Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Holocaust informational essay
Trail of Tears American Indians
Holocaust facts for essays
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
The Assassination of the Innocent The Holocaust vs. The Trail of Tears
6.5 million Jews and 4,000 Cherokee Indians all together thats 6,504,000 just so the inconsiderate leaders could have their land and blame them for everything. In 1933 the Jews world turned upside down by Adolf Hitler when the Holocaust started he hated the Jews because of their race and religion. He blamed them for the Great Depression following WWII. On the other hand The Trail of Tears started when Andrew Jackson signed the Indian Removal Act. Although there are some similarities between the Holocaust and The Trail of Tears, there are also many differences.
Although they happened 4,982 miles away and almost 95 years apart, the Holocaust and the Trail of Tears
…show more content…
were both the result of power-hungry dictators seeking to control a weaker population. The Holocaust started on January 30th 1933 in Europe. The reasons for the Holocaust consisted of Hitler blaming the Jews for the Great Depression following WWII and Hitler also hating the Jews because their religion and race. The Holocaust was in Europe mostly Germany, Poland, and Austria. However, The Trail of Tears happened in the United States in the states of Georgia, Alabama, Arkansas, Illinois, Missouri, North Carolina, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Tennessee (American Indian Removal and Resettlement 2). The Trail of Tears started because of the Indian Removal Act. The Indian Removal Act was signed into law by President Andrew Jackson on May 28, 1830, authorizing the president to grant unsettled lands west of the Mississippi in exchange for Indian lands within existing state borders (Indian Removal: The Trail of Tears 1). The white settlers took over the Indians land when they were brutally taken out of their homes and made to walk over 2,000 miles in severe winter weather. Both the Jewish and the Indians suffered horrific fates at the hands of brutal, sadistic killers. The victims in the Holocaust consisted of not only Jews but also the mentally handicapped and the dissenters. The perpetrators in the Holocaust were Adolf Hitler, The Nazis, and SS/Gestapo. Adolf Hitler On the other hand the victims in the Trail of Tears were the Indians which consisted of the Cherokee, Choctaw, Seminole and many more (Andrew Jackson's Indian Policy 2) But, the perpetrators in the Trail of Tears was Andrew Jackson, Military and Militia, and the White Settlers. At gunpoint nearly 15,000 Cherokees were forced to go to concentration camps to await final orders to trek for nearly 1,00 miles (Rolo 1) The Jews and the Indians both had to face the devastation of not only losing their rights and homes,but losing their life as well, although the modes and methods for these losses was strikingly different.
For the Jews they lost a lot. They lost all rights because of the Nuremberg laws, the Nuremberg laws were two laws which excluded the Jews from German life, as well as took away some of their natural rights. They were first declared at the annual Nazi rally held in Nuremberg in 1935. They also lost their homes and most of them lost their life. They couldn’t marry, they lost businesses, they couldn’t move away. Homes were looted and taken, they forced to march or to board trains/convos to get to concentration camps they were killed mobile gas vans, gas chambers, and was murdered by SS. Strangely enough the Indians they lost almost same thing. They went to concentration camps before they walked to the Indian territory, They lost their homes and Andrew Jackson took away every right and lied to the Indians saying if they moved to the Indian Territory and walked over two thousand miles that he would give them five million dollars in return but he lied and never gave it to them (Indian Removal: The Trail of Tears 1). In all the Jews and the Indians lost so much just because their religion and
race. All though there are some similarities between the two genocides there are also a lot of differences. Some similarities include they were both sent to concentration camps to await their death. Both the Indians and the The Jews had their rights taken and all their possessions were taken away. But the Trail of Tears happened 106 years before The Holocaust and they happened on other sides of the world. In numbers there is no comparison between these genocides but they both had a very big impact on this world and the people in it.
