Adversity is the forerunner to kindness: a progenitor that encompasses the suffering of the raw, human experience. With the understanding of tribulations comes a greater empathy to share with others: the commonality among all living things that surpasses appearance and material. The renowned journalist William Allen White once stated, “If each man or woman could understand that every other human life is as full of sorrows, or joys, or base temptations, of heartaches and remorse as his own…how much kinder, how much gentler he would be”. This tragic lesson is apparent in both Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Ernest Gaines’ A Lesson Before Dying: liberation is only available to those who seek beyond the surface of a “monster” or “hog”, …show more content…
down to the misunderstood goodness of a fallen man. The misconception of an isolated outcast fuels fear and rage in society as well as the victim, furthering violence, seclusion, and pain. When the restraints of superficial judgment are abandoned, the way is paved for an individual to become more receptive and sympathetic. However, those who live within the constructs of external prejudice fail to accept the diversity that encompasses life itself. With the elimination of preconceived notions comes the potential for a universal understanding of humanity. When prosecuted by society, the easiest coping method is to reclude into self-imposed solitude. Internal kindness or innocence is cruelly overlooked for the sense of judgment, leading to oppression and loneliness. In Frankenstein, Victor Frankenstein’s tormented Creation is endowed with a “…heart [was] fashioned to be susceptible of love and sympathy…” (Shelley 122). He longs for the acceptance that accompanies a normal human life, such as that of the DeLacey’s, which he observes after he abandons civilization for the isolation of the mountains. The Creation shares innately good desires with the rest of man: the primal want for love, acceptance, and a companion. However, when the universe denies him this chance, he turns to violence and revenge to attempt to communicate. In addition, in A Lesson Before Dying, Jefferson is a misunderstood soul: a young man ripped from the clutch of life, only to meet the consequences of a crime he does not commit. Portrayed as a murderer, he is forced to live the remainder of his days alone with his thoughts in a jail cell. Jefferson copes with his pain by shutting out those who attempt to aid him, expressing his frustration silently as a coping mechanism for fear. Grant states, during a visit with Jefferson, “He was full of anger - and who could blame him? - but he was no fool. He needed me, and he wanted me here…” (Gaines 130). Both individuals crave the basic need of human affection, contact, and sympathy: an internal commonality of all mankind. However, the cruelty of the world strips their innately innocent ways to those of fear and vitriol. Rejection from society includes a motive, either internal or external. However, in the case of both Jefferson and the Creation, prejudice imposed by the “external” world prevents their potential from fully evolving. For Jefferson, or, as he is deemed, the “hog”, the racial prejudices of Bayonne in the 1940s prevent his prosperity. The African-American minorities of the town must submit themselves to humiliation and demoralization at the hands of the white men: addressing them as superiors, going to “colored” establishments, and abiding by the white man’s law without question. For example, when he is delivering Jefferson’s sentence, Jefferson’s judge states, “But let us say he was (guilty). Let us for a moment say he was (guilty). What justice would there be to take his life? Justice, gentlemen? Why, I would just as soon put a hog in the electric chair as this” (Gaines 8). Externally, Jefferson is constantly reduced to the colour of his skin: he is nothing more than another cog in the rigged judicial system of America, which relies on the scapegoat of those who cannot be protected. His imprisonment, however, furthers the idea of being a “hog” into Jefferson’s mind, to where he is nothing but another black man fallen at the feet of a world against him. This exact conflict is also apparent in the portrayal of the “monster” in Frankenstein.
When Victor animates his accomplishment, he is distraught by its physical appearance, stating that, “…no mortal could support the horror of that countenance” (Shelley 52). The outside judgment of the Creation from both his creator, and eventually, the rest of civilization, prevents the monster from fulfilling his emotion in healthy, normal ways. In the novel, beauty is a virtue. Elizabeth, for example, is treated as a tenderly cherished trophy: Victor describes her as a cherub, a “…a possession of my own” (Shelley 14). In a superficial society, the monster revels in his ugliness, forcing him into loneliness without choice, or even intent. When the Creation looks in the transparent pool to see his reflection and states, “…I was in reality the monster that I am, I was filled with the bitterest sensations of despondence and mortification. Alas! I did not yet entirely know the fatal effects of this miserable deformity” (Shelley 88), he realizes that his ostracization is caused by uncontrollable and permanent circumstances. His pain and internal desolation come from the external consequences of his appearance: abandonment from his creator and the rest of mankind. Although the monster is innately kindhearted, no human can look past his looks to understand and sympathize with the sorrow and misfortune he is doomed to …show more content…
feel. However, in both novels, the redemption the “monsters” face facilitates the spread of sympathy and understanding to those previously blinded by the constructs of judgment.
