What does it mean to be an AIG student? We tend to hear this being referred to only certain students. Parents and teachers have different views on what it means to be a gifted child. Also, AIG students and students who are not AIG differentiate in their opinions. Teachers sometimes find it challenging to teach AIG students and end up not teaching them anything. When we first hear the letters "AIG" or the words "gifted student", what comes to mind? To some those three letters do not mean anything. “When parents think of their children as gifted, they usually think of high IQ scores, high SATs, high ACTs, high grades, and the like”. AIG is an acronym for Academically/Intellectually Gifted. An academically gifted child will learn more quickly …show more content…
and will probe more deeply into the topics than his or her average ability classmate. They will also display a greater interest in reading, a greater independence and self initiative, and transfer learning from one area to another than their ordinary peer. “Joseph Renzulli developed the three ring conception of giftedness that has been a popular view of giftedness for over thirty years.” The three rings represent three clusters of traits that according to Joseph Renzulli combine and interact with each other to form a creative accomplishment or gifted behaviors. “Those three rings are above average ability, creativity, and task commitment. Renzulli also realized that for those three rings to develop personality traits such as optimism, courage, romance with a topic, physical and/or mental energy, and vision/sense to destiny were needed to develop student potential.” In other words an above average student is one who relates their learning to outside topics and are able to “think outside the box” is considered gifted. Moreover, some teachers may have a misconception of the needs of gifted students.
There are teachers that believe a gifted child should be able to do well, need little to no assistance, and should work with other less gifted students to assist them. Other myths about gifted students include “they are good at everything and should be reminded of that when they fail to perform at high levels and they do not need special programs as they will be able to perform at high levels regardless”. These myths come from not understanding gifted children. Teachers often want each of their students to gain knowledge in their classes, this can often be a challenge when having gifted students. Cathy Kroninger, a former educator from the Chatham County schools, stated that she believed that “gifted students usually learn less new material than any other group in an academic year” and this is often caused by the “lack of curriculum modification, a lack of exposure to higher level thinking skills, and lowered expectations”. To be able to teach a gifted child Kroninger suggests it is best to first identify them. There are students who are bright and students who are gifted. “A bright child enjoys school and understands ideas, while a gifted child enjoys learning and constructs abstractions. A bright child is a good memorizer, a gifted [one] is a good guesser. A bright child will work hard while a gifted child plays around, yet tests well… A bright child is pleased with his or her own learning, …show more content…
while a gifted child may be highly self-critical”. Kroninger found it helpful to make cluster groups, where gifted children are with other gifted children. Doing this provides the gifted students with the same learning challenges that other students have. “It also allows the teacher to give gifted students greater depth at their own cognitive level rather than simply having them “work ahead” with lessons or resources designed for older students”. As a former teacher Cathy Kroninger always wanted to provide enough resources to help her students and be able to meet their needs. Equally important is what the AIG or gifted student thinks about themselves, other gifted students, and their teachers.
Most gifted “students [are] intrinsically motivated, earn high grades, and perform well at tasks. [Also, they tend to] take pleasure from the achievement, effort, and successful completion of a task”. When interviewing Ivette Martinez, an AIG student that is currently a ninth grader attending St. Stephens High School, on what she thought it meant to be an AIG student, she responded with “the first words that come to mind are above average, high recognition, determination, and hard work”. She continued on to state she “feel[s] like it is a recognition, [she] consider[s] it a good thing when [she is] being called an AIG student because [she has] worked hard to get there. [She also feels] important because it is hard to get there. It is an overall good feeling”. When asked if she had any worries or doubts when being referred to as an AIG student Ivette said, “I feel like I have to keep up with the label by not slacking off or doing anything to not be considered an AIG student… because if I did, for example stopped doing my homework or not tried my best and gave my one hundred percent in everything I do, I feel like I would be downgraded”. Also, when asked how she viewed herself when being compared to other students who were not AIG Ivette simply stated that she “would not like to be in the same core classes as them because that would make [her] feel dumb”.
Competition was the first word Ivette said when questioned about what her views were on other gifted students. She went on to say that she wants “to be the top student, the best of the best”. When later asked for her opinion about how teachers taught students like her, she responded with, “I feel like they could do more. I mean I didn’t feel challenged until I entered high school because then I could choose my classes. I chose classes in which I knew I would actually have to do work, try hard to pass and get good grades”. To put it briefly some gifted students do not feel challenged during primary and intermediate grade school. Gifted students also feel competition between themselves and other gifted students, in this case it is good because that encourages them to do better in school. Overall when asking what it means to be an AIG student, you will receive answers that vary from one person to another. A simple and brief answer to that is, one who learns more quickly, displays more interest in subjects, transfers their knowledge from one field to another more easily, reads more, and has a greater sense of independent learning than the average student.
Ryser, G. R., & McConnell, K. (2003). Scales for Identifying Gifted Students. Waco, TX: Prufrock Press.
New York: Cambridge University Press. Ryser, G. R., & McConnell, K. (2003). Scales for Identifying Gifted Students. Waco, TX: Prufrock Press.
