Combining Western Medicine and Traditional Medicine in South Africa

2022 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Why traditional medicine is better

The clash between the western (or scientific) and traditional approaches to medicine has existed for many years. The conceptual differences between the two schools of thought resulted in mistrust between scholars of representing them. Each one of the approaches can be effective in some medical cases and neither can offers complete solutions in others. However, the western approach has been proven to be much more effective in treating serious deadly conditions that require complex diagnosis, surgeries, and drugs. South Africa, where the HIV/AIDS epidemic takes countless lives daily, could greatly benefit from an availability of medical achievements provided by the western doctors. At the same time, due to political, cultural, and economic reasons, the traditional healing is still the dominating method in this country. Being trusted by the local population and an integral part of the local culture, traditional healers can play a key role in building a trust between the local population and western doctors. Western, or scientific medicine, primarily uses drugs and surgeries for treating patients. Its treatments are based on diagnoses provided by trained doctors and nurses. In general, the approach is to address symptoms of various illnesses and conditions. Western medicine is heavily relying on science and scientific researches particularly in chemistry and biology. The traditional medicine is mostly practiced in Asia, South America, and Africa. As oppose to the western medicine, it relies on the powers of natural resources, spirituality, and physical contact. Typically, traditional healers don’t go to formal medical schools; they are trained by other healers within their communities. They use herbs, animals, minerals, an... ... middle of paper ... ... Culture, And Controversy. M.E. Sharpe, Inc. Print. Bolognesi, Natasha. AIDS in Africa: A Question of Trust. Nature 443.7112 (12 Oct 2006): 626-627. Print. Himmel, Martin. "Sangomas." Witness. Al Jazeera. Doha, Quatar. 14 June 2009. Web. 21 Nov 2013. Liverpool, Joan, at el. “Western medicine and traditional healers: partners in the fight against HIV/AIDS.” Journal of the National Medical Association 96.6 (June 2004): 823. Print. 21 Nov 2013. McVeigh, Karen. “Steve Jobs Regretted Delaying Cancer Surgery, Biographer Tells CBS”. The Guardian. 21 Oct 2011. Web. Nov 24 2013. Steinberg, Jonny. Sizwe's Test. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2008. Print. Swaine, Jon. “Steve Jobs 'Regretted Trying to Beat Cancer with Alternative Medicine for so Long'” . The Telegraph. 21 Oct 2011. Web. Nov 24 2013. “The World Factbook”. CIA. Central Intelligence Agency, 2014. Web. 24 Nov 2013.

Show More
Related

  • Voodoo Health Practices

    1032 Words  | 3 Pages

    “Voodoo medicine” is a common healing practice in the country of Haiti, and is performed by a voodoo practitioner. Some people go to other folk healers. These include people such as a “docte fey” (leaf doctor), a fam saj” (lay midwife), a “docte zo” (bonesetter), or a “pikitrist” (injectionist). (Purnell and Paulanka, 2003)

    Read More

  • Paul Monette's Borrowed Time: An AIDS Memoir

    703 Words  | 2 Pages

    It is almost impossible for Monette and his friends to determine when the bad times began. Gradually, rumors of a terrible disease became a reality. In 1982, an undefined “gay cancer” became...

    Read More

  • AIDS and the CIA

    854 Words  | 2 Pages

    Statistics have been show a frightening increase in AIDS/HIV cases. As of the year 2012, South Africa has had the most cases of HIV/AIDS coming to a total of 6,070,800 ("Country Comparison :: HIV/AIDS”). This is a huge contributing factor to this conspira...

    Read More

  • Native American Medicine and Spiritual Healing

    1088 Words  | 3 Pages

    In fact, Native American medicine men belief is firmly grounded in age-old traditions, legends and teachings. Healing and medical powers have existed since the very beginning of time according to Native American stories. Consequently they have handed down the tribe's antediluvian legends, which i...

