Gender Equality and Communism

2205 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Policies towards women under mao zedong

Gender Equality and Communism

Equality for women was a pillar of the ideology of communist regimes that ascended to power in Eastern Central Europe with Soviet support following World War II. Since religion was declared illegitimate by communist theory, marriage was not considered sacred; rather, it was deemed a capitalist mechanism for oppressing women. Thus, communist regimes began instituting policies intended to facilitate gender equality. However, the actual methods employed by communist regimes to encourage equality for women had varying effects (e.g., incorporation of women into the labor force). Furthermore, it appears that many communist regimes encouraged gender equality in theory, but promoted a traditional patriarchal family hierarchy in practice. Indeed, the vary nature of bureaucratic soviet-style communism may be considered to be patriarchal. This contradiction between communist theory and practice concerning gender equality is evident in the films: Loves of a Blond, Man is Not a Bird, and Adoption.

In her book entitled Women’s Equality, Work, and Family in the Czech Republic, Alena Heitlinger asserts,

“ … Czechoslovakia adopted a Marxist-Leninist approach to women’s equality … based on Friedrich Engels’ hypothesis that the emancipation of women would result from the abolition of private property, the productive employment of women, and the socialization of private domestic work and child care [which would give time for self-realization in public life]” (88).

This hypothesis may have proved successful, but the principles it was based on were never fully implemented. The first part of the hypothesis hinged on the abolition of private property, a goal that the communist regimes managed ...

... middle of paper ...

...tentions, but actually may have served to objectify women further.

Therefore, it is apparent that the methods employed to exact gender equality were incapable of achieving success because there was no coordinated effort to eradicate the existing patriarchal undertones pervading Eastern European Communist Society. Moreover, the very of nature of communism, in spite of the rhetoric propagated by communist leaders, may have served to reinforce the patriarchal tendencies already existent in society.

Works Cited

Forman, Milos. Loves of a Blond. Czechoslovakia, 1965.

Heitlinger, Alena. Women’s Equality, Work, and Family in the Czech Republic.

Makavejev, Dusan. Man is Not a Bird. Yugoslavia, 1965.

Mesazros, Marta. Adoption. Hungary, 1975.

Verdery, Katherine. From Parent-State to Family Patriarchs: Gender and Nation in Contemporary Eastern Europe.

Show More
Related

  • Cultural and gender comparison of Russia and the US

    779 Words  | 2 Pages

    Gender roles in Russia have dramatically changed since the fall of the former Soviet Union and the fall of communism. It is hard to look directly at the constitution of Russia seeing as though the drafting and redrafting of their constitution is still underway. However, looking at the constitution of the former Soviet Union, you can see it is clearly stated that: “Women and men have equal rights.” It is very clear that in the Soviet Union they were trying to make it so that women and men were equal. It is still clear today that those same basic ideals are present in Russia. Women are clearly more equal in their country than in ours. In the workforce as well as in the home, women play a more equal role than in the present day United States. However, for the sake of this paper, let us just look at the infrastructure of Russia, formerly known as the Soviet Union or USSR.

    Read More

  • The Baba And The Comrade Gender And Politics

    1005 Words  | 3 Pages

    Bolsheviks entered the political world in 1917 with the ideas of deliberating women and making them equal to men as well as this idea of westernizing Russia. Based on the book, both ideas were closely associated. Women were seen as raw materials that can be used to transform. As a result, women who were already member of the Communists party were sent to the countryside to transform primitive women also known as babas and transformed them into Comrades, the free and knowledgeable women. These transformed women would then move to the city and work in factories and industrial workshop to westernize and industrialize Russia and that will symbolize women freedom and equality to men. Even though these women will have a much lower...

    Read More

  • Feminism and Gender Identities in Post Communistic Eastern Europe

    673 Words  | 2 Pages

    There is a problem with women’s view of gender identity in post communistic Eastern Europe. In the post-communism era there has been a promotion of gender difference rather than equality, where the status of women has regressed. There has been a lack of availability for economic opportunities and female representation in politics. These issues are addressed in the articles; ‘Incorporating Gendered Identities into Transition Studies,’ ‘Women in Post-Communist politics’ and ‘Feminism and Post-Communism’ and I will investigate the reasons why women are confused of their role in society post-communism.

