Comparing Freud's Explanation of Dreams and Davidson's Theory of Action

2660 Words6 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Freud the interpretation of dreams

Comparing Freud's Explanation of Dreams and Davidson's Theory of Action In The Interpretation of Dreams (henceforth ID) Freud claims that "the dream is a wish-fulfilment" (der Traum ist eine Wunscherfüllung) - an assertion which constitutes not only the title of one of the central chapters of the book, but also one of its main theses. But what exactly does defining the dream as the fulfilment of a wish imply? What relation do dreams bear to desires? And how can a wish be fulfilled in (or through) a dream? In this essay, I would like to examine Freud's claim in his own terms, as well as in the light of the philosophy of action, particularly that of Donald Davidson. On a related note, I will also make an excursion into Tamas Pataki's ideas regarding intentional character of mental phenomena. To begin with, the fulfilment (Erfüllung) brought about by dreams must be sharply distinguished from the satisfaction (Erfriedigung) achieved through action in waking life. According to Freud, dreams arise as a response of the sleeping mind to a desire which it is unwilling or unable to satisfy, precisely because of its sleeping state. This response consists in the purely mental enactment of the situation desired, in such a way that the reality beyond the dream remains unaffected. It is in this aspect that the fulfilment and the satisfaction of desires differ for Freud: for although they are both triggered by the subject's wish or desire, satisfaction entails the actual modification of the state of things in reality, whereas the fulfilment brought about by dreams only takes place in the sleeper's mind. But this is a strange notion indeed - why w... ... middle of paper ... ... "Actions, Reasons, and Causes", in D. Davidson (2001) Essays on Actions and Events, Oxford: OUP. Freud, Sigmund (1913) The Interpretation of Dreams, translated by A.A. Brill. New York: Macmillan. Hopkins, James (1982) "Introduction" to R. Wollheim and J. Hopkins (eds.) Philosophical Essays on Freud, Cambridge: CUP. Lennon, Kathleen (1994) "Reasons and Causes", in S. Guttenplan (ed.) A Companion to the Philosophy of Mind. Oxford: Blackwell. Pataki, Tamas (2000) "Freudian wish-fulfilment and sub-intentional explanation", in Michael P. Levine (ed.) The Analytic Freud, London: Routledge. --------------------------------------------------------------------- [1] And indeed at the root of representational judgement itself, as Freud claims in his short text on denial (Die Verneinung).

Show More
Related

  • Essay Comparing Psychodynamic Approach To Development

    1208 Words  | 3 Pages

    Freud’s theory was developed from speculation based on

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud Theory Psychosobt

    1129 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sigmund Freud is known as the founding father of psychology. If it wasn’t for Freud and his work psychology probably wouldn’t be around today (Javel, 1999). Although Freud had many followers there were some who didn’t agree with his work and found his work to be very controversial. There were also many who criticized his work, one of his most controversial and criticized work was his psychosexual stages of development and his believes about the famous “Oedipus Complex.” Psychoanalysis is the first known modality used to treat individuals with psychological disorders. Freud’s work was a foundation for many whether they believed in his work or not. From his work other psychologist

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud And Dream Analysis Theory

    774 Words  | 2 Pages

    From Sigmund Freud 's point of view all his theories were proven in this book. His first theory of Defense Mechanism was present when Jack’s mom used denial when she believed Jack was just a rebirth of her daughter who died during birth, so she didn’t feel the need to face the feelings of the daughter 's death. His second theory of Psychosexual Stages was present when Jack had a strong oral fixation of needing to “get some”, or else known as breast feeding from his mom, and phallic stage because Jack mentioned repeatedly throughout the book about his penis. Freud’s third theory was the Dream Analysis theory, because Jack later on in the book, experienced dreams that could be assumed to represent meaning to Jack’s real life and the struggles

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud's Theory Of Psychoanalysis

    741 Words  | 2 Pages

    Sigmund Freud believed that he “occupies a special place in the history of psychoanalysis and marks a turning point, it was with it that analysis took the step from being a psychotherapeutic procedure to being in depth-psychology” (Jones). Psychoanalysis is a theory or therapy to decode the puzzle of neurotic disorders like hysteria. During the therapy sessions, the patients would talk about their dreams. Freud would analyze not only the manifest content (what the dreamer remembers) of the dreams, but the disguise that caused the repressions of the idea. During our dreams, the decision making part of personality’s defenses are lowered allowing some of the repressed material to become more aware in a distorted form. He distinguished between

    Read More

  • Freud and Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

    2600 Words  | 6 Pages

    Freud, Sigmund. New Introductory Lectures on Psycho-Analysis. Ed. James Strachey. Trans. James Strachey. Standard. Vol. 22. London: Hogarth Press, 1964.