The Jews were taken from their homes and lost many of their possessions too. In both instances, these people lost many things but the worst part was they were stripped of their rights, although they were stripped of different rights the Jews lost the freedom of speech and religion. While the Japanese lost the right of freedom, to choose where to live. The Japanese not only had a rough life in the camps, but also had a long, rough road ahead of them to come out in the real world. “The truth was, at this point Papa did not know which way to turn.In the government’s eyes a free man now,he sat, like those black slaves you hear about who,when they got their freedom at the end of the Civil War, just did not know where else to go or what else to do and ended up back on the plantation, rooted their out of habit or lethargy or fear”(Houston
There are many similarities between the German Holocaust and the genocide of the Native Americans but there is many differences. In 1838 Andrew Jackson proposed the indian removal act to remove the Native Americans and put them into reservations. In 1933 Adolf Hitler called for all jews to be put in “ghettos” or slums. The jews were then put into concentration camps and many died before even getting there. During the “Trail Of Tears” over four thousand Cherokee Indians died while going to the reservations. During the German Holocaust over six million Jewish people were killed at the concentration camps. According to the www.USHMM.org “ The Germans and their collaborators killed nearly two out of every three European Jews as part of the
In the Holocaust, the jews lost their rights (Nuremberg Laws), Loss of home (ghettos/concentration camps), and Loss of life…. Jewish people Couldn’t marry, lost businesses, couldn’t move away, Homes looted and taken, forced to march or to board trains/convos to get, concentration camps, Mobile gas vans, gas chambers, and they were murdered by SS. All of the people who helped exterminate the jews caused and helped this. Not just them, they didn't have but a few people helping them and saying what's right and what's wrong in this case. They would say that they didn't know that all of these horrific things were occurring. Unlike the holocaust, the indians had people fighting for what's right. The indians did have to walk miles on foot, but they did have supporters. People trying to end the madness. The indians lost their land, lost their rights, and lost privileges. Andrew Jackson offered the indians five million dollars upon a successful relocation. The indians agreed, but when they were related, he didn't give them anything.... He lied to the
From the removal of Native Americans in Georgia to the persecution of Jews in Nazi Germany, the crime of greed affected millions. Condemned men, women and children suffered cruelty, starvation and being raped and beaten in a brutal way. Although dissimilar by geography and time, the pain and torment experienced by the Native Americans in a route that became known as, "The Trail of Tears", unite them with their Jewish brothers. Prejudice, race, politics, and powers are strong similarities and differences between the Holocaust and the Trail of Tears.
Millions upon millions of people were killed in the holocaust, that is just one of many genocides. There are many similarities between different genocides. Throughout history, many aggressors have started and attempted genocides and violence on the basis of someone being the "other".
The purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast the American Slavery and the Holocaust, in terms of which one was more malevolent than the other. Research indicates that “the “competition” between African-American and Jews has served to trivialize the malevolence which both has suffered” (Newton, 1999). According to L. Thomas “A separate issue that contributes to the tension between blacks and Jews refer to to the role that Jews played in the American Slave trade.”
When people hear genocide they normally think of the Holocaust which was the persecution of Jews by the Nazi’s. This took place under Adolf Hitler’s rule but there have been other genocides throughout history. The Armenian Genocide is one of the many that have taken place. It took place in the Ottoman Empire between the years of 1914 to 1918 (“Armenian” Armenian). It started when the “Young Turks” took control of the government (Beecroft). The Holocaust and Armenian genocide are similar in the reasons that started them, but they are different in who was involved and how the two genocides were executed.
The Holocaust and the Bosnian genocide had many similarities and differences in their course of events. Unfortunately, genocides like the Jewish Holocaust and the Bosnian genocide still continue to happen today. Jews were constantly persecuted before the Holocaust because they were deemed racially inferior. During the 1930’s, the Nazis sent thousands of Jews to concentration camps. Hitler wanted to wipe out all the European Jews in a plan called The “Final Solution to the Jewish Problem” (World History).
