Comparing Chopin's Piano Music with Schumann's

628 Words2 Pages

When comparing the piano works of Frederick Chopin and Robert Schumann, it is important to take into account the number of works each wrote in comparison to their other outputs as a composer. Chopin wrote almost exclusively for piano but this was far from the case with Schumann. The important piano works of Chopin include sonatas, preludes, etudes, polonaises, mazurkas, waltzes, nocturnes, scherzi, and ballades. Thematic development and structure are considered to be Chopin's weak points in his compositions and this is thought to be especially true in longer pieces such as the three piano sonatas. One critic strongly criticised these pieces as they did not stick strictly to sonata form. Others however, feel that as they are Romantic sonatas, and therefore the structure is not as important as it was in Classical music, that they "should not be straightjacketed by the rigours of sonata form." The 24 Préludes (Op 2) are often compared to the Préludes of J.S Bach's Well Tempered Clavier and although both sets are similar in many ways, Chopin's are not meant as introductory pieces as Bach's, which are designed to lead into fugues, as they stand strongly on their own as poetic miniature piano pieces. Chopin wrote two collections of twelve Études (Op 10, Op 25) and they are very different to the piano studies of composers from Clementi to Kalkbrenner, which had gone before. The nature of Chopin's Études is the same as that of other composers in that individual pieces are devised to deal with a specific technical difficulty, but Chopin transformed them into pieces of music which had real feeling and depth. The Polonaise is a stately national dance originating from Poland and written in triple time. Chopin's Polonaises, though retaining the characteristics of the dance, became a way for the composer to convey his passionate feelings of his homeland. Also composed was a Polonaise-Fantasie which begins as a Polonaise but then continues into almost an extended improvisation. Waltzes were very popular in Chopin's time as they had grown in the late eighteenth century and, in the same way the composer had reacted to Polonaises, Chopin wrote his waltzes in a personal way, conveying the moods and feelings of a ballroom in which they would be danced. The third dance form that Chopin wrote music for was the Mazurka, which again was a Polish dance in triple time, but this time with a dotted rhythm. It was danced in a speed somewhere between that of the Polonaise and the Waltz, though Chopin never intended his Mazurkas to be danced to, they were again to project a view of Poland though a different one to the Polonaise.

Open Document