    Read More

  • Ancient Greek Medicine

    1683 Words  | 4 Pages

    The direct relationship between one and the ability to restore one's body to its original state of health may never be fully comprehended. The fields of medicine and health are two most paramount features affecting the daily lives of all beings. Throughout recorded history, various cultures concoct their own methods of alternative medicine for treatment and therapy which is then relied on by todays nations. Medicine in its earliest times begins with the ancient civilizations' assimilation with the world around and their beliefs on how things function. Ancient Greek medicine may have began with spiritual beliefs but Greek practitioners had steered the medical profession in the right direction for modern times.

    Read More

  • Methods and Myths of Traditional African Medicines and its Place in Modern Society

    1236 Words  | 3 Pages

    Traditional African medicines, and the spiritual healers that administer these medicines are an important part of African society. For many centuries and even millenniums these healers with there spiritual and naturalistic remedies have been responsible for taking care of the African world as we know it. Traditional African medicines have been a greater help to all of society and modern science, but still lie at the root of much controversy over its ability to be a valid healing tool. Some doctor’s and scientist believe that a possible placebo effect may be the root of what makes these remedies and rituals work; but there is also evidence that suggest that many of the ingredients found in our medicines today are also found in the natural animal and plant products used by the healers. In fact many pharmaceutical companies have recently been looking at the content of these natural substances in hope of finding chemical compounds that can help modern science in producing modern medicines to cure disease. Despite modern day societies use of the healers remedies in modern medicine, there still seems to be some confusion as to who the healer really is and what their motives are. Many people using naïve thought process perceive the healer as one practicing witchcraft. This may be due to the disbelief that natural substances are capable of healing, or the belief that ritualistic and spiritualistic ceremonies and practices stem from evil or voodoo. Despite all of this opposition and change into a more scientific world, the healer remains as one of the most sought after people in the African world, and even in large African cities were western heal...

    Read More

  • Zulu Traditions of Health and Healing

    1334 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Merriam-Webster English Dictionary defines medicine as “the science that deals with preventing, curing, and treating diseases”. Throughout the cultures of the world, the study of medicine and its pragmatic application play an absolutely imperative role in how given societies operate. Amongst the Zulu of Southern Africa, ideas surrounding the notions of both health and healing find themselves deeply embedded into the over-arching culture. Traditional practices, which include those of medicinal nature, perform important functions in the maintenance of many indigenous African societies, including the Zulu (Washington 2010, 25). In fact, it is estimated that upwards of 80% of the black African population associate with traditional healers (Kelmanson et al 2000, 241). The Zulu hold traditional healing and medicine in high regard. Within the contexts of established Zulu healing, medicine takes two distinct forms: (1) medicine that concerns itself with physical conditions, dealing with physiological conundrums, and (2) medicine that is implemented magically and ritualistically to produce a result (Sithole and Beierle 2002). Through the analysis of the nature of illness in Zulu society, the examination of Zulu medical practitioners, and the investigation of the methods used for medicinal practice, one can obtain a better understanding of traditional Zulu medicine as a holistic entity.

    Read More

  • Healing Techniques: Ethnomedicine

    1462 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to Erickson (2008) ethnomedicine entails the study of the healing techniques and medical systems of a particular cultural group, comparisons of said systems between cultures, and the increasing prevalence of multiple-system approaches. She goes on to describe the role of medical anthropologists as studying the interaction that occurs between culture and health, and the use this information to understand and improve health related issues. Moreover, she defines culture as the set of beliefs, perceptions of the world and values that are shared within a society, which are utilized in experience interpretation and behaviour generation. The medical systems and practices utilized vary based on the culture in question, and their belief systems (Pelto and Pelto, 1997). A common trend seen in ethnomedicine is the use of multiple medical systems within a culture, known as pluralism (Erickson, 2008). This stems from the integration of other established medical systems or practices into the dominant medical system of a region. This topic will be examined in reference to the practice of tuina in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), and the integration and alteration of this practice into the Western world, alongside the biomedical model.

