Who Is To Blame For Bruno's Death

644 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Analytical essay on the boy in the striped pajamas on plot character and imagery the book

Bruno's death. The most tragic part of “The Boy in the Striped Pajamas”. The part where EVERYONE shed tears. Who is it to blame for Bruno's and Shmuel's death? Is it the father. He was the commander of Auschwitz, where they countless numbers of jews in gas chambers. Bruno and Shmuel were also killed in a gas chamber. On other hand was it Bruno, himself that is the reason he died. That his loyalty to his friendship got him killed. Nevertheless, was Pavel and Shmuel. They could told him how horrible the camp was. They knew what trouble they could bump into in Auschwitz. First of all, Bruno’s father Ralf was the commandant of Auschwitz or as Bruno calls it “Out-With”. He ordered the jews that were killed with Bruno. He knew this was no place …show more content…

The reason he went to the other side of the fence was his loyalty and friendship to Shmuel. After, Bruno does not stand up to Lieutenant Kotler. He is ashamed. “‘I’m very sorry, Shmuel… I can’t believe I didn’t tell him the truth I’ve never let a friend down like that before. Shmuel, I’m ashamed of myself.’” (p.175) He does not want to lose his friend, therefore he helps Shmuel find Shmuel’s father. Bruno never knew about the gas chambers. Even when they went to the gas chambers, which they did not know where gas chambers, he said “‘I expect that we’ll have to wait here till [the rain] ease off.” He never knew that they were going to get …show more content…

So why did they not warn Bruno about it? Pavel was never allowed to talk to talk to Bruno. He was just supposed to peel vegetables and help around. He was not even supposed to put bandages on Bruno, when Bruno hurt himself. It never came to Pavels mind that Bruno would end up in the gas chamber. Why would? He is just a kid. He has no reason to go the other side of the fence. What about Shmuel? He was the one who asked Bruno to come and help find his dad. When they went for the march he never knew where they went. He never knew about the gas chambers. Moreover, if he knew that asking his only best friend, Bruno to do something Shmuel knew that would get Bruno killed. Would he do it? NO, of course

Show More
Related

  • Troubled Bruno in The Hostage

    709 Words  | 2 Pages

    Other people in Bruno’s class were scared of him and though being scared they respected him. Because he had this kind of scared respect for him he was voted class president and was left alone. People stopped seeing him at school for a while and soon found out that his dad died. He was killed in the mafia, which affected him strongly. When he came back no one said anything and at this time he really need some one to talk too. But no one did because they were scare of him. The only person that came was the narrator was the only person who even came up to him and he did not even let her say it. But she could tell that he really enjoy her even coming up to him to attempt to talk to him.

    Read More

  • Striped Pajamas Vs Night

    600 Words  | 2 Pages

    While the adults show their disgust and hatred to the Jews, Bruno doesn't mind them and is nice to Pavel, the Jew that got him the tire, and later becomes friends with Shmuel. Bruno’s father is a soldier and is in charge of the concentration camp. Even with all the Jew hating Germans around him, he still goes out to visit Shmuel and doesn’t let them ruin his friendship. Near the end of the movie Bruno shows his friend how much he cares by entering the camp to help look for Shmuel’s father, who had gone missing. While entering the camp, Bruno learned first hand how bad the camps actually were and wished he hadn’t come. Even with these feelings he still wants to help his friend, which eventually leads to his demise.

    Read More

  • Stripped Pajamas Archetypes

    612 Words  | 2 Pages

    mature. When Bruno first discovers the fence, a boy called Shmuel faces him. The use of

    Read More

  • Striped Pajamas Dehumanization

    492 Words  | 1 Pages

    Yet, one is more aware about what is taking place at these concentration camps than the other. Shmuel is dehumanized at a young age in the concentration camp. He becomes nothing but a walking corpse. While being treated like an animal, Shmuel is beaten and starved constantly. They stripped him away from his clothes and put him into a striped uniform that Bruno mistakens as pajamas. He is detached from his family, friends, and home. Bruno is under the impression that he has got it hard. Yet, do any of us actually know what it’s like to “have it hard?” Bruno was separated from his friends and home in Berlin. Although he left behind most of his childhood, Bruno stayed with his family and lived in a lovely house. He had maids and servants. Bruno was well fed and taken care of properly. One day, Bruno snuck out where he wasn’t supposed to go. He loved adventures and exploring new things. He came across a very large fence that seemed to be for animals. On the floor of the other side of the fence Bruno saw Shmuel. They talked and eventually became friends. Bruno constantly asked about the “pajamas” Shmuel and the others had to were. Bruno thought it was part of a game they played since the uniforms had numbers on them. Shmuel tried to explain that it wasn’t a game, but Bruno was ignorant about the situation. Bruno didn’t even know that his father was a Nazi soldier. He knew his father’s job was very important because that is what his parents

    Read More

  • Euphemism In The Holocaust

    1472 Words  | 3 Pages

    When Bruno moved to Auschwitz he was completely oblivious to the Holocaust. When he met Shmuel, he became slightly more aware, but couldn’t comprehend what it all meant. It is ironic that his innocence sheltered him from the traumatizing truth of the Holocaust, but it is what killed him in the

    Read More

  • The Boy in the Striped Pajamas: Book and Film

    1359 Words  | 3 Pages

    One day when Shmuel gets sent to shine glasses at his house him and Bruno start talking. A soldier see them and Bruno told him he didn’t know who he was, and the soldier beats the boy, Bruno feels terrible and want to make it up to Shmuel. Bruno wants to understand why the life behind the fence is so awful and why Shmuel isn’t happy. Bruno thinks it’s not better, but interesting because there are other kids to play with. They form a strong bond that can't be broken by anything and it makes him realize that his friends in Berlin weren't as special as Shmuel is and their friendship. The two boys have been talking and have been friends for about a year and decide that Bruno wants to go on the other side of the fence to see what its like and help him find his papa.

