote her novels in Thornton, Yorkshire, England. This novel later became a classic literature novel. ( Bronte) She wrote in the 1800’s and her novel reflects the time period, which she wrote in with the various techniques and themes. In the novel Jane Eyre, Charlotte Bronte uses literary devices such as, imagery and themes like religion and feminism to demonstrate the time period in which she wrote.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Imagery In King Lear

    729 Words  | 2 Pages

    This is the turning point in the play, and accurately describes the madness not only in Lear, but the rest of the kingdom as well. The chaos brought about by the storm is a symbol for the disorder that accompanies Lear's removal from power and descent into insanity. The storm is a

    Read More

  • Analyzing King Lear's Tragic Flaws

    862 Words  | 2 Pages

    King Lear is a play about a tragic hero, by the name of King Lear, whose flaws get the best of him. A tragic hero must possess three qualities. The first is they must have power, in other words, a leader. King Lear has the highest rank of any leader. He is a king. The next quality is they must have a tragic flaw, and King Lear has several of those. Finally, they must experience a downfall. Lear's realization of his mistakes is more than a downfall. It is a tragedy. Lear is a tragic hero because he has those three qualities. His flaws are his arrogance, his ignorance, and his misjudgments, each contributing to the other.

    Read More

More about Comparing King Lear And A Thousand Acres By Jane Smiley

Open Document