In the resolution of Frankenstein, the Creation explains his motives and regrets to Walton on the ship, detailing the suffrage he undergoes whilst murdering all who Victor had ever loved. The Creature explains how the live of violence and inhumanity he adopts brings him an unforgivable sense of regret, only to be quenched by lighting himself on fire: “Polluted by crimes, and torn by the bitterest remorse, where can I rest but in death?” (Shelley 197). Communication with the men on the boat, to the monster, facilitates redemption through an explanation of his cruel actions, and builds a sense of deep-rooted empathy for his torturous life. This apotheotic farewell facilitates an understanding of the machinations of the monster, and his stolen potential to be the “…much kinder…much gentler” man he was never given the chance to
be. Similarly, in A Lesson Before Dying, Jefferson facilitates the potential for kindness and sympathy in both himself and his community through his heroic redemption. Through the lessons he undergoes with Grant, he learns to be a more forgiving person to both himself and the broken hatred and bias of his town. On the day of his execution, Jefferson raises himself above his racial role through his bravery, uniting those under the commonality of a young man’s immense strength in times of adversity. He facilitates self-kindness that reflects onto his community, building a more understanding and sympathetic future for those tainted by injustice, whilst undergoing his own self-actualization: the graceful evolution from “hog” to writing, “…tell them im strong tell them im a man” (Gaines 234). Grant, in addition, is the catalyst for Jefferson’s realization, which raises him above his racial and societal role. Not only does Jefferson become more than his label, but Grant gains a greater sympathy for the suffering of one less fortunate: as a much kinder and gentler soul. The ability to become a more tolerant individual is often inhibited by external injustice; however, these prejudices may often serve as outlets for change. The universal understanding of humanity is achieved through gaining a broader worldly perspective on the lives of others and leading a more sympathetic existence. Only when external judgment and bias is deserted may enlightenment and kindness take dominance over mankind, despite external appearances. There is a keen commonality sacred among all living things: to understand sorrow, joy, and the primal functions and desires of life. With the ability to accept love and the similarities of the human experience comes the facilitation of a universal understanding that no man is innately monstrous: he may only be shaped so by man himself.
First, Before the monster is created Victor says that he hopes this creation would bless him as his creator, and that the creature would be excellent nature and would be beautiful. After the creature is created Shelley creates sympathy for him by Victor’s description of him in a unique yet horrific way, “he’s ‘gigantic,” “deformed,” “yellow skin scarcely covered the work of muscles and arteries beneath” this makes the creature abhorrent to typical humans. When thinking of the descriptions together, Shelley has created a vivid, unnatural image of the monster in the mind’s eyes. The language Shelley uses is powerful and emotive “shall I create another like yourself, whose joints wickedness
In drastic contrast to Victor, The creatures early beginning had no ounce of love as victor had as Victor gave none. Naomi Hethering describes Victors want to give affection to the creature “only fleetingly“ as his first responses to the creature were of disgust, even to the point of saying “Dante could not conceived”(43) such a horror. Appearance alone caused major alienation of a son to a father or creator, and when your father cannot even accept you where can you turn? Society's judgement on appearance continues to be illuminated as his sight alone causes an entire villages to immediately erupt in violence and causes old man to run with speed “of which his debilitated form hardly appeared capable”(90). Mary Shelley addresses this conflict directly later as the creature sees his own reflection and is horrified. We know the creatures character character is good as seen with his interactions with the Blind DeLacy so the only thing to pin this drastic alienation is the creature's appearance. His appearance and happenings with others drove his contempt of the beautiful. This seen with his interactions with Justine Moritz, as he prematurely decided what her reaction would be to seeing him and resented her for it, saying that “she shall suffer...be hers the punishment”(128). Mary Shelley illustrates a picture of horror on so manys faces during the
Shelley 94). Victor’s various thoughts of rage and hatred that had at first deprive him of utterance, but he recovers only to overwhelm the creature with words expressive of furious detestation and contempt, as he recalled creature’s misdoings to his loved ones. However, Victor pauses to “conceive,” to “feel,” and to “reason” with monster (M. Shelley 94). As Victor follows his creation, he notices the “air [to be full] of exultation” and “the rain” beginning “to descend,” showcasing Victor’s consent to change his view. (M. Shelley 98). Chapter 10 is exemplary of the Romantic Period where story becomes an allegory for real emotions and struggles. Victor’s
