Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Limitation of indigenous education
Native American tribes DBQ
Comparing western education models with native american education
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Limitation of indigenous education
Summary
In the American Indians and the Boarding School Experience, by David Wallace Adams, he argues that the boarding schools were designed to civilize Indian children. The boarding school main goals were to adapt Indian children into the lifestyles of the white man. The boarding schools cut all the boys hair and left them bald changed their native names and the children had to adjust to the whites food. Whites believed Indians were uncivilized and savage individuals. The boarding schools were built to teach children to be well-mannered humans as whites, forget about their old customs and beliefs, learn Christianity and follow the whites lifestyles. The whites taught Indian children the bible and have them forget about their religious beliefs
…show more content…
and prayers where they were not permitted to pray inside the boarding schools. The boarding schools wanted to get rid of the Indian man and establish a new white man inside the Indian children and create a saved man where the Indian spirit would be gone. In the Antimiscegenation Laws and the Enforcement of Racial Boundaries by Rachel F. Moran, she argues that antimiscegenation laws were designed to regulate for different races to conceive or marry. The main goal of the antimiscegenation laws it to restrict sex and marriage freedom where blacks, Japanese and Chinese were not able to get involved and had to keep their love life or sex preferences aside. Moran overviews the history of prohibiting sex and marriage between blacks and whites and maintaining a color line in the United States. Racial hierarchy was reinforced in not letting whites get involved with other races because they believed whites were superior to others. There were many Mulattos who were light skinned and looked as a white individual, but did not receive white privileges because they came from black and white individuals. Chinese and Japanese were also not able to gain citizenship or get involved with white individuals. There were more males than females and many men were not able to marry or have kids because Chinese women were not able to come to the United States and they were not able to marry or conceive with white women. The prohibition of people of color getting married or having sex with white individuals was to secure hierarchy of whites and not have races get involved and create children and change the antimiscegenation laws that were created in the United States. Discussion In recent years, the United States created laws that led to people of color being less superior to whites. The U.S. was a hierarchy state that made people of color inferior to whites and many were prohibited of privileges whites had. Hierarchy led to many people of color being forced to lose their cultures and beliefs to adapt to the American culture. Hierarchy did not let people of color express their true love for others or let their cultures grow. The Unites States was a hierarchy state where Americans wanted to control every aspect of people’s lives. The United States did not want other cultures or religions to adapt to society and loose Christianity. Americans wanted people to practice Christianity and not change the laws or cultures that existed. Indians, black slaves, Chinese and Japanese had different skin color, different cultures and beliefs than Americans and Americans created and developed negative boarding schools or laws to not permit the development of other cultures or people of color marrying whites. For example, there were many blacks, Japanese and Chinese men in the United States where men outnumbered women four to one. Men of color were not permitted to marry white women and their family lines would be gone and their cultures would not continue to exist. Similar to the Indians, the culture of blacks, Japanese or Chinese would be gone as well because they were not able to marry white women and they would not have children and also Indian children would grow up in an American culture where their children would not know the Indian culture and the culture of people of color would slowly fade away. In the United States antimiscegenation laws were created to separate races from getting married or from having sex. Blacks would be punished if they would get romantically involved with white women or want to marry. If black men were suspected of having sexual acts with white women they would severely punished by being lynched (Moran, 132.) The United States did not want black men to interfere with white women at all that it led to them being threatened with their lives. For example, in a song named Strange Fruit, by Billie Holliday, it represents blacks being considered strange fruit that would hang from the trees. Whites would violently hang black men who would have intimate relationships with white women and the men who were lynched would not be removed from the trees to warn other black men that they would also get lynched if they got romantically involved with white women. Similarly, Indian children would also get punished if they did not do what the Americans ordered them inside the boarding schools. For example, Wallace says that Indian children were forced to abandon their traditional foods and eat American food and many times the children would not be served a proper portion of food and many would be left hungry to a point where the children felt half-starved (Wallace, 49). The Indian children were not treated good inside the boarding schools because the schools were designed as prisons and the children were the prisoners where they were forced to adapt to the American culture. Many of the Indian children lost their native names, foods, languages and hair and blacks, Japanese or Chinese lost their chances of marrying women they could fall in love with because of their background and cultures. Blacks, Indians, Japanese and Chinese would be threatened or punished if they did not follow the laws or keep their cultures from growing and rising. Americans wanted others to follow the rules they created and wanted to get rid of other cultures and adapt people into Christianity and the American culture.
