Analysis Of Gerard Jones's Essay Violent Media Is Good For Kids

950 Words2 Pages

In Gerard Jones’ essay titled “Violent Media Is Good for Kids”, he discusses the issue of media violence kids are exposed to. He personally believes violent media is good for children and their development. While many people may argue with him on his stance, he experienced violence as a child, even though his parents tried to shield it from him, and thus it resulted in him believing violence is acceptable for children (Jones 565). His belief that violence is good for children came from Marvel Comics, particularly the Hulk (565). Jones and Melanie Moore, a psychologist, agree violence stories “… to meet their emotional and developmental needs…” (Jones 566). Jones has created a program called Power Play, to enable children to tell heroic, combative, and powerful stories. However, he does believe violence has caused some real-life violence (Jones 567). Jones said that, ‘“I am going to argue that it’s helped hundreds of people for every one it’s hurt…’” (qtd. by Jones 567). Jones thinks American society has such a huge fear of ‘“youth violence’”, it has progressively made the fear into a reality (567).
Jones is trying to convince readers that violence is acceptable for the younger generation. He could easily influence someone into believing media violence is the best for kids. I thought he did …show more content…

He used a quote from Melanie Moore about how people crave ferocious stories (566). This author used a lot of personal opinion and personal details about his own life. He did not use any concrete data and facts in his paper, which might have helped his argument. Since he is a comic book writer and has felt the effects of violence in the media, his opinions could be credible (Gerard Jones-IMDB). He also has seen personal effects in a person’s life due to media violence, so that also makes him credible. When I searched Power Play, I did not find anything on this program. He did not use any sources, and this makes this paper hard to

Show More
Related

  • Hollywood Stop Exposing Our Kids To Violence Analysis

    439 Words  | 1 Pages

    Violence is often something people complain about to others. When there is an argument it may come to violence. Movies are causing people to become violent because when heroes in movies use violence to beat up the villains, this shows children violence is okay. The article claims that filmmakers should be blamed by putting violence in their movies. Therefore it is up to the parents to watch over their kids. But in a counter argument it claims that violence in music is okay and that the parents should know their kid’s tolerance to violent scenes.

    Read More

  • Violent Media Is Good For Kids By Gerard Jones

    1682 Words  | 4 Pages

    Violent Media is Good for Kids, by Gerard Jones, is an article which makes many claims to support the argument that a controlled amount of violence could be beneficial for a young, developing child. Even though the topic of this article can be controversial, the claims serve to support the argument in many noteworthy ways. It is written in such a way that it tells a story, starting when the author was a child and working its way to adulthood. In this case, the author uses, what I believe to be just the correct amount of rhetorical strategy, and fulfills his goal of writing the article. This argument is interesting and, at the same time, effective.

    Read More

  • Violent Media...Good for Kids?

    955 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...ssibly help more than harm. Experience has taught me that when a child walks in fear of expressing their feelings they bottle up all of their emotions; simply because they’re afraid of the consequences. Teaching children to appropriately use and appreciate violent media will help them build confidence, “power, and selfhood.” (Jones 287) He successfully executes the use of rhetorical methods and offers solutions to the opposing viewpoint. Jones’ consistent use logical and emotional appeal entices the reader and effectively persuades; this clearly substantiates his deserving of the top persuasiveness prize.

    Read More

  • A Rhetorical Analysis Of Violent Media

    117 Words  | 1 Pages

    It has been happened frequently in today’s society that parents and teachers try to keep children away from violent media. Children are taught that violent is not right and dangerous. In the article, “Violent Media Is Good for Kids”, Gerard Jones asserts that allowing children to violent media instead of banned it can bring great benefit to children during their growing stage. By watching violent media, children learn to overcome fear, control the rage and prove the real self from the superheroes in the story. Jones believes that violent entertainment can assistance children to fulfill emotional and development need. In my opinion, Jones develops a persuasive argument because of his strong emotions, considerable evidences and reasonable assumptions.

    Read More

  • Stephen King Research Paper

    640 Words  | 2 Pages

    There are a lot of people who either wonder or believe that violent media is bad for people and mostly children. Not all violent media is bad. Sometimes when people have a stressful day they will play video games to let off steam. A few people like watching horror movies because of the thrill of being scared. But if you’re a kid with no friends or you are alone most of the time, you might enjoy comic books. They are filled with action and heroes. Doing any of these can give off a sense of adventure, thrill, and excitement. It doesn’t mean that you’re going to go off and start hurting people because of it. There is a lot of evidence that states the media affects viewers by encouraging violent behavior and weakening their creative ability. The question is whether the media is truly the problem, or is it the parental role that is the problem.

    Read More

  • Media Violence: Censorship Not Needed

    1589 Words  | 4 Pages

    Valenti, Jack. "Violent Movies Do Not Make Children Violent." Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation. 4 May. 1999. Rpt. in Violence in the Media. Ed. James D. Torr. San Diego: Greenhaven. 2001. 72-74.

