A Modern Fable: “The Catbird Seat” by James Thurber

1288 Words3 Pages

This short story entitled “The Catbird Seat” is a modern fable. The definition of a fable is a simple story with animal characters in which the big strong animal is bested, overcome by, or made a fool of by the weaker character. A modern fable is a fable that takes place in modern times. This short story by James Thurber takes place in New York City around the 1940s. Many fables written before are very much alike “The Catbird Seat” when it comes to being a fable. For example, in “The Tortoise and the Hare” the cocky, arrogant rabbit keeps on boasting about how speedy he is to the scrawny, sluggish turtle. In the end, the turtle overcomes the pompous rabbit in a race because the rabbit underestimated the turtle. Also, in “Henny Penny”, Henny Penny gets tricked by a malicious, large fox named Foxy Loxy into bringing all her friends into his cave to be eaten. Henny Penny gets rid of Foxy Loxy using her cleverness to trap him. These short stories demonstrate many of the qualities of a fable. “The Catbird Seat also includes the framework of a fable.

Ms. Ulgine Barrows is the Foxy Loxy of this modern fable. She is the bulky, obnoxious, and arrogant animal in this story always bullying the people around her. The author uses many examples of animal imagery to paint a picture of Ulgine. She would always romp like a circus horse around the offices, elevators, and hallways of F. & S., the company she works for. She profaned the halls with her quacking voice and braying laugh. A few of “Ugline’s” masculine features such as being huge, burly, and built suggested that she was an ox rampaging around the halls of F. & S. Her last name Barrows resembles a burrow. Her first name, Ulgine, resembles “Ugline” making her appear as an unsightly creatu...

... middle of paper ...

... Seat” is a modern fable because the meaning of a fable suggests that this story is a fable. The moral of this fable was that “Brains Beat Brawn.” “The Catbird Seat” has shown many qualities of a fable that other fables have shown. There were two animals in which one was weaker and clever and the other was stronger and bigger. The bigger animal, Ms. Barrows was always bullying the weaker character, Mr. Martin. In the end, the weaker character defeated the bigger character not with strength but with cunningness, cleverness, and intelligence. This happened because the mightier character was an arrogant, self-centered, and cocky animal. The weaker character’s unexpected clever plan to trick the overconfident character taught the larger character a lesson. All of this criteria for a fable happens in “The Catbird Seat” which means the “The Catbird Seat is a modern fable.

Show More
Related

  • The White Heron And A Caged Bird Comparison

    902 Words  | 2 Pages

    However, it is much more rewarding to try and look for the less obvious differences and find out why they are there and what they mean. For example, one less obvious difference is the bird choice and it happens to represent something larger, in my opinion. In “The White Heron” we see a big and majestic bird that is looked at as a specimen or the epitome of beautiful. However, in “A Caged Bird”, the way the author describes the bird as “an old canary that flits and sings” could possibly be purposeful to the way the author wants us to view it. I personally think that the author wants us to see the bird as old to add meaning to the fact that it is still happy and chipper after all of these years if being caged. The obvious differences between the types of birds that the author used to portray these stories could have more meaning to them then just an image. For example, maybe the author was trying to say that smaller birds, or people who say within themselves and try to make themselves smaller, tend to get caged whereas large and majestic birds, or people who open themselves up to the world, tend to be sought after and viewed as a magnificence. Now, I realize that this does not support the reasons behind either of the birds’ attitudes, but it does give good

    Read More

  • To What Extent Curley's Wife a Victim in Of Mice and Men

    898 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Of Mice & Men, the character Curley’s Wife is depicted as flirtatious, promiscuous, and insensitive. However, her husband Curley sees her as only a possession. Most of the workers at the ranch see her as a tart, whereas Slim, the peaceful and god-like figure out of all the men, see her as lonely. This answer will tell us to which extent, is Curley’s wife a victim, whether towards her flirtatious behaviour, or to everyone’s representation of her.

    Read More

  • Feminist Lens In John Steinbeck's Novel 'Of Mice And Men'

    824 Words  | 2 Pages

    From her first appearance in the story, Curley’s wife is described as a different kind of threat, one who is all artifice and manipulation from her red lips and fingernails to her red mules, “on the insteps of which were little bouquets of red ostrich feathers” (Steinbeck 31). The imagery Steinbeck uses, paints her as a woman who is quite bold, but fragile with a passionate essence.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Lemuel Gulliver's Dream

    543 Words  | 2 Pages

    Lemuel Gulliver describes a wildly fanciful dream from a perspective that, when analyzed, illustrates his conceited character and ignorance at his surroundings. Throughout his dream, Gulliver expresses how much more civilized and privileged his race is compared to the Yahoos, yet does this in a factual way that does not hint at contempt. Similarly, he does not seem to realize how abnormal his situation is throughout the dream, and casually remarks on each aspect of his environment without actually paying attention to details or what is really going on. Despite how seemingly self-absorbed Gulliver appears in his account of his dream, at the end he does reflect on his own life compared to the Yahoo's, and he makes the connection of how closely related his species and their's are (Swift 2473). This connection gives insight into Gulliver's mind, and shows that Gulliver may possibly be more aware then he seems.

