slaverybel Morrison’s Beloved as Chronicle of Slavery?

1094 Words3 Pages

Morrison’s Beloved as Chronicle of Slavery?

Stories written in our present time about slavery in the eighteen-hundreds are often accepted as good accounts of history. However, Toni Morrison’s Beloved cannot be used to provide a good chronicle in the history of slavery. While writing about black female slaves and how they were the most oppressed of the most oppressed, Toni Morrison, herself as a female black writer, has a very bias view, as seen by many others. Beloved is written in a completely nonlinear fashion that makes it very difficult to view as a good account of history; the jumping around that it goes through makes it very difficult to place oneself into the story. Due to this jumping around that the book proceeds through, multiple viewpoints are easily created which completely derail the reader from the actual truth of what really happened. In many cases, Beloved does not show sign of what a true history would entail, as understood in the articles and essays of many.

It is ridiculous to say that Tony Morrison’s book is a good account of history. It would be nearly impossible for a black woman to try to write about the history of prejudices against black slave women without having bias views. Stanley Crouch, in his essay “Aunt Medea”, talks about how language is counterfeit and those who tell history only tell their perspective (Crouch, 39); the view is entirely biases because of what they have been through. Morrison even stated herself, as noted in Maggie Sale’s article “Call and Response as Critical Method: African-American Oral Traditions and Beloved”, that she “wanted to write literature that was irrevocably, indisputably black” (Sale, 42). Cynthia Griffin Wolff, author of “‘Margaret Garner’: A Cincinn...

... middle of paper ...

...d not really happen, just what the gross public wants to see as their idea of how it should have happened. This takes us back to Wolff argument about how the “community” view is the real view of what happened (Wolff, 105-106). This not only strengthens the argument by stating how feminist views come in to play, buy also how a story is created from the actual truth being passed on.

Many books written today quite possibly do create a feeling and setting that would make for a good account of history. However, because of bias views, multiple perspectives fueled by these bias views, and jumping around which tends to confuse the reader, Beloved neglects to be convincing as a good account of history of slavery. It will always just be a good story that heightens the personality of it’s characters through it’s clear, simple style of description and powerful emotions.

Open Document