    Read More

  • The Destruction of Identity in Vertigo, The Tenant, & Mulholland Drive

    2856 Words  | 6 Pages

    Freud’s Master Plot. New York: Harvard University Press, 1984. pp 90- 112.

    Read More

  • Psychological and Christian Theories

    586 Words  | 2 Pages

    that Freud concluded reflects in some of his work and even in his theory: Psychoanalytic

    Read More

  • Freud's Theory of Dreaming and Repression

    1030 Words  | 3 Pages

    The relationship between dreaming and repression is complex and requires thorough understanding of Freud’s theory thus it is better to get to know some of the terms and concepts Freud raises in study of dreams. As all the information is gathered, it is believed that the wish as fulfilled is shown only in a state of repression during sleep.

    Read More

  • How Have Psychodynamic Therapies Changed Since Freud?

    1295 Words  | 3 Pages

    Freud, S., Strachey, J., Freud, A., Rothgeb, C., & Richards, A. (1953). The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud (1st ed.). London: Hogarth Press.

    Read More

  • Unraveling the Intricacies of Dreams

    1163 Words  | 3 Pages

    Dreams are series of thoughts, images, and sensations occurring in a person’s mind during sleep. Dreams occur during a certain stage of sleep known as REM. Several different psychologists, including Freud and Hobson, have studied dreams. Psychologists have provided many theories as to what dreams are and the meanings behind them.

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud's Psychoanalytic Theory of Dreams

    1185 Words  | 3 Pages

    During the transition from the nineteenth to the twentieth century, a psychologist named Sigmund Freud welcomed the new age with his socially unacceptable yet undoubtedly intriguing ideologies; one of many was his Psychoanalytic Theory of Dreams. Freud believed that dreams are the gateway into a person’s unconscious mind and repressed desires. He was also determined to prove his theory and the structure, mechanism, and symbolism behind it through a study of his patients’ as well as his own dreams. He contended that all dreams had meaning and were the representation of a person’s repressed wish. While the weaknesses of his theory allowed many people to deem it as merely wishful thinking, he was a brilliant man, and his theory on dreams also had many strengths. Freud’s theories of the unconscious mind enabled him to go down in history as the prominent creator of Psychoanalysis.

    Read More

  • Advantages And Disadvantages Of Psychodynamic Theory

    1444 Words  | 3 Pages

    The driving force behind this theory is that all experiences are internalized and influence the ongoing actions of every individual. The relationship between unconscious and conscious drives is vital to understand, because this is what motivates behavior according to Freud. This theory is a social construction, just as all theories are, of Freud’s own experiences. It is important to understand this, and to take the good with the

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud: The Comparison Of The Id, Ego And Superego

    935 Words  | 2 Pages

    The methods he used to obtain his information and data raised questions by other scientists. His research on children was lacking, as was his use of empirical studies, his research was male-dominated and also lacked universality. The theory of the id, ego and superego develops from birth into childhood therefore the use of case studies on adults and the lack of empirical study does not seem feasible enough to have developed this theory. First of all there is no guarantee that the memories of these adults on their childhood would be accurate, there was not any factual, re-testable data so it lacked reliability and validity secondly each case and person’s experience is different and therefore cannot be use to determine the development of an entire population. Freud’s theory was further biased due to him overlooking social and environmental aspects, which prevent universality; he was a European man who researched other upper middle class Europeans whose everyday living and circumstances differed greatly from others in

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud and Psychoanalysis

    2351 Words  | 5 Pages

    The aim of this essay is to clarify the basic principles of Freud’s theories and to raise the main issues.

    Read More

  • Existentialism Essay

    1090 Words  | 3 Pages

    … Freud's own existence as a person pointed beyond the deterministic presuppositions of his theory … Freud's own largeness and depth of humanity as a man surpassed his scientific theories.1

    Read More

More about Comparing Freud's Explanation of Dreams and Davidson's Theory of Action

Open Document