    Read More

  • Gender and Equality in the Workforce in the USSR

    5439 Words  | 11 Pages

    For every person, different reasons exist to go out and seek employment. These reasons, however, stem from the type of government that people are ruled by. In Russia, during the period that will be discussed, a Socialist government ruled the USSR. It was under this government, that everyone was to have a job and unemployment was to be kept at a minimum. During this socialist regime, the attitudes to working will be taken from the perspectives of three related women. The first woman, Mela Krul, was born in 1932 and is the mother of Alla Veitsman and Helen Krul Zlatkin. Alla Veitsman is the oldest sister and was born in 1954. Although her work experience under the socialist government is brief, it shows signs of the progress that women made during the middle to late 1900s. Helen Zlatkin, born in 1962, had no work experience in the former USSR, but her personal account demonstrates the types of choices that women made in order to have both family and work. Mela Krul was the only one who had extensive work experience in the USSR, but she was able to see the changes and progress that women underwent through the daily activities and choices that both of her daughters made. As these three women came to the United States of America, along with their families, they faced a democratic government where employment was not guaranteed and women did have to face the hardships of unemployment, and more importantly, inequality. It would be the values and traditions that both Alla and Helen believed in that allowed them to be successful and relatively unaffected by inequality.

    Read More

  • What Is To Be Done Analysis

    707 Words  | 2 Pages

    Immediately, the story sets off with Vera living under the rule of an autocratic mother who wants to have her marry the son of their tenement block owner. Although Vera has aspirations of her own, she is bound to a lifelong servitude to her family and a loveless marriage to which she does not want to commit. This shows how not only men contributed to women’s subordination in Russia, but the women had a social role in this as well. Vera’s mother wants her to marry rich in hopes of gaining money, power, and status. All of these motives show how Vera’s mother thinks in her own best interest before her daughter’s happiness, and even hints at how desperate not only women, but people of lower class were to escape their social stigma. However, arranged marriage and lifelong servitude is not unique in only...

    Read More

  • Second Wave Feminism Essay

    728 Words  | 2 Pages

    At this point, the difference perspective in ideology and political action has divided the women movement into some feminism types; socialist, Marxist, radical, liberal and many others. While liberal feminist focus their struggle for equality on civil, economic, and political rights, and education, the feminist socialist and Marxist believe women 's oppression is “the product of the political, social and economic structure within which individuals live.” (Tong, 1998: pp.94). Although some other people suppose that the feminist Marxist and socialist is quiet different, but both of them believe the source of women oppression are capitalism and patriarchy. The Marxist feminism is rooted in 19th century thinker such as Marx and Engels, whether

    Read More

  • Life Under Socialism Essay

    1372 Words  | 3 Pages

    Despite men and women being portrayed as equals, in reality, the percentages of genders in different careers were astonishingly skewed. Men also were overwhelmingly prominent in the highest paying careers while women help most of the lower paying careers. Conformity under Socialism was also a huge Soviet ideal and was portrayed as such. In reality, though, citizens who lived under Socialism did whatever they could to be unique despite the consequences. Some things they did in secret, like drawing pictures that were not depicting the Soviet ideals like Sis, or buying goods through the illegal black market. These actions expressed people’s uniqueness, which was not stifled by the State’s portrayal of conformity. Looking at how life under Socialism was portrayed during that time period is a completely incorrect view of the harsh reality of life under

    Read More

  • Compare and Contrast Women’s Suffrage Movements

    1322 Words  | 3 Pages

    “Compare and contrast women’s suffrage movements of the late nineteenth and early centuries with the European feminist movements of the 1960’s and 1970’s.”

    Read More

  • Japanese Culture Essay

    1361 Words  | 3 Pages

    Recently the concerns of women around their equality in society has become a hotly debated topic in the public spot light. Much of the debate concerns women and the ingrained sexism that permeates most cultures. Many women's activists feel that this ingrained sexism has widened the gap between men and women in a political, social, and economic sense. And for the most part they do have strong evidence to support these claims. Women have suffered through millennia of male dominated societies where treatment of women has been, and in some cases still is, inhuman. Women are treated like subhuman creatures that have only exist to be used for procreate and to be subjugated by men for household use. It has only been very recently that women have become recognized as equals in the eyes of men. Equals in the sense that they have the same political and social rights as males. While the situation has improved, women still have to deal with a male oriented world. Often women in the workplace are thought of as inferior and as a liability. This can be due to concerns about maternity leave, or women with poor leadership skills. But also in part it is due because of the patriarchy that controls all aspects and dynamics of the culture, family, politics, and economy. Even developed countries like The United Kingdom, United States, Germany, and France, could be classified as a patriarchies. These countries may not agree with this notion because of expansive, but not complete changes, that have gradually equalized women in society. However, there are developed countries that openly express a patriarchy and have enacted little societal changes to bring equality to women. Japan is one such country, and t...

