Analysis Of Malinche In Chicana

837 Words2 Pages

Maria Herrera Sobek and Tere Romo both analyze how Malinche is depicted, mostly in the form of visual imagery. Instead of seeing her in a negative light, as do most Mexicans, they offer an alternative analysis that depicts her as the center of Chicana movement and separates patriarchal misperceptions from the reality. Maria Herrera Sobek looks at pictures and texts with Malinche, seeing her as a beautiful, intelligent, powerful young woman who was a skilled translator. Because she was born and raised to a noble family, by some accounts, she developed translating skills. This allowed for her language dexterity and communication with Cortes and the Tlaxcalans. Throughout the imagery that portrays her, Malinche is a confident woman who commands …show more content…

This gave her socio political mobility, contributing to her status over those like Cortes. Malinche had a large amount of power. In Miguel Gonzalez’ painting with Moctezuma, Malinche, and Cortes, both Malinche and Cortes are on the highest platform in the painting while everyone else, including Moctezuma is on a lower level. This depicts status, and puts Malinche as an indigenous woman on a higher level than an indigenous man. She is also, elegantly dressed and slightly taller than Cortes. Although she’s been europeanized through religion, she serves as a link between the indigenous culture and the European. Romo argues that Malinche stands as a symbol for the indigenous. Even though she has been converted and Europeanized, her native roots remain. Romo furthers this idea when she provides the alternative explanation to Malinche’s tears in Cecilia Alvarez’ painting. Instead of her tears symbolizing her guilt as a traitor, she is instead representing the native women who have suffered the same injustices that she has. Not only does Malinche still have her native roots, she also represents native …show more content…

She compares Malinche and Cortes to Adam and Eve because they are the forebears of the Mestizo race. Although this is partly false because their child, Martin, is not the first Mestizo who is born, I would say that because Malinche and Cortes are so popular in Mexican culture, it’s easy to see why they continue to be confused as the first parents of the Mestizo race. The body Cortes is stepping over is the vanquished native. Tere Romo sees Cortes position as asserting spanish male dominance over both Malinche and the native. Romo claims that Orozco is addressing Cortes’ control over both the native on the ground and Malinche by stepping over one and restraining the other. Throughout the other paintings, Sobek and Romo mention the dress of Cortes and Malinche. In Orozco’s mural, they’re both naked meaning that the differences between the two cultures would seem less obvious in a materialistic sense. However, in their naked state, even without Cortes’ armor and Malinche’s huipil, they are still very different because Cortes has light skin and Malinche dark brown skin. Through this, it becomes clear how Malinche is a link between the two cultures because she is holding hands with Cortes, and, as Sobek put it, she is the “forebear” of the Mestizo

Open Document