As he goes off to college, interested in the science behind life and death, he ends up going his own way and attempts to create a living being. Victor “had worked hard for nearly two years, for the sole purpose of infusing life into an inanimate body” (Shelley 43). The being Victor has created does not by any means sit well with him. As victor is away from his family and for six years, he is neglectful to them, which only adds to his sorrow and misery. Victor’s isolation is brought upon him because of himself, however his creation, or “the monster”, is isolated from any connections with humans against his will. To start out, the monster would have had Victor there with him, but Victor is ashamed of what he has created, and abandons the monster. The monster is a very hideous being, which sadly is a contributing factor to his isolation. With nobody to talk to at any time, naturally this will be condescending and frustrating. Although the monster is able to
As a tragic hero, Victor’s tragedies begin with his overly obsessive thirst for knowledge. Throughout his life, Victor has always been looking for new things to learn in the areas of science and philosophy. He goes so far with his knowledge that he ends up creating a living creature. Victor has extremely high expectations for his creation but is highly disappointed with the outcome. He says, “I had desired it with an ardour that far exceeded moderation; but now that I had finished, the beauty of the dream vanished, and breathless horror and disgust filled my heart” (Shelley 35). Frankenstein neglects the creature because of his horrifying looks, which spark the beginning of numerous conflicts and tragedies. At this point, the creature becomes a monster because of Victor’s neglect and irresponsibility. The monster is forced to learn to survive on his own, without anyone or anything to guide him along the way. Plus, the monster’s ugly looks cause society to turn against him, ad...
Victor had created the creature with the vision from his dreams of a strong, tall perfect being with no flaws. His years of study with the unnatural and science had come to this final conclusion and masterful idea that he was determined to finish. To his surprise, he had created the opposite, “For this I had deprived myself of rest and health. I had desired it with an ardour that far exceeded moderation; but now that I had finished, the beauty of the dream vanished, and breathless horror and disgust filled my heart.” (Shelley 35) Victor is saddened by what he thinks of as a failure. He leaves his own apartment to go sleep in his court yard outside following his creation. He begins to isolate himself from the creature because of his fear of the creature’s outward appearance. He loses all hope for the creature without even learning anything about him. The fact that Shelley begins to refer to the being that Victor created as a “creature” shows Victor’s ignorance and lack of acceptance. It is Victor’s prejudice that blinds him of the creature’s true potential due to the unwanted preconception that follows the creature as he finds meaning in
So, when he created Frankenstein “the monster” he turned out to be this grotesque and unnatural creature which was different from what Victor had imagined. However, at the site of looking at his creation, Victor is now spooked by his appearance and immediately turned off by his own creation. For example, in chapter 5 Victor says, “I had desired it with an ardor that far exceeded moderation; but now that I had finished, the beauty of the dream vanished, and breathless horror and disgust filled my heart. Unable to endure the aspect of the being I had created, I rushed out of the room, continued a long time traversing my bed chamber, unable to compose my mind to sleep.” (Page 35). Again, we can see Shelley’s use of Gothic elements infused with the monstrous theme. However, this causes Victor to immediately stray away from the monster because he views his creation as repulsive and upsetting. Which marks the first sign of abandonment that Victor places on his creation. This doesn’t do any justice for Victor because now the monster is trying to assert himself into Victor’s life but yet feels more and more neglected from the absence of love that Victor doesn’t want to give in terms of having a relationship with
In Frankenstein, Victor’s monster suffers much loneliness and pain at the hands of every human he meets, as he tries to be human like them. First, he is abandoned by his creator, the one person that should have accepted, helped, and guided him through the confusing world he found himself in. Next, he is shunned wherever he goes, often attacked and injured. Still, throughout these trials, the creature remains hopeful that he can eventually be accepted, and entertains virtuous and moral thoughts. However, when the creature takes another crushing blow, as a family he had thought to be very noble and honorable abandons him as well, his hopes are dashed. The monster then takes revenge on Victor, killing many of his loved ones, and on the humans who have hurt him. While exacting his revenge, the monster often feels guilty for his actions and tries to be better, but is then angered and provoked into committing more wrongdoings, feeling self-pity all the while. Finally, after Victor’s death, the monster returns to mourn the death of his creator, a death he directly caused, and speaks about his misery and shame. During his soliloquy, the monster shows that he has become a human being because he suffers from an inner conflict, in his case, between guilt and a need for sympathy and pity, as all humans do.