Americans wanted to save the man from other different cultures and races. For example, Americans wanted Indian children to adapt to the American cultures and practice their religions. As Indian children began to change into speaking English and practicing Christianity, Americans did not treat them like other American children. Indian children were forced to forget their cultures and were obligated to use different clothing similar to American children, but the clothing was uniform that all the children used alike. The boarding schools were designed to save the man from the Indian culture, but there was no equality and the schools were very similar to military training camps. Indian children would have to eat at a certain time, dress a specific ways and would have a schedule for every activity performed inside the boarding school. The boarding schools goals were to make Indian children into civilized people, but many of the children had terrible experiences inside the schools. For example, in the film we saw in class of Our Spirits don’t speak English, many Indian adults who were inside the boarding schools when they were children said they experienced sexual and mental abuse and were taught industrial training where children would not have professional jobs in their futures, but domestic jobs. Also, Americans did not permit blacks to marry white women because they wanted America to be a better society and not have races mix. For example, there were many Mulatto children who had very light skin, but did not receive whites privileges. Mulatto and Indians were very similar where they adapted to the American culture and dressed as Americans, but were still treated differently by Americans because of the Racism that existed in society. Americans forced Indian children to join boarding schools to make them civilized
and black men or Japanese or Chinese were not able to get involved with white women because it would be uncivilized and Americans wanted to keep a civilized and white supremacy society in the united States. The antimiscegenation laws and the boarding schools were very similar because both of them did not let blacks; Chinese and Japanese or Indians express who they truly were inside. Americans did not let Indian children truly express their belifes and religions or keep their hair because they were not considered civilized and wanted to get rid of the Indian man and create proper Indian children who were not savage in society. Americans wanted to keep the U.S. under control and not let other people of color take their jobs, replace their religion or have different clothing and that is why people were forced to forget about their cultures. Indian children were considered savage because of the way they lives in their reservations, but that was their lifestyles and Americans wanted to keep order in society and have the norm of having one culture and maintaining it like that. Americans prohibited many things from people of color that did not develop other cultures or races of getting married because of racism that existed in the United States. Racism led to boarding schools and antimiscegenation laws that did not let others reveal their true selves or have other cultures and beliefs from growing in society. Response I really enjoyed reading these two articles because I feel I can relate to them in some extent. In the American Indians and the Boarding School Experience, it was a very sad and tragic experience that many Indian children had to go through. It was very inhuman of Americans to force Indian children to forget where they came from and change their appearances. It was very terrible that Indian children were not able to wear what they wished and their cultures were beginning to be gone. Indian children would be taught the American culture and their culture and belief would begin to fade and their Indian cultures would be gone forever. My culture, beliefs and where I came from are very important to me and I would be extremely sad and feel empty if I was forced to forget my culture. It is very important to know where we came from and not forget our roots because our culture will always represent who we are and who we will teach our future kids or other family members who we are. In the Antimiscegenation Laws and the Enforcement of Racial Boundaries, it was also a very tragic rule where different races where not able to marry or conceive children. My cousin is Mexican and she is married to a white male, where they have three children and live a very happy life. It would be terrible to see that my cousin and her husband would not be able to be together because of racial boundaries. We are in a new era where different races are able to marry and conceive and that makes me very happy because we have freedom and the ability to be happy.