    Read More

  • The Women's Movement

    1811 Words  | 4 Pages

    The women’s movement had been characterized by women's wish to acquire equal legal status to men by obtaining civil and political rights recorded in the Constitution and legislation. In Romania, the first wave of the feminist movement had been held simultaneously with the women’s movement in West, and it had been a movement of the elite, educated women with access to international information. An important period of this movement was before the establishment of the Romanian Constitution in 1923. It was the most democratic Constitution and women started an intense activity of lobbying for their rights until 1947. Between 1947 and 1989 Romania was pushed under Soviet influence by the Red Curtain, and the feminist activity was eradicated. Although Communism proclaimed gender equality between men and women, this had been acted contradictorily in public sphere and private life. Freedom has been detracted by the Communist Party, and women’s private lives had been controlled by the Party by limiting their legal rights. After the Romanian Revolution in 1989, it was taken a modest initiative on the situation of gender equality and women’s rights in Romanian society. Since 1989 until the present, Romanian women’s roles and rights in society is becoming a priority in Romania. In addition, the promotion of equal opportunities for women and men is also a priority in the democracy, and under Western influence and European legislation. This essay will attempt to outline the difficulties representing the causes of the women’s movement and some of the effects of social, economic and political rights.

    Read More

  • Gender Inequality Theory

    761 Words  | 2 Pages

    By using theories of popular ideology as base material, the same errors committed by early generations of male scholars will be repeated. This is a critical barrier to defining gender inequality. Perhaps the fact that gender inequality, like other forms of inequality, creates two competing sets of myths has been continuously overlooked. One myth that shows men’s advantage, the other one that reflects women’s. Making opposite claims about what is considered true or just, and yet share some particular

    Read More

  • Women's Rights Dbq Essay

    835 Words  | 2 Pages

    In document one, alexandra Kollontai states that the communist party does not care for the female working class. She says that even though the bourgeois do have a women's movement in affect, the working class had no help. She herself is a bit of an anomaly seeing as she had a reputation in economic and social literature before the Russian Revolution. She was one of the few women with such a title before the revolution. Because she had this advantage, she was able to see exactly how the female working class is suffering. In document six, Castro made a speech to the Federation of Cuban Women saying that the Cuban Communist Party is very discriminatory towards women. He acknowledges that women contribute to the party and have sacrificed a lot for the revolution. He even admits that women have higher revolutionary qualifications than men do. Even though Castro made this speech to the Federation of Cuban Women, they were not his intended audience. He was speaking to the communist party, showing his discontent for the way women were being treated. He then goes on to say that they are currently trying to fix this issue, further supporting the women's rights movement in Cuba. Document seven is an open letter by a women's group in Romania for Elena Ceausescu, the wife of the Romanian, communist dictator. The letter says that Ceausescu should know what it is like for the working class women. They spend many hours working and are expecting to come home and do even more work to provide food for their families. It then goes on to state that this lifestyle is very hard and strips them of their will to live, saying that that is ‘utter misery and injustice’. Elena Ceausescu is known for her lavish lifestyle and since she is the wife of the leader, she doesn't face discrimination. Even though she doesn't struggle, she still has the power to change something for the female working class and yet, she doesn't. This goes to

    Read More

  • The Pros and Cons of Life in Communist East Germany in Goodbye, Lenin

    2212 Words  | 5 Pages

    A Reversal of Fortunes? Women, work and change in East Germany. Rachel Alsop. Berghahn Books. 2000

    Read More

  • Karl Marx And The Communist Manifesto

    1347 Words  | 3 Pages

    Born from the revolutions of 1848 throughout Europe, Marxism sought to end the class struggles that were destroying the continent. The solution to the problems of all nations occurred to Marx to be Socialism, a branch that is presently known as Marxism. Under this seemingly “utopian” socioeconomic system, equality was granted to all citizens who were in essence a community of one. “. . . universal free education; arming of the people; a progressive income tax; limitations upon inheritance; state ownership of banks. . .”(Palmer 506). These rights of which constituted Marxism eventually went on to be incorporated in Leninism and modern-day socialism. At least in its beginning, the intent of Marxism and the Communist League were noble towards the goal o...

    Read More

  • Equality Between Men and Women

    1487 Words  | 3 Pages

    Equality is a concept mankind never is able to grasp correctly. Of course humans will always search for different solutions to create fairness, but factors such as human greed, ignorance of mass populations, and even biological aspects stagnates the process of equality. The oldest and most relevant discussion on equality lies with the difference of sex; man versus woman. Initially, men, because of their physical superiority, were given the prospects many women never even dreamt to have. Conversely, as time has progressed, women have fought this unfair treatment with demands of suffrage and similar rights to those of their male equivalents. Greatly enough, this generation has done an exceptional job in the challenge of overcoming sexism and inequality. However, will this search for equality ever end? When can we say we have created an equal race of men and women? The fact of the matter is that it is truly impossible to have equality between the sexes because of predisposed circumstances that are not easily controllable in the slightest bit.

    Read More

More about Gender Equality and Communism

Open Document