Rather, it is others who alienate it because of its grotesque appearance. The monster is quite literally ‘born’ into perpetual isolation beginning with Victor’s abandonment of it. He denies it domestic safety when he flees to his bedchamber. Victor disregards the monster’s utterance of “inarticulate sounds while a grin wrinkled his cheeks,” then escapes its outstretched hand “seemingly to detain [him]” [Shelley 49]. Examining the monster’s body language as though an impressionable infant, its actions can be read as a child-like plea for its father though the absence of speech not yet learned. Instead, its unattractive appearance causes Victor to run, leaving the creature alone with no information about himself or his surroundings. Therefore, Victor’s abandonment is a crucial justification of the monster’s negative experiences with society and nature and actions in desiring community. The monster’s alienation from family is the missing first school of human nature, and the first lesson where he learns he does not belong. The creature leaves into the wilderness to learn about the world and himself on it own, only to understand his interactions are
... Therefore, the qualities that cause people to detest the creation are all products of Victor’s hands, and out of the creation’s control. Before the creation comes to life, Victor is pleased with its physical appearance; "His limbs were in proportion, and I had selected his features as beautiful" (Shelley 34). Within hours after the creation is alive, Victor recalls a much different story in his mind, saying, "I had gazed on him when he was unfinished; he was ugly then" (Shelley 35). It is in this ignorant fashion that Victor and the other humans the creation meets destroy his identity by rashly inventing the identity of a murderous "wretch," rather than an unfortunate child, which the reader believes he was.
The creator of the monster, Victor Frankenstein is a man full of knowledge and has a strong passion for science. He pushes the boundary of science and creates a monster. Knowledge can be a threat when used for evil purposes. Though Victor did not intend for the being to be evil, society’s judgement on the monster greatly affects him. As a result he develops hatred for his creator as well as all man-kind. Victor’s anguish for the loss of his family facilitates his plan for revenge to the monster whom is the murderer. While traveling on Robert Walton’s ship he and Victor continue their pursuit of the monster. As Victor’s death nears he says, “…or must I die, and he yet live? If I do, swear to me Walton, that he shall not escape, that you will seek him and satisfy my vengeance in his death…Yet, when I am dead if he should appear, if the ministers of vengeance should conduct him to you, swear that he shall not live-swear that he shall not triumph over my accumulated woes and survive to add to the list of his dark crimes” (pg.199). Victor grieves the death of William, Justine, Clerval, Elizabeth and his father. Throughout the novel he experiences the five stages of grief, denial/ isolation, anger, bargaining, depression and finally acceptance. Victor denies ...
One of the most influential contributions in the formation of the monster’s character is Victor’s failure as a creator and a father. As a creator, Victor has the responsibility of providing for his creation, just as God provided for Adam and Eve. At the same time, Victor also falls under the role of a father, and should therefore seek to strengthen the familial bond between the two of them. However, Victor fails in both of these endeavors, because he cannot accept the monster in his deformity. “Frankenstein’s sole regret… is that he did not create an aesthetically pleasing being” (Bond). Victor, due to his skewed vision of humanity, believes outer beauty to be a reflection of inner character, and that because of the monster’s hideous appe...
Victor Frankenstein serves as an instrument of suffering of others and contributes to the tragic vision as a whole in this novel. He hurts those surrounding him by his selfish character and his own creation plots against his master due to the lack of happiness and love. The audience should learn from Frankenstein’s tragic life and character to always remain humble. We should never try to take superiority that is not granted to us because like victor we shall suffer and perish. He had the opportunity to make a difference in his life and take responsibility as a creator but his selfishness caused him to die alone just like what he had feared.
To conclude, in Frankenstein, the theme of creation and destruction is portrayed and shapes both Victor and the monster. Due to Victor’s and humanity’s hatred and abandonment of the being, the creation strangles Victor’s brother, best friend, and wife. Overall, Shelley’s message is that inhuman creation generates destruction in the novel where the creation of the monster leads to the destruction of Victor internally, the murder of his best friend, and the assassination of his beloved family
While the monster gains a feeling of hatred and a desire for revenge after he is abandoned and treated pitifully, Frankenstein continuing reinforces the suffering of his creation, and likewise the suffering of himself. Frankenstein is completely to blame for the misery that he endures. Victor creates a being only for his own fulfillment, and afterwards abandons the great responsibility that he bears for it. To make it worse, Frankenstein intentionally ruins the monster 's happiness and gives him the same horrendous treatment that the rest of mankind gives the monster. Victor 's selfish actions cost him his family, bring him to the brink of insanity, and make a terrible creature out of a loving and compassionate being. Victor Frankenstein is a true