By introducing how Christopher Columbus coining the term “Indian” influenced the initial perception of Native Americans. Although he paints them as intellectual, generous, and happy people, there is also account of them being cannibalistic, thieves, and intimidating. As a result of this depiction and many more, American Indians are never seen as good enough in comparison to Whites due to not being Christian and civilized. Along with this view, they were seen as “wilder” and “savage” Indians, which is to this assumption that Native Americans do not have guidance (13). Also considered heathens, this idea that converting them to Christianity came about through Alexander Whitaker’s pamphlet. Furthermore, separation of American Indians according to tribes was unheard of and resulted in grouping all the tribes into the same customs and beliefs. In effect, they were described as the opposite of Whites by lacking features necessary to being successful as a Caucasian
In 1887 the federal government launched boarding schools designed to remove young Indians from their homes and families in reservations and Richard Pratt –the leader of Carlisle Indian School –declared, “citizenize” them. Richard Pratt’s “Kill the Indian… and save the man” was a speech to a group of reformers in 1892 describing the vices of reservations and the virtues of schooling that would bring young Native Americans into the mainstream of American society.
People know about the conflict between the Indian's cultures and the settler's cultures during the westward expansion. Many people know the fierce battles and melees between the Indians and the settlers that were born from this cultural conflict. In spite of this, many people may not know about the systematic and deliberate means employed by the U.S. government to permanently rid their new land of the Indians who had lived their own lives peacefully for many years. There are many strong and chilling reasons and causes as to why the settlers started all of this perplexity in the first place. There was also a very strong and threatening impact on the Native Americans through the schooling that stained the past and futures of Native Americans not only with blood but also with emotion. It was all a slow and painful plan of the "white man" to hopefully get rid of the Indian culture, forever. The Native American schools were created in an attempt to destroy the Native American way of life, their culture, beliefs and tradi...
You simply cannot justify ripping a child from a loving home and stripping them of their culture and placing them in prison like dormitories where you attempt to “civilize” them. Deculturaliztion will never be a right or just act. Decades later the Native Americans are still picking up the pieces from the wrecking ball that was the Indian Boarding School experience.
The government’s goal was to Americanize them into society. America is based on immigrants from all over the world. Each of them brought their own customs, culture and values and integrated them in society. Native Americans however, were known as savages because the government saw them as uncivilized and uncontrollable. Although the United States claims, it is a free country and states in the first amendment that you may believe in any religion you want without persecution but it did not give that right to the Natives. Instead, the government was trying to convert the Native Americans religion to catholic or christen completely forgetting many people came to America to escape religious persecution. The government were trying to assimilate the Natives by taking away their religion and
This school was significant because it changed the way they lived for the rest of their lives. The boarding school’s mission was to help Native Americans adjust to American culture by influencing upon their children white lifestyles, or what was close to it. However, this did not seem to help Native Americans. Many of the children weren’t welcomed back home because some of them could no longer remember the life they used to lead and were therefore thought of as a shame to all Native Americans and their heritage. Many came back not knowing how to speak their native tongue, or even not knowing their tribes’ rituals. In some ways, the Americans did accomplish what they set out to do, they did change many Native Americans, but there were cases in which they didn’t. Some students disobeyed the rules and continued to speak their native tongue and practice rituals in secret in school. This was resistance inside the school, and resistance also happened outside of the school. However, if children were caught disobeying the rules they were punished. Some parents were angry that they weren’t allowed to see their kids when they wanted, so few would resist allowing their children to go back after breaks. Others would run away with their children and families, though this was a tough choice to
...to the foundation of American Society. We continue to support and maintain these social norms through deliberated and non deliberated ways, forced servitude and the advancement of racial legislation fostered racism in the United States. The most intellectuals of their time, contemplated to the degree of what the New Worlds people were considered to be human. Some Europeans had hope for Natives and possible guidance, but it became evident, that profit and status were more viable entities than any sort of human decency or equality. As minorities began to unify and protest discrimination, legislation was built off of Anglo-Saxon domination and ideologies, only to continue to delay the growth of colored people. Laws like the Chinese Exclusion Act, Separate but Equal, and Jim Crow Laws are just a few examples of such legislation inflicted upon colored groups in America.