    Read More

  • Cultural Anthropology And Health

    1284 Words  | 3 Pages

    Though it is “discrete” and “natural identity”, it can be very difficult to treat and possibly cure. Many cultures have different ways to cure diseases. The term “ethnomedicine” stood out to me while reading. Ethnomedicine is defined as the involvement with comparative study of local systems of health and healing rooted in culturally specific norms and values. In addition, it involves the the was locally rooted cultures create unique strategies for identifying and possibly even curing diseases that were spread amongst the society. In addition to ethnomedicine, another important term that stood out to me while reading was “ethnopharmacology”. Ethnopharmacology is essentially a documentation of what locals use to heal their sick and ill. These healing remedies are comprised of natural substances, such as herbs, powders, teas, and animal products. What I find most interesting about this particular way of healing a treating the sick and ill is, most Western biomedicine used is considered to be a form of ethnomedicine. In fact, Guest states, “Today medical anthropologists use the concept of ethnomedicine to refer to local health systems everywhere. (p.400)” Continuing on the subject, there was a very important example that stood out to me through ethnomedicine and

    Read More

  • Faith Healers: A Force in Nigeria

    938 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Faith Healers are out in force in Nigeria. There is a problem with medicine. Medicine is so far removed from the understanding of most people who it appears to be medicine.

    Read More

  • Different Types Of Qi And Qi

    733 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...h concerns within the human body. Additionally, Western medicine encourages the patient to rely primarily on the doctor and tending to overlook the healing of the self.

    Read More

  • Annotated Bibliography On Hiv Aids In South Africa

    1089 Words  | 3 Pages

    This book covers a wide range of subtopics on the issue of HIV and AIDS prevalence in South Africa. The authors provide information in a neatly organized way that allows readers to easily find the information they are looking for. The book is divided into 7 sections with multiple chapters in each section. The sections are as follows: Birth of a rapidly growing epidemic, The virus, the human host and their interactions, HIV risk factors and prevention strategies, Focal groups for understanding the HIV epidemic, the impact of AIDS, Treating HIV, and What does the future hold? Sections 1, 3, 5, 6, and 7 will provide good background information on my topic for my paper.

    Read More

  • Difference Between Conventional And Alternative Medicine

    1027 Words  | 3 Pages

    Conventional medicine often visualizes the disease by itself and concentrates focuses more on a quicker fix than on different approaches. Alternative medicine can make a distinction with the body and its environment as a holistic system; a disease materializes in case of an imbalance between’s all of the body’s functions. Conventional medicine is hardly as efficient for treating critical situations, but less suitable for managing chronic diseases. Alternative medicine hinder fast results, but they are usually more stable and longer lasting, as it oftentimes is an individual’s life style. Alternative medicine relies mostly on natural elements and ancient techniques from other nations, whereas conventional medicine prefers chemical and scientifically approved methods of diagnoses and treatments by the Food and Drug Administration.

    Read More

  • Advantages And Disadvantages Of Traditional Medicine

    1309 Words  | 3 Pages

    This section argue from traditional African worldview that the use of traditional medicines are good for our health because when one is ill/sick the traditional doctor/healer is consulted whereby the person will be given certain herbs to be healed without any use of technology, traditional medicine are

    Read More

  • Traditional Medicine Vs. Traditional And Modern Medicine

    599 Words  | 2 Pages

    Living in a healthy condition is very essential for everyone’s life. There are many diseases that can affect people’s health. Most of diseases are serious, and they can potentially kill us if we do not treat them as soon as possible. Medicine is very important to prevent diseases before infecting people or treat them after they get sick. In the last fifteen years, medicine has been incredibly improving from what it was previously, but it still shares several traits with traditional methods. Traditional and modern medicine are methods of treatment that have similarities and differences between them.

    Read More

More about Combining Western Medicine and Traditional Medicine in South Africa

Open Document