    Read More

  • Counter-Point Argument Analysis: Hollywood, Stop Exposing Our Kids To Violence

    674 Words  | 2 Pages

    When the reader sees this it makes them wonder if watching these violent actions does actually desensitize themselves, and even make them feel less sympathy for victims of violent crimes. These thoughts really connect with the reader, and might even persuade them to decrease the amount of violence they watch. The author cites work from a former university professor stating, "What we call entertainment is really propaganda for violence. If you manufacture guns, you don’t need to advertise, because it is done by our entertainment industry" (Point para #6). The author is trying prove that when kids watch violent movies it is just advertising things like guns and other sorts of weapons. The professor believes that violent movies are just propaganda for violence, as kids may think the movies are cool

    Read More

  • Violence And Rage By Gerard Jones Summary

    503 Words  | 2 Pages

    Many people believe that violent media is bad and that we should get rid of all negative images, thoughts and ideas that are available for our children to see. I feel that it is impossible and an unrealistic way to think! Especially in today’s day and time. It is everywhere and we have full access to that and much more in the palm of our hand. Furthermore, violence was here long before the video games, comic books, and just violent media as a whole. Our country was founded on violence and crime and it has been going on in our country since before America was America. It has not and is not going anywhere! Instead of trying to block it out and filter it from our children, we should find ways to channel the negativity into something positive. I believe that is the point that Jones was making in this article.

    Read More

  • Gerard Jones's Violent Media Is Good For Kids

    1264 Words  | 3 Pages

    It, instead, can serve as an effective emotional outlet. This is the author’s position, and he competently argues for it in his essay. On the positive side, he gives examples that clearly illustrate how violent media can play a positive role in the emotional development of children, but on the negative side, he provides weak empirical/scientific evidence to support his thesis. The essay would have been more affective if he left out the study, and instead used outside sources to support his

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay

    1354 Words  | 3 Pages

    First of all, in the article “ Violent Video Games and the Supreme Court” by Ferguson(2003), it mention that “In 2005 the American Psychological Association (APA) released a resolution on video game violence linking violent video

    Read More

  • Protecting Children from Television Violence

    1390 Words  | 3 Pages

    Freedman goes on to explain that the FCC has no substantial scientific evidence stating that there is a correlation between fictional violence and real-world aggression among young audiences. He has completed research in 1984 and 2002 on the relationship between media violence to actual acts of violence on the street. Because he has completed research projects related to this topic, Freedman’s statistical evidence shows that there is a reduction in youth violence and it essentially does not cause real-world crimes (Freedman Par. 1). The FCC continues to claim that exposure to media violence does in fact increase aggression, and yet their readers continue to believe their fabrications. Freedman argues that people who research media violence tend to disregard and omit the opposing facts.

    Read More

  • Mass Media Violence And Violence Essay

    1739 Words  | 4 Pages

    Mass media is part of our daily lives, it is said that it can influence a person’s choice, view or behavior. An increase in violent crimes in our society, have led people to blame mass media violence due to the fact that it can increase violent and aggressive behavior which will eventually lead to them committing a violent crime. Even though there are many factors that may contribute to these types of behaviors, can mass media really be that influential on us? There have been researches done to see if there is any link between mass media violence and violence and aggressive behavior. For example, the study done by Professor Bushman of Ohio State University, found out that people who played violent video games for three consecutive days showed an increase in aggression and hostile behavior (Larsen). Now there are those who disagree that mass media violence can influence an individual to behave violently or aggressively. Joshua Quittner, the author of the article “ARE VIDEO GAMES REALLY SO BAD?”, says that he likes to play the bloodier games like Samurai-slashing Bushido Blade and Tekken 2. He says does not feel that these games have altered his behavior or have hurt him in any way, instead he says that these games help improve his reflexes.

    Read More

  • Disadvantages of Video Games

    1321 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...onditions that ensure an adequate counterbalance increasing consumption in some cases, end up having a negative effect on children. Children learn best through demonstration followed by imitation, with rewards for doing things the right way. While not all are affected the same way, it can be said that, in general, violence in the media affects attitudes, values and behaviors of users. You run the risk that children end up understanding that it is reasonably practicable to resort to violence. The fear is that the models of aggressive behavior can be considered suitable. Thus, in an investigation, a good proportion of children (third) defined as normal acts of violence they had seen him mightily little. It is not; here is a risk of direct imitation, but rather a change in terms of reference: where extreme violence appears to be normal any more light may seem harmless.

    Read More

  • Media Violence Essay

    1082 Words  | 3 Pages

    By the time a child reaches the age of one, they see about 200,000 acts of violence on television. (Nakaya, 3). The Media has been becoming more and more violent over the years. A poll in an issue of Times Magazine, from 2005, showed that 66 percent of Americans think that there is an abundant amount of graphic acts of violence on televisions (Nakaya, 18). People are exposed to thousands of acts of violence through video games, television, and movies. Many studies show that media violence increases violent behavior in in humans. Studies show, violent video games, and graphic television have physiological effects on children. The government has very few regulations on media violence. Some people believe the government shouldn’t limit content because others might be insulted by its material. Media violence is such a broad topic and has such a large presence in daily lives, so we cannot simple get rid of it. The Federal Communications Commission stipulates, “By the time most children begin the third grade, they will have spent the equivalent of three school years in front of a television set.” Even though the government shouldn’t censor the media, Media violence is becoming a serious issue because it is becoming more violent, it makes people behave violently, and it has little regulations.

    Read More

  • Disadvantages Of Media Violence

    866 Words  | 2 Pages

    In “ Is Media Violence Damaging to Kids?” written by Sasha Emmons, he first explains his dilemma

    Read More

More about Analysis Of Gerard Jones's Essay Violent Media Is Good For Kids

Open Document