Board of Education outlawed educational segregation, the Illinois School District had created a completely different gifted program for Hispanic students, separate from the White students’ gifted program. Ford found that in 2009 and 2001, the RDCI (The Relative Difference in Composition Index) researched and concluded “at least one half million African American and Hispanic students combined are not identified as gifted” (Ford 145). While African American Students are rising to be the majority race in public education, the percentage of African Americans even being recognized as gifted or academically accelerated, is not proportionally increasing (Ford). Society hold precedents with people who have superior intelligence over those who do not, but how can superiority even be concluded when all people are not given the opportunity to have an enriching education? African Americans are not able to increase their percentage of gifted students because African American students are not given the chance to be even recognized as worthy or capable of such achievements. As society advances further academically and leaves African Americans with an unquail education, the percentage of African Americans attending college and entering professional careers
Gifted and talented programs are intrinsically valuable to many children’s education as they provide a system in which all students involved are engaged, challenged, and intellectually stimulated. In "How People Learn", Donovan, Bransford, and Pellegrino (1999) stress the importance of each student being given reasonable and appropriate goals based on his or her level of understanding and competency (p. 20). Gifted and talented programs help institutionalize the attempt to meet all student’s needs by providing uniquely appropriate challenges which aim to keep every student engaged, thus receiving the best chance at success. Although there are many valuable and important aspects of gifted education, there are also significant issues rooted in the base of America’s gifted and talented programs, one of which I will address throughout this paper. In my opinion, the most notable problem which troubles gifted and talented programs is the system by which students are selected to join their school’s gifted and talented program.
Based on the information you have read in the text and any experiences you have had as a teacher, what do you think are the issues gifted students face as they go through school?
There is a phenomenon happening in most schools throughout the country. Asian students as young as seven years olds are labeled as gifted and enrolled in various accelerate programs to further develop their talents. Certainly, most of these students are deserving of the honorable recognition. However, many skeptics do question how many of them are viewed as exceptional students based upon the stereotype: they are genetically smarter than their non-Asian peers.
Gardner, H. (2000). The giftedness matrix: A developmental perspective. In R. C. Friedman, & B. M. Shore (Eds.), (pp. 77-88) American Psychological Association.
The Integrated Curriculum Model has three main dimensions advanced content, process/product, and issues/themes. The first dimension, advanced content, is content that it at a higher level. In English Language Arts the readings are usually two grade levels above. Within advanced content, diagnostic-prescriptive approaches are used to promote new learning. Teachers are to continually pre-assess students before teaching content to make sure they are teaching at the appropriate level for the gifted students. In the second facet of the model it ensures that the students are thinking and processing information at higher complex levels. The third dimension of the Integrated Curriculum Model centers gifted and talented students learning around major issues and themes. To connect the themes and issues to real world applications is creating a deeper understanding of the material.
Most gifted students have a wide range of interests. Type I enrichment will expose Jaeda to new ideas and exciting topics which will help her discover new areas of interest. Type II enrichment aims to develop cognitive and affective processes. Jaeda will be able to pursue additional training in her chosen area of interest. She will be able to engage in creative thinking and problem solving which will help her to find answers to all the questions she might have about that topic. Since students are expected to work in groups in Type II enrichment, the teacher can also use this opportunity to build on Jaeda’s team work skills. Type III enrichment is only offered to students who have interest and ability for task commitment. If Jaeda is able and willing, she could take on the role of a first hand inquirer (Renzulli and Reis, 1997). She could investigate real world problems and create an authentic product or service. This will help to develop self directed learning skills which would be beneficial not only for high school but also for her life long learning. Teacher can look for opportunities in both Type II and Type III enrichment to help Jaeda develop her leadership skills, for example, Jaeda could share her original work with an audience or teach some newly acquired knowledge to her
One of the most controversial things about gifted and talented education is the criterion educators use to identify the gifted and talented. In the past, a student’s intelligence, based on an I.Q. score, was considered the best way to determine whether or not they qualified as gifted. As a result of using this method of identification, many gifted and talented students are not discovered nor are they placed in the appropriate programs to develop their abilities. Talents in the arts or an excellent ability to write are not measured on an I.Q. test but are abilities that may certainly qualify a student as gifted or talented.
Nine years ago, President Bush signed the No Child Left Behind Act into law. One of the chief problems with NCLB is that it required all students to meet a minimum standard but nothing above it. Therefore, funding for many gifted and other high-achievement programs has been cut. More and more, all students have been funneled through the same track so that they can meet the same minimum standards. While gifted students have never been a priority when it comes to legislation, in recent years, they have become even less of one, and this has had a very real and tangible impact on our best a...
Although genius is a word that is completely different from intelligence, people often confuse genius with intelligence, because genius is a word that is related to intelligence. Genius is an “extreme degree of creative or other ability, usually demonstrated by exceptional achievements” (APA Dictionary of Psychology: Genius), therefore genius is unable to be used as a proper tool in defining intelligence. As a result of genius being a word of those who possess great intelligence and accomplish notable intellectual achievements, people often confuse the definition of genius with the definition of intelligence. Although genius is a high level of intelligence, g...
During an observation, there three types of first grade students that were observing a gifted, typical and special need. Some common characteristics of a typical first grade student they may ask many questions, very social, interest in learning, bossy with friends, enjoy doing projects and very energetic. They also understanding of their testing behavior and interested in learning, enjoy art, riddles and poems (Responsive Classroom, 2011). Some characteristics of a gifted student have strong curiosity, high level of language and verbal development, great capacity to process information and have long attention span. Gifted students also have a higher understanding of self-awareness and persistence and goal directed (Duke University, 2008). Some
The term “gifted” can mean many things. Up until recently it was the word used to describe people with profoundly high intelligence. Now, adding the words “creative” and “talented”, the category of giftedness has been extended to include not only exceptionally intelligent people, but also people with extraordinary ability in other areas, not just with IQ tests (Drew, Egan, & Hardman, 2002).
The Oxford Dictionary defines intelligence as “the ability acquire and apply knowledge and skills.” Many people are born naturally intelligent, able to grasp and understand concepts easily, with little work. In children, it is easy to separate those born with higher intellectual ability from the rest, because they easily excel in learning. This skill is often lost by those born with it, and through a great deal of work others attain it. In order for an individual to have true intelligence into her adult years, she must foster what gifts she is given, and strive to better her self academically. Even as early as elementary school, many who are born with natural talent begin to fall behind intellectually. These students are often not