What Is Brutus Position In Antony's Funeral Speech

In Act III of Julius Caesar, Brutus and Antony give their infamous funeral speeches. Brutus explains the conspirators murder of Caesar to defuse the raging crowd. Antony then changes the people newfound hate for Caesar into outrage again. The persuasive skills of these two clash in a battle for control of Rome’s citizens. Antony clearly is the superior speaker in this engagement. His position as Caesar’s friend, his logical evaluation of Caesar’s lack of ambition, and his heart wrenching speech sway the people to his point of view.
Brutus’ outstandingly honorable reputation contests Antony’s record as a blunt loyal friend of Caesar’s. Brutus starts out his speech by asking for the people’s attention because of his reputation. “Believe me for mine honor, / any dear friend of Caesar’s, to him I say that Brutus’ love to Caesar was no less than his,” explains Brutus. (III: ii:17-19) While Brutus does have a good reputation it does little to convince the audience. Though it does quiet the crowd, which may have been the main intention of the statement. On the other hand, Antony uses his position as a friend of Caesar’s. Antony tells the audience, “He was my friend, faithful, and just to me.” (III: ii:83) This

Caesar’s death is explained as a necessary deed to the people. He tells the people, “But, as he was ambitious, I slew him.” (III: ii:25-6) This coerces the citizens to side with Brutus because they wish to remain a republic. Antony seizes the opportunity to prove that Caesar was not an ambitious man. To negate the point Antony says, “I thrice presented him a kingly crown, / Which he did thrice refuse.” (III: ii:94-5) The people are then convinced that Caesar couldn’t have been ambitious if he refused ultimate power over Rome. A tyrant would not have refused an opportunity to be crowned as king. Antony’s use of common knowledge more masterfully convinces the