    Read More

  • Of Mice And Men - Curley's Wife

    1157 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the Steinbeck novel ‘Of Mice and Men’, he introduces us to the character of Curley’s wife. She could be interpreted as a mis-fitting character in the novel, as no one relaters to her. This essay will go on to examine the character of Curley’s wife and how characters perceive her and how this influences the readers interpretation of her.

    Read More

  • Of Mice And Men - Symbolism

    473 Words  | 1 Pages

    Curley and Curley’s wife both represent evil both oppress and abuse the migrant workers. Curley especially harasses Lennie because of Lennie’s strength and how enormous he is. This is a symbol of cat and mouse.

    Read More

  • Boys and Girls by Alice Munro

    829 Words  | 2 Pages

    In conclusion , I believe that as strong as the protagonist’s self image of herself was, one girl is no match for all of society, which has efficiently put her “in her place”. This manipulation of the girl’s self image is not only the end of her unique identity, but it is also a blow against freedom and individualism. Unfortunately for this horse, she could not roam free forever, and she has finally been caught.

    Read More

  • Dialectical Journal For The Catcher In The Rye

    1370 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Catcher in the Rye, a charming tale of Holden Caulfield, its main character as he finds his way through New York City after once again being expelled from his school. The focus now is at the near end where he enjoys his time with his little sister, Phoebe riding an ordinary carousel within a zoo. A relaxing occurrence, starting from page 232 to 233 in the life of our main character which has become rare after every ordeal he has gone through not so long ago. It’s at this moment he is given reprieve, time to simply think, which lead me to ask myself the meaning of this event. After the spark of curiosity my questions had emerged such as why, and how this one little event could be entangled with the rest of the book. They had bore fruitful

    Read More

  • Anne Bonny And Mary Read

    684 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the book A General History of the Pyrates, often attributed to Daniel Defoe, Anne Bonny and Mary Read are cast as clear examples of this archetype. They are made sinful, beastly deviants who refuse to conform to the passive gender norms expected of her. This is made evident by their scandalous origins, descriptions of their rugged looks, their crass and bold behavior unbefitting of a woman, and the way in which they are both made spectacles of for the pleasure of the public.

    Read More

  • The Purpose of the Narrator in The Zebra Storyteller and The Yellow Wallpaper

    810 Words  | 2 Pages

    In The Zebra Storyteller the narrator is a Siamese cat but the narrator is also an outsider. During the story the cat tells a story to his friends about how skillful and 'powerful' he is at killing zebras. Towards the end of the story the cat is handed his fate; he is kicked and killed by a zebra, who sensed feared when approached. At the end of the story Holst concludes with the statement, "That is the function of the storyteller." This statement pertains to the idea of the function the storyteller has or how they create the atmosphere and set the grounds in which the story is based on. There are many functions of the storyteller. They can teach a lesson, control the story, entertain, and stretch one's own imagination. In this story it is a great example how the story can take a sudden unexpected turn and shock the reader. The narrator can take twists and turns and can make expected or even unexpected outcomes in the story. A good example in the story would be where the narrator states, "The zebra storyteller wasn't fit to be tied at hearing a cat speaking his language, because he'd been thinking about that very thing" (Holst 1971). At this point the narrator changes the reader's perspective and sheds light on an upcoming event in the story. Which turned out to be a big event where the Siamese cat got killed. Of course this story is fictional but it is an excellent story to portray how a narrator can expand the reader's imagination.

    Read More

  • A Fable for Tomorrow by Carson

    430 Words  | 1 Pages

    A Fable for Tomorrow by Carson How does the Author of the following extracts use language to convey

    Read More

  • Disguised Motives for Murder in Short Stories by Edgar Allen Poe

    1419 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the stories, “The Tell Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat,” both narrators have a misguided perception that induces their senses to confuse reality with delusions. This misguided perception is brought on by the abnormal psychology of both men. This is a common theme in Poes’ stories. In “The Black Cat” the narrator feels a sense of fright and disgust when reviewing the attached behavior of the second cat. Poe’s description of the second cat is eerily similar to that of the first cat, Pluto. As author Magdalen Wing-Chi Ki states, “the narrator is convinced that it ‘must be’ Pluto on account of two things: it follows him around in the hope of becoming his absolute partner, and one of its eyes is gone.” A rational person understands that it is impossible for the second cat to be Pluto, but the narrator is so misguided that he believes this inconceivable delusion. This mistaken fantasy fuels the narrator’s madness, giving him more evidence that mu...

    Read More

  • Aesop's Fables

    1374 Words  | 3 Pages

    Introduction: I chose to research the genre of fables, specifically Aesop’s fables. I only informed of the basics of fables. To be frank with you I don’t even think there is much to know about fables. What is there to know? They contain lessons, animals, and they are short.

    Read More

  • Incarnate Night-Mare Analysis

    51 Words  | 1 Pages

    References made to the dark feline which portray it as a "thing" of wicked extents, an "incarnate Night-Mare," serve to elevate our advantage and the pressure of the story as we hold up to witness what will and how the inquisitive relationship between the storyteller and the feline will resolve itself.

    Read More

  • Charlie's Cabin: A Short Story

    974 Words  | 2 Pages

    Opening the front door to the cabin, as Charlie stood just behind him holding the screen door open, Bass was assaulted by stale air and dust.

    Read More

More about A Modern Fable: “The Catbird Seat” by James Thurber

Open Document