Of course these two horrible tragedies aren't entirely the same but in some similarities they do compare such as, how horrendous the SS guards treated the Jewish men and woman. They murdered innocent families and the ones who surrendered would be held captive in what they called Concentration Camps. Many Jewish families tried hiding and escaping during this time and some in the end were able to get to a safe area like Yang and her family. In the movie Schindlers List, it explains how many Jewish families hid their personal belongings such as necklaces, bracelets, rings by swallowing them or hiding them in food so the guards could not find them. Before the Holocaust began, some areas in Europe removed Jewish children from the school, until 1938 when they were all banned from attending German schools. Discrimination and isolation within education for children began to take place. After reading some information about the holocaust, I came across a website about why the holocaust ever started. It states that "the holocaust started because of ingrained antisemitism both in Germany and the countries it conquered, compounded by propaganda and the resources of a
The word “genocide” is a general term. It is vague and could be used to group together and refer to a number of very unique events in history. Defined as the systematic murder of a specific group of people, genocides have occurred since ancient times. America’s most famous genocide, and the longest genocide in history, was the Native American Genocide. Considered to have begun the day the Mayflower hit the shore of Massachusetts, and ended in 1924 when the Indian Citizenship Act was past, the Native American Genocide lasted for over four centuries. In the 15th century, over 10 million Native Americans lived on the land that is part of the modern day United States. By 1900, that number was a mere 300,000. Most Americans, however, hardly know
Native Americans lost everything once white settlers set foot on America. Their entire lives changed right in front of their eyes, all because people were taking things that didn’t belong to them. The white settlers took everything from them, almost all of them died, or had to relocate; today Native Americans are still going through the same stereotypes and racism, and are seen as very dangerous.
“Quantie’s weak body shuddered from a blast of cold wind. Still, the proud wife of the Cherokee chief John Ross wrapped a woolen blanket around her shoulders and grabbed the reins.” Leading the final group of Cherokee Indians from their home lands, Chief John Ross thought of an old story that was told by the chiefs before him, of a place where the earth and sky met in the west, this was the place where death awaits. He could not help but fear that this place of death was where his beloved people were being taken after years of persecution and injustice at the hands of white Americans, the proud Indian people were being forced to vacate their lands, leaving behind their homes, businesses and almost everything they owned while traveling to an unknown place and an uncertain future. The Cherokee Indians suffered terrible indignities, sickness and death while being removed to the Indian territories west of the Mississippi, even though they maintained their culture and traditions, rebuilt their numbers and improved their living conditions by developing their own government, economy and social structure, they were never able to return to their previous greatness or escape the injustices of the American people.
At the beginning of the 1830s there was nearly 125,000 native Americans that lived on “millions of acres of the land of Georgia, Tennessee, Alabama, North Carolina and Florida”.(history.com) These lands had been occupied and cultivated by their ancestors for generations before. Then because of The Trail of Tears was an “800-mile forced journey marked by the cruelty of soldiers”. (Tindall P.434) and by the end of the forced relocations very few Native Americans remained anywhere in the southwest. “working on behave of the white settlers federal government forced them to leave their lands and walk miles to an “Indian territory””.(history.com) .This all happened because of the Indian Removal act of 1930, which authorized the relocation of the eastern Indians to the west of the Mississippi river. The Cherokee Indians tried to fight the relocation and even with the Supreme Court’s support Andrew Jackson still forced them to leave their land. By the 1840s there wasn't many Cherokee Indians that still remained in the southwest.
The Trail of Tears was one of the deadliest and most gruesome act of violence ever carried out in the 19th century. It would result in the death of 4000 Indians in a forced relocation of 15000 Cherokee. This march was directly carried out by the United States Government and the Jackson administration. It was characterized at the time as a humanitarian alternative to letting the Native Americans die at the hands of land hungry white settlers. However, this event was inherently evil as it was purely based on greed, racism, and the unspoken purpose of prolonging southern society; it was also unconstitutional in multiple aspects.
The Trail of Tears was a hard battled journey for the Cherokee Nation. The Cherokee were driven to move west. They had to compromise and sign treaties, which drove them out of their land by the U.S. government. This was unfair to the Cherokees; the white settlers wanted the land for gold. Trail of tears is historically monumental because it shows the U.S. government cruelty to the Native Americans. It was unfair rights because they basically stole Cherokees land to satisfy their hunger for gold.