Christianity's Influence in Indigenous and Western Perspectives

Chrisianity is present in both writers perspectives, even if it is not intentionally done. Mandelbaum represents a western way of thinking that is largly influenced by Christianity. In his writing, Mandelbaum often compares Indigenous ways of thinking to western perspectives adhering to overpowering dominance it has established within North American society which has had many impacts. Colonialism has also influenced Indigenous perspectives in the form of residential schools, the 60’s scoop, and various pieces of leglislature that were fashioned in attempts to assimilate Indigenous peoples. Unfortunatly, this has created a lasting impact, and Christianity is ever present in both communities.

Accuracy

Dion, and Mandelbaum accuratly portray Cree culture even though they have distinct perspectives that are vastly unique. Both works accuratly depict Cree culture with a historical perspective which will remain accurate as it (1) history can not be rewritten, and (2) ceremonies and teachings generally do not change but can adapt over time. Although they are accurate on these accounts, they fail to address current issues which brings

In failing to address a female perspective only half of the story is being told. There are many customs that only a woman will know, and understand the full extent of. This is my main critique of Dion’s work in that if the other side was acknowledged, it would have not only strengthened the paper, but given the reader an enhanced understanding of what it truly means to be a Cree woman. I will give Dion credit for not attempting to take on that perspective himself as it is not appropriate to do so for obvious reasons. Mandelbaum on the other hand highlights the role women played in the community accurately depicting both the unfavourable, and postive aspects of