In the 1870s, the U.S. government enacted a policy of assimilation of Native Americans, to Americanize them. Their goal was to turn them into white men. Schools were an important part of facilitating their goal. In 1879, Richard Henry Pratt founded the Carlisle Indian School. It was the first school in which Native American children were culturally exposed to American ideology. The idea for the boarding school first came through treatment of Cheyenne warriors. In the 1860s, Americans were in the midst of a major western migration. Settlers were moving into the western region, pushing natives off lands, and in some cases, killing livestock. Warriors then took revenge on settlers and soldiers. General Sherman called for “the extermination of the natives.” Groups of warriors were captured, arrested, and charged without a trial.
Residential schools were first established in the 1880's to solve Canada's “Indian Problem”. Settlers in Canada thought of the First Nations people as savages, and the goal of the residential schools was to civilize them and integrate them in to white Canadian society. The first operators of residential schools thought of their forced integration as a benefit to native peoples. One of the overseers of residential schools wrote to the Sisters in charge of St. Joseph's Mission at Williams Lake that “It now remains for ...
At these boarding schools, Native American children were able to leave their Indian reservations to attend schools that were often run by wealthy white males. These individuals often did not create these schools with the purest of intentions for they often believed that land occupied by Native American Tribes should be taken from them and put to use; it is this belief that brought about the purpose of the boarding schools which was to attempt to bring the Native American community into mainstream society (Bloom, 1996). These boarding schools are described to have been similar to a military institution or a private religious school. The students were to wear uniforms and obey strict rules that included not speaking one’s native tongue but rather only speaking English. Punishments for not obeying such rules often included doing laborious chores or being physically reprimanded (Bloom, 1996). Even with hars...
The article “Indian Education and Missions in Colonial Virginia” by W. Stitt Robinson, Jr. focuses on native American education. This article gives great insight into trying to educate the Indians. Unfortunately, a lot of times the motive of teaching was to enforce Christian morals and improve relations. Now on the surface improving relations doesn’t sound bad, but the motive was
The Canadian and American governments designed a residential school system to assimilate Indigenous children into Western society by stripping them of their language, cultural practices as well as their traditions. By breaking these children’s ties to their families and communities, as well as forcing them to assimilate into Western society; residential schools were a root cause of many social problems, which even persist within Aboriginal communities today.
"Compressed emotions," that is the explanation a teacher once gave to the ongoing question, "What is poetry?" He said it was someone's deepest emotions, as if you were reading them right out of that person's mind, which in that case would not consist of any words at all. If someone tells you a story, it is usually like a shell. Rarely are all of the deepest and most personal emotions revealed effectively. A poem of that story would be like the inside of the shell. It personifies situations, and symbolizes and compares emotions with other things in life. Louise Erdrich's poem Indian Boarding School puts the emotions of a person or group of people in a setting around a railroad track. The feelings experienced are compared to things from the setting, which takes on human characteristics.
In Joel Spring’s, “Deculturalization and Struggle for Equality”, he argues that during the construction of the new world (contemporary United States) nonwhite racial groups were created by elitist in order to have them deculturalized and maintain a system of racial superiority. Native Americans, Puerto Ricans, Mexicans, Blacks and Asians were each subject to systematic oppression in regards to racial formation, deculturalization, segregation and nation building. These dominated groups share the struggle of equality in this nation where “All men are equal” brought upon them by educational policies contrary to their socioeconomic interest and appealing to Euro-Americans.
Boarding school experiences resulted in direct causes for interpersonal violence within the Native American communities. While the experiences of Native Americans in boarding schools is not entirely lost on the dominant American population, the brutal reality and resulting consequences for Native communities is not fully appreciated. Poupart (2003) explains that it is estimated that nearly three quarters of Native Americans that attended Euro-American ran boarding schools, where they were forced to assimilate into dominant culture or else, experienced physical and sexual abuse regularly. Native Americans were forced to cut their hair, don dominant culture clothing, were beaten if they spoke their Native language, and removed from their cultural way of life to learn skills that the dominant culture found fitting. In fact, boarding school abuse was so prevalent for Native Americans that there are existing communities where not a single living adult did not experience or witness abuse. What results out of generations growing up in boarding schools is not only a loss of culture, but a loss of