    Read More

  • The Boy In The Striped Pajamas Quotes

    915 Words  | 2 Pages

    Bruno goes with Shmuel in the concentration camp and in the camp, Bruno finally discovers what Shmuel has to suffer. They see soldiers everywhere and very thin people with sunken eyes. Even as Bruno and Shmuel see all of this they stick together in the name of friendship and brotherhood. As they get cramped in the dark room, with light slowly closing, Bruno and Shmuel hold hands and never let go at this scene. The author's theme is clearly shown because when everyone is screaming and panicking, Bruno and Shmuel never let go of each other in the dark and eventually hug to the point where their story ends. The theme is shown because the light is used to represent time and as it fades away; Bruno and Shmuel hold hands showing their friendship and how strong it is when they never let go. The first time we see Shmuel, he is thin, pale, and sunken eyes. Bruno ask Shmuel if he wants food and Shmuel says yes, as Bruno is told time and time again that he should not be near the fence, he takes the risk and goes to it to fulfill his promise to a friend that he has only just recently

    Read More

  • Flaherty CC Essay

    1020 Words  | 3 Pages

    ... a perfect example of a truly innocent person (Shmuel) and an arguably unsympathetic character (Bruno) whom can be portrayed as denying the truth meeting the same fate. As we can see by Lennie’s death and Bruno’s death, ignorance and innocence lead to the same fate in the end.

    Read More

  • Gillett v. Holt

    2020 Words  | 5 Pages

    Gillett v. Holt The doctrine of proprietary estoppel is an equitable intervention in cases where the enforcement of legal rights is considered by the courts to be unconscionably unfair. The essence of the doctrine arises, as defined by Snell: '[when] one (A) is encouraged to act to his detriment by the representations or encouragement of another (O) so that it would be unconscionable for O to insist on his strict legal rights.' (McGhee, 2000, p.637) In the absence of a written agreement, estoppel acts as an evidentiary tool with which the courts can help ensure fair interaction in property dealings. Proprietary estoppel is a method by which informal arrangements are recognized as being capable of creating proprietary interests.

    Read More

  • The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas by John Boyne

    1030 Words  | 3 Pages

    Bruno is a 9 year old boy growing up in a loving, but typically authoritarian German family in the 1930?s. His father is a senior military officer who was appointed Commandant of Auschwitz? a promotion that requires upheaval from their comfortable home in Berlin to an austere home in the Polish countryside. The story explores Bruno?s difficulty in accepting and adapting to this change - especially the loss of his friends and grandparents. Boyne gives personality and family to the sort of person who today is generally demonised by western writings - the people who administered and controlled the death camps in which over 6 million Jews, Gypsies, homosexuals, and others were deemed to be grossly inferior by Hitler and his cohorts.

    Read More

  • Who Was Responsible For Bruno's Death

    1073 Words  | 3 Pages

    The father was too enamored with his position as the Commandant to pay any attention to his son. His position as Commandant enabled him to give the order that killed his son. Bruno’s father was responsible for the family moving to Auschwitz, which sparked a chain of events that ultimately caused Bruno’s death. The father was responsible for Bruno’s death in The Boy in the Striped Pajamas.

    Read More

  • Theme Of Relationships In Boy In The Striped Pajamas

    855 Words  | 2 Pages

    Though only the relationship between Bruno and Shmuel, and the relationship between Bruno’s mother and father were only discussed, there were much more relationships. If I were to give advice to one of the relationships, it would be to Bruno’s mother and father. I would tell the father to have discussed to his wife his job details, and whether or not his wife would be okay with joining him. This way, if the mother was not okay, she could have stayed in Berlin with the kids, ultimately preventing Bruno’s

    Read More

  • The Boy In The Striped Pajamas Research Paper

    622 Words  | 2 Pages

    He never really knew why Shmuel was on the other side of the fence. In the book, Bruno asked his sister, Gretel, “‘Are we Jews?’” (Boyne 182). This shows that Bruno had very little knowledge of what was really happening in Auschwitz and all around the world. Boyne had also made Bruno use a very shameful and inappropriate term in his book.

    Read More

  • The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas: Personal Response to the Film and Novel

    1826 Words  | 4 Pages

    Bruno is irritated and shocked when he’s told they’re moving from Berlin but being a very naive boy doesn’t understand why their family has to leave. The story follows on as Bruno sets out from his house in Auschwitz to explore and finds a boy the same age as him sitting on the ground, on the other side of a fence. His name is Shmuel, a Jewish boy held captive in a concentration camp, but Bruno believes the camp is just a farm. Their friendship cements but is separated by a barbed wire.

    Read More

  • Innocence in The Boy in the Striped Pajamas by John Boyne

    596 Words  | 2 Pages

    Bruno, an eight year old boy at the time of the war, is completely oblivious to the atrocities of the war around him - even with a father who is a Nazi commandant. The title of the book is evidence to this - Bruno perceives the concentration camp uniforms as "striped pajamas." Further evidence is the misnomers "the Fury," (the Furher) and "Out-With" (Auschwitz). Bruno and Shmuel, the boy he meets from Auschwitz, share a great deal in common but perhaps what is most striking is the childhood innocence which characterizes both boys. Bruno is unaware that his father is a Nazi commandant and that his home is on ther periphery of Auschwitz. Shmuel, imprisoned in the camp, seems not to understand the severity of his situation. When his father goes missing, Shmuel does not understand that he has gone to the gas chamber.

    Read More

More about Who Is To Blame For Bruno's Death

Open Document